Dining space in office not a ‘trade' activity, says HC
The case dates back to June 27, 2024, when an inspection was carried out by the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) in the premises of M/s. Bob Capital Markets Ltd. Pursuant to the inspection report, it was found that the company was running an 'eating house canteen' in its premises without a licence. The canteen had two microwaves, tea/coffee vending machine, induction, refrigerators, and tables for service purposes, in the designated area.
Noting that the licence was not produced, the BMC alleged that the company was carrying on trade in the premises and directed it to stop the service immediately, failing which it would take necessary action as per the provisions of the MMC Act, 1888.
Taking cognisance of the issue, the magistrate court on September 23, 2024, issued the process under the provisions of the MMC Act. Aggrieved by this, the company approached the Bombay high court, challenging the order under provisions of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS).
The company clarified that the 'eating house canteen' is a designated dining area for the employees to consume food during their meal breaks. It further stated that the arrangement of the microwaves, vending machines, refrigerators and the tables were made for the employees as a goodwill gesture, for them to heat the food and avail tea/coffee.
It further stated that the appliances are for self-service purposes, utilised by the employees and such is neither sold nor purchased by any person. 'The concerned officer failed to consider and understand the difference between a dining area and a canteen,' the company said. Highlighting that the meaning of 'Eating House' refers to activities for monetary benefit, the company stressed that the place provided is merely a dining area with absolutely zero trade.
On the other hand, BMC pointed out a circular dated August 13, 2001, which lists vending machines as 'licensable' under the MMC Act. The civic body further highlighted a list of minor and major trades under the Public Health department, which termed the tea vending machines as 'catering establishments' falling under trade requiring a licence.
After hearing both the sides, the single-judge bench of justice Madhav Jamdar quashed the criminal complaint filed by the BMC, stating that there is no material on record to show that any 'trade' is being conducted in the premises, which is the main requirement for attracting punishment under the MMC Act.
The bench observed that providing a separate dining area for the employees and arranging such appliances for their convenience does not amount to carrying out trade or commercial activity. Citing the definition of 'eating house' under the MMC Act, the court stated that no element of 'profit' was present in the case. Therefore, it quashed the process ordered by the magistrate court, holding that it passed without any basis and is without any material on record concerning ingredients of provision.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
8 hours ago
- Time of India
BMC razes illegal structures at two Kamala Mills restaurants in Mumbai, cancels licences
M umbai: BMC on Tuesday demolished the unauthorised constructions at two restaurants of Living Liquidz in Kamala Mills compound at Lower Parel, and cancelled both its licences. Civic officials said it had illegally converted a garment store on the ground and first floors into a restaurant-bar and wine shop, and a tailoring shop on the ground floor into another restaurant. Following complaints of unauthorised construction, encroachments, and illegal operation of restaurants, pubs, and bars in the IT Park section of Kamala Mills, additional municipal commissioner Ashwini Joshi directed a site inspection and necessary action. Based on her instructions, on July 31, action, involving demolition and seizure, was carried out at various establishments including Theobroma, McDonald's, Shiv Sagar Hotel, Nano's Café, Starbucks, Bira Taproom, Toast Pasta Bar (Food by Devika), and BKT House. Continuing this drive on Monday and Tuesday, during an inspection at Living Liquidz, it was found that a garment store on the ground and first floors had been converted into a restaurant-bar and wine shop, and a tailoring shop on the ground floor into a restaurant. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Got Lower Back Pain? Try This Food – It Might Soothe the Ache (It's Genius!) Read More Undo Additionally, several violations were found, such as covering open spaces in violation of FSI rules, unauthorised roofing on the terrace, illegally constructed walls, unauthorised conversion of space into cold storage, unauthorised alteration of door structures, and the construction of wooden and glass partitions. You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai On Monday, a stop-work notice was issued to Living Liquidz, and on Tuesday, the demolition action was carried out. BMC also cancelled the licences of both restaurants for illegally expanding commercial space and operating in a manner that posed a threat to public safety without obtaining the mandatory fire safety certification. BMC stated that similar action will continue in the future.
News18
14 hours ago
- News18
Mumbai Coastal Road: Why BMC Wants To Deploy 200 Extra Engineers For Versova-Dahisar Link Road
The 22.9 km Versova-Dahisar Link Road is the second phase of Mumbai's Coastal Road, connecting North Versova all the way to Dahisar Taking note of infrastructure projects such as the Goregaon-Mulund Link Road (GMLR), Madh-Versova bridge and reconstruction of other bridges currently underway, the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) has proposed deployment of around 200 additional officers to supervise the Versova-Dahisar Link Road (VDLR) project. The proposal is currently awaiting administrative approval from Municipal Commissioner Bhushan Gagrani, the Free Press Journal reported. Acting on the state's orders, the BMC has expedited Phase II of the Mumbai Coastal Road Project (MCRP). The 20-km Versova-Dahisar Link Road (VDLR), costing Rs 16,621 crore, aims to ease traffic congestion. Additionally, a 5.6-km, 45m-wide elevated road from Dahisar to Bhayandar will be built at Rs 3,304 crore. Work begins in August 2025 and is expected to finish by December 2028. The BMC has created a dedicated department for the construction and maintenance of the 10.58 km Phase I of the MCRP, stretching from Marine Drive to the Bandra-Worli Sea Link. The Versova–Dahisar Link Road: Mumbai coastal road phase II The 22.9 km Versova-Dahisar Link Road is the second phase of Mumbai's Coastal Road, connecting North Versova all the way to Dahisar. The BMC has issued work orders for the VDLR under the overall Coastal Road scheme, comprising multiple packages and designed as an extension northward from the existing southern Coastal Road segment toward Bhayander, according to reports. It will be a mix of double elevated roads, roads on stilts, cable-stayed bridge, cut-and-cover tunnels. It will connect to Bandra-Versova Sea Link and Goregaon-Mulund Link Road (GMLR). The MCZMA formally approved the Phase 2 alignment (Versova to Dahisar and further to Bhayander) in September 2024. While CRZ clearance has been secured, construction is pending additional approvals from the MoEFCC, Bombay High Court, forest department, and clearance regarding mangrove diversion. Once completed, the Coastal Road will enable signal-free, controlled connectivity from Nariman Point through Worli, Bandra, Versova, Dahisar, and up to Bhayandar/Virar, dramatically cutting travel times and easing congestion across the Western Suburbs. It is expected to be completed around December 2028. view comments Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Indian Express
15 hours ago
- Indian Express
To make way for Mumbai's Coastal Road, BMC to demolish a flyover that was constructed just seven years ago
The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) is set to bring down the Veer Savarkar flyover at Goregaon West since the structure is falling in alignment with the Mumbai Coastal Road project's second phase, which will connect Versova in the western suburbs with Dahisar in northern Mumbai. The premium flyover, one of the primary connectors, was built in 2018 at a cost of Rs 27 crore. Locally, the bridge is also known as the MTNL flyover and originates from near the Radisson hotel adjoining the Western Express Highway (WEH) and extends till Rustomjee Ozone. The MTNL flyover became operational in 2018 after staying in the pipeline for more than a decade. At present, the flyover provides a direct connection to Goregaon and Malad areas from the WEH, bringing down travel time to less than ten minutes, which used to take more than 45 minutes. As a result, the demolition of this flyover will lead to immense traffic congestion in the western suburbs. According to the civic body's norms, the structural feasibility of any newly constructed bridge is set to last at least 20 years. Civic officials said that the proposed alignment will connect a portion of the coastal road with the upcoming Goregaon Mulund Link Road (GMLR) to provide 'When this flyover was conceptualised, there was no direct connectivity planned between the second phase of the coastal road and the GMLR since both these projects were planned independently. As part of the revised plan, there has been a proposal to connect these two corridors so that motorists can get direct east-west access as well. As a result, the MTNL flyover is falling in line with the project, and we have proposed its demolition,' said an official privy to this project. The official said that as an alternative, a double-decker flyover has been planned that will provide vehicle access between Mindspace and Dindoshi, where the current flyover stands. The civic officials said that the blueprint of the bridge has been prepared and is being sent to the civic administration for final approval. The proposed second phase of the coastal road has been divided into six different packages. Package A will cover 4.5 km between Versova and Bangur Nagar (Goregaon), and package B will cover 1.66 km between Bangur Nagar and Mindspace (Malad). The packages C and D will include twin tunnels – 3.9 KM long – connecting Mindspace at Malad with Charkop in Kandivali. Package E will be 3.78 km, connecting Charkop with Gorai, and the final package, F, will be 3.69 km, connecting Gorai with Dahisar. From Dahisar, the civic authorities are constructing another 5.6 km elevated corridor that will extend till Bhayander in the Mumbai Metropolitan Region (MMR). The overall project will be 25 km long, and the total cost of these two projects has been pegged at Rs 20,000 crore. The BMC secured environmental clearances last year, allowing the project to proceed, and on-ground work commenced this year. Phase two of the coastal road will feature a series of underground tunnels, a cable-stayed bridge, and vehicular interchanges, all designed to enhance north-south connectivity. The coastal road will also provide connectivity with the Goregaon Mulund Link Road (GMLR) an east-west connector that is also being constructed by the Mumbai civic body.
