Female law firm worker sued for victimisation after male colleague mentioned 'pretty privilege' and told her 'good girl'
Catherine Guinee reported Aaron Hodges to bosses for claiming that attractive women are more likely to secure contracts, an employment tribunal heard.
The 49-year-old also complained that he had said 'good girl' to her and his remarks led to him receiving a warning about the 'need to be careful about his use of language in the workplace'.
However, after Miss Guinee lost her job shortly afterwards she launched legal proceedings claiming the firm had failed to investigate her allegations properly.
Her claims were dismissed after the tribunal ruled that her employers had not ignored her complaint.
The hearing in central London was told Miss Guinee started working at Pogust Goodhead, a London-based law firm with over 500 staff members, in March 2023.
The firm set up a call centre for people to make claims relating to the diesel emissions scandal, with Miss Guinee - who suffers from multiple sclerosis - hired as a client services supervisor.
The hearing was told that shortly after she started she made the complaint to boss Urika Shrestha about colleague Mr Hodges.
Employment Judge Anthony Snelson said: 'We find that, probably very early on [Miss Guinee] did complain privately to her colleague about an exchange with Mr Hodges in which he had said 'good girl' to her and another in which the two had discussed 'pretty privilege', the notion that female candidates regarded as good-looking were more likely to secure training contracts than others seen as less attractive.
'We accept [Ms Shrestha's] evidence evidence that she spoke with Mr Hodges and reminded him of the need to be careful about his use of language in the workplace.'
The tribunal did find that Ms Shrestha did not tell Miss Guinee that she had had this conversation, however,
The tribunal heard that on April 11 - ahead of a meeting - she sent a message to her boss complaining about competition within the team.
She sent another message to the head of HR, saying: 'I have relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis. I do not need mind games, being messed around, being pulled one way and another.'
She then approached another line manager, clearly agitated, and started shouting that things were 'bullshit' and that she was being denied her access to certain reports because she was a woman.
When the meeting started, when a colleague was speaking, Miss Guinee started pointing and shouting at her, the hearing was told.
She again complained of 'bullshit' and called her a 'little girl', which shocked the other members of the team. She then called Mr Hodges 'adopted', 'scummy' and a 'money-grabber' and claimed Ms Shrestha was treating staff like 'slaves'.
Ms Guinee was then asked to go home and it was later agreed by colleagues that she should be fired as 'she did not meet the standards required for her role'.
She then sued for disability and sex discrimination as well as victimisation.
Regarding Mr Hodges' remarks, the tribunal said: 'We find that there was no 'failure' to follow up the complaint' and also ruled that her gender and MS had nothing to do with her being fired as no one involved knew of her illness.
EJ Snelson said: 'If, as we find, the decision to dismiss was taken at a time when the decision maker had no knowledge of the relevant medical condition, it follows that that condition cannot have been the reason, or a material reason, for the dismissal.
'It was common ground that at the time of dismissal [Miss Guinee] had taken no sick leave. She exhibited no symptoms in the workplace.
'The person who dismissed her was the very person who had interviewed and appointed her only a month earlier. The notion that he was disposed to discriminate against on her grounds of sex is entirely unsubstantiated.
'[Miss Guinee] was dismissed in accordance with her contract, under which [Pogust Goodhead] was at liberty to terminate on notice.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
4 minutes ago
- The Independent
Police investigate after video of men spraying water pistol at Orthodox Jews
Police have launched an investigation after a video of two men firing a water pistol at members of the Jewish community was circulated on social media. In a now deleted video, two men were seen laughing as they sprayed traditionally-dressed Orthodox Jewish adults and children with water on the streets of Manchester. Greater Manchester Police said a crime had been reported after the video was shared online. "A crime has been recorded, with multiple lines of enquiry being actively investigated," the force said. "We are working closely with partners to provide reassurance to the communities impacted, and we encourage anyone who has been targeted to contact us on 999 in an emergency, 101, or by reporting on our website.' The video was shared on Instagram and YouTube before it was taken down. Community Security Trust, a charity which monitors antisemitism across the UK, described it as "an appalling antisemitic video". The Independent has contacted the account that uploaded the video. One of the men told The Jewish Chronicle they 'sincerely apologise' if anyone felt offended and said: "I honestly don't understand the hate we're getting right now. It was just a simple water gun prank using a small toy — nothing more. "I have two other 'Water Gun Prank' videos filmed with British people, and everyone was smiling, laughing, and the vibe was great. 'I don't understand how this suddenly became labeled as hate speech. It's not hate speech in any way — it's just a normal human joke, nothing offensive or targeted. "We do not accept being called hateful or being accused of spreading hate speech. That's simply not true. We respect all people regardless of their race.'
The Independent
4 minutes ago
- The Independent
Millions to receive emergency alert in ‘largest public safety exercise in British history'
Britain is set for the 'largest public safety exercise in British history' next month as a mobile phone emergency alert test is rolled out. Millions of smartphones on 4G and 5G networks across the UK will make a loud siren-like noise and vibrate at 3pm on 7 September. The trial is part of the UK's emergency alert system which is designed to warn people of disasters like storms or wildfires. 'This test will be one of the biggest public safety exercises in our nation's history,' cabinet minister Pat McFadden said. 'From major storms to wildfires, this system could save your life in an emergency,' he said. 'Just like the fire alarm in your house, it's important we test the system so that we know it will work if we need it.' The first test was in April 2023. Since then, five alerts have been sent, including during major storms when lives were at risk, Mr McFadden said. The government used the system during Storm Eowyn in January to warn people in Scotland and Northern Ireland about severe weather. In December, around 3.5 million people in Wales and south-west England received an alert during Storm Darragh. A warning was also triggered in February last year when an unexploded 500kg Second World War bomb was found in a Plymouth back garden. The alert will read: 'This is a test of Emergency Alerts, a UK government service that will warn you if there's a life-threatening emergency nearby. 'You do not need to take any action. In a real emergency, follow the instructions in the alert to keep yourself and others safe. Find simple and effective advice on how to prepare for emergencies at Japan has similar emergency alert systems due to frequent earthquakes and tsunamis. The USA also has warning system in place. In 2018, Hawaiian residents were mistakenly sent an alert telling them a ballistic missile was inbound as US president Donald Trump and North Korean leader Kim Jong Un exchanged nuclear threats. Officials blamed miscommunication during a drill and the Hawaii Emergency Management Agency chief resigned over the blunder.
The Guardian
4 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Matthew Law obituary
My brother, Matthew Law, who has died aged 63, was for more than 20 years a beloved tutor at the Boat Building Academy, the 'wooden boat school', in Lyme Regis, Dorset. The academy's motto, 'Launching People (and Boats)', perfectly encapsulated Matthew's own motivation. Thirty years sober at the time of his death, he tirelessly supported others struggling with addiction. He was an exceptional mentor: funny, original, gentle and passionate. Born in Dorking, Surrey, Matt was the second son of Tim, a headteacher who loved sailing, and Anne, who had worked as part of the Student Movement House organisation in Kenya, Tanzania and Burma. Growing up in Bude, Cornwall, meant playing in the sea and on the downs. Our family moved with my father's job to Hertfordshire, and Matt attended Cavendish school in Hemel Hempstead. Work experience as a thatcher and a summer job on tugs in Southampton harbour showed his affinity for craft and boats. He got a scholarship to Gordonstoun school in Scotland for his sixth form. After a year studying humanities at Middlesex Polytechnic, he returned to the family home, by now in Wareham, Dorset, and worked for the RNLI as a labourer and in their research department in Poole. In the early 80s Matthew joined the Tate Gallery in London as a technician, combining his love of art with his forklift driving skills. From there, he joined a year-long EU youth expedition, driving a convoy of 4x4s from London to Cape Town, engaging in projects along the way. After jobs in London as a management consultant, then a researcher for a Confederation of British Industry film project, in 1989 Matthew joined the Irish aid agency Goal, driven by a desire to return to Africa to work in relief and development. He managed their Khartoum office for a year, and in 1990 he helped establish Action Africa in Need in Nairobi, setting up a new aid route into war-torn South Sudan. This led to him overseeing the south-east region of Kenya for Unicef, establishing refugee camps and aid routes for the thousands fleeing conflict in Somalia. In 1995 he embarked on a master's in development studies at Trinity College Dublin, where he got sober and a distinction. After a stint at Save the Children in London he made another change. He undertook a year of training in 1999 at the wooden boat school and was apprenticed at Latham's boatyard in Poole, then returned to the school as a tutor, quickly assuming substantial responsibility for its operation. One of his colleagues in Lyme Regis described the 'many hours we spent in fits of giggles, trying to pull ourselves together to look more professional. I think it was all this laughter that made him such a hit with the students.' He was a wonderful teacher, hugely knowledgable, with a genuine interest in those around him; and an enthusiast for, among other things, dogs, fun, his family, calligraphy, friends, exuberant rearrangements of the English language, and chocolate eggs. He is survived by me, and by his niece, Eliza and nephew, Seamus.
