
Worth bearing in mind hot-favourite ABs have lost past three to France
There has, fairly, been plenty of noise around the French sending a weakened team to our shores for a three-test series.
And it is, for all the bluff being muttered about the depth of French rugby, a significantly weakened team.
There is no Antoine Dupont — the peerless halfback is injured on top of his usual reluctance to play in the southern hemisphere.
There is also no Romain Ntamack, no Damian Penaud, no Thomas Ramos, no Gregory Alldritt, no Louis Bielle-Biarrey, and no Thibaud Flament.
Remarkably, just two players — captain Gael Fickou and winger Gabin Villiere — remain in the squad from the French team that started the November test against the All Blacks.
Straightforward 50-point victory then, eh?
Hmm.
Not to get all Chicken Little about the situation, because facts are facts, but All Blacks fans might want to keep a few things in mind.
The first — and I am absolutely certain most supporters have either forgotten or blocked this out — is that France have won their past three tests against the All Blacks.
All three of those clashes were in Paris, granted. But a losing streak as much as three against any opposition makes grim reading for any New Zealand rugby team, and there should be some intense motivation to ensure the streak does not reach four.
Secondly, it is a sad reality that the All Blacks have underwhelmed under the Dunedin roof in recent times.
They were given a heck of a fright by an average English team last year — in Scott Robertson's first game as coach — before escaping with a 16-15 win.
They also laboured to a 23-20 win over a depleted Wallabies team in Dunedin in 2023, and of course they were beaten 23-12 by the Irish at the stadium in 2022.
"Underwhelming" was also, broadly speaking, the adjective most commonly used to describe Robertson's first year as coach.
The All Blacks lost four tests last year and seemed to struggle to establish their identity in the post-Ian Foster era.
More is expected this year, and it would be nice if the tone could be set in the Dunedin test, the first for the Dave Gallaher Trophy.
While Robertson — who, to be fair, has consistently said he has never known a bad French team, and that they are dangerous when under-estimated — has shown boldness with some of his selections, he has rewarded players for form.
Highlanders hero Fabian Holland completes the most fantastic fairytale, and Otago No 8 Christian Lio-Willie is rewarded for his consistency with the Crusaders.
There will be much interest in how Rieko Ioane performs back on the wing, whether this could be the start of Billy Proctor cementing his place in the No13 jersey, and what a radically rejigged loose forward trio can do.
This might — again, not to be seen as someone suggesting the sky will fall down — also be an important night for Otago rugby fans.
It seems highly possible this will be the last All Blacks test for a while. Christchurch's fancy new house opens next year, and there will be fewer home tests in both 2026 and 2027.
Make the most of it tonight, just in case.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


NZ Herald
7 hours ago
- NZ Herald
All Blacks vs France: How Jordie Barrett's Irish experience enhances All Blacks comeback
From Dublin to Dunedin, Jordie Barrett is ready to showcase his newfound Irish intelligence. Seven months in Ireland has evolved Barrett's game and, he believes, returned him in better shape than emerging from some taxing Super Rugby campaigns. Barrett arrived home from his successful sojourn with Leinster two weeks ago


NZ Herald
8 hours ago
- NZ Herald
All Blacks vs France: Where the first test will be won
The accuracy and speed demanded by test rugby are a significant step up from the Super scene, which usually requires a period of adjustment. How that quartet channel nerves bubbling within will determine their ability to seize the biggest occasion of their careers. All Blacks debutants Fabian Holland, Christian Lio-Willie, Ollie Norris and Du'Plessis Kirifi. Photo / Photosport Last year, in Scott Robertson's first test as head coach, the All Blacks escaped with a knife-edge one-point victory against England in Dunedin. While the venue is the same, on many fronts this year is different. From the extended management to incumbent players, a vastly greater shared understanding and cohesion is carried through from Robertson's shaky year one to the start of year two. The mood emanating from the All Blacks camp this week is much calmer compared to this time last year. And, of course, there's the significantly weaker opposition… French done before the start line? Averaging 14 test caps per player, and with much of their elite talent left at home following their Top 14 domestic final, there's every reason to suggest France are a puncher's chance at best against the All Blacks. Fabien Galthié has named eight rookies in his 23-man squad for this first test – five in the starting team. They include Bayonne first five-eighths Joris Segonds, loose forward Alexandre Fischer, lock Tyler Duguid, wing Tom Spring and prop Giorgi Beria. South African-born Jacobus van Tonder, Paul Mallez and Regis Montagne will debut off the bench too. Midfielder Gaël Fickou will captain France in Dunedin. Photo / Photosport Gaël Fickou, the classy 94-test veteran, captains the French from the midfield. Toulon wing Gabin Villiere, starting tighthead prop Rabah Slimani (57 caps) and towering lock Romain Taofifenua, who will emerge from the bench, boost overall experience, but there is no escaping the green, developmental French B side. Racing 92 halfback Nolann le Garrec is one to watch in a French backline typically stacked with attacking strike. But after one warm-up match against a heavily depleted English side – due to their extensive British and Irish Lions contingent in Australia – this green team could well be exposed. Tall timber Missing first-choice props Tamaiti Williams and Tyrel Lomax is a blow for the All Blacks. While they won't lack scrummaging power, Ethan de Groot and Fletcher Newell do not boast the same mobility or deft ball skills. The All Blacks should, though, dominate the air. With three locks – Holland, captain Scott Barrett and Tupou Vaa'i, there are no excuses for the All Blacks to not cleanly claim their restarts and lineouts. They should be able to target the French throws, too. Vaa'i, starting his first test at blindside flanker since the opening 2023 World Cup defeat to France in Paris, has trained on the side of the scrum for the past 10 days. Tupou Vaa'i in action against Argentina last year. Photo / Photosport With five loose forwards in their 33-man squad, the All Blacks were always light in this department, with Vaa'i and Barrett designated blindside cover. Few, if anyone, envisioned the All Blacks throwing Vaa'i straight into the No 6 jersey, though. It's unfair to compare anyone with Springboks enforcer Pieter-Steph du Toit, but that is clearly the prototype the All Blacks are seeking with their blindside – a big man capable of commanding the air and imposing a physical imprint around the field. Last year, Vaa'i proved he is evolving into a world-class lock. This weekend, he's asked to broaden his brief to project a modern, mobile, bruising blindside flanker. Injecting impact Finishing what they start sits at the forefront of the All Blacks' improvements this year. The composition of their bench, while inexperienced this week, points to their desire for notable impact. Come the second half, if the French remain in the contest, they will be wary of the power and pace the All Blacks unleash from their ever-evolving bench. Damian McKenzie has a point to prove with Beauden Barrett preferred as starting playmaker. As fatigue sets in, McKenzie will be at his lethal, game-breaking best. When the All Blacks want to lift the tempo further in the closing quarter, Cortez Ratima's speed to the base will be injected. Quinn Tupaea, ahead of his first test in four years, promises to bring the midfield punch he displayed for the Chiefs all season. Quinn Tupaea makes a break against the USA. Photo / Photosport Kirifi's turnover prowess should provide opportunities to pounce on the counterattack against a disjointed defence. He will be itching for his long-awaited debut and must, therefore, harness the same controlled decision-making that typified his leadership with the Hurricanes. Chiefs hooker Samisoni Taukei'aho, returning for his first test since the World Cup final, rookie prop Ollie Norris, Pasilio Tosi and Samipeni Finau round out the quartet of mobile, powerful forwards aiming to add a blend of power and offloading the French may struggle to contain. Liam Napier is a Senior Sports Journalist and Rugby Correspondent for the New Zealand Herald. He is a co-host of the Rugby Direct podcast. For live commentary of this weekend's All Blacks v France test, go to GOLD SPORT or iHeartRadio.


Otago Daily Times
9 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Test fever rises as fans show love for All Blacks
A Dunedin rugby fan is hanging out for an All Blacks win tonight, because "who doesn't love to beat the French?" Rugby fans were out in force at the Wall Street Mall yesterday, waiting in a long line to get a signature from All Blacks Ethan de Groot, Noah Hotham, George Bower, Patrick Tuipulotu and Billy Proctor. Roman, 6, and Ardie, 9, along with their mother Kiri Manuel, were chuffed to get posters and a stuffed bear signed. Roman and Ardie were most excited for a win, and "to see the All Blacks beat the French", Ms Manuel said. "Who doesn't love to beat the French?" Dunedin artist Koryu Aoshima draws a chalk mural of a rooster and a kiwi battling at the Dunedin Railway Station yesterday to celebrate tonight's All Blacks v France test at Forsyth Barr Stadium. PHOTO: GREGOR RICHARDSON At the Dunedin Railway Station, artist Koryu Aoshima was commissioned to do a chalk mural for people arriving by train from Mosgiel. He was drawing a kiwi and a rooster to represent the two teams playing.