Rassie Erasmus doesn't have a first-choice flyhalf: ‘Each one has his strengths'
He said the opposition, game plan for the week and how his bench was split will all determine which No 10 he plays. They all have their own strengths and weaknesses.
The Springboks generally kicked for touch when they won a penalty in their early-season games against the Barbarians, Italy and Georgia. But a traditional approach may be required against tougher opposition in the Rugby Championship, especially when games are tight.
The Springbok flyhalf conundrum
The Springboks won their last match 55–10, against Georgia at Mbombela Stadium, despite starting flyhalf Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu missing four of his five kicks. He was replaced in the second half by Handré Pollard, who was excellent in front of the posts, as always. He nailed all four of his conversions and scored a try.
But Erasmus has opted to start with Feinberg-Mngomezulu or Manie Libbok in most matches lately, using the other player or Pollard from the bench. Pollard only started one of the four games so far, though he played the full 80 minutes against Italy at Loftus.
Feinberg-Mngomezulu and Libbok have been stronger in open play than Pollard, though less dependable in front of posts. The former achieved an 85.7% kicking success rate in the last United Rugby Championship, while his Stormers teammate Libbok recorded 72.6%.
Yet it was Libbok who shone in front of posts in the second Italy Test, coming back from two misses to slotting his next five.
It is somewhat of a conundrum for Erasmus, who was evidently backing Libbok and Feinberg-Mngomezulu's open play, after they shone in the United Rugby Championship. But it is hard to judge the number of potential points they created versus those they lost in front of posts.
Rassie: Using all three makes the team less predictable
'I actually think all three of them are above average in every single department,' Erasmus said. 'Each one has his different strengths. I think it will depend on the opposition.'
He said it would also depend on his forward-back bench split, and he may even employ utility back Damian Willemse.
'It will depend on whether we go a 6–2 split or 7–1 or 5–3. Probably if you go 6–2, someone like Sacha will work lekker, or Damian Willemse. It will depend on what the plan is on the day.
'We don't have a first choice currently. If it was now a semi-final or final, it will be this flyhalf. If it is a running open game and we have a 7–1 split, it will be this guy. Then, if we really want to grind it out, it will be that guy.
'We like to think that doesn't just keep our options open, but it's harder to analyse. Less predictable.'
This article first appeared in The Citizen.
Breaking news at your fingertips… Follow Caxton Network News on Facebook and join our WhatsApp channel.
Nuus wat saakmaak. Volg Caxton Netwerk-nuus op Facebook en sluit aan by ons WhatsApp-kanaal.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The South African
3 hours ago
- The South African
When will Springboks name team to face Wallabies?
After a couple of days off, the Springboks regrouped on Sunday to begin preparing for the back-to-back Test matches against the Wallabies in Johannesburg on Saturday 16 August and Cape Town on 23 August to start the Rugby Championship. There will be great excitement and anticipation for the first team announcement considering that it will provide some genuine insight into the thinking of Rassie Erasmus after plenty of experimenting with selection during the July internationals. Especially after seeing the Wallabies' competitive performances against the British & Irish Lions, Erasmus will surely be planning to bring a number of first-choice players and combinations into the mix for the first Test against Australia. It's expected that the first Springbok team of the Rugby Championship will be named on Tuesday, 12 August, with the exact time still to be confirmed. A recent training camp featured a series of gym and field training sessions, as well as boardroom sessions, and Erasmus said they will delve deeper into the opposition from this week. 'We have laid a good foundation, and next week we will zone more into what we expect from Australia and start developing plans to counter what we expect from them,' he said. 'They showed against the British & Irish Lions what they are capable of, so we need to be ready mentally and physically for what they will throw at us in South Africa.' The matches against Australia will be followed by successive Tests against the All Blacks in Auckland and Wellington (on 6 and 13 September) and Los Pumas in Durban and London (on 27 September and 4 October). 'We had an intense week of conditioning to get the players ready for what will undoubtedly be a challenging Rugby Championship campaign against some of the top teams in the world,' Erasmus added. 'So we are pleased with the strides made and the mind-shift the players made for what will be a completely different contest against Australia, New Zealand, and Argentina. 'We identified a few key areas of our game that we felt we needed to improve on after the Incoming Series, and we incorporated those areas into our training and conditioning blocks this week. 'The teams we will face in the next few months will ask different questions and pose different challenges, so it was important for the group to align on what to expect in the next few weeks, so this camp was vital in ensuring that we prepare adequately for what lies ahead.' Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 0211. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
IOL News
6 hours ago
- IOL News
Sharks will rise again, says JP Pietersen after Currie Cup annihilation at the hands of the Bulls
JP Pietersen is looking for answers after a bruising 64-0 Currie Cup loss to the Bulls at Loftus — the biggest defeat in the rivalry's history. Photo: Backpagepix Image: Backpagepix A proud former Springbok, JP Pietersen cut a disconsolate figure after his Sharks side were smashed 64-0 by the Bulls in a second-round Currie Cup fixture at the weekend. What made it worse was having to sift through the wreckage in search of positives. Sharks director of rugby John Plumtree has tasked Pietersen with treating the Currie Cup as a development platform to unearth players capable of competing in the United Rugby Championship (URC). While that broader vision holds merit, it doesn't make the weekly hammerings any easier to bear. Pietersen has effectively been asked to take boys into battle against men — and it shows. The Sharks have conceded more than 100 points in two games, and the scale of the Bulls' demolition job was the heaviest defeat between the sides in the tournament's history. The bigger challenge is public perception. Sharks fans, largely unmoved by long-term planning, only see the scoreboard — and their frustration is mounting. 'It is a tough one,' Pietersen said with considerable understatement. 'Our chief objective is to develop players. The URC is a long season, and the Sharks want to increase their depth. A number of our players will be away with the Springboks. 'Our opponents over the last two weeks, the Lions and the Bulls, maybe see things differently if you look at their starting line-ups.' The plan, as Pietersen explains, is to find players now who can tour Europe when the URC resumes. 'We have goals to win the URC and/or the Champions Cup,' he said. 'Plum is looking for players capable of touring in the URC after the Currie Cup. Discovering players up to that task is our chief objective.' There were, at least, small flickers of defiance in the closing stages at Loftus. With fears mounting that the Bulls might hit triple figures, the Sharks rallied to stem the bleeding. 'We were better in the final quarter,' Pietersen acknowledged. 'Will we turn it around? I believe we will. There will always be a fight from us. We will have a full crack at the Cheetahs next week in Durban. 'As a coach, you hurt for the players. It is hard to see your players broken in the change room.' Pietersen admitted his side had been physically dominated.
The South African
6 hours ago
- The South African
Stormers trying to poach Springbok from Bulls?
The Stormers are working behind the scenes to bring Springbok tighthead prop Wilco Louw back to Cape Town as a long-term solution to their front row concerns following Frans Malherbe's extended injury absence. The Stormers are reportedly in talks to bring Louw back to the Cape as they search for a top-quality tighthead prop to step into the role vacated by the injured Malherbe. According to Rapport , the franchise is eager to sign Louw before his contract with the Bulls expires in June 2026. The 29-year-old Bok front-ranker, who weighs in at 133kg, is being viewed as a potential long-term anchor for the Stormers scrum as uncertainty remains over Malherbe's playing future. Malherbe has not featured in nearly a year due to a persistent back injury, and while newly capped Springbok Neethling Fouché has stepped into the role admirably, the Stormers are thin on experienced cover in the position. A source close to Louw confirmed to Rapport that discussions are underway. 'Nothing is finalised yet,' the source said. 'He's a family man, but if he returns to the Cape, it'll be for rugby reasons.' Louw previously played for the Stormers from 2015 to 2019, building a strong reputation during his initial stint in Cape Town before moving abroad. He has since returned to South African rugby with the Bulls, where he is currently contracted. What makes the Cape particularly appealing to Louw is his personal connection to the region. He owns a farm in the Cederberg and has family who still live and work in the area, making a move home both practical and emotional. Louw has earned 18 Test caps for the Springboks and is expected to feature in the upcoming Rugby Championship. His experience, size, and scrummaging power would be a valuable asset to the Stormers as they look to remain competitive in the United Rugby Championship and beyond. The Stormers have not made any official statement, but negotiations are understood to be ongoing. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 0211. Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
