Ontario expands pension plan to self-employed doctors previously excluded
Since January, doctors with their own practices have been able to join the same pension plan enjoyed by colleagues who work in hospitals — and bring their receptionists, nurses and any other staff along for the ride to retirement.
Hundreds of self-employed physicians have expressed interest and more than 75 have taken steps to become part of the $123 billion Healthcare of Ontario Pension Plan, also known by its acronym pronounced 'hoop.'
While the opening wasn't created with the troublesome doctor shortage in mind, it can't hurt, says a senior executive.
'If the ability to access the defined-benefit pension like HOOPP is the reason for a physician to set up shop in or stay in Ontario, that's fantastic,' says Rachel Arbour, a lawyer and head of plan benefits, design and policy.
'But we're here to provide really good pensions and retirement for health-care workers, and this is one of the reasons why we looked at growing our plan to physicians,' she adds. 'We believe we play an important role in recruitment and retention. Health-care employers in our province can say to their staff 'we can offer you a great pension.''
The plan boasted a solid
9.7 per cent gain
on global investments last year on behalf of 475,000 members and retirees in health care across the province.
Opening the pension plan to self-employed physicians who have established their own medicine professional corporations and agree to pay a membership fee to the Ontario Hospital Association is the result of years of work and urging from within the health-care sector, including the Ontario Medical Association. The change to include self-employed doctors involved getting approval from Ontario's pension regulator and the Canada Revenue Agency.
The OMA offers a group retirement savings plan to its members — who include 31,500 practicing physicians — but recognizes that many would also like to have a traditional pension plan with defined benefits.
'It has a good track record,' says Kimberly Moran, a chartered accountant and the OMA's chief executive officer, of the HOOPP pension.
While the shortage of an estimated 3,500 family doctors has many root causes,
such as heavy workloads, long days and administrative paperwork
, Moran notes the new pension offering provides 'a little bit of help.'
Recognizing it was politically vulnerable because of the
doctor shortage
, Premier Doug Ford's Progressive Conservatives pledged $1.4 billion in new spending on the eve of Ontario's Feb. 27 election campaign for expanded primary health-care teams, with Health Minister Sylvia Jones acknowledging 'there's no doubt people have been waiting a long time, too long, frankly, to get connected to a family-care practitioner in their community.' Ford has also added more spaces in medical schools and a new medical school is opening at Toronto Metropolitan University in Brampton next fall, but will take years to produce fully trained doctors.
The OMA said 8,600 physicians have retired or left their practices since 2018, meaning two doctors are lost for every three new ones added to the health-care system.
As many jurisdictions around the world compete with each other for med school graduates, more than 750 doctors have reached out to a HOOPP hotline about the pension plan after reading full details posted on the organization's website.
They are encouraged to discuss the prospect of joining with their own financial advisors.
'Every doctor is going to have a slightly different set of circumstances they're going to have to work through and make sure that it makes sense for them,' says Moran.
Aside from paying a membership fee to the Ontario Hospital Association, which would not reveal the dollar value but said the cost is 'modest' for doctors, physicians joining the plan make contributions both as the employer and the employee, based on income. Those contributions are tax-deductible.
'It's about half-and-half in terms of doctors who are sole practitioners and those who have staff with them,' Arbour says. 'We would love the family physicians, their nurses, the receptionist, the whole bucket of people supporting that practice to come into our plan. The longer you're in our plan, the bigger your pension income will be upon retirement.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
06-08-2025
- Yahoo
Ontario, medical association near new compensation deal they say will help retain, recruit family doctors
The Ontario government and the Ontario Medical Association (OMA) say they're close to reaching a new compensation deal for doctors working in family health organizations, which is intended to draw more physicians to family medicine amid a provincial doctor shortage. Both parties say the proposed changes, which would impact roughly 6,500 family physicians, are intended to encourage more doctors to practice or remain in comprehensive family medicine. Negotiations are happening as more than two million Ontarians are without a family doctor. The new model, called FHO+, would allow doctors to bill for administrative tasks that are currently unpaid, on top of clinical tasks, according to the OMA. The Ontario College of Family Physicians says in an average week, doctors spend about 19 hours on administrative tasks, such as filling out forms, charting and reviewing test results. An OMA spokesperson said in an email that the new compensation model "recognizes family physicians are treating patients with increasingly complex conditions, which often require physicians to spend more time completing administrative tasks." "We believe allowing family physicians to bill for this larger administrative workload will attract and retain more of them in Ontario," Julia Costanzo said in the emailed statement. "Our hope is that this new model will enable more Ontarians to [be] able access a family doctor." WATCH | Breaking down Ontario's family doctor shortage: The FHO+ model will also end "negation," the OMA statement said, the practice of financially penalizing a family doctor when a patient of theirs who is part of a family health team goes to a walk-in clinic or an emergency department for non-emergency care. The proposed deal would update the current compensation model, which pays doctors working in the province's 615 family health organizations through capitation. While different doctors are compensated in different ways, most family doctors get an annual payment from the government for every patient on their roster, with payments adjusted for factors like age and patient complexity. Bachir Tazkarji, a family physician and medical director of the teaching unit at Summerville Family Health Team, says he thinks the new deal would make comprehensive family medicine a bigger draw for new doctors. "Physicians are staying away from comprehensive family medicine practice, because they have less compensation, where, if they're working in hospitals or O.R., for example, they get compensated for more of this work," he said, adding that about 15 to 35 per cent of his month is spent doing administrative work. "I would think this [deal] is going to be very attractive and helpful to physicians for a better quality of life, reducing burnout and improving the patient's care, improving the direct contact with patients," he said. Health Minister Sylvia Jones told reporters at an unrelated news conference Wednesday that she would not comment on the details of negotiations with OMA, but that talks have been generally positive. A spokesperson for the Ministry of Health said in an email that the "FHO+ model incentivizes enrolling new patients, promotes shifting procedures to clinics instead of emergency departments, and strengthens incentives for after-hours care to expand access." The proposed deal was sent to arbitration in June, with a ruling expected in the fall. OMA CEO Kimberly Moran says the deal is about 90 per cent agreed upon and would be in place in April 2026 if finalized. She told CBC Radio's Here and Now Wednesday that while it's important doctors are compensated for "the really large and alarming amount of clinical administration time that they're spending," the province also needs to support physicians with teams and artificial intelligence tools that will reduce the work in the first place. "They didn't go to medical school [to be] on their computer. They went to medical school because they like to treat patients," she said. The Ford government has promised to connect every Ontarian to a family doctor or primary care team by 2029.
Yahoo
26-07-2025
- Yahoo
Ontario hospitals are doing more with less, but at a cost
Ontario hospitals have become experts at efficiency in recent years, in part because they have had to. But that has come at a cost, according to a new report from the Ontario Hospital Association (OHA). Among those costs are record waits in emergency departments, a growing number of hospitals facing deficits, and a weakening capacity to deal with surges in demand, according to Anthony Dale, president and CEO of the OHA. Given rising health system pressures, the current situation is not sustainable, says the OHA. 'Over time, the strain on the sector has left hospitals with little ability to expand to manage surges in demand — be it the increasing needs of the population, or the next pandemic,' the report titled: Ontario Hospitals — Leaders in Efficiency warns. Ontario ranks the lowest in Canada when it comes to per capita spending on hospitals. The province spends $1,935 per person. The average spent by other provinces is $2,209. It would cost Ontario $4.4 billion a year to fund Ontario hospitals at that rate, according to the report. Ontario's relatively low per capita spending is often pointed to by critics as a sign that the government is failing to properly support health care, but the Ontario Hospital Association sees some positives in the numbers. Its new report notes that Ontario hospitals have achieved good results for patients while also achieving high levels of efficiency. While there is room for improvement and a clear need for reinvestment, Ontario's health system overall performs well in comparison to other provinces,' according to the report. Hospitals in Ontario have accommodated the 'growing and aging population while facing a shortage of beds' by reducing the need for hospitalizations through greater use of less-invasive, same-day procedures and outpatient services, along with other innovations and quality improvements, according to the report. As a result, the average length of hospital stay in Ontario (in 2023-24) was 6.8 days, the lowest in Canada. The Canadian average was 7.3 days, with Alberta recording an average of 8.0 days and Manitoba recording an average of 10.1 days. But there are limits to how much and how fast lengths of hospital stays can be reduced, warns the report, noting a shortage of home and community care may contribute to a longer stay for some patients. By some key measures, Ontario hospitals outperform hospitals in other provinces, despite the per capita funding differences. Ontario hospitals perform among the best in the country according to a measure that reflects whether hospitals are successful in reducing patient deaths and improving care. By other measures that track how well hospitals are doing, though, there are signs that some improvements could be slipping. Ontario had seen improvement in hospital readmission rates (the percentage of patients who return to the hospital for any reason within a specific time — usually 30 days — after being discharged) until 2022-2023, but rates increased in 2023-2024, giving Ontario a below-average performance. The number of patients who received emergency hip fracture surgery within 48 hours has improved recently in Ontario, but remains below average compared to other provinces. Delaying hip fracture surgery can increase a person's risk of death. The report notes that it will take an investment in a range of health services to maintain the kind of care required. That includes increased and coordinated home care, rehabilitation, long-term care and primary care. Dale said hospitals are proud of their efficiency, 'but you can't count on continuing to harvest significant efficiencies from the hospital sector. We need to turn the page.' Without change, he said, 'the system will find it harder and harder to meet the full needs of the population that expects access to care. Let's stop focusing on a single-minded obsession with efficiency. We have to look at this in a different way'. That includes more funding for innovation as well as giving hospitals a better long-range picture of how big their budgets will be. Additional hospital beds and staffing support will help hospitals, the report says. 'However, what will shape the health system to meet future needs is further investment in research and innovation to change the way hospitals work. It's a necessary next step toward adaptability and to ensure the delivery of both efficient and high-quality care to Ontario's growing and aging communities.' Join us! The Ottawa Citizen is hosting an exclusive food and beverage tasting event where you can try bites from some of the city's best restaurants and sample beverages from breweries and wineries. Meet the chefs and try their signature dishes with members of the Citizen news team. Learn more about Ottawa Citizen Best Restaurants and buy a ticket here. Related Egli: Two nights in hospital showed me we need to do better for our health-care system 'A tax on sick people': Ottawa hospitals have record-breaking year for parking revenue
Hamilton Spectator
14-07-2025
- Hamilton Spectator
Not feeling well? Read this before you Google your symptoms
Don't diagnose yourself. That is the message from Ontario's doctors who are raising awareness that Google doesn't have a medical degree, miracle cures can't be found on TikTok and artificial intelligence (AI) often provides as much misinformation as fact. Alarmed by the rise in do-it-yourself (DIY) medicine , the Ontario Medical Association (OMA) is warning that no matter how real it looks, quizzes can't diagnose illness, influencers don't have quick-and-easy secrets to good health and real harm can come from misdiagnosis, delayed treatment and using medication prescribed to someone else. 'When patients take health into their own hands and they actually implement some of these do-it-yourself treatments or remedies, unfortunately there are often consequences,' OMA president Dr. Zainab Abdurrahman said at a media briefing July 9. 'They can cause unnecessary harms, prolong symptoms or prolong them from actually getting the care they need.' It can be tempting to give in to posts and advertisements that appear to have immediate, accessible answers and are specifically targeted to your social media feeds based on your trends. 'At least one patient out of three will bring up some form of self-diagnosis or self-management,' North Bay psychiatrist Dr. Valerie Primeau said during the briefing. 'People are … looking for quick answers, and the internet is willing to try to provide those answers.' Doctors understand why patients increasingly want to take matters into their own hands at a time when an estimated 2.5 million Ontarians don't have a family physician and specialists can be hard to access. Many people don't have time to seek out medical care because they are working or caring for family members. Some don't trust the medical system or fear interacting with health-care providers. 'It's just so easy to get online and try and get information,' London radiation oncologist Dr. David D'Souza said at the briefing. 'When you're looking for hope, I think some of the things that … appeal to people are things that are all natural, treatments with very few or no unpleasant side effects, or they offer miraculous outcomes.' Doctors say they are now seeing medical DIY from tweens to seniors over age 80. But D'Souza has seen firsthand the danger posed by misinformation and DIY medicine, including delayed care, patients choosing treatment with no evidence behind it or even being convinced to turn away from proven medicine altogether. 'I had a young woman diagnosed with cervix cancer, and she was not ready to accept conventional treatment and decided she was going to pursue other remedies that she had heard about,' D'Souza said. 'She came back two years later, unfortunately, with her disease having progressed and spread and in a lot of pain. Unfortunately, our ability to control her cancer and give her a long-term good outcome was severely compromised.' Misdiagnosis is another major concern of turning to the internet for answers about what is causing symptoms, resulting in unnecessary treatments, undue stress or the real problem going undiagnosed. 'Some of the things that my colleagues and I have seen more in recent years is patients coming to us and saying … 'I saw a video on TikTok and it sounds like I have all the criteria, that must mean that I have this disorder,' Primeau said. 'If you think you have an illness, obviously that will increase anxiety … and you may not actually suffer from an illness.' Self-diagnosis has become a particular problem for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), with quizzes popping up online — many are free, but some require payment — that purport to be accurate. 'We have inattention in general as a society right now, so it's just something that resonates a lot with us,' Primeau said. 'If I ask … 'Have you ever been distracted or had trouble with organization or answering all your emails?' I think most people are going to say, 'Yes,' and this is why I think there is a rising trend to self-diagnose.' But confirming ADHD as an adult requires a deep dive into the past, Primeau said. 'ADHD is a neurodevelopmental illness, and I think people forget that,' Primeau said. 'You technically have to have it in childhood before a certain age, and that is not portrayed in social media.' Some patients have even admitted to trying a friend or family member's medication because they believed they had the same illness. 'It's led to side effects,' Primeau said. 'That can be dangerous.' As the public gets more comfortable with using AI, doctors fear medical DIY will become more common, which is one of the reasons the OMA is raising the issue. 'I have patients now that talk to ChatGPT to get advice and to have a conversation,' Primeau said. 'If we don't address it now and help people navigate this, they will struggle.' The problem with turning to AI is that it provides 'partial truths and partial misinformation,' Toronto endocrinologist Dr. Alyse Goldberg said at the briefing. Online resources also aren't obligated to keep medical information confidential and may not safeguard patient privacy. When looking for medical information online, doctors recommend going to the websites of major hospital networks like Hamilton Health Sciences, St. Joseph's Healthcare or the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health. They also suggest turning to trusted organizations and agencies like the Canadian Cancer Society, Cancer Care Ontario, the Heart and Stroke Foundation of Canada, Public Health Ontario or the OMA itself. 'It's probably difficult for members of the public to distinguish what would be reputable versus not,' Primeau said. 'I would always recommend seeking help from your family physician or a professional.' Doctors say to watch out for claims of cures never seen before or treatments kept hidden from the public. Be wary of overgeneralized videos and quizzes. Remember anecdotes are not the same as clinical trials, and what works for one patient may not be the right fit for another. 'I think in general, it's really hard in the sea of information to tell the difference,' Goldberg said. 'I always recommend (to) bring what you found to your primary care provider or a professional if you're able to, to make sure that you can tell what is appropriate and what isn't.' Doctors say they are now seeing medical DIY from tweens to seniors over age 80. 'We want to ensure that we are talking about this, we are addressing this because it is an important issue,' Abdurrahman said. 'We're going to have more and more people seeing this because social media is so pervasive in our day to day lives.' Error! Sorry, there was an error processing your request. There was a problem with the recaptcha. Please try again. You may unsubscribe at any time. By signing up, you agree to our terms of use and privacy policy . This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google privacy policy and terms of service apply. Want more of the latest from us? Sign up for more at our newsletter page .
