Hip operations uproar leaves Taoiseach in a bind
Year in year out, week in week out, the stories keep coming.
Hardly a day passes in Leinster House without at least one TD bringing somebody's personal suffering to the floor of the
Dáil
in an attempt to ease their pain.
The agony of children stuck on waiting lists. The anguish of parents fighting to be heard. Heartbreaking accounts of lives disrupted by a broken system.
It's an endless loop of the same story – delays, cancellations, blunders, scandals, oversights, overruns, service shortcomings, miscommunication, non-communication, obfuscation – when all the while patients deteriorate and loved ones protest.
READ MORE
Inevitably, it seems the only remedy left is to go public – but this time in a political, not a medical treatment, way.
The rolling story continued in the Dáil on Tuesday. Another instance of an extremely concerning foul-up in the health service.
[
Families whose children had hip surgeries sent letters in advance of report publication
Opens in new window
]
The Opposition is already calling it a scandal.
The Taoiseach couldn't say that.
He can't draw any conclusions until he sees the final report, which is imminent. However, the always careful
Micheál Martin
was concerned enough to say 'the implications are disturbing' if it turns out some of the assertions in a draft report are true.
But in the litany of woes forever unwinding in Dáil sessions, the latest one comes with a standout difference.
This story comes has a bizarre twist, like a sick joke at the end of a particularly dark tale.
Because while the Dáil record is stuffed with contributions from TDs pleading on behalf of constituents desperate to access essential services or languishing on long waiting lists, in some cases waiting for years for vital surgery while in constant pain, the current controversy represents a reversal of the usual problem.
The Taoiseach sounded thoroughly fed up with the repeated charge that he was concealing something
In a grotesque irony, the uproar is about children having their hip operations in a timely fashion, only for it to emerge that they may not have needed those operations in the first place.
The issue was raised by
Sinn Féin
's
Mary Lou McDonald
and
Aontú
's
Peadar Tóibín
during Leaders' Questions.
The irony of the situation was not lost on Peadar.
'On a daily basis, families are struggling to get healthcare for their children and the dysfunction in the healthcare system is leading to enormous delays and enormous difficulties for those families. And here we have a situation where families actually manage to get operations for their children and we find out that, in many cases, those operations were unwarranted and unnecessary.'
What happened and how? Why did nobody pick up on this?
'There is an excruciating absence of information.'
Mary Lou was on the same track.
She accused the Taoiseach of 'an absolute lack of clarity' on what took place in the three hospitals concerned.
'You have given neither information nor reassurance to parents,' she told Micheál Martin, accusing him of 'ducking, dodging and diving' and refusing, even now, to give basic information.
But the Taoiseach is constrained in what he can say until the audit report into possibly unnecessary hip operations has gone to the Minister.
His frustration in the face of stiff Opposition questioning was clear for all to see.
'Nobody is stonewalling and nobody is refusing to give information,' he told her.
Later, during the order of business, Pádraig Rice of the
Social Democrats
, who is the new chair of the Dáil health committee, could see 'a scandal of nearly unparalleled proportions' unfolding as many more children had operations outside the two-year audit period. The number affected could run to thousands.
'Let me ask you, for the third time today, when will the audit be published? And if you can't give us a date or explain the lack of urgency in dealing with this issue, can you tell us how deep does the rot go?'
The Taoiseach sounded thoroughly fed up with the repeated charge that he was concealing something.
'Deputy, you said 'for the third time today'. I am not playing politics with this issue, nor should you. And don't be saying things like it's not credible,' he angrily replied, stressing that the audit is rightly independent of the
Government
.
'So less of the high, self-righteous sort of rhetoric about this.'
Micheál was very worked up.
He understands the anxiety that parents have when a child needs surgery and that is why a comprehensive and independent investigation that stands the test of time is need.
Yet all he was hearing was the Opposition deputies accusing him of trying to hide the truth.
'Of course, we do want to reveal the truth. No holds barred, not holding anything back,' he fumed. It might be alright for them to kick off over a draft report first published by The Ditch, but the Government has to abide by 'legal and proper procedure ... There has to be feedback. That's what happens in audits.'
As Micheál protested, Mary Lou accused him of keeping parents in the dark while
Pearse Doherty
, her deputy leader, kept telling him: 'You haven't a clue what's coming up!'
The Taoiseach was truly exasperated.
'It's just unacceptable,' he sighed, that for the Opposition to deliberately politicise an issue which is causing such anxiety to parents.
'I find it reprehensible.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Children making Confirmation asked to include vaping in their abstinence pledge
Children making their Confirmation in Ireland will be invited, from next year, to take an expanded 'pledge'. As well as vowing to abstain from alcohol until adulthood, they would abstain from vaping and smoking. The pledge has long been a rite of passage for 12- and 13-year-olds receiving the Catholic sacrament, traditionally involving a promise to abstain from alcohol and drugs. The development forms part of Church leaders' efforts to encourage children to make healthier lifestyle choices in their formative years. The Irish Bishops' Drugs and Alcohol Initiative, in partnership with the Catholic Primary School Management Association, which provides advice and support to the boards of management of over 2,800 schools, will make a new online module available to all schools whose students wish to take the updated pledge. READ MORE The expanded pledge seeks to honour Matt Talbot who died 100 years ago last week. Talbot was first exposed to alcohol aged 12 and became a heavy drinker before quitting when he was 28 and devoting his life to spirituality. He was described as 'a person of hope, faith, and charity' by Archbishop of Dublin, Dermot Farrell. The Irish Catholic Bishops Conference said that the updated pledge 'supports our young people in terms of physical and mental health, and goes some way to address the concerns of parents regarding new and harmful substances impacting the health and wellbeing of their children'. [ Child-related benefits lift 150,000 children out of poverty, ESRI finds Opens in new window ] Chris Macey, director of advocacy with the Irish Heart Foundation, said such practices 'normalise vaping in the eyes of children'. A ban on the sale of vaping products and e-cigarettes to people under 18 came into effect in 2023. According to a 2024 Growing up in Ireland survey, almost 10 per cent of 13-year olds had tried vaping.
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
The onerous cost of Crohn's disease: ‘It becomes a choice between paying for a utility bill or medication'
People react in different ways to grief, but the day after the death of a close family member, Amy Dennis developed stomach cramps and diarrhoea. Just a teenager at the time, her GP put it down to being bereaved, but the symptoms persisted and the bouts of diarrhoea became a recurring issue that played havoc with her life. As time went on, and her situation didn't improve, it was thought that she could have had an intolerance to gluten – the protein found in grains – but it wasn't until she began to get 'properly sick' that a thorough investigation was undertaken. It was discovered that she had Crohn's disease – a chronic and debilitating digestive condition with lifelong consequences. The condition can require the need for surgery, hospitalisation, immuno-suppressing treatments and higher risks for some forms of digestive cancers. READ MORE 'At the start of 2021, during the second Covid lockdown, I began to lose extreme amounts of weight from both diarrhoea and vomiting,' says the now 23-year-old. 'I went from 84kg down to 48kg in under a year. I was hospitalised for an unrelated issue, but that is when I had more blood tests and a colonoscopy, which led to me being diagnosed with Crohn's disease in December 2022.' [ Inflammatory bowel disease: 'I remember being in primary school and thinking maybe if I skip breakfast, my stomach won't hurt' Opens in new window ] Once diagnosed, living well with this condition is possible, but it does come with a cost, as medication, new dietary requirements and other treatments add up. Crohn's disease and colitis, two types of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD), affect about 40,000 people in Ireland. Research published last month showed that 60 per cent of people living with IBD face 'financial difficulty' as a result of their condition. The report, launched by Crohn's and Colitis Ireland, showed that patients spend an average of €3,252 annually on managing their condition including treatment and dietary needs , while 47 per cent have avoided seeking necessary medical care due to cost. Figures showed 62 per cent reported that taking time off work due to their condition has negatively affected their financial situation 'to some or a great extent'. Costs associated with attending medical appointments also play a significant role. Some 85 per cent said that mileage and travel costs added to their financial burden, 83 per cent had issues with parking fees, 62 per cent with overnight stays for medical appointments, and 49 per cent cited childcare fees as taking a toll financially. Dr Orlaith Kelly, consultant gastroenterologist at Connolly Hospital in Dublin, says Crohn's disease can be diagnosed at any age, but commonly presents in people aged 15-35, with a second wave of diagnoses occurring at 50-60. Treatment is not curative, but can control the disease, which can have very debilitating symptoms. 'Given the age profile of patients, IBD can often impact people when they are ordinarily at the height of their working lives or entering work life or parenthood,' says Dr Kelly. She says that 60 per cent of people living with IBD face financial difficulty directly because of their condition, while almost half have avoided necessary medical care because of the cost. 'In a cost-of-living crisis, for some, often it becomes a choice between paying for school uniforms, a utility bill and maybe forgoing medication or missing an appointment to work to do so,' she says. 'And this has obvious impact on patients' wellbeing and health down the track, possibly resulting in an emergency visit or more hospitalisation when the disease flares or is out of control.' It would be good for us to be able to enrol in the long-term illness scheme, or at least lowering the cost of the drugs payment scheme for us — Amy Dennis Amy Kelly, chief operating officer at Crohn's & Colitis Ireland, urges the Government to 'listen to the needs of the community and to improve access to care in Ireland'. 'This includes including Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis in the chronic disease management programme and expanding medical card eligibility, ensuring equitable access to essential medical care,' she says. 'This inclusion would provide free, structured care, potentially reducing patients' out-of-pocket healthcare expenses through fewer emergency room visits, hospital admissions and lower medication costs.' According to Dr Orlaith Kelly, care for patients should cover access to more IBD physicians and multidisciplinary team members such as specialist nurses, psychologists and surgeons in a more timely and uniform manner across the country. This also includes timely access to intestinal ultrasound, endoscopy and MRI scans when needed and to infusions and theatre slots. 'This requires joined-up thinking at national programme level, provision of adequate resources to assess current needs through accurate data capture and adequate resourcing of this area in hospital and national health budgets,' she says. 'The truth is this type of strategy will in fact save money along with countless improvements in quality of life for the patients by avoiding the long-term complications and [emergency department] visits, which inadequate care or lack of access can so often lead to.' Dennis says this would be a welcome relief for herself and others with IBD. 'It would be good for us to be able to enrol in the long-term illness scheme, or at least lowering the cost of the drugs payment scheme for us,' she says. 'I shouldn't have to choose between putting petrol in my car or getting the food and medication which is necessary to control my condition.'
Irish Times
12 hours ago
- Irish Times
Children's hospital commentary often `ill-informed' contractor BAM tells Minister for Health
The new national children's hospital has attracted 'a great deal of adverse and often ill-informed comment', the chief operating officer of building contractor BAM has told the Minister for Health. In a letter to Jennifer Carroll MacNeill last month, John Wilkinson said 'all necessary resources' were 'being and will be deployed' to the project. The letter comes after the Minister wrote to the BAM Group in April seeking assurances it remained committed and able to meet the agreed programme for the hospital. The correspondence was partially released to The Irish Times under the Freedom of Information (FOI) Act. READ MORE The Oireachtas Public Accounts Committee (PAC) was told last month that BAM had extended the substantial completion date of the hospital from June to September 30th of this year. Patients are now not expected to be treated at the facility until June 2026 at the earliest. David Gunning, chief executive of the National Paediatric Hospital Development Board (NPHDB), the body overseeing the project, told the PAC that BAM had achieved about 60 per cent of its planned progress set out within its programme in the past seven months. In her letter to the company, dated April 15th, Ms Carroll MacNeill also sought assurances for early access to 'necessary areas' of the hospital that are completed to the required standards and finishes to 'support our shared ambition to open this hospital as soon as possible'. She said the NPHDB had informed her officials that actual progress had fallen behind what was required 'in order to meet your own programme, including completion and commissioning of those areas required for early access'. [ Numbers working on children's hospital project dropped by third since January, politicians hear Opens in new window ] In response, Mr Wilkinson said: 'As you will be fully aware, this is a project which has attracted a great deal of adverse, and often ill-informed, comment in the past but I hope that it is now becoming clear that the hospital, once fully completed, will make an exceptionally important and valuable contribution to children's health in Ireland for a long time to come.' Mr Wilkinson said it was 'correct' that actual progress had fallen behind programme. He said since meeting the then minister for health Stephen Donnelly in October 2024, BAM had received more than 60 further change orders and employer's requirements directions 'including several that require substantial additional works to be undertaken'. A change order is a document used to alter the original agreement on a construction project. Mr Wilkinson said under those circumstances 'it is inevitable that the project timeline extends'. 'Notwithstanding the disruption this creates, our project team has worked tirelessly to re-plan the revised work scope and minimise the overall delay, all in the interests of completing the project as early as possible,' he added. Mr Wilkinson also said BAM was committed to allowing Children's Health Ireland early access to the hospital. 'We believe that early access can begin in the coming weeks, if the current positive progress continues,' he said. The latest cost for the project was put at €2.2 billion with building on the site at St James's Hospital in Dublin beginning in 2016.
