Youth homelessness advocate says Budget fails most vulnerable
Photo:
RNZ / Luke McPake
A youth homelessness advocate says this year's Budget delivered
no support for young people
, calling proposed changes to benefit access "cold" and "harsh".
Manaaki Rangatahi Pou Arahi (chief executive) Bianca Johanson told RNZ she was hopeful the Budget would offer targeted relief for Māori and unemployed rangatahi (young people) - but that hope quickly faded.
"We knew there wasn't going to be a lot for Māori," she said.
"But we were hopeful there'd be something for rangatahi, seeing that such a high rate of them are unemployed... but we didn't see any alleviation."
Johanson said, "Māori were ignored in this budget."
"That has been disheartening."
Manaaki Rangatahi is a national youth homelessness collective dedicated to ending youth homelessness in Aotearoa.
It was established in 2018 as a way of consolidating the mahi of different organisations who are also trying to tackle youth homelessness.
Johanson said the sector was seeing the impact of the cost of living crisis, particularly on youth facing housing insecurity - the majority of them Māori.
"For us at Manaaki Rangatahi, we see homelessness, we see a lot of the struggle. People are really hurting."
Minister for Social Development Louise Upston announced in this year's Budget that from July 2027, 18 and 19-year-olds would now have their
Jobseeker and emergency benefits tested
against their parents' incomes.
The policy is forecast to save the government about $163 million over four years, but the income levels parents would be tested against have not yet been decided by Cabinet.
Johanson said the proposed changes were likely to make things harder for the already most vulnerable.
"If the rangatahi is the one that has to do all that advocacy for themselves, go and get their parents' details - this is a very complex situation.
"There are so many people who are the 'working poor' having to support an 18 or 19-year-old on top of all their other expenses. It could actually drive rangatahi out of home."
She fears the proposed changes could create more tension within households and push some youth into harm's way - such as crime and violence.
"I see a lot of these decisions as causing more harm and putting rangatahi and whānau into stressful situations which can create harm. There's no way that this is going to create any kind of unity in the whānau, or support whānau to be together."
"[Māori] are the head of really terrible statistics in Aotearoa - so this Budget and many of the policies that the government have brought forward, aren't exactly addressing them."
She believed kaupapa Māori principles, like manaakitanga, should be at the forefront of decisions made by the government.
"If we're looking at this government and the manaaki that they've shown to Māori, and to rangatahi, it's very absent," Johanson said.
"We see culture as a solution and as a tool of healing. It is what heals our rangatahi in a lot of our youth housing programmes."
Johanson says "youth homelessness is not in a straight line, it's not in a little tiny box," and a more tailored approach is needed to address it.
Photo:
Felix Walton/RNZ
Johanson said as it stood, New Zealand did not have a strategy dedicated to support those that were the most vulnerable - rangatahi impacted by homelessness.
"Rangatahi are our future and we're not investing in the future," she said.
"We are damning our children and our rangatahi, the most vital, important people for our future as a country to what? Living on the streets? To be without work? To have really high mental health and suicide stats? I don't understand the logic."
Upston previously said the purpose of the welfare system was to support those who needed it the most.
"With this announcement, we're clearly saying that 18- and 19-year-olds who don't study or work and can't support themselves financially, should be supported by their parents or guardians, not by the taxpayer."
Johanson believed this response was out of touch.
"It's harsh, it's cold, "she said.
"Most people in Aotearoa want to give others a fair go. But we've got kaumātua and kuia working into their 70s and 80s to survive. We've got rangatahi who've been born into homelessness, who don't know what it's like to have their own bedroom - and now we expect their parents to provide support too?"
Louise Upston
Photo:
RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
In response, Upston said the government was "taking steps to make sure work, training or study is the focus for all young people".
"This government recognises that the welfare system should be available for those who most need it. However, we aren't willing to watch any young New Zealanders get stuck on the benefit," she said.
"Recent forecasts show that people under the age of 25 on Jobseeker Support will spend an average of 18 or more years on a benefit over their lifetimes - 49 percent longer than in 2017. That's why I prioritised Welfare that Works in Budget 2025."
Upston said the "Welfare that Works" package included secure funding for two years of Community Coaches and bonus payments - "giving Jobseekers under 25 years more coaching, an assessment of their needs, an individual plan and holding them accountable for achieving that plan."
In terms of the specific policy settings for the 18-19-year-old initiative, final decisions on the parental assistance test will be made later this year, including settings for access to hardship and supplementary assistance.
"The design of the test is likely to take into account a range of considerations including (but not limited to) parents' income level, nature of relationship with the 18- or 19-year-old and circumstances such as whether the parent or guardian are in hospital or in prison."
Associate Housing Minister Tama Potaka.
Photo:
RNZ / REECE BAKER
Minister for Māori Development and Associate Minister of Housing Tama Potaka said the government was investing in rangatahi Māori through education and housing initiatives.
"The government is investing in rangatahi Māori through the overall increase in education funding as well as the extra investment in Māori education specifically, which includes additional funding for kura, te reo Māori proficiency and training for kaiako [teachers].
"Our aspirations are the same as those shared by many parents across the motu: we want to see all rangatahi make the most of their talents. That's why we're saying 18 and 19-year-olds who aren't working or studying should be supported by their parents or guardians, not the taxpayer."
He said it was "wrong" to say the government did not care about housing for vulnerable young people.
"Our housing policy has lifted hundreds of Māori whānau and tamariki out of dire emergency housing and into better homes. That can mean a world of difference for young people in terms of better health, regular school attendance or maintaining employment."
Johanson was calling for the government to engage with those directly affected.
"We always ask the government to come talk to us before they make some of these quite strange sanctions and expectations on whānau," she said.
"We are the sector experts. Rangatahi are the experts. Come and talk to us."
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
25 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Dearth of Indian-language classes at New Zealand schools
Photo: 123RF Community leaders and educators are calling for greater recognition of Indian languages in New Zealand's public schools. While the Indian population had leapfrogged the Chinese community to become the country's third-largest ethnic group , languages such as Hindi, Punjabi and Gujarati remained largely absent from the public education sector, they said. The 2023 Census recorded 292,092 people who claimed Indian heritage, a 22 percent increase since 2018. According to Stats NZ, Hindi was now the country's fourth most spoken language, while Punjabi ranked ninth. Punjabi also recorded the fastest growth between 2018 and 2023 - an increase of 45.1 percent, Stats NZ said. Despite the growth of the Indian population and rising interest in Asian-language options at public schools , community leaders said opportunities to study Indian languages remained scarce. Rohit Kumar, editor of Hindi literary magazine Bharat-Darshan, said many in the Indian community wanted to preserve and learn heritage languages such as Hindi, Punjabi and Gujarati. However, Indian languages were not consistently offered in public schools and remained far less integrated into many curriculums compared to Māori, Spanish, French, Japanese or Chinese, Kumar said. He said community-run language schools remained the primary places where Indian heritage languages were taught. "These schools often operate on weekends or after hours, run by volunteers, cultural organisations or faith-based groups," Kumar said. "They play a vital role in keeping the languages alive, though access and quality can vary depending on location and resources." Kumar wanted schools to possess structured curricula and standardized teaching resources that would allow young people and bilingual learners to study Indian languages. He said community programs also needed sustained support through funding, teacher training and partnerships with the Ministry of Education. Narendra Bhana, former president of the New Zealand Indian Central Association Photo: RNZ / Blessen Tom Narendra Bhana, former president of the New Zealand Indian Central Association, said a community language school had been running for about 80 years at the Auckland Indian Association's Mahatma Gandhi Centre, offering students opportunities to learn Gujarati and Hindi. "The demand is definitely there," Bhana said. "At the moment, we have nearly 100 kids coming to learn languages and culture every Sunday." However, the school relied entirely on volunteer teachers and received little financial support, Bhana said, noting that this created barriers around teacher availability and limited the supply of teaching materials. Bhana wanted Indian languages - at least Hindi - to be incorporated into the education system. "New Zealand is now a multicultural society, especially Auckland," he said. "We need language options for these children." Navtej Randhawa, a fourth-generation Indian New Zealander from Punjab and a former National Party candidate for Panmure-Ōtāhuhu, called for Indian heritage languages to be taught in public schools. "At present, community-led initiatives are the backbone of heritage language education," Randhawa said. "These spaces are vital, but they are limited in reach and capacity." Randhawa said responsibility for preserving Indian languages had largely fallen to volunteer-run community schools instead of being embedded in mainstream education. "There is no systemic provision by the Ministry of Education for Indian heritage languages, despite the Indian diaspora being one of the oldest and fastest growing in New Zealand, with a history stretching back 135 years," he said. "Without structured support, children are left reliant on informal and under-resourced community efforts. We need meaningful investment and recognition." He said political and community lobbying was key to ensuring Indian languages - and the history of the Indian diaspora - were given their rightful place in New Zealand's multicultural education system. Navtej Randhawa's family migrated to New Zealand in the early 1920s from the Punjab region in India. Photo: Supplied Auckland's Papatoetoe North School currently offers two bilingual Hindi classes for Year 3 to Year 6 students. Principal Stan Tiatia said the availability of heritage-language options reflected community demographics. "The student population is about 50 percent Pasifika, 30 percent Indian or Fijian Indian, and 20 percent Māori," Tiatia said. "The school needs to reflect the community, rather than the other way around. The value of Hindi needs to be developed, given the rise in population of speakers." Tiatia said the value of providing Hindi and other heritage languages in public schools had been a positive learning experience for students, helping them see how heritage-language learning could also support English acquisition. However, he said the school lacked a structured curriculum for Hindi. "There's no support, no resources available for Hindi bilingual education," he said. "So, we've had the access directly from India or try to access what we can locally." Vaughan Couillault, principal of Papatoetoe High School Photo: Supplied Vaughan Couillault, principal of Papatoetoe High School, said the school started offering Hindi classes in response to strong demand from the community more than a decade ago. "I've got a significant Indo-Fijian population at my school," he said. "There was a demand for it." However, he said Hindi was only offered to junior students up to Year 10, as it was not an NCEA subject. "When students get into Years 11, 12 or 13, they're focused on getting the qualifications," he said. "Learning Hindi won't let them do that, because there's no curriculum structure in New Zealand for it. "We could offer it perhaps in Year 11 or Year 12, but students won't take it because it doesn't provide them with a qualification. It actually puts them at a disadvantage from a qualification point of view." Couillault said offering Hindi-language classes to meet community needs had made a real difference, proving valuable for students to earn qualifications in what was, for many, their second language. He said many schools would have trouble finding room in their curriculums to include additional languages. "We haven't got that infrastructure in place at the moment," he said. "But that's the thing about a curriculum - it always has the opportunity to evolve over time." Latest Education Ministry data on secondary school language enrollment showed Japanese remained the most popular Asian language in 2024, with 12,257 students enrolled. Chinese ranked second, with 5415 students, while interest in Korean had continued to grow, doubling since 2017 to reach 166 students in 2024. However, no Indian languages were specifically listed as subjects or NCEA subjects alongside Japanese, Chinese and Korean. Auckland's Papatoetoe North School offers two bilingual Hindi classes for Year 3 to Year 6 students. Photo: Supplied Juliet Kennedy, president of the New Zealand Association of Language Teachers, a nonprofit organisation that advocates for language education, said the group supported the inclusion of Indian languages in school curriculums but noted that several layers of bureaucracy would need to be overcome for this to happen. Kennedy said debate persisted over which Indian languages should be prioritised given the number of options. "Obviously Hindi would be one," she said. "But Punjabi and Gujarati are also widely spoken, so I think they should be included as well." Kennedy said schools nationwide needed to create pathways to include all heritage and community languages in their curriculums. Hayley Welch, acting general manager of Te Poutāhū Curriculum Centre at the Education Ministry, said learning a second language was not compulsory in New Zealand schools but the New Zealand Curriculum included a specific component that focused on learning languages. "There is no requirement for schools to offer a second language," Welch said. "But all schools with students in Year 7 to Year 10 should be working towards offering students opportunities for learning a second or subsequent language." Welch said schools made their own decisions about teaching programs. "Schools usually select languages that suit the interests, resources and needs of the school and community," she said. "The ministry does not collect data on which languages are taught in which schools across the country." Welch said a draft of the refreshed New Zealand Curriculum , including an updated learning languages component, was expected to be available for use and feedback from the fourth term this year, with implementation in all schools planned from 2027. "The ministry remains committed to reflecting New Zealand's diversity in education," Welch said. "We are interested in how the national curriculum might support broader language inclusion in the future, and we welcome ongoing engagement with communities on issues like this."
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
How does name suppression work?
Name suppression laws are back in the headlines this week, after a member of a wealthy family was jailed for possession and importation of child sex abuse material, the 46-year-old was granted permanent name suppression... For many following these cases, name suppression can feel unfair or unjust. So, we thought it would be a good opportunity to get a better idea of how name suppression rules work in New Zealand and how we stack up compared to other countries. Auckland University Law Professor Mark Henaghan joins Emile. To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
RNZ News
2 hours ago
- RNZ News
Watch: Judith Collins and Winston Peters reveal new $2.7b planes and helicopters
The government has revealed the planes chosen to replace the Defence Force's ageing 757s, and a fleet of helicopters to be based on New Zealand's frigates. Defence Minister Judith Collins and Foreign Minister Winston Peters unveiled the plans to purchase five MH-60R Seahawk helicopters to replace the existing maritime fleet, and two Airbus A321XLR aircraft to replace the 757s. The helicopters make up the bulk of the total $2.7 billion expense, costing more than $2b, while the planes account for a $620 million capital cost and four-year operating cost of $80.86m under a six-year lease-to-buy agreement. They would be procured directly through the United States' Foreign Military Sales programme instead of going to a wider tender, with Cabinet to consider the final business case next year. The more than 44-metre Airbus model is a long-range aircraft and can fly 11 hours or 8700km non-stop, can carry up to 9100kg of cargo and up to 244 passengers - but a standard commercial layout would accommodate half that. It can be crewed by just three people, but the usual standard is seven. The nearly 20-metre Seahawks require three crew, can reach speeds up to 333km/h and fly up to 963km, and can carry up to 1500kg. They are armed with an Mk54 anti-submarine torpedo, AGM-114 Hellfire air-surface missiles, crew-served machine guns and Advanced Precision Kill Weapon Systems. Collins said they would "ensure New Zealand has a critical combat capable, interoperable and dependable fleet", with the Seahawks being versatile and adding combat and deterrent capability. "The MH-60R Seahawk is a great aircraft for what New Zealand needs and fulfils our objective of having a more integrated Anzac force, and the new planes will give us reliable aircraft to deploy personnel and respond to international events," she said. "The decision to acquire the extra long range aircraft reflects the importance of having an aircraft capable of such things as returning safely from Antarctica if it is unable to land due to conditions on the ice." Peters said it showed the government was responding to a "sharply deteriorating security environment". "Global tensions are increasing rapidly, and we must invest in our national security to ensure our economic prosperity." In April, the coalition government announced its 2025 Defence Capability Plan , setting out a spending blueprint for the next 15 years. The plan shows a boost in New Zealand's defence spending to $12 billion, $9b of which is new spending over the next four years. The government has committed to reviewing the plan every two years. According to the plan, given the "deteriorating strategic environment", New Zealand's military needs to be "increasingly combat capable, interoperable with our partners, able to act as a force multiplier with Australia, and make the most of innovation which allow us to be more effective". Some of the most expensive projects are replacing maritime helicopters (estimated to cost at least $2b), investment in software (at least $1b), replacing the Boeing 757 fleet (up to $1b), new armoured vehicles (up to $1b), and investment in defence estate assets (up to $1b). Collins has also mentioned uncrewed inflatable boats, drones, and long-range aircraft. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
