How AI is infiltrating labor union contracts, in Pittsburgh and beyond
Workers in industries with strong unions, meanwhile, are recognizing the necessity of proactively addressing potential threats AI poses to job security by leveraging their bargaining power.
The key is striking a balance between encouraging employers to adopt new technologies to be competitive and protecting workers from new technologies that could erode workplace safety or job security, said Kim Miller, assistant to the international president of the United Steelworkers (USW).
While workers in some trades are embracing AI, those in more creative fields are cautious about new tools. Union experts told Technical.ly there's no one-size-fits-all approach, but there are key things unions can start doing now, like getting workers to the bargaining table.
'Having workers at the table is very important upfront, and we always encourage that,' Miller said. 'I will say that in the best-case scenario, we are working with the employer well before any technology is implemented.'
USW knows this because, despite 'steelworkers' in its title, the organization's breadth expands far beyond that.
It represents 850,000 workers across North America in industries ranging from metals, mining, rubber, and chemicals to paper, oil refining and more. The union also represents workers in the service, public, healthcare and higher education sectors. Last year, USW expanded its local reach by becoming the representative for over 6,000 faculty at the University of Pittsburgh and then over 1,000 grad students.
Some unions are ready to embrace AI in cases in which it doesn't currently present downsides for represented workers.
'Best-case scenario, we are working with the employer well before any technology is implemented.'
Kim Miller, United Steelworkers
Matt Spence, director of media for the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW), believes AI is benefiting the workers his union represents.
IBEW represents roughly 750,000 workers and has had a presence in Pittsburgh since 1897. Today, electricians are benefiting from the additional work related to maintaining or modernizing energy generation and transmission systems that support large-scale tech projects or energy demands related to AI, Spence said.
Several pro-business groups did not respond to Technical.ly's requests for comment.
Creative fields grapple with AI content takeover
Unions in fields like news, academia and content creation view generative AI as a real threat to job security, fearing it could devalue the work their members create.
Zack Tanner, president of the Newspaper Guild of Pittsburgh, which represents faculty at Point Park University and striking journalists from the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, said AI hasn't yet been part of contract negotiations for the workers he represents since other high-level issues currently take precedent, but 'it's not a matter of if, it's a matter of when.'
While the union does not currently have any formal policies surrounding the use of generative AI in the workplace, Tanner said the Guild has already fought against the replacement of human-made work with AI-generated content.
In the future, Tanner anticipates AI will be addressed on a case-by-case basis.
There have been some AI tools released in the last couple of years, like transcription software or upgrades to Photoshop, that have helped unionized workers do their best work, Tanner said. However, other generative AI tools 'spit in the face' of the time workers have invested in developing their creative skills, he said.
For now, Tanner sees the rise of AI in the workplace as a 'traditional labor battle, just with a brand new technology.'
'[We have to] make sure that our creative input and our work is valued to the extent that it should be,' Tanner said, 'and not let management publish a bunch of AI slop and garbage that hasn't been vetted or edited by somebody that would otherwise have the talent to do such a thing.'
Union strategies can focus on upskilling workers, policy advocacy
Other strategies unions can employ when raising concerns about AI include making sure current workers are upskilled when new technologies are introduced in the workplace and using collective bargaining power to ensure job retention, Miller said.
Along with advocating for retraining programs, workers and unions can push for government policies that protect workers on a national scale, said Lou Martin, a professor and expert on labor and working-class history at Chatham University.
Efforts to strengthen the social safety net for displaced workers have been made before, Martin said. The consequence of automation in the 1950s spurred support for the War on Poverty, ultimately leading to the creation of crucial social support programs like Medicare and the bolstering of Social Security benefits.
'As a society, we should have a more humane policy for displaced workers,' Martin said. 'It's oftentimes people who suddenly lose their livelihood who are the most desperate, depressed, angry, and we just don't need any more people to go through that. So, we should have policies that watch out for these folks and make sure that they have the time and support they need to get through that transition.'
AI is a new frontier — but the conundrum isn't new
Union strategies to protect workers in the face of new technology aren't from an entirely new playbook. Technological changes are constantly changing labor dynamics.
'I think there are a lot of parallels between automation of manufacturing and mining in the 1950s and the potential for AI over the next 10 or 20 years,' Martin said.
During the 1950s, automation was introduced as an opportunity to increase productivity and wages. While it did do that to some extent, automation also caused mass unemployment and layoffs in manufacturing and mining.
This time, white-collar, college-educated, knowledge-based professions might be the most vulnerable to disruptions from AI tools, according to both Martin and Tom Mitchell, a professor at Carnegie Mellon University's School of Computer Science.
AI is not a passing fad; advancements and adoption of the tools will continue, per a November report mandated by Congress on the workforce implications of AI, to which Mitchell contributed. The report also concluded that while it's difficult to predict the exact timeline, nature or specifics of these advances, the impact will be widespread across industries.
The biggest wild card question that remains, Mitchell said, is which jobs will be automated, meaning fully replaced by AI, versus augmented, enhanced or supported by emerging tools.
For example, some toll booth jobs have been fully automated with the rise of computer vision software, while radiologists' work has been augmented by AI systems that analyze X-rays to enhance diagnostic accuracy.
What can workers and unions do, as jobs are redefined by the tasks that AI does better than humans and vice versa? Both Mitchell and Martin say workers should start planning for possible changes now by learning how the tools could be used in their workplace.
'While AI is the conversation of the moment,' said Miller, of USW, 'workplace change and new technologies, this is something that's been kind of a constant in our union for a very long time.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Technical.ly
14 hours ago
- Technical.ly
Pennsylvania government agencies aim to expand employees' use of artificial intelligence
Pennsylvania is pushing to expand the use of artificial intelligence tools in government agencies, and local governments are set to follow suit. For local and state agencies, it's a way to ease the workload by directing artificial intelligence to complete routine tasks that would otherwise take hours — at the cost of tens of thousands of dollars. As Pennsylvania leaders aspire to set the state up as an AI and data center hub, the commonwealth is one of the first states to examine generative AI usage across the state government. The state launched a year-long generative AI pilot program last January, with 175 employees across 14 agencies incorporating ChatGPT Enterprise into their work, including brainstorming ideas or proofreading documents. 'The most frequent uses of ChatGPT among employees in the pilot were tasks like writing assistance, research, brainstorming, and summarizing large amounts of text or data — all of which can be applied broadly across our workforce,' said Dan Egan, communications director for the Office of Administration. The state paid $108,000 for the ChatGPT Enterprise licenses, training, and support for the pilot program. OpenAI even cited Pennsylvania's pilot program in a press release announcing ChatGPT Gov, designed specifically for government use. A majority of employees in the pilot reported a positive experience and saved an average of 95 minutes per day using it — results that encouraged the state to do more with artificial intelligence. 'We want to provide more employees with responsible access to AI-powered tools when those tools can help employees work more effectively and efficiently,' Egan said. 'We are currently exploring ways to expand access to these tools to employees.' He added that training on 'safe and responsible AI use' will be a prerequisite for any state employees to use AI tools. But experts warn that AI, particularly generative AI — which outputs text, images, and even videos based on prompts users put in — poses a host of risks and ethical considerations. Generative AI has a tendency to create falsehoods and present them as facts, a process known as hallucinating. 'You have to understand that generative AI in particular, it can be incorrect,' said Cole Gessner, responsible AI program manager at Carnegie Mellon University's Block Center for Technology and Society. 'You have to treat it almost like it's a summer intern, right? You have to double check its work.' The Block Center advised the state on implementing AI in its pilot program and has worked with government leaders across Pennsylvania. Now, the state Department of Human Services is considering the use of AI. 'The Department of Human Services is exploring opportunities to responsibly use AI to drive efficiencies that promote an employee-first approach,' DHS press secretary Brandon Cwalina said. 'As with any emerging technology, we have policies and oversight in place to guide its responsible use, and we will continue to assess advancements that may support our work.' Currently, the commonwealth's AI policy prohibits using generative AI to make decisions for employees and requires the user to review and verify anything created by generative AI. It also prohibits putting any private data or information into generative AI tools. All state IT policies are reviewed on an annual basis, and the commonwealth's AI policy is set to be reviewed in March. While the state has a policy in place, most local governments don't have specific guidelines for how to handle AI use. Allegheny County is an exception: it's developing an AI policy with hopes of finalizing it this year, said county spokesperson Abigail Gardner. Gov. Josh Shapiro signed an executive order in 2023 establishing standards for generative AI use in state government. It also created a Generative AI Governing Board to oversee policy and implementation. In March, he created a Generative AI Labor and Management Collaboration Group, which takes input from employees and labor representatives when considering AI use in government. 'The Shapiro Administration has consistently emphasized that generative AI is not a replacement for the knowledge and experience of Commonwealth employees,' Egan said. And while the statewide move to incorporate generative AI is new, AI has been used in government for years. Climate modeling, for example, has relied on machines locating patterns and analyzing large data sets, said Cole von Glahn, senior technology policy analyst at the Environmental Policy Innovation Center. 'A lot of what we do in the world relies on deep learning techniques that have been around for a very long time,' von Glahn said. 'The generative AI side of things, I think, is much more experimental. I can see ways in which it can be useful in government. Right now, I'm not convinced that those ways outweigh the risks.' But for some elected officials, artificial intelligence is a promising tool to streamline bureaucratic processes, especially permitting. 'If you think about applying for a permit, it's going to be the same 12 boxes that everybody has to fill out. There are rules about how these things are analyzed by people,' von Glahn said. 'You can translate that to the way the machine would be looking at it.' Rep. Jason Ortitay (R., Allegheny/Washington) hopes to launch a pilot program at a Department of Environmental Protection district office to test how AI could be used to process permit applications. 'It's got to be piloted and it's got to be tried and then trusted before it's adopted on a much broader scale,' he said. 'What you don't want to happen is you implement it and it causes all sorts of chaos, because that's not the whole point of it. The point is to make it better, streamlined, more efficient.' He plans to discuss it with the DEP and Shapiro's office after the state budget is finalized. The Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh is also examining the use of AI to streamline processes, specifically with housing applications. HACP is finalizing a contract with an AI company that partners with public housing authorities, to implement AI in the processing of recertifications. HAPC has around 5,100 tenants and most recertify every two years. The yearlong pilot program is likely to begin this year, said Monty Ayyash, HACP's senior IT director. The HACP approved a payment of around $160,000 for the AI in June with an estimation that it would reduce processing times by up to 50% and backlog by up to 75%. The HACP also launched a one-year pilot of Google Gemini for 60 of its employees in April. So far, employees have mainly used it to optimize communication, such as drafting internal documents or suggesting improvements to emails, Ayyash said. 'We're adding the AI component very conservatively,' he said. 'We are monitoring any sort of behavior that might indicate that it could really challenge the actual day-to-day business operations that our employees are used to doing, so we don't want to stop them from getting their job done in place of learning AI.'
Technical.ly
5 days ago
- Technical.ly
Philly's FORT Robotics lands $19M to scale machine safety platform
Biotech has always been a regional strength, and there's news about wins in that sector, but the Philly ecosystem also saw strong performance that points to other sectors on the rise. Robotics is one: On the heels of last year's Ghost Robotics acquisition and the continuing success of Burro, this month brought an announcement that FORT Robotics added a major chunk to its Series B, upping its total raise to over $60 million. Meanwhile, Dispatch Bio emerged from stealth and announced it had raised $216 million over the last three years. Plus, tech workforce development program Hopeworks received a donation from Dell Technologies to launch AI hubs. Get all the details on the latest money moves below the hiring trends chart. FORT Robotics raises $18.9 million FORT Robotics, which makes wireless functional safety systems for autonomous machines, raised an additional $18.9 million for its Series B round. The Center City company previously raised $25 million for its Series B, in 2022. Since then, the company launched a new hardware system that offers distributed control over internet protocol and wireless networks and allows users to control fleets of machines. It's now expanding its reach to industries beyond agriculture, construction and warehousing, FORT's CEO Samuel Reeves told 'This next period will be all about extending and enhancing our existing platform,' Reeves said. 'Building more comprehensive safety solutions that can continue to displace traditional machine control systems.' The company now has 550 customers, he said, and this additional funding will help increase its operations to support them. Hopeworks partners with Dell to increase AI education Dell Technologies donated equipment to tech workforce development org Hopeworks to launch AI Innovation Hubs at both its Camden and Philly campuses. Hopeworks declined to share the dollar amount of the donation. The hubs include Dell Pro Max workstations, which allows users to run large language models and store large amounts of data, according to Hopeworks CEO Dan Rhoton. The workstations will be infused into all aspects of Hopeworks training, including as a mock interview tool, lessons on how to use AI for productivity and integrating it into its work experience programs. The plan is to open up these AI hubs to other workforce organizations in the city, allowing more people to become familiar with the technology, he said. Dell's support also allowed Hopeworks to start an AI navigators program, where program participants will go out into the community and teach about AI. 'In an AI-powered world, our young adults aren't limited by knowing the right people or going to the right school or knowing how to write an email the right way,' Rhoton said. 'AI can eliminate a lot of those equity gaps.' Dispatch Bio launches with $216B after three years in stealth Biotech company Dispatch Bio emerged from stealth at the end of July, announcing it had raised $216 million since being founded in 2022. The company is developing a treatment for solid tumors, an antigen called Flare that identifies solid tumor cells and directs the body's immune system to those cells. Dispatch announced it closed a second installment of its Series A funding round, raising another $100 million. The company's original Series A closed in 2023 and raised over $100 million, Sabah Oney, CEO of Dispatch, told 'The financing will support Dispatch's growth, further expand its platform capabilities, and advance its first therapeutic candidate into clinical studies through … initial data readout,' Oney said. While the company has a presence in both Philly and San Francisco, 75% of the company's employees and its research and development facility are based in the Philly area, he said. More Money Moves: Global biopharma company AbbVie will acquire cell therapy company Capstan Therapeutics for $2.1 billion. A Penn spinout, Capstan's headquarters is in San Diego, but its research operations are in Philly. Social services organization SEAMAAC was selected to receive a $500,000 grant by Asian Americans Advancing Justice to support digital skills, AI literacy and job readiness training. Exton-based business communications company White Label Communications acquired Grupo NGN, an AI communications platform. Penn Spinout Carisma Therapeutics entered a merger agreement with OrthoCellix. This deal comes shortly after the company laid off most of its staff earlier this year. Statewide digital equity nonprofit KINBER received an ARPA Digital Connectivity Technology Program grant from the PA Broadband Development Authority to distribute 200 laptops to community partners across the state.
Technical.ly
5 days ago
- Technical.ly
2025 AI Horizons Pittsburgh Summit
Date and Time 12:00am Location Bakery Square, Pittsburgh Ticket Information Go to event Event Description The race for AI adoption, commercialization, and market leadership is on. Join the world's leading researchers, innovators, and adopters as we explore how AI is transforming healthcare, manufacturing, defense, finance, robotics, and beyond.
