‘I did not bring my daughters to die': Russian mother defends decision to live in cave in India
Police officers patrolling the slippery trails of Ramteertha Hills in India's Karnataka state stumbled upon an unusual sight earlier this month when they saw a cave curtained with a cloth and a little blonde girl running out barefoot from a hole in the mountain.
The woman, identified as Nina Kutina, 40, had made a home deep in the woods with her daughters, aged five and six, police said. The family had no valid visas and was undocumented in the country.
Police officer Sridhar SR confirmed the family had been residing in the cave for over a week.
Authorities are now arranging for Kutina's repatriation to Russia, as she had overstayed her visa. She and her daughters have been transferred to a detention facility for foreign nationals living in India illegally.
Kutina has defended her decision to live in the wild with her daughters and said they were healthy and happy in the forest, as they are now held in a detention centre near state capital Bengaluru, awaiting deportation.
Kutina's case has since snowballed into a tale of adventure, parental rights, bureaucracy, and international legal hurdles.
A forest dwelling discovered by chance
Authorities had ramped up forest patrols in the Gokarna forest bordering tourist hotspot Goa due to landslide risks in the area and on one such patrol when they found the dwelling on 9 July. The cave in which Kutina was found lay within the jungle and was her home for over a week.
Kutina was reluctant to leave the cave as officers tried to warn her about the dangers of living in the wild.
Sridhar SR says, 'It is nothing but her love for adventure that brought her here''.
He says Kutina told the police that she had worked as a tutor of Russia n language in Goa and spent time in the cave meditating by candlelight, feeding her children, painting, singing, and reading books.
Kutina has defended her decision to live in a forest. 'We were not dying, and I did not bring my children, my daughters, to die in jungle. They did not feel bad, they were very happy, they swam in waterfall, they lived, had very good place for sleeping, a lot of lessons with art making, we made from clay, we painted, we ate good, I was cooking with gas, very good and tasty food,' she told ANI news agency.
Kutina says they were not living far from civilisation. She chose that location because it is very close to a village from where she bought supplies.
'It's very big and beautiful cave, and not small, and it's like it has window to look to ocean.'
Who is Nina Kutina?
Russian by birth, Kutina has told Indian news agencies that she has not lived in Russia for 15 years. She has travelled extensively – Costa Rica, Bali, Thailand, Malaysia, Ukraine, Nepal – and says she gave birth to four children, including a son who died in a road accident in Goa last year. Her other son, aged 11, lives in Russia.
The two girls with her in the forest were reportedly fathered by Dror Goldstein, an Israeli businessman currently residing in India. He told NDTV that Kutina had left Goa with the children without informing him, prompting him to file a missing persons complaint.
Goldstein is now pushing for joint custody and opposes the government's plan to deport the children to Russia.
Police say Kutina sent a long and emotional text message to her friends after she was found in the cave. In the message, she condemned the authorities for forcibly removing her and her family from a peaceful, natural life into what she describes as a prison-like shelter.
'And we were placed in a prison without sky, without grass, without a waterfall, with an icy hard floor on which we now sleep for 'protection from rain and snakes',' she wrote.
"Not once in our entire life there did a snake ever harm us. Not a single animal attacked us. For many years, the only thing we feared was people." She also expressed her anger with humans, saying they are the 'only creatures who act abnormally'.
"I'm hurt by the world of humans – where people with no proper education are given positions that give them power over the lives of others – whole families, even,' she added.
"They carry out these horrifying vigilante 'justices,' based purely on their fears – on childish fairytales – not on real experience, not on knowledge, but on rumours, on cowardice."
Their life in the cave
The three were found with only their belongings, including plastic mats, a few clothes, some grocery items, and packets of instant noodles. There was no electricity or running water, but Kutina says they were content. Days were spent swimming in a nearby waterfall, cooking simple meals, and making art from clay and natural materials.
The entrance to their cave had been curtained off with colourful saris.
Videos shot by police show the children smiling and dressed in bright Indian clothes, seemingly at ease. Kutina told reporters that they had access to groceries from a nearby village and that she made sure her daughters were well-fed and engaged.
Kutina's forest stay, she says, was not driven by spirituality but by their love for nature. A Hindu idol of Panduranga Vittala, an avatar of the god Krishna, was found in her cave.
'It is not about spiritually... it's not about it, we just like natural because it gives us health....'
The children have not attended school so far, according to a The Times of India report.
Kutina, who claims to be a trained teacher in art and Russian literature, said she plans to formally homeschool her children with proper documentation.
'I earn money through all these activities. And if I don't have any work, if I can't find anyone who needs what I can offer, then my brother, my father, or even my son helps me. So we always have enough money for what we need,' she said.
Her legal status
The puzzle of when and how Kutina entered – or re-entered – India remains unsolved.
Police found an old passport showing she arrived in India on a business visa in October 2016, valid till April 2017. She overstayed and was eventually issued an exit permit by Goa's Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO) in 2018.
She then travelled to Nepal on 19 April 2018 and some other places before she returned after three months. Reports suggest she's been in India since at least 2020, though no clear immigration record exists to verify this.
She said "travelled to at least 20 countries" and she has travelled to around "four of them since leaving India in 2018".
Kutina says the visa lapse was unintentional – a result of grief over her son's death. 'We don't have a valid visa. Our visa finished. I was so sad, I could not think about visa,' she said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
3 minutes ago
- The Independent
A 15-year-old boy with no criminal history ended up at Alligator Alcatraz after rush to fill facility
Authorities detained a 15-year-old boy without a criminal record at Alligator Alcatraz amid the haste to fill up the Florida facility, according to reports. As the state scrambled to open the controversial detention center, Alexis, the teenager, seems to have been caught up in the mix. On July 1, three days before the facility officially opened, Florida Highway Patrol stopped a vehicle packed with Alexis and his friends before handing him over to federal authorities, the Miami Herald and Tampa Bay Times first reported. Alexis endured three days in the rapidly built facility consisting of tents and chain-link pens, his father told the Tampa Bay Times. The Florida Division of Emergency Management, which oversees the facility, admitted he had been detained, explaining he lied about his age when officers stopped him. 'While at Alligator Alcatraz, an individual disclosed they had misrepresented their age upon arrest to ICE. Immediate action was taken to separate and remove the detainee in accordance with federal protocols,' a spokesperson for the division told The Independent in a statement. 'This is one of many problems with illegal immigration: individuals are in our country without any way to verify their identity.' Three days after he was detained, on July 4, authorities transferred the boy from Alligator Alcatraz to a shelter for migrant children that is operated by the federal Office of Refugee Resettlement, the Tampa Bay Times reported. State officials told the outlet that Alligator Alcatraz doesn't house minors. It's unclear what steps are being taken to prevent something similar from happening in the future. The Independent has reached out to a spokesperson for the governor's office for more information. The episode captures the chaos around the facility's opening. Alligator Alcatraz, constructed to help accelerate President Donald Trump's immigration crackdown, was meant to hold the 'most menacing migrants, some of the most vicious people on the planet," the president said. As of this week, the facility holds more than 700 people, but only one-third of them have criminal convictions, reports found. 'The case is important to highlight to ensure that there is oversight and safeguards in place because an adult facility is not a place for a child,' immigration attorney Alexandra Manrique Alfonso told the Times. The 15-year-old was handcuffed while being transferred to the facility, Manrique Alfonso said, noting that he had been housed with adults. Ignacio, the teen's father, told the Times that he believes his son told authorities he was an adult when the car was pulled over because he was afraid of being separated from the group if he mentioned his true age: 'It was because of fear.' Ignacio only learned his son was detained after one of the teen's friends called from the facility — three days later. Alexis later called his father, who told him to come clean to officials that he was a minor. Ignacio then sent a photo of Alexis' birth certificate via text and told his son to ask for permission to use his phone to prove his age; he was transferred after they confirmed his age, the outlet reported. Now, Ignacio is trying to reunite with Alexis. He's even taking a paternity test. 'It is very sad that a lot of families are being separated,' he told the outlet. The father came to the U.S. in 2018 after fleeing his hometown of Chiapas, Mexico due to violence; his son followed him to Florida two years later, the outlet reported. 'When you're apart from your kids, you miss them. If you don't see them, you feel their absence,' the father told the Times. 'I am pleading with God that we can be reunited.'
Scottish Sun
4 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Putin's cyber spooks who hacked Skripal's family in series of attacks are unmasked by British intel chiefs
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) RUSSIAN spies who led a series of attacks on Britain have been exposed by UK intelligence chiefs. Whitehall has imposed sanctions on Vladimir Putin's spooks responsible for years of hacking and other actions in the UK. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 3 Yulia Skripal and her father Sergei were poisoned by Russian spies in 2018. Yulia was also hacked by Putin's spooks before the attack Credit: East2west News The measures target three GRU military intelligence units and 18 spooks — two of whom were accused of hacking the phone of defector Sergei Skripal's daughter. Ivan Yermakov and Aleksey Lukashev — both wanted by the FBI — are said to have targeted Yulia five years before Russia poisoned her and her dad with nerve agent Novichok in Salisbury in 2018. Others hit with sanctions are believed to be behind bombings and arson attacks in Britain and Europe in retaliation for support for Ukraine. They face a range of restrictions such as having financial assets frozen. Foreign Secretary David Lammy said: 'GRU spies are running a campaign to destabilise Europe, undermine Ukraine's sovereignty and threaten the safety of British citizens. "The Kremlin should be in no doubt; we see what they are trying to do in the shadows and won't tolerate it.' Three men were this month convicted of torching an East London warehouse involved in shipping aid to Ukraine, on the orders of Russia's Wagner Group mercenaries. Spy chiefs are also probing if Russian agents were behind an incendiary device that ignited at a DHL hub in Birmingham last year. Similar incidents have been reported across Europe. 3 Ivan Yermakov is said to have targeted Sergei Skripal's daughter Yulia five years before Russia poisoned her and her dad Credit: Reuters 3 Aleksey Lukashev is also said to have targeted Yulia before she was poisoned with nerve agent Novichok in Salisbury in 2018 Credit: FBI
South Wales Guardian
an hour ago
- South Wales Guardian
UK sanctions Russian spies trying to ‘destabilise Europe'
Those sanctioned include a unit that targeted the daughter of Sergei Skripal years before Russian agents attempted to murder him in Salisbury with the nerve agent Novichok. Others are accused of belonging to units that have carried out cyber attacks in the UK, France, Germany and the US – while also facilitating strikes on civilian targets in Ukraine. Foreign Secretary David Lammy said: 'GRU spies are running a campaign to destabilise Europe, undermine Ukraine's sovereignty and threaten the safety of British citizens. 'The Kremlin should be in no doubt: we see what they are trying to do in the shadows and we won't tolerate it. That's why we're taking decisive action with sanctions against Russian spies.' In total, 18 officers of the GRU, Russia's military intelligence unit, have been sanctioned, along with three men linked to Moscow's efforts to spread disinformation in West Africa. They include five men said to have been involved in a cyber attack on Yulia Skripal in 2013, in which the GRU's Unit 26165 targeted her emails with malware known as X-Agent. Development of X-Agent is said to have been overseen by Lieutenant-Colonel Sergey Morgachev, and involved Aleksey Lukashev, Ivan Yermakov, Sergey Vasyuk and Artem Malyshev, who have all been sanctioned. Lukashev and Yermakov are said to have carried out the attack on Ms Skirpal's emails, five years before members of a separate GRU unit poisoned her and her father with Novichok. The Foreign Office accused Unit 26165, which is already sanctioned, of attempting to disrupt investigations into the attempted murder of the Skripals along with another already-sanctioned GRU outfit, Unit 74455. On Friday, the UK added GRU Unit 29155 to the sanctions list, accusing it of carrying out the poisoning and saying the incident 'underscores how GRU Units integrate cyber operations into hybrid activity with the aim of furthering the Kremlin's objectives'. Also sanctioned are Aleksey Morenets and Yevgeney Serebriakov, accused of carrying out 'close access operations' against the Organisation for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons in The Hague, Netherlands. As well as carrying out cyber attacks in Western Europe, Unit 26165 is said to have conducted operations in Ukraine, including carrying out reconnaissance that facilitated the 2022 attack on the Mariupol Theatre that killed hundreds of civilians, including children. The UK and our allies are striking at the heart of Russia's energy sector by lowering the Oil Price Cap. This will directly hit Putin's most critical revenue stream and drain his war chest. We will keep up economic pressure as we stand by — David Lammy (@DavidLammy) July 18, 2025 Several of the men sanctioned on Friday are already wanted by the FBI in the United States. They include Colonel Aleksandr Osadchuk, said to be the commanding officer of Unit 74455. He and others have been charged with a series of offences in connection with Russian attempts to interfere in the 2016 US election. Other men sanctioned by the UK on Friday, including Morenets and Serebriakov, are accused of targeting anti-doping organisations and other sporting bodies around the 2016 Olympic Games in Rio De Janeiro. Meanwhile, the UK joined the EU in lowering the price cap on Russian oil as Ukraine's allies sought to increase pressure on Moscow to engage in peace talks. The cap, which is currently 60 US dollars per barrel, will fall to 47.60 dollars from September 2 in a move Chancellor Rachel Reeves said was aimed at 'exploiting' President Vladimir Putin's 'biggest vulnerability'. Energy revenues account for around 30% of the Russian state's income, making them a key source of funding for the Kremlin's war in Ukraine. Ms Reeves, who is attending a meeting of G20 finance ministers in South Africa, said: 'The UK and its EU allies are turning the screw on the Kremlin's war chest by stemming the most valuable funding stream of its illegal war in Ukraine even further.' Mr Lammy added the UK would not 'stand by' while Mr Putin 'continues to stall on serious peace talks'.
