&w=3840&q=100)
Real wages rose most for managers, declined for clerks: CSEP study
Growth in real average annual income between 2017-18 and 2023-24 has been the highest for 'administrators and managers', while wages of 'clerks' have declined, shows the latest paper by private think tank Centre for Social and Economic Progress (CSEP).
The paper, authored by Amaresh Dubey and Laveesh Bhandari, estimated average annual growth in daily real wages for seven occupations for the period.
The data showed real daily wages for 'administrators and managers' grew at an annual average of 6.7 per cent to ₹611.9 in 2023-24 from ₹414.1 in 2017-18.
Wages of 'clerks' declined at an annual average of 1.3 per cent to ₹397.6 from ₹429.7 in the period.
'The most notable increase in annual incomes has been among those classified as administrators and managers. While there is some variation in real growth, the key issue is that overall real wages have not increased significantly for most segments,' the paper read.
In the six-year period, real daily wages for other occupation groups like 'sales and service workers' saw an average annual growth rate of 0.64 per cent to ₹262.5 from ₹252.6, while those of 'agriculture and fishery workers' and 'professionals, associate professionals' grew 0.72 per cent and 0.81 per cent, respectively.
'We believe that this low wage growth, despite high employment growth, is not a temporary anomaly. It is indeed a matter of concern. Although the six-year period is not particularly long, it is not short either. If these trends persist, they could impact not only equity but also long-term economic growth,' the paper said.
The paper shows growth in the real average annual wage of educated Indians has seen a decline during this period.
Real daily wages of 'graduates and above' saw an annual average decline of 0.22 per cent to ₹517.7 from ₹524.6 during this period, and those of 'secondary, higher secondary and diploma holders' also went down by 0.12 per cent to ₹281.1 from ₹283.2.
On the other hand, the average real wages of 'low educated Indians' saw a paltry increase over this period. The data shows that people who are categorised as 'literate but below primary' saw their wages rise by an average of 1.63 per cent during this period, followed by people who are categorised as 'primary educated' (1.10 per cent) and 'not literate' (0.96 per cent).
The study examined the broad patterns of employment emerging in India, utilising datasets from the National Statistics Office (NSO), specifically the Employment and Unemployment Survey (EUS) and the Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS).
Among other findings, the paper showed employment has been increasing steadily throughout the period under consideration, with female employment rising faster than male employment.
It also showed there is relative stagnation in cropping-sector employment, with the non-cropping sector, which includes livestock and higher-value agriculture accounting for two-thirds of employment growth.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Print
4 hours ago
- The Print
India posts current account surplus of USD 13.5 bn in Q4FY25: RBI data
'India's current account balance recorded a surplus of USD 13.5 billion (1.3 per cent of GDP) in Q4:2024-25 as compared with USD 4.6 billion (0.5 per cent of GDP) in Q4:2023-24 and against a deficit of USD 11.3 billion (1.1 per cent of GDP) in Q3:2024-25,' RBI said. However, on annual basis, the current account was in deficit at USD 23.3 billion (0.6 per cent of GDP) during 2024-25, said the 'India's Balance of Payments during the Fourth Quarter (January-March) of 2024-25' released by Reserve Bank of India. Mumbai, Jun 27 (PTI) India posted a current account surplus of USD 13.5 billion or 1.3 per cent of GDP in March quarter 2024-25 as compared with USD 4.6 billion in the year-ago period mainly on account of surge in services exports and higher remittances, according to RBI data released on Friday. Balance of Payments is an indicator of the country's external payment scenario. Merchandise trade deficit at USD 59.5 billion in Q4:2024-25 was higher than USD 52 billion in Q4:2023-24. However, it moderated from USD 79.3 billion in Q3:2024-25. 'Net services receipts increased to USD 53.3 billion in Q4:2024-25 from USD 42.7 billion a year ago. Services exports have risen on a y-o-y basis in major categories such as business services and computer services,' RBI said. Personal transfer receipts, mainly representing remittances by Indians employed overseas, rose to USD 33.9 billion in Q4:2024-25 from USD 31.3 billion in Q4:2023-24. It further said the net outgo on the primary income account, primarily reflecting payments of investment income, moderated to USD 11.9 billion in Q4:2024-25 from USD 14.8 billion in Q4:2023-24. In the financial account, foreign direct investment (FDI) recorded a net inflow of USD 400 million in Q4:2024-25 as compared to an inflow of USD 2.3 billion in the corresponding period of 2023-24. Foreign portfolio investment (FPI) recorded a net outflow of USD 5.9 billion in Q4:2024-25 as against a net inflow of USD 11.4 billion in Q4:2023-24. There was an accretion of USD 8.8 billion to the foreign exchange reserves (on a BoP basis) in Q4:2024-25 as compared to an accretion of USD 30.8 billion in Q4:2023-24. On Balance of Payments (BoP) during 2024-25, RBI said India's current account deficit at USD 23.3 billion (0.6 per cent of GDP) during 2024-25 was lower than USD 26 billion (0.7 per cent of GDP) during 2023-24, primarily due to higher net invisibles receipts. Net inflow under FDI at USD 1 billion during 2024-25 was lower than USD 10.2 billion during 2023-24. During 2024-25, FPI recorded a net inflow of USD 3.6 billion, lower than USD 44.1 billion a year ago. Commenting on the data, Aditi Nayar, Chief Economist, ICRA said while the current account balance expectedly reported a seasonal surplus in Q4 FY2025, the size of the same overshot expectations, amid a surprise dip in primary income outflows in the quarter. Amid expectations of a widening in the merchandise trade deficit as well as a moderation in the services trade surplus in Q1 FY2026 vis-a-vis Q4 FY2025, 'we expect the current account to revert to a deficit in the ongoing quarter', she said. PTI NKD NKD ANU ANU This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
The Hindu
4 hours ago
- The Hindu
U.S. visa hurdles push Indian students toward Germany, Taiwan, and New Zealand
Many Indian students who aspire to study abroad are at a crossroads after the Trump administration increased the scrutiny for issuing student visas. The U.S. is currently taking measures to collect more information from the social media accounts of foreign student visa applicants. It was announced that foreign students applying for a visa must unlock their social media accounts for government review. This condition is extended to all individuals applying for an F, M, or J non-immigrant visa. As these visa rules unfold, students weigh their options in the study abroad market. SEVIS data shows the number of Indian students in the U.S. declining from 2024 to 2025, whereas the number of Indian students enrolling in German universities increased by approximately 67.77% from 2022 to 2025. Taiwan also emerges as a choice for STEM students. The number of Indians going to Russia has increased by 59.1% in 2025 when compared to the figures in 2022. The professor of practice in the Department of Educational Leadership and Higher Education at Boston College, Chris R Glass, writes on his substack, 'I ran an analysis that compares SEVIS data from March 2024 and March 2025. The most dramatic shift is the 27.9 percent decline in Indian students. ' Germany's incentives for international students Roshita Bugatha, a first-year student of the University of Europe in Potsdam, Berlin, says, 'Availing of student visas in the U.S. has become tedious. In Germany, you will receive a 'Resident Permit' card within one year of availing of a student visa. You get work visas for one and a half years, which is way better than the U.S.' Talking about why she chose Germany over the U.S., Ms. Bugatha says, 'The government supports the unemployed by taking care of their rent, insurance, and providing a certain amount for survival. In the United States, the current situation is bad as jobs are not guaranteed.' For many years, European countries served as a second option for those who failed to get into institutions in the United States. Germany is now emerging as a popular destination for Indian students, with the number of enrollments into German universities increasing by 67.77% from 2022 to 2025. The Lok Sabha unstarred question from March 2025 shows that 34,702 Indian students went to Germany as opposed to 20,684 in 2022. This trend has, however, not dawned right now. Tanay Lunkad was preparing for the SAT exams and aiming to study in the United States soon after his Class 12 in 2016. But he changed his mind when he learnt that universities in Germany offer programmes in the English language. He has now completed his master's degree in Sustainable Management at RWTH Aachen University and is currently working in a tech company in Germany. To encourage the intake of international students, Germany offers various courses in the English language. It has also introduced programs in a combination of English and German under a flexible system. Students can opt for learning German in any of the semesters desired by them. Apart from it, various scholarship programs are being offered in the universities that encourage students to learn the German language along with the rich history of Germany. Mr. Lunkad said that the STEM courses have seen an uptick in Germany, as it has a strong foothold in the realms of manufacturing and technology sectors. In recent times, it has attempted to increase its footprint in finance and commerce. 'The education imparted in the German institutions is more practical when compared to the Indian education system. Our premier institutions, namely IITs, are on par with the universities here. Otherwise, we are more theoretical in our framework. This is the main difference between the two education systems,' says Mr. Lunkad. Other destinations The other countries that emerged as the favourite destinations for Indian students are France and New Zealand, according to a report by Arpan Tulsyan, Senior Fellow at the Observer Research Foundation. In 2025, an upward trend was registered when compared with the figures of 2022. The unstarred Lok Sabha question shows that the total number of Indian students in 2022 for New Zealand was 1605, which went up to 7297 in the current year. Likewise, the cumulative figure for France in 2022 was 1605 against 8536 in 2025, as per the Lok Sabha unstarred question from March this year. 'Although European countries such as France and Germany offer programs in English to attract international students, the job market acts quite differently. Preferences are given to those who are fluent in German or French, as it is considered important to integrate and socialise in the workplace', says Mr. Lunkad. Students have started learning German and French before visiting these countries. 'The clamour for these new destinations arises from Tier One and Tier Two cities. A majority of the crowd is drawn from states such as Kerala, Karnataka, Gujarat, and Maharashtra,' said Sumit Bothra, an education consultant. 'The popular courses in these countries are Engineering, Medicine, Finance, and Marketing. France is not a sought-after destination for STEM students and witnesses a student crowd for their Master's in business administration at their premier institutions. Engineering and production are sought-after jobs in Germany,' says Mr. Bothra. New Zealand and Taiwan The Lok Sabha documents of unstarred questions show that New Zealand witnessed a jump of 354.7% when compared to the figures during 2022. 'It is a new place filled with plenty of job opportunities. The tuition fees are equivalent to those charged by the U.S. institutions,' says Sumit Bothra, Education Consultant. The tuition fees for an undergraduate course in New Zealand is $ 35,000 to $55,000 per year, as per the government-owned web portal Study in New Zealand. The tuition fees in the U.S. for a bachelor's degree are $30,780 for public institutions and $ 43,350 in private institutions, according to the College Board, a 120-year-old U.S.-based nonprofit that pioneered SAP and AP tests. According to the web portal the tuition fees in Germany hover around $ 22,970 for a bachelor's degree. In France, the public institutions charge tuition fees around $ 3,273 and private institutions charge around $20,676, according to the web portal 'The master programs are popular in New Zealand, and vast opportunities are available for our students who get absorbed in the market easily,' said Maria Charles, Education Consultant. The other traditional education hubs, such as Singapore and Russia, still continue to serve as an option for Indian students. The number of Indians going to Russia has increased by 59.1% in 2025 when compared to the figures in 2022. The emerging country in the bloc is Taiwan, which remains a favorite for STEM students. 'A total of 3500 students are currently pursuing education at all levels in Taiwan,' Mr. Bothra says. He adds, 'The job market in Taiwan is thriving as they have a strong base for healthcare, manufacturing, and engineering production. Indian festivals are celebrated in Taiwan, as our students are culturally integrated, which is not possible in other traditional destinations like Japan, where language is the main barrier'.
Business Standard
4 hours ago
- Business Standard
Real wages rose most for managers, declined for clerks: CSEP study
Growth in real average annual income between 2017-18 and 2023-24 has been the highest for 'administrators and managers', while wages of 'clerks' have declined, shows the latest paper by private think tank Centre for Social and Economic Progress (CSEP). The paper, authored by Amaresh Dubey and Laveesh Bhandari, estimated average annual growth in daily real wages for seven occupations for the period. The data showed real daily wages for 'administrators and managers' grew at an annual average of 6.7 per cent to ₹611.9 in 2023-24 from ₹414.1 in 2017-18. Wages of 'clerks' declined at an annual average of 1.3 per cent to ₹397.6 from ₹429.7 in the period. 'The most notable increase in annual incomes has been among those classified as administrators and managers. While there is some variation in real growth, the key issue is that overall real wages have not increased significantly for most segments,' the paper read. In the six-year period, real daily wages for other occupation groups like 'sales and service workers' saw an average annual growth rate of 0.64 per cent to ₹262.5 from ₹252.6, while those of 'agriculture and fishery workers' and 'professionals, associate professionals' grew 0.72 per cent and 0.81 per cent, respectively. 'We believe that this low wage growth, despite high employment growth, is not a temporary anomaly. It is indeed a matter of concern. Although the six-year period is not particularly long, it is not short either. If these trends persist, they could impact not only equity but also long-term economic growth,' the paper said. The paper shows growth in the real average annual wage of educated Indians has seen a decline during this period. Real daily wages of 'graduates and above' saw an annual average decline of 0.22 per cent to ₹517.7 from ₹524.6 during this period, and those of 'secondary, higher secondary and diploma holders' also went down by 0.12 per cent to ₹281.1 from ₹283.2. On the other hand, the average real wages of 'low educated Indians' saw a paltry increase over this period. The data shows that people who are categorised as 'literate but below primary' saw their wages rise by an average of 1.63 per cent during this period, followed by people who are categorised as 'primary educated' (1.10 per cent) and 'not literate' (0.96 per cent). The study examined the broad patterns of employment emerging in India, utilising datasets from the National Statistics Office (NSO), specifically the Employment and Unemployment Survey (EUS) and the Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS). Among other findings, the paper showed employment has been increasing steadily throughout the period under consideration, with female employment rising faster than male employment. It also showed there is relative stagnation in cropping-sector employment, with the non-cropping sector, which includes livestock and higher-value agriculture accounting for two-thirds of employment growth.
