Deep Dive Podcast: Have rising commercial rents reached a tipping point?
Amid rising rents and growing competition, some Singapore businesses are closing down or relocating to cheaper premises. A local bakery in Siglap recently announced on social media it was moving out after its rent was increased by 57 per cent. Are commercial rent hikes spiralling out of control, or is this simply market forces at work?
Steven Chia and Otelli Edwards speak to Ethan Hsu, head of retail at Knight Frank Singapore, and Terence Yow, managing director of Enviably Me Group of Companies and chairperson of the SG Tenants United for Fairness.
Here is an excerpt of the conversation:
Steven Chia, host:
Is there such a thing as a fair price?
Terence Yow, chairperson of Singapore Tenants United for Fairness (SGTUFF):
For those of us who have been in this business for 15 to 20 years, the benchmark for the rent occupancy to price ratio is about 15 per cent. That means if your shop (makes) $10,000 a month, a good healthy rent would be 15 per cent of that, which is $1,500.
Today, we are seeing rent ratios (ranging) from a healthy range of 20 per cent to an unhealthy range of about 50 per cent or more. Based on our observations, particularly among fellow small business owners, the occupancy cost has dramatically increased.
Steven:
Is there a list that tells us who's paying what and how much they're paying?
Terence:
No. There isn't data on this.
Otelli Edwards, host:
Do you think that the data should be transparent?
Terence:
That is something I've been advocating for a while. Again, I refer back to what we have done for residential units. Today, there is full data transparency (for residential units). You can almost identify which floor of which condo was the last transacted price.
And I would argue that such transparency measures have helped the market. It has helped both developers and buyers. I would strongly advocate for something similar in our sector of the market, although there are quite a few technical difficulties, since these are rentals, not purchases.
Ethan Hsu, head of retail at Knight Frank Singapore:
(But) these are leases and not sales. If it's a sale, then you can caveat because you have an interest in the property that you have purchased.
But once it's a lease, especially if it's a private lease held by a private landlord, it can be (considered) a trade secret. That's because that's how (landlords) price their shops in order to be competitive with the other units.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
an hour ago
- Business Times
CapitaLand Investment expands fund with Japan asset acquisition at 30 billion yen
[SINGAPORE] CapitaLand Investment (CLI) on Monday (Jun 9) announced that it secured additional capital commitments from new and existing institutional investors for its value-add lodging private fund, CapitaLand Ascott Residence Asia Fund II (Clara II). The latest fundraising includes the acquisition of a prime mixed-use asset in Tokyo at more than 30 billion yen (S$267.2 million). This is Clara II's third asset, and its second in Japan. As a result, CLI's funds under management will increase by around S$470 million, as it holds about 20 per cent stake in the fund. 'This reflects the continued strong investor interest in the fund's strategy to reposition under-utilised assets into high-performing living assets in key Asia-Pacific gateway cities,' the company said. Japan is one of Asia's most developed and liquid real estate markets, supported by deep capital pools, said Mak Hoe Kit, CLI managing director of lodging private equity funds. 'Leveraging local enterprise, we secured this off-market opportunity at an attractive entry price,' he added. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up Mak also noted that through their first lodging private fund, they achieved strong performance in Japan with the divestments of two assets at premiums above target returns. Japan's strong tourism rebound further supports the fund's investment strategy. In Tokyo, revenue per available room (RevPar) in 2024 was 43 per cent higher than pre-pandemic levels in 2019, with growth continuing into 2025. Meanwhile, the number of foreign visitors to Japan also surged, rising 28.5 per cent on year to a record 3.9 million in April. The prime mixed-used asset The newly acquired asset is located in Shinjuku, one of Tokyo's most popular districts for shopping, entertainment and business. As part of Clara II's value-add strategy, the property – currently comprising hotel, residential, and ancillary office and retail components – will be upgraded and repositioned into a 179-unit serviced residence managed by Ascott, CLI's lodging business arm. It will be rebranded as Citadines Shinjuku Tower Tokyo and launched in phases from the second half of 2026. The 22-storey building will feature a mix of studio suites and one to three-bedroom apartments, for both short and long-stay guests. It aims to cater to corporate guests on extended stay from nearby offices, as well as domestic and international travellers. In Japan, CLI has a diversified portfolio of more than 70 lodging, office, logistics and self-storage properties across nine cities including Tokyo, Osaka and Nagoya. Shares of CLI closed 0.8 per cent or S$0.02 higher at S$2.56 on Friday.
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
CDL pops after selling South Beach stake to Malaysians; SIA Engineering hits five-year high
CDL's share price rose 8.5 per cent over the week to close at $5.25 on June 6. PHOTO: ST FILE SINGAPORE – City Developments Limited (CDL) popped last week, after it announced it will sell its 50.1 per cent stake in the South Beach mixed project to its Malaysian partner's IOI Properties Group for about $834.2 million. The transaction is expected to result in a gain on disposal of about $465 million for the financial year ending Dec 31, 2025, which will be used to reduce bank borrowings and lower its debt, CDL said on June 4. The company had said in 2024 that it aimed to divest $1 billion in assets, and has announced about $600 million in divestments so far. CDL's share price, which had declined following a public dispute between executive chairman Kwek Leng Beng and his son, chief executive Sherman Kwek, over control of the company's board, rose 8.5 per cent over the week to close at $5.25 on June 6. SIA Engineering hit a five-year high of $2.98 on June 6, outperforming its average target price of $2.71 as investors ploughed into the stock. The aircraft maintenance provider has been a favourite stock pick among analysts, who have begun identifying companies that could benefit from an expected capital infusion into local stocks before the end of the year. As part of an effort to revive the stock market, the Monetary Authority of Singapore will be allocating $5 billion in seed capital to Singapore-based funds for investing in local stocks, and expects to shortlist suitable investment strategies by end-September. Analysts reckon the funds will likely be deployed before the end of 2025. SIA Engineering rose 8.5 per cent through to the week, and closed on June 6 at $2.94. Great Eastern to address share trading suspension Great Eastern Holdings on June 6 finally announced that minority shareholders will be able to vote on the delisting of the insurance company or a resumption of trading, nine months after its shares were suspended from trading on the Singapore Exchange (SGX) due to an insufficient public float of less than 10 per cent. If shareholders vote in favour of delisting, major shareholder OCBC Bank will make a final exit offer of $30.15 per share, valuing the remaining 6.28 per cent it does not own at $900 million. This revised offer represents a 17.8 per cent premium over OCBC's initial offer of $25.60 per share in May 2024. Independent financial adviser (IFA) Ernst & Young has assessed the new offer as fair and reasonable, after previously finding the earlier offer unfair but reasonable. The delisting decision will be made solely by minority shareholders, as OCBC – which already owns 93.72 per cent – will abstain from voting. The proposal requires at least 75 per cent approval at the upcoming extraordinary general meeting. Of the 6.28 per cent of shares that OCBC currently does not own, two prominent shareholder families – the Lees and the Wongs – own a combined 3 per cent. In January, it was reported that OCBC CEO Helen Wong had met them to persuade them to accept the earlier offer, though those efforts were reportedly unsuccessful. The Lee family, which has ties to OCBC's founding, is expected by some to support the delisting. However, if the Wongs choose not to vote in favour, the resolution would require unanimous support from the Lees and the rest of the minority shareholders to pass. If the delisting vote fails, shareholders will then vote on whether to resume trading of Great Eastern's shares. This resolution also requires 75 per cent approval. OCBC will be able to vote on this resolution. Under the trading resumption plan, Great Eastern will carry out a one-for-one bonus issue, giving shareholders a choice of receiving either regular voting shares or Class C non-voting shares. OCBC has indicated that if the delisting does not go through, it will vote in favour of the trading resumption and choose to receive Class C shares, at Great Eastern's request. This move would reduce OCBC's voting stake from 93.72 per cent to 88.19 per cent, restoring the minimum public float required for trading to resume. OCBC has also stated that if the delisting fails and trading resumes, it has no intention of making another offer for the remaining shares. Some analysts view the revised offer positively, noting that it is now considered fair, is in line with peer valuation multiples and offers a 17.8 per cent premium over the earlier bid. However, they also caution that if trading resumes, liquidity in Great Eastern shares is likely to be limited due to OCBC's more concentrated shareholding in the company. Other market movers Units of Keppel DC Real Estate Investment Trust (Reit) rose 2.3 per cent to $2.24 on June 6, after it was announced that the Reit will replace Hong Kong-based conglomerate Jardine Cycle & Carriage on the Straits Times Index (STI), following a quarterly review. The move, which will take effect on June 23, increases the total number of Singapore Reits on the index to eight, and is expected to increase their combined weight in the index to more than 10 per cent. Internet service provider NetLink NBN Trust will replace Keppel DC Reit on the STI's reserve list. The other four companies on the reserve list are CapitaLand Ascott Trust, ComfortDelGro, Keppel Reit and Suntec Reit. Oiltek International, a provider of vegetable oil processing technology, jumped by more than 9 per cent to 60.5 cents on June 6, when it successfully transferred its listing from the Catalist to the SGX mainboard. The company first listed in March 2022 at 23 cents per share. CEO Henry Yong said the move will enable Oiltek to gain greater visibility, liquidity and access to capital. Oiltek International jumped by more than 9 per cent to 61 cents on June 6, when it successfully transferred its listing from Catalist to the SGX mainboard. PHOTO: OILTEK Ms Lee Khai Yinn, a partner at SAC Capital, which was Oiltek's former sponsor, said the company's move to the mainboard is an example of how the Catalist can serve as a platform for emerging firms to scale and succeed. Shares of Singapore Paincare Holdings rallied last week after the Securities Investors Association (Singapore), or Sias, noted that a privatisation offer of 16 cents on May 27 undervalues the stock. Sias noted that Singapore Paincare was listed at 22 cents per share at a premium to its unaudited net asset value per share in July 2020 during Covid-19, when valuations were depressed and the STI was trading at around 2,500. It pointed out that the company should now be valued at a similar premium, at around 36 cents to 37 cents, given that the STI is trading at around 3,900, and 'well-managed healthcare companies generally trade at premiums to their net asset value'. In any case, minority shareholders of Singapore Paincare should wait for a report to be released by an appointed IFA before selling their shares on the open market, said Sias. Shareholders who do sell on the open market will not have recourse if the privatisation offer price is subsequently revised upwards, Sias added. It also reminded shareholders that 'for a delisting to take place, the IFA has to conclude that the offer is both fair and reasonable'. The Catalist-listed counter closed on June 6 at 17.4 cents, up 11.5 per cent through the week. What to look out for this week All eyes will be on US consumer price index data for the month of May, which will be released on June 11. US consumers probably saw slightly faster inflation in May, notably for merchandise, as companies gradually pass along higher import duties, Bloomberg quoted analysts as saying. Despite US President Donald Trump's efforts to pressure the Federal Reserve into quickly lowering interest rates, Fed chairman Jerome Powell has indicated they have time to assess the impact of trade policy on the economy, inflation and jobs market. Join ST's Telegram channel and get the latest breaking news delivered to you.
CNA
an hour ago
- CNA
CNA938 Rewind - Making sense of the $52,000 rental bid for Tampines clinic
CNA938 Rewind The successful bid for the ground floor Tampines clinic unit in Tampines had raised eyebrows in recent days, sparking conversations over rental fees and healthcare costs. Health Minister Ong Ye Kung had also expressed his dismay at the monthly rental bid. Andrea Heng and Hairianto Diman speak with Ethan Hsu, Head of Retail, Knight Frank on how the bidding process works.
