Disability activist Cara Darmody claims law being broken as children 'left to rot' on waiting lists
A schoolgirl who has held protests outside the Dáil for better autism services has claimed the Government is "blatantly" breaking the law and "permanently damaging children".
Cara Darmody, who recently held a 50-hour protest at the gates of Leinster House as part of her years-old campaign, told TDs children are being 'left to rot' on HSE waiting lists to get assessed.
She said that an Assessment of Need (AoN) must be carried out within six months.
Addressing an Oireachtas committee in the Dáil, she said in 93% of cases, children are assessed outside the six-month timeframe.
Under the Disability Act 2005, the HSE is legally obliged to have a child's special needs assessed within six months but it has repeatedly failed to do this over the past 20 years.
Among those affected by special needs resourcing issues are her two severely autistic brothers, Neil — a 12-year-old who was only formally diagnosed as autistic in December 2016 despite being referred by a public health nurse when he was aged around 16 months to local HSE child services as a child of concern — and John.
Cara told members of the Joint Committee on Disability Matters: 'I cannot do anything to change the permanent damage caused to Neil and John.
'But I can advocate to stop damage being done to autistic children in the future. Let's cut straight to the chase — I'm here today to call out the blatant Assessments of Needs law-breaking by the Taoiseach and the Government.
'Three different Taoisigh have made promises to me to fix this issue, and all have dramatically failed.'
Cara, from Tipperary, raised this among other issues when she met Simon Harris when he was taoiseach last year on the first day of protest vigils she held outside the Dáil and the Taoiseach's Office last summer.
The teenager met Micheál Martin in 2022 when he was taoiseach, and also lobbied him to put more resources into special needs assessments and therapies.
Cara, who got 97% in her Junior Cert maths in 2022 to help raise awareness and €82,000 in funding for better services for autism locally and nationally, also lobbied Leo Varadkar, when he was taoiseach.
Her father Mark told the committee that despite raising the issues with Mr Martin again recently and trying to get him to declare a national emergency on the lack of special needs assessments and therapies, he said: 'He doesn't buy into this emergency. He said it was just words.'
He added: 'We are sleepwalking into a disaster."
Read More
Family of Clare boy killed by van challenge decision to bring no charges over death
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
18 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Tariff ‘uncertainties' could ‘weigh heavily' on Irish economic growth
Ireland is the country most exposed to the threat of US tariffs after Mexico and Canada, the OECD said on Tuesday, with exports to the US accounting for close to 20 per cent of GDP. The group's economic outlook says Donald Trump's trade policies will damage consumer and business sentiment in Ireland and could 'weigh heavily' on economic growth if the US administration adds pharmaceuticals to the list of imports subjected to tariffs. The Paris-based organisation also warned that public spending in the Republic is 'surging' as the new Government rolls out measures announced in Budget 2025. While the State's tax revenues remain strong, the impact of Mr Trump's trade agenda could lead to 'weaker' returns, putting pressure on the public coffers. The OECD said these 'looming risks warrant greater fiscal prudence' on the Coalition's part. READ MORE The organisation also warned that mounting uncertainties around tariffs are expected to weigh on consumer and business sentiment and 'restrain business investment and household consumption' in 2025 and 2026. Due to the 'key role of a few foreign-owned multinationals in export-oriented sectors, like pharmaceuticals or advanced computer and business services', it said, new industry-specific tariffs could lower economic growth and 'adversely impact fiscal balances'. In Ireland, GDP group is now projected to come in at 3.7 per cent this year, falling to 2.3 per cent in 2026. Modified domestic demand, which controls for the big distortions arising from the activity of multinationals, is projected to expand by 2.2 per cent in 2025 and 2.1 per cent best year, in 2026, below its long-term average of 2.7. Gloablly. the OECD forecasts global economic growth to slow to 2.9 per cent this year from 3.3 per cent in 2024. It expects the rate of expansion in the US will tumble further, to 1.6 per cent from 2.8 per cent last year – an outlook that is significantly lower than its projection 2.2 per cent in March. Washington's policies have tipped the world economy into a downturn clouded in heightened uncertainty, with the US among the hardest hit, it said in its twice-yearly economic outlook report on Tuesday. 'Weakened economic prospects will be felt around the world, with almost no exception,' chief economist Alvaro Pereira said. 'Lower growth and less trade will hit incomes and slow job growth.' The assessment indicates how Trump's policies have become the most pressing problem for the global economy, with no easy solution in sight. The situation could yet be exacerbated by retaliation from US trading partners, a further erosion of confidence, or another bout of repricing on financial markets, the OECD said. The club of 38 rich countries published its forecasts just as its members' ministers convene in Paris for an annual meeting. Top commerce officials are expected there include US trade representative Jamieson Greer and EU trade commissioner Maroš Šefčovič. Lin Feng, a representative from China's ministry of commerce, is also scheduled to attend. 'Agreements to ease trade tensions and lower tariffs and other trade barriers will be instrumental to revive growth and investment and avoid rising prices,' the OECD said. 'This is by far the most important policy priority.' Yet the organisation also said that even if Trump reversed course on tariffs, the bonus in terms of growth and reduced inflation would not materialise immediately, due to a persistent drag from heightened uncertainty over policy. For the US, the OECD said curbs on immigration and a sizeable reduction in the federal workforce add to the trade-related drag on the economy. It also cautioned that the budget deficit will expand further as the effect of weaker economic activity will more than offset spending cuts and revenues from tariffs. Inflation in the US will also move higher this year, making it likely that the Federal Reserve will not resume easing policy until 2026, according to the OECD. That process may even be derailed if consumer-price expectations get de-anchored, it added. Besides the fallout from global trade, the organisation also warned that fiscal risks are intensifying around the world, with 'tremendous' pressures for more spending on defence, climate and ageing populations. It called for governments to reduce non-essential spending and raise revenues by broadening tax bases. – Additional reporting by Bloomberg
Irish Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
PBP's Paul Murphy joins March to Gaza as Irish people detained on way to protest
People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy will join a Global March to Gaza this weekend to demand that humanitarian aid be allowed through to the population in Gaza'. Mr Murphy flew to Cairo on Thursday and will join a delegation of 50 Irish people. An estimated 3,000 people will be on the march, which is aiming to reach the Rafah Crossing in Gaza by Sunday. However, organisers started to receive reports that people arriving in Cairo to join the march are being detained, with reports of some deportations. Mr Murphy said: 'The organisers of the Global March to Gaza have received reports that about 200 participants have been detained by the Egyptian authorities, including three participants from Ireland. 'This is a peaceful march to Rafah to demand that humanitarian aid be allowed through to the population in Gaza that is being starved by Israel. 'There is no reason why any participant should be detained. 'The Irish government must contact their Egyptian counterparts to insist that participants from Ireland should be permitted to join this peaceful march.' In the Dáil, his party colleague Ruth Coppinger asked Tánaiste and Foreign Affairs Minister Simon Harris to contact Egyptian authorities. He responded: 'I have been discussing this matter with my colleagues in the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade. 'We are monitoring the situation very closely. I have asked for an update from our embassy in Egypt and that our consular section keep me directly updated on these matters. 'The protection and well-being of any Irish citizen in any part of the world is something my Department and the Government takes extremely seriously and I will be keeping a close eye on this.' A spokesperson for the Department of Foreign Affairs confirmed it had been 'contacted by a small number of citizens and is providing consular assistance'. They added: 'As with all consular cases, the Department does not comment on the details of individual cases. 'The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade encourages all travellers to Egypt to consult the relevant travel advice.' Speaking before leaving for Cairo, Mr Murphy told RTÉ's Morning Ireland that the march will be peaceful. He said: 'These are peaceful, pro-Palestine, Palestine Solidarity protests. 'We have clear guidelines on what we're doing. We're not trying to forcibly break through into Gaza or anything like that. 'It is a peaceful demonstration. Unfortunately, we're hearing reports of people being detained at the airport. 'Israel has called on Egypt to stop this peaceful protest, but we're still urging Egypt to allow this to go ahead.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Hip operations uproar leaves Taoiseach in a bind
Year in year out, week in week out, the stories keep coming. Hardly a day passes in Leinster House without at least one TD bringing somebody's personal suffering to the floor of the Dáil in an attempt to ease their pain. The agony of children stuck on waiting lists. The anguish of parents fighting to be heard. Heartbreaking accounts of lives disrupted by a broken system. It's an endless loop of the same story – delays, cancellations, blunders, scandals, oversights, overruns, service shortcomings, miscommunication, non-communication, obfuscation – when all the while patients deteriorate and loved ones protest. READ MORE Inevitably, it seems the only remedy left is to go public – but this time in a political, not a medical treatment, way. The rolling story continued in the Dáil on Tuesday. Another instance of an extremely concerning foul-up in the health service. [ Families whose children had hip surgeries sent letters in advance of report publication Opens in new window ] The Opposition is already calling it a scandal. The Taoiseach couldn't say that. He can't draw any conclusions until he sees the final report, which is imminent. However, the always careful Micheál Martin was concerned enough to say 'the implications are disturbing' if it turns out some of the assertions in a draft report are true. But in the litany of woes forever unwinding in Dáil sessions, the latest one comes with a standout difference. This story comes has a bizarre twist, like a sick joke at the end of a particularly dark tale. Because while the Dáil record is stuffed with contributions from TDs pleading on behalf of constituents desperate to access essential services or languishing on long waiting lists, in some cases waiting for years for vital surgery while in constant pain, the current controversy represents a reversal of the usual problem. The Taoiseach sounded thoroughly fed up with the repeated charge that he was concealing something In a grotesque irony, the uproar is about children having their hip operations in a timely fashion, only for it to emerge that they may not have needed those operations in the first place. The issue was raised by Sinn Féin 's Mary Lou McDonald and Aontú 's Peadar Tóibín during Leaders' Questions. The irony of the situation was not lost on Peadar. 'On a daily basis, families are struggling to get healthcare for their children and the dysfunction in the healthcare system is leading to enormous delays and enormous difficulties for those families. And here we have a situation where families actually manage to get operations for their children and we find out that, in many cases, those operations were unwarranted and unnecessary.' What happened and how? Why did nobody pick up on this? 'There is an excruciating absence of information.' Mary Lou was on the same track. She accused the Taoiseach of 'an absolute lack of clarity' on what took place in the three hospitals concerned. 'You have given neither information nor reassurance to parents,' she told Micheál Martin, accusing him of 'ducking, dodging and diving' and refusing, even now, to give basic information. But the Taoiseach is constrained in what he can say until the audit report into possibly unnecessary hip operations has gone to the Minister. His frustration in the face of stiff Opposition questioning was clear for all to see. 'Nobody is stonewalling and nobody is refusing to give information,' he told her. Later, during the order of business, Pádraig Rice of the Social Democrats , who is the new chair of the Dáil health committee, could see 'a scandal of nearly unparalleled proportions' unfolding as many more children had operations outside the two-year audit period. The number affected could run to thousands. 'Let me ask you, for the third time today, when will the audit be published? And if you can't give us a date or explain the lack of urgency in dealing with this issue, can you tell us how deep does the rot go?' The Taoiseach sounded thoroughly fed up with the repeated charge that he was concealing something. 'Deputy, you said 'for the third time today'. I am not playing politics with this issue, nor should you. And don't be saying things like it's not credible,' he angrily replied, stressing that the audit is rightly independent of the Government . 'So less of the high, self-righteous sort of rhetoric about this.' Micheál was very worked up. He understands the anxiety that parents have when a child needs surgery and that is why a comprehensive and independent investigation that stands the test of time is need. Yet all he was hearing was the Opposition deputies accusing him of trying to hide the truth. 'Of course, we do want to reveal the truth. No holds barred, not holding anything back,' he fumed. It might be alright for them to kick off over a draft report first published by The Ditch, but the Government has to abide by 'legal and proper procedure ... There has to be feedback. That's what happens in audits.' As Micheál protested, Mary Lou accused him of keeping parents in the dark while Pearse Doherty , her deputy leader, kept telling him: 'You haven't a clue what's coming up!' The Taoiseach was truly exasperated. 'It's just unacceptable,' he sighed, that for the Opposition to deliberately politicise an issue which is causing such anxiety to parents. 'I find it reprehensible.'
