AI's role in mental health grows, sparks expert concern
Dr Prabha S Chandra, Professor and Head of Psychiatry, NIMHANS, said, the information has its positive and negative sides. She informed that patients are using AI as a convenient tool for them to seek solutions.
Experts said people are validating the use of AI as they are not comfortable sharing their personal details with strangers, they fear being judged. The age group that is using AI is between 18-25 years.
Conversation is essential to beat mental health issues. On one hand, it can reduce the load on therapists, but on the other, there is a need to understand and evaluate the process as in the long run, this will have adverse consequences, said ADBS coordinator and principal investigator, NIMHANS, Dr Sanjeev Jain.
Officials in the Karnataka health department said that AI was becoming a challenge for them to reach out to people in peri-urban and rural areas as people are using AI to seek solutions to their problems. 'The solutions AI gives cannot be used for all, as one size does not fit all. The number of people approaching us is less,' said a mental health expert working with the health department.
IISc, Centre for Brain Research experts said, 'Use of AI is affecting the cognitive skills and brain development. Now people are already stressed because of their over-dependence on it.'
Dr Ajit V Bhide, noted consultant psychiatrist and former president of the Indian Psychiatry Society said, it should never be recommended as the first choice, especially when seeking medication.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
29 minutes ago
- Economic Times
Couple follows ChatGPT for travel tips, what happened at the airport was a shock for them and a big lesson for others
Synopsis People are using AI chatbots for guidance. But experts warn against over-reliance. A Spanish couple missed their flight to Puerto Rico. ChatGPT gave them wrong visa advice. In another case, a man was hospitalised. He followed ChatGPT's dietary advice. He replaced table salt with a toxic substance. These incidents highlight the risks of trusting AI blindly. As artificial intelligence (AI) continues to advance rapidly, more people worldwide are turning to chatbots for guidance. However, experts caution against over-relying on AI tools for everyday decisions and problem-solving—a warning highlighted by a Spanish influencer couple's recent mishap. The pair ended up missing their flight after following travel advice from ChatGPT. — BrightlyAgain (@BrightlyAgain) In a viral video, Mery Caldass is seen crying while her boyfriend, Alejandro Cid, tries to comfort her as they walk through the airport. 'Look, I always do a lot of research, but I asked ChatGPT and they said no,' Caldass explained when asked if they needed a visa to visit Puerto Rico for a Bad Bunny concert. She said the chatbot assured them no visa was necessary but failed to mention that they required an ESTA (Electronic System for Travel Authorisation). Once at the airport, airline staff informed them they could not board without it. 'I don't trust that one anymore because sometimes I insult him [ChatGPT]. I call him a bastard, you're useless, but inform me well that's his revenge," she added, suggesting the chatbot held a is not the first time AI chatbot advice has gone wrong. According to a case study in the American College of Physicians Journals, a 60-year-old man was hospitalised after seeking dietary advice from ChatGPT on how to eliminate salt (sodium chloride) from his meals due to health concerns. Following the chatbot's suggestion, the man replaced table salt with sodium bromide—a substance once used in medicines during the early 1900s but now known to be toxic in large doses. Doctors reported he developed bromism as a result. "He had replaced sodium chloride with sodium bromide obtained from the internet after consultation with ChatGPT, in which he had read that chloride can be swapped with bromide, though likely for other purposes, such as cleaning," the report stated.
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
Good, bad and sick
As AI companies delete the health disclaimers, the chatbots are running amok playing doctor, doctor Doctors may be wishing they could return to the good old days of Dr Google. Because Dr AI is much more formidable competition and foe. What's dangerous is how a chatbot super personalises vast amounts of health data and then, via conversational intimacy, seduces the patient to take its advice when what's needed is seeing a real medical professional. In a case reported in Annals of Internal Medicine this month, a man developed bromide toxicity, a rare condition, after consulting ChatGPT about reducing salt in his diet. It advised him to swap sodium chloride with sodium bromide. The thing is, if he hadn't landed in the hospital, this wouldn't have gone on record. Last month, another US study found that compared to more than 26% of chatbot answers to health queries in 2022, less than 1% in 2025 contain some kind of warning about the LLM not being a doctor. This finding is especially troubling as the Stanford and US researchers used the likes of mammograms and chest X-rays to screen for disclaimer phrases. It indicates how much AI companies are encouraging people to use it for health advice. At the GPT-5 launch event, for example, a person spoke about uploading her biopsy results onto it and taking its help to decide whether to pursue radiation. Actual medical advice is not plain pattern matching. It engages with the complexity of individual medical histories and circumstances. AI can be useful in the health sector in many ways. But Indians already pop enough pills prescribed only by their neighbourhood chemist. Substituting professional medical judgement with chatbot advice would worsen their health horribly. GenAI models, even as they become more capable and authoritative, must also use proper disclaimers and safeguard against the dangers of providing diagnosis in place of a doctor. Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email This piece appeared as an editorial opinion in the print edition of The Times of India.
NDTV
21 hours ago
- NDTV
ChatGPT For Weight Loss? How A Wellness Expert Dropped 10 Kg With AI
ChatGPT has been making waves since its launch in 2022. From planning travel itineraries to creating sustainable fitness plans, people are finding ways to integrate the artificial intelligence (AI) tool into their everyday lives. Simran Valecha, a health and weight-loss expert, is among the people who used ChatGPT to create a weight-loss plan. In an old Instagram post, she revealed that she lost 10 kg - all while eating ice-cream - thanks to an AI-created diet plan. Simran Valecha's Weight Loss Prompt That Helped Her Lose Kilos She even shared the prompt that helped her lose weight. "Steal my ChatGPT prompt and create your own weight loss plan," she wrote in the caption. The prompt she used: "I am (height) and I weigh (weight). I want to lose weight in a sustainable manner. Can you please prepare an Indian diet chart for me that includes 3 main meals and 2 -4 snacks. I work (timing: ex, 9-6) job and spend (hours spent travelling)/I work from home. I workout in the (morning/evening/night). My preferences for breakfast include (write your preferences). My preferences for lunch include (write your preferences). My preferences for dinner include (write your preferences)." According to Valecha, the AI-generated meal plan catered to her needs and preferences, making it easier to stick to. She added that AI has changed how we live. "We can all get a diet plan online - I understand that what you actually need to lose weight." 1. Support to actually implement the diet because we understand that every day looks different. 2. Someone to guide you on how to eat at restaurants during your diet. 3. Someone to talk to when you eat a brownie at 2 am because you were stressed. 4. Someone to tell you what to actually do - because every "expert" is offering different opinions on how to lose weight. View this post on Instagram A post shared by Simran - Health, Wellness & Weight Loss Expert (@simvalecha) Is Using ChatGPT For Weight Loss A Good Idea According to Healthline, AI-based fitness plans isn't all bad - but it comes with its limitations. The pros include creating general meal plans and offering basic information, which can be a good starting point. However, the cons are significant: AI can't offer nuanced advice, assess your physical condition, or track your progress. It may even provide outdated or misleading information. Experts suggest that while ChatGPT can be a helpful tool, it should never replace professional medical or nutritional guidance. You should always consult your doctor before making any major lifestyle or dietary changes.
