Family welcome prosecution of private prison where inmate died of Covid-19
He was asthmatic and unvaccinated, and died on October 24 that year in the West Lothian prison run by Sodexo on behalf of the Scottish Prison Service, after his health deteriorated.
During the 12-day period, he was not seen by a nurse, and reported being breathless and coughing up significant amounts of blood, it was claimed.
It is alleged that in the last four days of his life, he repeatedly requested medical attention via his cell intercom, to be promised by the prison officers that someone would see him in the morning, but nobody came.
On October 24 2021, he was found dead in his cell, and his death was described as 'agonising' by his family's solicitor, Aamer Anwar.
The family of Calum Inglis including father Alan, second left, mother Jen, second right, and his sister Frances Marr, right (Andrew Milligan/PA)
His family spent three-and-a-half years campaigning for an investigation into his death and participated in both the UK Covid-19 Inquiry and the Scottish Covid-19 Inquiry.
On Wednesday, it was announced that a prosecution of HMP Addiewell would take place, after a meeting between the Inglis family and Lord Advocate Dorothy Bain KC at the Crown Office in Edinburgh.
Following the meeting, Mr Anwar said: 'The family are grateful to the Lord Advocate for giving them hope of justice.
'Today she told them that she has instructed a criminal prosecution of Addiewell prison run by Sodexo Ltd and Lothian health board for their alleged failures to properly manage the medical care of Calum Inglis.
'Today is historic, as it will be the first prosecution of a private prison in Scotland, but also one of the first prosecutions relating to 6,000 Covid deaths reported to the Crown Office, including 15 prison deaths.
'Calum was 34 when he contracted Covid as a prisoner at Addiewell prison in October 2021. He was diagnosed with Covid on October 12, 2021.
'On October 24 2021 he was found lying dead, after being left alone to suffer a slow and agonising death.
'Calum was a much-loved son and brother. His family hope that their love for him, the relentless campaign they have fought for him, will leave a lasting legacy.'
It has taken three-and-a-half years to be here Alan Inglis, father of Calum Inglis
Mr Inglis's sister Frances Marr said: 'It is the best news we could have hoped for.'
His father Alan Inglis said: 'It has taken three-and-a-half years to be here. After the meeting with the Lord Advocate, it is apparent that the investigation was very thorough.
'It's a reflection of that, they have all the information they need to go forward. For that we are grateful.'
He said participating in the inquiries had opened up 'a roller-coaster of emotions' and served as a reminder of 'Calum's circumstances and the way he died'.
Speaking previously outside the Scottish Covid-19 Inquiry, Mr Inglis described the situation as 'barbaric', and said: 'Calum was unvaccinated and was asthmatic.
'Within the next 12 days Calum's health would deteriorate rapidly. Throughout this entire period he was not seen by a nurse.
'He reported being breathless and coughing up significant amounts of blood. In the last four days of his life he repeatedly requested medical attention via his cell intercom, to be promised by the prison officers that someone would see him.
'On October 24 2021, two years today, my son was found unresponsive in his cell. He died alone, without help, without dignity.
Alan Inglis, the father of Calum Inglis, welcomed the announcement (Andrew Milligan/PA)
'The Scottish Covid Inquiry must find out which protocols the prison were following at this time, protocols that would allow such barbaric behaviour to take place, and to examine the staff work culture within that prison where staff must have known how ill my son was, yet did nothing.
'I am looking for accountability and looking to this inquiry to deliver it.'
Ms Bain said: 'I understand the tragic loss felt by Calum's family and their wish to know what happened to him and would like to thank them for meeting with me today to talk about the progress of the investigation.
'I am committed to ensuring that the facts and circumstances surrounding Calum's death are thoroughly investigated by the relevant agencies, fully considered by COPFS and aired in the appropriate legal forum.
'The family and their legal representative will continue to be kept updated in accordance with their wishes.'
A spokesperson at HMP Addiewell said: 'We understand that this continues to be a very difficult time for Mr Inglis's family and our thoughts and condolences remain with them.
'It would be inappropriate to comment further at this stage, but I can confirm that we are continuing to work with all relevant authorities in advance of any future fatal accident inquiry.'
A Scottish Prison Service spokesperson said: 'Our thoughts continue to be with the family and loved ones of Mr Inglis.
'The Scottish Prison Service is fully committed to working with the Scottish Covid Inquiry and supporting it's important work.'
NHS Lothian has been contacted for comment.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Edinburgh Reporter
18 hours ago
- Edinburgh Reporter
Scottish Government appoints new Chief Scientific Adviser
The Scottish Government has appointed a new Chief Scientific Adviser who will take up his new position on 5 August. Professor Calum Semple, OBE, is appointed for an initial three year term. Professor Semple is a Consultant in Paediatric Respiratory Medicine at Alder Hey Children's NHS Foundation Trust and became Professor of Outbreak Medicine and Child Health at the University of Liverpool in 2018. He has helped the UK Government through the Swine Flu pandemic in 2009, and was on the World Health Organisation Scientific Advisory Committee during the Ebola Emergency and as a member of the Scientific Advisory Group for Emergencies during the Covid pandemic. Business Minister Richard Lochhead said: 'Science is the bedrock of our society and economy and at the heart of government decision making. From health to the economy to the environment and everything in between, it is a fundamental part of our everyday lives. 'I am delighted to welcome Professor Semple to the role of Chief Scientific Adviser and look forward to his valuable insight and advice as the Scottish Government continues to work with our world leading science sector to highlight Scotland's strengths as a science nation and ensure it is front and centre of everything we do.' Professor Semple said: 'I am thrilled to have this opportunity to work for the people and government of Scotland, providing evidence and scientific advice to support our policymakers. I particularly look forward to collaborating with Scotland's vibrant communities of scientists and engineers in our schools, universities and industries, who inspire and drive the innovation essential for future economic growth. I will ensure that science and evidence remain at the heart of how we shape a fairer, greener, and more prosperous Scotland. 'I would like to thank my wife, friends, and colleagues at the University of Liverpool and Alder Hey Children's Hospital who support my career and enabled this important appointment. Their encouragement and collaboration have been vital to my journey.' Professor Semple will advise the government with independent scientific advice on 'issues of strategic importance'. He will also have a role in inspiring new scientists and championing the country's leading science and research base. He qualified from Oxford with a PhD in Clinical Virology at University College London and a Bachelor's Tripos in Cell Pathology, immunology and virology at Middlesex Hospital Medical School. He became Consultant in Paediatric Respiratory Medicine at the University of Liverpool and Alder Hey Children's Hospital in 2002. He is also Professor of Outbreak Medicine and Child Health at the University of Liverpool. He will retain these posts although his principal appointment will be with The Scottish Government. He was appointed OBE in 2020 for his contributions to the COVID-19 response and was elected a Fellow of the Faculty of Public Health by distinction in 2022. Like this: Like Related
STV News
18 hours ago
- STV News
Families left 'scrambling' as secure ward to close within weeks
A secure hospital ward for people with complex learning disabilities in North Ayrshire is set to close within weeks, leaving vulnerable patients and their families scrambling to make alternative arrangements. The local health and social care partnership (HSCP) has decided to permanently close Ward 7A at Woodland View hospital from July 14 after the care within the ward 'fell far short of standards and expectations'. The 206-bedroom mental health facility and community hospital near Irvine was built in 2016, and Ward 7A is an eight-bed unit that provides assessment and treatment for patients who have complex learning disabilities and complex mental health needs, often associated with a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder. The ward has experienced 'significant challenges' for several years, according to partnership director Caroline Cameron. 'These challenges are mainly due to delays in discharge for patients to move to more appropriate community settings, an increasingly unsuitable physical environment for our patients, recruitment and retention of staff, and incidences of violence and aggression in the ward,' Ms Cameron said. 'Despite the commitment of our dedicated staff group and clinical team, the care within Ward 7A, Woodland View, has fallen far short of our standards and expectations. 'The challenges in Ward 7A have not improved and it is no longer suitable for patients to remain there.' The decision, announced to families and carers just one month before the ward's date of closure, has left families scrambling to find appropriate alternative accommodation. Fraser Malcolm, who has been in the hospital for four years, is one of the Ward 7A patients who will be impacted. Fraser, now 21, has limited speech and a rare chromosomal condition that affects one out of 85,000 to 100,000 males. STV News Andrew and Karen Malcolm Before he was sectioned, Karen Malcolm, Fraser's mum, described him as a 'very sociable wee person' who was active in the sailing community, well-known at the local horse stables, and 'the heart and soul of the party' on family occasions. The problems started during the Covid lockdowns when 17-year-old Fraser couldn't see family or loved ones and didn't get to do the things he enjoyed. 'We'd reached out to social work quite a few times to ask for help, and their solution was to phone the police,' Karen said. 'Fraser was taken away from home on March 9 by police to Woodland View hospital. We were told he was there for a six-to-12-week assessment. He is still there to this day.' Andrew and Karen have been fighting to get their son out of Woodland View for the past four years. They have a litany of complaints and concerns about the facility and how they've treated Fraser since he was sectioned. Andrew Malcolm, Fraser's dad, said they have raised multiple concerns and asked 'awkward questions' about his treatment in the facility over the years, but said they have been 'shut out'. They say they have only been able to see their son from a window for a year. 'We haven't been in Fraser's room for a year now,' Andrew said. 'We used to hold the NHS in high regard, but I have to say our experience of the HSCP is absolutely shocking. 'You go to hospitals to make people better, but Fraser is considerably worse.' Andrew said the hospital has 'taken away Fraser's basic human rights'. 'He's profoundly deaf; he wears hearing aids, but in Woodland View, he doesn't. They took his hearing aids off of him because on one occasion he put his hearing aids in his mouth. 'He's doing it because there's nothing else to do. His room has nothing in it. He has no TV, no nothing. 'They've put film up on his window so he can't see out. He's in a prison cell. 'He's in there, doesn't know what's happening, can't hear, can't talk, and he comes to his own conclusions about what's happening and what's not happening. He's a very angry, confused young man who needs his family there, and his family's been excluded. 'The whole thing is just staggering. It's going back to the dark ages of institutions. Woodland View is an institution in a modern building. Fraser, along with six other individuals, is stuck in there.' Andrew and Karen said they were finally making progress towards getting Fraser out of Woodland View and into his own house when they received a letter from the partnership, on June 13, warning them that the ward would be closing in four weeks. They had assembled a care team and put together a 'robust 12-week discharge plan' to help Fraser transition. They said that it has all been taken away with the abrupt closure of the facility. 'We now have to compress a 12-week discharge plan into eight days,' Andrew said. The letter said Woodland View would work with families and patients to find 'an alternative placement or another hospital facility where they can receive care as close to home as possible'. While Fraser's family is 'ecstatic' that he's finally leaving the facility, they are extremely concerned about the short timeframe and a lack of transition. 'We want to get Fraser out and keep him out. And that can be done, but not in what is now eight days,' Andrew said. 'The whole thing disgusts me. It makes me really, really angry that we're in this situation. 'I don't think we've slept since we heard the news. We're so concerned about how he's going to react to this. 'I'm hoping something [registers] with him that 'this is better'. We're clinging to the idea that anything is better than where he is now. 'We're elated he's coming out of hospital, we're ecstatic. But he has to stay out of hospital. Without the transition, there's a high risk he may not.' In a follow-up response to the Malcolms, the partnership recognised that the 'situation and timescales are not ideal to support a perfect discharge from hospital, but on a balance of risk, there is no option for Ward 7A to remain open beyond July 14'. Ms Cameron added that the patients in Ward 7A are 'all delayed discharges whose medical input and treatment has ended.' 'These patients are not being cared for in the most appropriate place to meet their health and care needs,' she said. She said the partnership is 'committed to ensuring that people are only in hospital for as long as they require assessment and treatment'. 'Discussions are ongoing with patients, their guardians, staff, and other healthcare professionals, including other NHS Boards and local authorities, to make sure robust discharge plans are in place and implemented.' Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
The Independent
20 hours ago
- The Independent
Study reveals that older adults face longer ER wait times at hospitals
Older Americans are spending more time in emergency rooms than they used to, according to researchers. Boston physicians announced this week that the average length of stay and boarding times for people over the age of 65 had significantly increased between 2017 and 2024. The trends, the doctors note, indicate systemic challenges in hospitals around the country. They also signal an increasingly frustrating and potentially dangerous experience for patients. "Worsening emergency department lengths of stay and boarding contribute to emergency department crowding, reflect systemic health care dysfunction, and, most importantly, harm individual patients," they explained. To reach these conclusions, the doctors used data from 1,633 hospitals and 295 million patients. They analyzed emergency department encounters that were recorded between January 2017 and December 2024. They focused on the proportion of older adults with a length of stay over eight hours and the proportion of admitted patients waiting more than three hours between when they requested a bed and their admission. In 2017, 12 percent of more than 4 million emergency department encounters involved a length of stay over eight hours. By last year, that percentage had surged to 20 percent of more than 12 million encounters. During the same period, encounters involving boarding times over three hours increased from 22 percent of 1.8 million encounters in 2017 to 36 percent of 4.3 million encounters in 2024. The largest increase was reported in academic hospitals, with boarding times over three hours rising from 31 percent in 2017 to 45 percent in 2024. Before Covid, there were small spikes observed in both metrics that were followed by sharper rises during the pandemic's peak. From 2022 to 2024, as more Americans were vaccinated against Covid, both trends slightly declined. The authors suggested that these increases may be driven by several factors, such as increased patient complexity, growing demand, and ongoing staffing and resource shortages. Health care workforce shortages are projected to rise across the U.S. in the coming years, with demand far outpacing supply in some specialties, according to a report from the non-profit National Institute for Health Care Management Foundation. There could be a shortage of as many as 100,000 critical health care workers by 2028, the consulting firm Mercer warned. In recent years, many nurses and doctors have reported feeling burnt out — although burnout rates reportedly aren't as high as they were in the first years of Covid, a study out of Stanford Medicine found. But, emergency room overcrowding is nothing new. A 2022 survey by the American College of Emergency Physicians found that 97 percent of emergency room doctors said they experienced patient boarding times of more than 24 hours, and more than a quarter said patients were forced to stay in the emergency room for more than two weeks before getting a hospital bed. Solutions to this issue aren't yet ironclad. To attempt to fix it, doctors have suggested only treating patients with emergencies, expanding hospital capacity, changing admitting patterns, and making sure patients don't end up in the ER in the first place through enhanced disease prevention. One program started in 2020 set up hospital beds at patients' homes. Without established solutions, the outcomes can be negative for older adults, who make up more than 20 percent of emergency department visits, according to Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data from 2022. "You really don't want an 85-year-old or older patient lingering and sort of stranded in the emergency department for hours and days on end," Dr. Ula Hwang, medical director of geriatric emergency medicine at NYU Langone Health in New York City, told the American Heart Association in May. "It's been shown that if you're an older adult and you board in the emergency department overnight, you are at greater risk for developing delirium, even potentially having an inpatient mortality." The researchers noted that a new measure effective this year limits stays to under eight hours and admissions to within three hours. "Addressing these trends is critical to safeguarding both the health of older adults and the health systems caring for them,' the authors concluded. The findings were announced in a research letter published on Monday in the journal JAMA Internal Medicine.
