Alleged Malaysian drugs trafficker gets last-minute stay of execution in Singapore
Pannir Selvam Pranthaman was arrested in 2014 for having 52 grams (about 1.8 ounces) of heroin and sentenced to death in 2017. He is due to be hanged on Thursday, making him the fourth person to be put to death in the Southeast Asian country this year after two others were executed for drug-related crimes and one for murder.
Singapore anti-death penalty activist Kirsten Han said the Appeals Court allowed the stay of execution on the grounds that there is an ongoing constitutional challenge by other death row prisoners to a section under the drug law. Although Pannir is not involved, he has said in his plea the case could potentially impact his conviction.
Another factor for the stay is Pannir's complaint to the Law Society of Singapore against his former lawyer, where he is the main witness, Han said. The court in its judgement allowed his bid to mount another appeal against his conviction.
'This is a huge relief and very good news, but a stay of execution is not a complete stop,' said Han. "What Singapore needs now is an immediate moratorium on the use of the death penalty, with a view to full abolition. Pannir lives tomorrow, but as Singaporeans we must keep fighting to make sure no one is killed in our names ever again.'
Singapore's strict laws mandate the death penalty for anyone caught carrying more than 15 grams of heroin and 500 grams of cannabis. However, critics say the law only targets low-level traffickers and couriers.
Pannir's family, his lawyers and various rights groups noted that the Singapore court had found that he was merely a courier transporting the substance. The 36-year-old has said he didn't know he was carrying drugs. Still, the court had to hand down the death sentence after prosecutors refused to issue Pannir a certificate of substantive assistance, vouching that he helped their investigation, which would have spared him the noose, they said.
Vigils, songs and poems
Malaysian lawmakers called on their government to intervene to halt Pannir's execution and have him extradited to facilitate further investigation. The Malaysian government, which recently scrapped the mandatory death penalty, didn't respond to media queries.
'We oppose the use of the death penalty on drug mules who are themselves victims in the million-dollar transactions by syndicates that are roaming free,' Malaysian lawmaker Ram Karpal Singh was quoted as saying by The Star newspaper.
Pannir's last-minute reprieve was hailed by dozens of supporters attending a candlelight vigil at a park in Singapore. Holding placards and torchlights, they chanted 'Justice for Pannir' and ' Execution is not the solution.' Dozens others gathered outside the Singapore High Commission in Kuala Lumpur for a similar vigil, singing songs and reading excerpts of poems and letters written by Pannir.
Pannir, the third of six children, is the son of a church pastor who worked as a lorry driver to make ends meet, said another Singapore activist Kokila Annamalai. He loves music and played in the church band growing up, she said.
In prison, Pannir has penned letters, songs and poems about the anguish of being on death row and hopes of a second chance, she said. His family has shared some of his songs, which were sung by several Malaysian singers.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Press and Journal
6 days ago
- Press and Journal
Jail for Inverness takeaway worker who made false asylum claim
A former takeaway worker who made a false asylum claim under an assumed identity has been jailed for 11 months. Malaysian Tick Beng Lew lied to immigration officers, telling them he was a Chinese asylum seeker called Ming Liu. When his deception was uncovered, he admitted to pretending to be Chinese because he was certain he would be returned to Malaysia if discovered by the immigration authorities. He believed a Chinese national would have a '50/50' chance of staying in the UK. At his sentencing at Inverness Sheriff Court, Sheriff David Harvie told Beng Lew that public trust in the asylum system was 'essential' and branded his behaviour 'disgraceful'. Sheriff David Harvie said Beng Lew's false asylum claim was 'disgraceful behaviour'. Image: DC Thomson Beng Lew, 53, previously admitted to a charge of seeking to obtain leave to remain in the UK by deception. At the earlier hearing, fiscal depute Karen Poke told the court that Beng Lew had first come to the attention of authorities in 2019, when working at a takeaway in Inverness. He told the authorities he had arrived in the UK in 2006 and lived in a caravan at the back of the takeaway. 'He stated he was a Chinese national, his name was Ming Liu and he was born on 1 November 1975,' Ms Poke said. It later came to light that the man was, in fact, Tick Beng Lew, born in 1971. 'He was a Malaysian national and had no outstanding application for leave to remain in the UK,' the fiscal depute told the court. On September 6 of 2019 – after his first encounter with authorities – Beng submitted an application to remain in the country under the name Ming Liu. Home search found false papers In November 2023, as part of the investigation, Lew's Tarradale Place home was searched. At this point, he admitted that he had used a fake Chinese identity. 'He stated that as a Chinese national, it would be 50/50 whether he would be removed from the UK to China, however, if discovered by immigration, he was certain he would be returned to his home country of Malaysia,' the fiscal depute said. 'He further explained that he had had problems in Malaysia and did not want to return for that reason.' At the sentencing hearing, solicitor Samantha Morrison told the court: 'Mr Beng Lew is aware of the seriousness of this matter and his deliberate deception in relation to false identification.' She added: 'He has accepted responsibility, albeit at his trial. 'He is now going about the process of application for leave to remain in the UK by means of the correct procedure and is still awaiting the outcome of that application, which is currently on hold, awaiting the outcome of this matter.' Ms Morrison said Beng Lew was now unemployed and acting as a primary carer for his five-year-old stepson. She said: 'His partner has limited English and he assists in regard to the stepson's medical appointments and school and other appointments. 'A custodial sentence would have a detrimental impact to his family and his partner may have to give up work.' False asylum claim was 'disgraceful behaviour' But Sheriff Harvie told Beng Lew: 'There are refugees who face terrible circumstances and seek asylum in safe countries – you come from a safe country. 'You were not a refugee, you set out to abuse the system by securing false identification and pretending to be a Chinese national to attempt to secure asylum in the UK. 'It is essential that the public trust in the asylum system and deception, which is what you have pled guilty to, of that system, which is intended for those in greatest need as refugees, is disgraceful behaviour.' He jailed Beng Lew for 11 months.
Scottish Sun
30-07-2025
- Scottish Sun
Murder probe launched into death of model, 18, who fell 200ft from balcony after threesome with Bitcoin tycoon & wife
Cops had originally dismissed the Dutch model's death as an accident caused by a drug overdose HORROR PLUNGE Murder probe launched into death of model, 18, who fell 200ft from balcony after threesome with Bitcoin tycoon & wife Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A MURDER probe has been launched into the death of a teen model who plunged 200ft to her death after a threesome with an American Bitcoin tycoon and his wife. Ivana Smit, 18, was found naked on the sixth floor balcony of a high rise in Malaysian capital Kuala Lumpar in December 2017. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 7 A murder probe has been launched into the death of a 18-year-old model Credit: Newsflash 7 Cops had originally dismissed the Dutch model's death as an accident caused by a drug overdose Credit: Social Media 7 Alex Johnson and his Indonesian wife Luna admitted to have a sexual relationship with the model Credit: Facebook 7 Ivana plunged from the Persiaran Capsquare apartment block in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia She is believed to have fallen from a 20th-floor apartment owned by Bitcoin tycoon Alexander Amado Johnson, 45, and wife, Luna, 32. The couple admit to having had a threesome with Ivana on the night she died but deny any involvement in her death, and say they were asleep at the time of her fall. Cops had originally dismissed the Dutch model's death as an accident caused by a drug overdose. But judges gave her grieving mum, Christina Verstappen, permission to set aside a police verdict of "sudden death" and sue investigators for negligence. Now the investigation into the Malaysian police file has revealed a shocking catalogue of errors. Cops at first apparently failed to harvest DNA evidence from Ivana's body to see if anyone else had been involved in the tragic plunge. Then, when they did find DNA belonging to Johnson under Ivana's fingernails two months later, it sat on file without any action. Cops even allowed Johnson and Almazkyzy to flee the country a month later without any attempt to re-interview them, the High Court in Kuala Lumpur heard. Now cops and prosecutors have been ordered to reopen the investigation and pay Ivana's mother compensation and costs for her fight for justice. A verdict on 29th July awarded the heartbroken mum nearly £200,000 in compensation for police negligence. OnlyFans model left for dead after 'Dubai Porta Potty' party breaks silence… and reveals horror aftermath of ordeal Christina had sued Inspector-General of Police Dang Wangi, investigating officer ASP Faizal Abdullah, the government Home Minister, and the Malaysian government. She said they had all failed in their statutory duties and had been negligent in their investigation into what caused her daughter's death. The judge also ordered that Abdullah be removed from the task force re-investigating the case. Judge Roz Mawar Rozain said: "There were evidence preservation failures. There was inadequate witness and suspect handling. "There was forensic evidence of neglect, and there was expert evidence of dismissal. "The plaintiff is a direct victim, has suffered harm, and that harm suffered by the plaintiff is the direct and foreseeable consequence of the defendants' breach of duty." She added: "This sequence of events reflects a fundamental breakdown in investigative procedures. "The presence of DNA evidence linking a suspect to the deceased, especially under such suspicious circumstances, should have triggered prompt and decisive action to prevent the suspect from leaving the jurisdiction." A post-mortem at the time found Ivana to have cocaine, alcohol, and an amphetamine called PMMA in her blood. The couple denied having given Smit drugs or taking any themselves on the night that she died. 7 Picture shows Christina Carolina Gerarda Johanna Verstappen (left) with her daughter Ivana Smit (right) Credit: Newsflash 7 Ivana Esther Robert Smit fell from a condominium in 2017 Credit: Newsflash
BBC News
29-07-2025
- BBC News
Ryde e-bike rider guilty over pedestrian hit and run collision
An e-bike rider has pleaded guilty to knocking down a pedestrian in a hit-and-run collision which was caught on men were on the bike which careered into a 16-year-old girl in Ryde High Street, Isle of Wight, on the evening of 5 Douglas, 21, of Fishbourne Lane, admitted driving dangerously, without a licence, insurance or headgear, and failing to stop after an case was adjourned until 3 October at Isle of Wight Magistrates' Court while a pre-sentence report is prepared. CCTV footage from The Star Coffee & Ale House captured the moment the teenager was film showed one of the men talking to her as she lay on the ground, while the other man ran away with the the girl, who was not seriously hurt, was helped into a takeaway by a man, according to the The Star owner Rob Lyttleton said: "No excuse for the lads to tag team a bike that was motorised at that speed in these conditions."The road is fully pedestrianised from 10am until 6am."She was not expecting a vehicle at such speed to hit her in this area." You can follow BBC Hampshire & Isle of Wight on Facebook, X (Twitter), or Instagram.
