Does DC have a crime problem? Trump is right
Trump is right on one thing: America deserves a safe capital. Although it's improving in terms of its crime problem, it is still far from being a safe city. While crime in the district is falling from its post-pandemic peak, and violent crime is even at a 30-year low, the violent crime rate in Washington remains relatively high compared with other states, and the homicide rate is atypically high.
Tell us: In the wake of Trump's federal DC takeover, are you worried about crime? | Opinion Forum
Americans deserve a safe capital city. DC could be safer.
Part of the problem is that many crimes are less often prosecuted in Washington. Even crimes involving weapons are charged at a rate substantially below those of other major cities. Similarly, the district has become less likely to prosecute minors and young adults, according to the Manhattan Institute, a right-wing think tank.
Still, Trump is definitely exaggerating the crime problem to give a pretext for his latest actions, and he will likely end up taking credit for declining crime rates that have already begun to take effect. But that doesn't mean his idea of a crime-free Washington is wrong. I don't think the Trump administration is all that much more capable of running the nation's capital than the city leadership is, but I don't find it offensive that White House officials would try their hand at it.
Opinion: Supreme Court could end race-based voting districts. Good. They're antiquated.
Nor is Washington just another city. It does mean something to be the nation's capital, and representatives of foreign nations who visit are not seeing America's best when they come there. The home of our federal government has no business being among the most dangerous cities in the nation.
Trump's push is more about optics than safety
While Trump's message is right, his push to ramp up federal law enforcement in Washington is more about optics than meaningfully reducing crime.
Having uniformed Drug Enforcement Administration agents patrolling the National Mall and flooding the streets with 800 National Guard personnel sounds great in theory, but Washington's violent crime is concentrated in areas away from the Mall. It's all for show.
Trump can also only take control of the local police force for up to 30 days before needing congressional approval. What he can actually accomplish over the course of a month remains to be seen, but I am skeptical of his ability to enact any lasting change in the coming weeks.
Opinion alerts: Get columns from your favorite columnists + expert analysis on top issues, delivered straight to your device through the USA TODAY app. Don't have the app? Download it for free from your app store.
Temporary supplements from federal law enforcement and the National Guard could even help in the short term, but the problem of more than 800 police officer positions needing to be filled will remain even after those 30 days are up.
And what about filling the 15 vacancies on the Superior Court of the District of Columbia, which handles the city's criminal cases?
In the end, Trump's increased control over Washington is likely to blow over as a typical optics play, with little show in terms of results. He's overstating the problem of crimes and trying to take credit for declines that have already been happening without his intervention. It's just more smoke and mirrors.
Dace Potas is an opinion columnist for USA TODAY and a graduate of DePaul University with a degree in political science.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Evening Standard
3 minutes ago
- Evening Standard
Donald Trump is ‘not a force for good' London Mayor says
However he insisted that he would be 'more than happy to meet President Trump' saying he would seek to show him that it is 'possible to be proud to be a westerner and a proud to be Muslim, that it is possible to be British, and proud to be British, and be of Pakistani origin and be a law abiding citizen and we aren't three headed monsters'.
Western Telegraph
11 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Donald Trump is ‘not a force for good' London Mayor says
Sir Sadiq dismissed jibes that President Trump made against him on a recent visit to Scotland, where he claimed the London Mayor was 'a nasty person' who has 'done a terrible job'. The Labour politician said remarks such as those were 'water off a duck's back'. However, he told an event at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe it sometimes felt like he was 'nine years old again' and 'in the school playground'. But Sir Sadiq, speaking at the Political Party show with comedian Matt Forde, hit back at the US President, saying: 'Somebody who has views like he does about black people, about women, about gays, about Muslims, about Mexicans, thinks I'm nasty. 'Really. He is the leader of the free world, arguably the most powerful man in the world, and really.' He spoke out as he said that records showed since the middle of January this year – when Mr Trump began his second term in the White House – and July 'there have never been more Americans applying to British citizenship and living in London'. The Mayor said: 'So I think Americans have got good taste by and large.' He added that he hoped the President would come to London during his state visit to the UK next month, with Sir Sadiq stressing the 'diversity' of the capital was a 'strength, not a weakness'. Despite his comments about the US President, Sir Sadiq Khan said he would be 'happy' to meet Donald Trump (Jordan Pettitt/PA) Speaking about this diversity, he insisted: 'I think it makes us stronger not weaker, richer not poorer. 'And when President Trump says some of the things he does, it brings from the periphery to the mainstream, views that are potentially dangerous. 'He inadvertently – I'm not going to suggest he does it deliberately – he inadvertently could be radicalising people with views that could lead to them doing things that are dangerous.' He spoke out about fears that minorities 'could be treated less favourably because of the views of the President of the USA' as he accused Mr Trump of 'using London and our diversity as a political football, as a proxy for a culture war'. The London Mayor continued: 'On a personal level, it is water off a duck's back, but we can't run away from the fact that there are some really serious challenges we face as a western society and President Trump, in my view, I speak generally, isn't a force for good.' However he insisted that he would be 'more than happy to meet President Trump' saying he would seek to show him that it is 'possible to be proud to be a westerner and a proud to be Muslim, that it is possible to be British, and proud to be British, and be of Pakistani origin and be a law abiding citizen and we aren't three headed monsters'. The Labour politician said: 'I suspect President Trump may have formed a view of Muslims because of the actions of a small minority of really bad people who are terrorists and use Islam in a perverted way. 'What I would want President Trump to know is that is a very small fraction of Muslims across the globe. 'So if there was an opportunity to meet President Trump, I would be more than happy to do so.'
BBC News
33 minutes ago
- BBC News
Three Republican-led states to send National Guard troops to DC
Three Republican-led US states will send members of their National Guard forces to Washington, DC to bolster the roughly 800 troops President Donald Trump has already deployed to the Virginia Governor Parick Morrisey said he would send 300-400 of the state's National Guard troops at Trump's request. South Carolina will send 200 troops, and Ohio will send 150 military police from their National Guard, their governors declared a "public safety emergency" on Monday, claiming the nation's capitol was gripped by "complete and total lawlessness."Washington DC's elected officials have objected these claims, and hundreds of DC residents marched in protest on Saturday. Agents from several federal law enforcement agencies have spent the week patrolling Washington's most populous and touristed areas alongside the National Guard in Washington DC, where 92% of residents voted for Vice President Kamala Harris in the 2024 election, have expressed frustration with Trump's enforcement have taken to filming federal officers as they patrol and over the weekend, the frustration expanded into peaceful protests against the congregated in Dupont Circle, a central hub in the city, and marched through the streets chanting "Free DC!" Some banged drums and rang bells as they in Washington, DC have expressed concerns about crime in surveys, and a former employee of the Trump administration's Department of Government Efficiency (Doge) was attacked and beaten in the city has painted a portrait of the nation's capital as beset by "violent gangs and bloodthirsty criminals."But Mayor Muriel Bowser has rejected Trump's claims about rampant crime in the city. She acknowledged there had been a spike in crime in 2023 that has since dropped Police Department (MPD) data shows homicides dropped by 32% between 2023 and 2024 and reached their lowest level since data shows violent crime overall is down 26% so far in 2025, compared to the same point in 2024, according to MPD data. Robbery is down 28%, BBC Verify Trump administration initially tried to take command of the city's Metropolitan Police Department using the District of Columbia Home Rule Act, but rescinded the order after city officials took them to Judge Ana Reyes said that Mayor Bowser was required to follow White House directives.
