South given only their money, cess up 600%: Congress debunks Amit Shah's claim in TNIE interview
On the claim that total allotment to five states in south India under tax devolution during the Narendra Modi government had increased in Grants-in-aid, Praveen Chakravarty reacted saying, "not true."
He further added, "It belonged to the states. That's number one. No one is giving. There's not some of your money that you're transferring over. They're not some rulers here. They're not kings here. Number two, the Union government imposed what's called cess and surcharge."
Praveen Chakravarty further added that the cess and surcharge has gone up 600% in the last 11 years.
"And what does cess and surcharge mean? It means I will keep that money only for the Union government and not share it with the state governments. That's what cess and surcharge means. So they've actually kept more money for themselves instead of giving to states what legitimately belong to the states'
Amit Shah had said that the total allotment to the five states under tax devolution during the Modi government has gone up to Rs 10,96,754 crore from Rs 3,55,466 crore, a 209 per cent increase.
Grants-in-aid now stand at Rs 9,38,518 crore—it was Rs 2,18,053 crore during the UPA. That's a 330 per cent rise. Tamil Nadu saw a 207 per cent growth in tax devolution—from Rs 94,977 crore to Rs 2.92 lakh crore. And grants-in-aid increased by 342 per cent—from Rs 57,924 crore to Rs 2.55 lakh crore.
On the Telangana census, Shah had said: What they are doing in Telangana is a survey. We are doing a census. There is a difference. In Karnataka, they tried, but had to scrap it.
The Congress leader reacted thus, 'He (Shah) said that it was a caste survey in the state not census. I'm the convener of the Telangana consensus committee. I'm writing a 300 page report. I think the question was, I remember, if I remember right, that the Union government announced the caste census on pressure."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
35 minutes ago
- Time of India
Haryana urban local bodies increase financial powers of municipal commissioners and officers
Chandigarh: In a move that has reignited tensions over local governance authority, the Haryana urban local bodies (ULB) department has expanded financial powers for bureaucrats overseeing municipal bodies — sidestepping long-standing demands by elected mayors and council heads for greater administrative control. A notification issued last week grants municipal commissioners and executive officers significantly higher sanctioning authority for development projects, a shift that came just days after a national conference of urban civic bodies in Gurugram called for empowering elected local representatives. For more than a decade, mayors and presidents of municipal councils — many aligned with the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party — have lobbied to approve development works independently. Instead, they now face further marginalisation, with expanded financial control handed to officers and finance committees. "Despite protocol ranking us above senior bureaucrats, we remain at their mercy," said a mayor from northern Haryana, requesting anonymity. In Gurugram, municipal commissioners can now approve development works up to Rs 2.5 crore (previously Rs 50 lakh). Projects worth Rs 2.5-10 crore will require approval from a finance committee chaired by the mayor. Projects above Rs 10 crore and Rs 25 crore will go to the ULB minister and the chief minister, respectively. In other municipal corporations, commissioners can now sanction works up to Rs 1 crore independently. Finance committees can approve up to Rs 10 crore, with larger projects routed to higher authorities in a similar tiered structure. Municipal councils and committees will follow the same slabs as smaller corporations. The move deepens concerns of elected civic heads being reduced to figureheads. "There were cases where mayors were unaware of final work orders despite chairing finance committees," said the northern Haryana mayor.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Land in 2k villages within 15 days: CM Nayab Saini in outreach to Kumhars; assures aid under Rural Industrial Scheme
Chandigarh: Haryana chief minister Nayab Singh Saini on Sunday announced land allocation for Prajapati community in 2,000 villages of the state within 15 days, marking another move by the BJP govt to woo the state's backward classes (A) community. Saini's announcement came during an event to mark the birth anniversary of Maharaja Daksha Prajapati in Bhiwani. The Prajapati community is linked to the Kumhars, who are traditionally associated with pottery and clay work. They make up for 2.7% of the state's population, according to a 2019 estimate. During the day, the CM also inaugurated and laid the foundation stone of 19 projects worth Rs 234.38 crore. This included the inauguration of six projects worth Rs 87.42 crore and the foundation stone of 13 projects worth Rs 147 crore. Saini announced that in the next 15 days, land will be allocated to the Prajapati community in 2,000 villages of the state where panchayat land is available, ensuring the community has access to soil for making earthen pots. Beneficiaries will receive detailed information, including khasra numbers, about the land, he said. The CM also distributed land rights letters to Prajapati community members in Bhiwani. He announced that financial assistance will be provided to the people of the community who start micro-enterprises under the 'Haryana Rural Industrial Scheme'. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Is it legal? How to get Internet without paying a subscription? Techno Mag Learn More Undo Under this, a capital subsidy at the rate of 15% will be given on investment made on machinery and building construction in B, C, and D category blocks of the state. Apart from this, an interest subsidy of 7% per annum on term loans, with a maximum benefit of Rs 8 lakh annually, for a duration of 7 years would also be provided. Saini said the art of crafting clay utensils was a treasured heritage. "Pottery making is not just an art; it symbolizes the artistic vision, skill, and expertise of the Prajapati community," he said. The CM announced Rs 1.29 crore for various works in the Prajapati community dharamshalas across the state.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Tension in Harda as police clash with Karni Sena protesters
Bhopal: Tension gripped Harda district on Sunday after police resorted to lathi-charge, water cannons, and tear gas to disperse Karni Sena Parivar volunteers protesting over the arrest of their leaders. Over 60 members, including national president Jeevan Singh Sherpur, were arrested, prompting authorities to impose prohibitory orders under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS). Considering the situation, police force from nearby districts was also called in. On Sunday morning, volunteers of the organisation blocked a road and staged protests. Police initially tried to disperse the crowd with persuasion. When protesters refused to budge, tear gas shells were fired, and water cannons were used. Police then resorted to baton charge to clear the area. "The situation is under control now. More than 60 people were arrested, and prohibitory orders under Section 163 of BNS were issued," SP Harda Abhinav Chouksey told TOI. He added, "Mild force had to be used to disperse the crowd. The protestors who came from nearby districts were also sent back. Security has been beefed up. Police force from nearby districts were also called upon." Sources said that an office bearer of Karni Sena Parivar, named Ashish Singh Rajput, made a complaint with police earlier that he was defrauded of Rs 18 lakh by accused Mohit Verma and two others. On Saturday, police arrested Mohit Verma and were taking him to court when the volunteers of Karni Sena Parivar allegedly intercepted police and demanded to hand over the accused to them. "They were carrying sticks and seeking custody of the accused," Chouksey said. Sources said that when the situation escalated on Saturday, police arrested Karni Sena district president Sunil Rajput, Ashish Rajput, and two others. Sunday's protest was in response to those arrests, added sources.
