Hong Kong court begins hearing final arguments in Jimmy Lai's security trial
Mr Lai founded Apple Daily, one of the local media outlets that was most critical of Hong Kong's government.
People wait to enter the West Kowloon Magistrates' Courts (Chan Long Hei/AP)
His high-profile case that has stretched nearly 150 days, far beyond the original estimate of 80 days, is widely seen as a trial of press freedom and a test for judicial independence in the Asian financial hub.
It is unclear when a verdict will be delivered.
Prosecutor Anthony Chau on Monday discussed the security law concerning the collusion charges, arguing the request to impose sanctions must also include officials and not only states.
He planned to lay out other principle issues in the afternoon and make his closing statement Tuesday.
Earlier, prosecutors alleged Mr Lai asked foreign countries, especially the United States, to take actions against Beijing 'under the guise of fighting for freedom and democracy'.
On the first day of his testimony, Mr Lai denied he had asked then-vice president Mike Pence and then-secretary of state Mike Pompeo to take action against Hong Kong and China during the 2019 protests.
When Mr Lai's lawyer questioned him about an Apple Daily report saying he had asked the US government to sanction Beijing and Hong Kong leaders, he said he must have discussed it with Mr Pompeo, as he had no reason to doubt the accuracy of the report by the now-defunct newspaper he founded.
But Mr Lai said he would not have encouraged foreign sanctions after the national security law was enacted on June 30, 2020.
Closing arguments have been delayed twice, first due to weather then to concerns over Mr Lai's health. On Friday, his lawyer, Robert Pang, said Mr Lai had experienced heart palpitations while in prison.
The judges wanted him to secure a heart monitor and medication first.
After Friday's hearing, the Hong Kong government alleged foreign media outlets had attempted to mislead the public about Mr Lai's medical care.
It said a medical examination of Mr Lai found no abnormalities and that the medical care he received in custody was adequate.
When Mr Lai entered the courtroom, he waved and smiled to those sitting in the public gallery and briefly instructed his legal team in a voice audible to public attendees. He closed his eyes at times when the prosecution laid out its legal arguments.
The heart monitor was delivered to Mr Lai and he had no complaints about his health, Mr Chau said.
Mr Lai's years-long detention in solidarity confinement has drawn concerns from foreign governments and rights groups.
US president Donald Trump, before being elected to his second term in November, said he would talk to Chinese leader Xi Jinping to seek Mr Lai's release: 'I will get him out.'
In a Fox News radio interview in August, Mr Trump denied saying he would save Mr Lai, but rather that he would bring the issue up.
'I've already brought it up, and I'm going to do everything I can to save him,' he said.
China has accused Mr Lai of stirring a rise in anti-China sentiments in Hong Kong and said it firmly opposes the interference of other countries in its internal affairs.
Dozens of people waited in the rain on Monday for a seat in the main courtroom to see Mr Lai.
Former Apple Daily reader Susan Li said she worried about Mr Lai's health as he looked visibly thinner and she would continue to pray for him.
'I wanted to let him know we are still here,' she said.
When Hong Kong, a former British colony, returned to China in 1997, Beijing promised to retain the city's civil liberties for 50 years.
But critics say the promise has become threadbare after the introduction of the security law, which Chinese and Hong Kong authorities insist was necessary for the city's stability.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
15 minutes ago
- The Independent
China set to debut new advanced weaponry at massive military parade
China is set to showcase its latest generation of military technology, including advanced unmanned underwater vehicles, during a major parade scheduled for next month. Pictures leaked on Chinese social media showed preparations are already underway in Beijing, where the People's Liberation Army (PLA) will show off a lineup of new land and water-based weapons systems on 3 September to mark the 80th anniversary of Japan's World War II surrender. The parade is likely to be one of the largest in China's history, potentially eclipsing the 2015 parade marking the 70th anniversary. That event involved more than 12,000 soldiers and included international contingents from Russia, Belarus, Mongolia, Cambodia and others nations. Beijing has conducted two large-scale rehearsals this month, on the weekends of 9-10 and 16-17 August, attended by 22,000 and 40,000 people respectively when troops, police and spectators are included. Analysts say next month's parade will be an opportunity for the Chinese government to send a clear signal to its rivals and show off the fruits of an unprecedented programme of military modernisation. Though the event will largely be shunned by Western leaders, many other foreign officials are expected to travel to Beijing to attend after the conclusion of the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) meeting in late August. Xi Jinping, the president and head of the military, will deliver a speech on the occasion, which will feature 'new-type combat capabilities,' including hypersonic weapons and a range of electronic gear, Beijing has announced. Hundreds of aircraft, including fighter jets and bombers as well as ground equipment, some of which have never been seen in public before, will be featured in the parade, military officials said at a press conference. From trucks fitted with devices to take out drones, new tanks and early warning aircraft to protect China's aircraft carriers, military attaches and security analysts say they are expecting China to display a host of new weapons and equipment at the parade. China has the world's largest standing military, with more than 2 million personnel, and an increasingly sophisticated arsenal of missiles, aircraft carriers, and fighter aircraft. Navy power China is likely to display at least two types of extra-large uncrewed underwater vehicles (XLUUVs), according to leaked photos from the parade rehearsals. The vessels, estimated to be around 60ft long, were seen being carried across the city on massive transport vehicles, Naval News reported. Their torpedo-shaped hulls and pump-jet propulsion systems revealed that the underwater vehicles were built to be stealthy. Images showed one of the sea drones being marked as 'AJX002', while another type was photographed only under wraps. Six of the drones were reportedly spotted during the rehearsal. Four matched the AJX002 profile, while two appeared slightly larger. The AJX002 features four lifting lugs along its hull, indicating that it is crane-assisted. China operates the world's largest XLUUV program with at least five distinct types already in the water, Naval News reported. Armoured Vehicles The PLA will showcase its Type 99A main battle tank, which was developed as a replacement for the second-generation Type 88 tank, according to South China Morning Post. The development process for the Type 99 series, also known as the ZTZ-99, began in 1989 based on the design of the Soviet-era T-72 chassis. Weighing at around 55 tonnes, Type 99A tanks are the most advanced variant of the Type 99 series and have been deployed by the PLA since 2011. It features an upgraded 105mm main gun, an enlarged turret, a four-sided radar, and an integrated propulsion system. The main battle tank operates with a crew of three and measures up to 36ft in length. The Type 99A main battle tank is equipped with an advanced targeting system that allows the gunner to engage one target while the commander independently tracks the next, the SCMP reported. Its upgraded fire-control system features a third-generation thermal imager, meteorological sensors, and a ballistic computer—enabling precise engagement of targets at ranges up to 5km. Hypersonic and ballistic missiles A intercontinental ballistic missile system and hypersonic anti-ship missiles are among the advanced weaponry the Communist government will display at the parade. Photos on Chinese social media captured a new anti-ship missile from the YJ series being taken across the city for the parade rehearsals. The new YJ-15 missile was spotted along with the YJ-17, YJ-19 and YJ-20 hypersonic missiles. These sightings indicate China is advancing rapidly in hypersonic weapons technology, a field that has drawn global attention for its ability to evade traditional defence systems. Also visible in the images was a new transporter-erector-launcher (TEL) vehicle carrying a large, tarp-covered missile canister, which could be a new ballistic missile system. The anti-ship missiles and weapons with hypersonic capabilities will be particularly closely watched as the US and its allies prepare to counter China in any future regional conflict. Loyal Wingman An uncrewed combat air vehicle (UCAV), believed to be a Collaborative Combat Aircraft or loyal wingman drone, was spotted on the streets of Beijing during the rehearsals. Experts say the UCAV, which was spotted at the back of a truck, resembles either the Chinese FH-97 or the American YFQ-42A. Andreas Rupprecht, a Chinese military aviation expert, said that the scale of rehearsals alone already exceeds expectations. 'Just focusing on the aviation segment and what China is expected to showcase – the rehearsals for the parade alone are already exceeding everything one could have expected,' he told news outlet Defence Blog. The Victory Lap The 70-minute-long Victory Day parade, comprising 45 contingents of troops, will be surveyed by President Xi at Tiananmen Square alongside Russian president Vladimir Putin, according to reports. Authorities have stepped up security in downtown Beijing since the first rehearsals this month, setting up checkpoints, diverting road traffic and shutting shopping malls and office buildings. In Asia, World War Two ended on 2 September with the surrender of Japan after the US dropped atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in August 1945. Chinese Communist Party historians say China's casualties in the 1937-1945 Second Sino-Japanese War were 35 million. The Japanese occupation caused the displacement of as many as 100 million Chinese people and significant economic hardship, as well as the 1937 Nanjing Massacre, during which an estimated 100,000 to 300,000 victims were killed.
Reuters
16 minutes ago
- Reuters
Hong Kong democrat Jimmy Lai's lawyer defends basic rights in trial's final stretch
HONG KONG, Aug 20 (Reuters) - The lawyer for Hong Kong media tycoon Jimmy Lai argued on Wednesday that supporting individual rights is not a crime in the final stretch of a closely watched and years-long national security trial. Lai, 77, who founded the pro-democracy Apple Daily newspaper, has pleaded not guilty to two charges of conspiracy to collude with foreign forces, and a charge of conspiracy to publish seditious material. He faces a maximum life sentence. The trial is widely seen as a test for judicial independence in the financial hub under national security laws that were imposed by China in 2020 in response to mass pro-democracy demonstrations. Lai, a longstanding critic of the Chinese Communist Party, is one of the most high-profile figures to face prosecution under the law. His trial has been condemned by some countries like the United States as politically motivated. Hong Kong and Chinese authorities say Lai is being given a fair trial. Lai's lawyer Robert Pang, who began his final legal submission on Wednesday, said Lai had been defending and exercising basic rights. "It is not wrong to support freedom of expression. It is not wrong to support human rights," Pang told the three-judge panel that is expected to deliver a verdict later this year once this current round of final legal submissions is concluded after around one week. "It is not wrong to try to persuade the government to change its policy. Nor is it wrong not to love a particular administration or even the country, because ... you can't force someone to think in one way or another," Pang added. One of the judges, Esther Toh, said that this was not what the prosecution argued. "It's not wrong not to love the government, but if you do that by certain nefarious means, then it's wrong," Toh said. Pang also disputed the prosecution's citing of 161 articles published by the Apple Daily between April 1, 2019 and June 4 2021 as seditious, saying they were "insufficient to draw any inference" of a conspiracy. The prosecution alleges that Lai colluded with overseas officials including those in the first Trump administration to impose sanctions or conduct hostile activities against Chinese and Hong Kong authorities, including trade embargoes. Earlier on Wednesday, the prosecution wrapped up its final submission, saying there was "overwhelming evidence" to show Lai was the "mastermind" of the alleged conspiracy to collude with foreign forces. It added that Lai had done nothing to stop illegal activities engaged in by other co-conspirators and through advocacy groups critical of China, such as "Stand With Hong Kong" and the Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China (IPAC). Lai, whose health is fragile according to his family, was provided with a heart monitor and medication after the court was told that he had suffered heart "palpitations". Over 320 people have been arrested under the national security laws so far, including prominent activist Joshua Wong who is serving a 4-year, 8-month prison term for subversion, and now faces a fresh security charge.
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Tommy Robinson's message is bigoted regardless of who supports him
First, Murphy insists that 'both left and right have mishandled' immigration. This is misleading. The left has had no influence on immigration policy for decades. What Murphy calls 'mishandling' on the left is, in practice, grassroots defence of refugee rights and asylum protections. Policy has been entirely shaped by the right, whose governments steadily dismantled the progressive values and legal structures that once enabled newcomers to settle, gain citizenship, and contribute as taxpayers. Labour, since July 2024, have adopted Tory policy wholesale. To pretend this is a problem of 'both sides' is a false equivalence that lets those responsible off the hook. READ MORE: Reform UK hiring staff in London to write Holyrood manifesto Second, Murphy conflates Asian identity with Islam and sets 'Muslims' in opposition to 'LGBT people". This is simplistic and divisive. Asian communities are religiously and culturally diverse; Muslims themselves are not a monolith. To treat them as interchangeable is to erase that diversity. More importantly, Murphy ignores intersectionality. Queer Muslims and LGBT people of colour exist. They face both racism and homophobia, often simultaneously. Any analysis that sets one group against the other misses this lived reality. Third, Murphy tells of four young Muslim men shouting homophobic abuse outside a Manchester gay club, framing it as evidence of imported prejudice. Yet LGBTQI+ people in Britain have faced centuries of harassment from straight white Christians – and 'cultural Christians' – who still moan about being banned from gathering to intimidate women at health clinics in broad daylight. If abuse from four men in a car is treated as more threatening than that, it suggests a racial hierarchy in how prejudice is judged. And while Murphy highlights one incident involving Muslims, he ignores the fact that the vast majority of serious offenders across all crimes in Britain are straight white men. It is also that same demographic which makes up the bulk of mobs outside hotels housing refugees, spurred on by politicians and pundits urging them to see migrants as a threat to 'British values.' READ MORE: I can take on 'climate change denying' Farage in TV debates, says Lorna Slater Fourth, Murphy uses the example of Tommy Robinson's growing online following – including among LGBT people and Black men – to suggest that Robinson's message cannot be written off as 'pure racism.' But the issue is not the diversity of Robinson's supporters; it is the bigotry of his message. Far-right movements have long sought to co-opt grievances across identity groups. That does not legitimise their message; it shows how far-right narratives adapt to exploit fears. Finally, Murphy's silence is deafening where it matters most. The upsurge in anti-LGBTQI+ prejudice in Britain is not 'imported'. It stems directly from right-wing policy and rhetoric, especially the deliberate targeting of trans people. These attacks, now pursued as eagerly by Labour as by the Conservatives, have eroded protections and emboldened prejudice. To attribute fear in LGBT communities solely to migrants, even by citing a no-doubt-frightening experience, is to erase the role of Britain's governing parties in creating the climate of hostility. Murphy is right that refugees like Bella, a transgender teacher from Afghanistan, deserve protection. But unless we are honest about the real sources of threat – homegrown, political, and systemic – appeals to 'balance' risk becoming cover for injustice. Ron Lumiere via email
