Asking Eric: Soon to be ex-husband asking for alimony
This has put my grandchild in a difficult and confusing situation. He is 17 years old, and he loves both his parents. He feels he has to be loyal to his dad, because his dad says he is the victim. But he also acknowledges that he has never seen his mother so happy. They had a contentious marriage that made her quite anxious and unhappy.
I want to help my grandson navigate through this challenging time. What kind of advice can I give him?
– Worried Grandmother
Dear Grandmother: I'm so glad your grandson has you to help him during this time. He needs a trusted adult nearby who can tell him things he really needs to hear. Things like: 'It's not right that you're being put in the middle of this contentious divorce' and 'I know it's hard to hear negative things about your parents and I'm sorry' and 'No matter what you do, you're not being disloyal to either parent. They have a responsibility to show up for you and make sure you know you're loved unconditionally. They might fail at that – they're human – but when they do, remember that this isn't something that you caused.'
Most of all, remind him that he doesn't have to pick a side. Divorce is hard and your son is seeing new sides of his parents and that's going to take some getting used to. Robert E. Emery writes in the book 'The Truth About Children and Divorce,' 'children whose parents put them first from the start have a tremendous advantage over those whose parents cannot separate their feelings about their failed marriage from their feelings about the co-parenting partnership that will last the rest of their lives.' That didn't happen here, but you can make sure your grandson knows that he's a priority for you.
While the way he's being leveraged by his father is very inappropriate, it provides an opportunity for you to guide your grandson through an important part of growing up: seeing his parents as humans. Like all humans, they make mistakes sometimes, they give into their worst instincts, and they can fail the ones they're supposed to protect. This doesn't make them unworthy of love. Help your grandson to develop internal boundaries while you advocate on his behalf with the adults in his life. This will help him to have healthier relationships with his parents and with future partners.
Dear Eric: I was in a relationship with my ex, Yves, for about five years. During that time, we were well-off and supported each other. Yves eventually ghosted me without explanation, though I can admit we weren't as close as we had been at the start of our relationship.
Later, a friend, who is a close relative of Yves, mentioned that Yves was now dating someone named Tiffany. The situation took an unexpected turn a few months later when Tiffany called me asking for money. She said she needed help with rent because Yves refused to lend her any. Tiffany mentioned that she knew about Yves' wealthy ex-girlfriend and was seeking my assistance. When I told her this wasn't my concern, she argued that since we both dated Yves, we should be mutual friends. Yves is a great person, but should I trust Tiffany?
– Confused Single
Dear Single: Oh, how I wish I could put up a billboard in your town that reads 'For the love of all that is good, dear letter writer, please do not give Tiffany so much as the time of day.'
Yves ghosted you after five years? Unacceptable. Cruel and immature. And then Yves told his new girlfriend to ask you for money? Where is he getting the gall? Is there a gall mine in your town?
Tiffany's core assertion – you should be friends because you dated the same person – doesn't make any sense. And I wonder what Tiffany thinks you have in common besides Yves and, she hopes, the money. I think these people are trying to manipulate you. Don't let them.
Dear Eric: Regarding the letter from 'Happy Family', who was looking for a 'snappy comeback' for relatives wondering why/when/if her daughter plans to be married, I suggest the comeback be 'why would you ask that?' putting a bit of a spotlight on the intrusiveness of the question. Regardless of the inquirer's response, a simple 'huh' or 'I see' ends the conversation.
– Comeback Again
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Washington Post
2 days ago
- Washington Post
Asking Eric: Wife continually interrupts spouse
Dear Eric: I have been married to a wonderful woman for many years. She is educated and has many years of practical experience. But if there is anything that makes me 'bite the bullet' it's her interruptions mid-delivery from me. I have dared to call her out for interrupting me and she will say I'm taking too long to make a point, even in a short first sentence (because she knows what I am going to say anyway). I am also educated (engineering) with many years of hands-on and practical experience. My conversational practice is different. I wait things out, actively listening, and by the time the person is done I've dismissed what I was going to say lest I have to go back to an earlier point where that person took the conversation and it has changed context. I don't interrupt. I will raise a finger. Often, she won't stop, and I have no desire to rewind the conversation. So, what say you about communication practices in such an environment? Yup, I'm too passive. But I don't want an argument about an argument that ignores the original issue. — Uninterrupted Uninterrupted: No one person gets to define the rules of a conversation. So even if she's thinking ahead or, heaven forfend, getting a little bored, that conversation needs to be a two-way exchange you're building together. I understand the difficulty of your situation: talking about how hard it is to talk to each other can be more frustrating than productive. Try picking one subject or time to test out a new dynamic. Say, dinner, for instance. You can tell her, 'I'd like to tell you a story. You might get ahead of me, but it would be really great if you'd let me get my full thought out. Could you listen?' Setting the expectation upfront may help her to shift her thinking. This isn't you 'talking badly,' this is an opportunity for connection, and she can modify her behavior and response. There are a number of conversational prompt card games that couples find helpful, and they might be a good testing area for shifting the dynamic, as well. I particularly like Esther Perel's card game 'Where Should We Begin?' Choose a night, pick a card, and commit to each other that you're going to listen fully before responding as part of the game. Dear Eric: My mother and I have owned a home together for the last 20 years following my divorce. When we purchased the home, it was understood that it was only an investment for me. I have now met a wonderful man, and we would like to start our lives together. My mother, though, would like us all to live together in the home she and I share. We don't want that. My mother would be able to buy a smaller home with her half of the profit, were we to sell our current home. My mother, however, does not want to move or sell. She loves the house and is very proud of it. I have explained that I would like to move forward with my boyfriend, so that he and I can start our life together. She wonders why we cannot do that while living together. I have explained over and over again that this is not what he and I want. She says she will leave when I 'throw her out,' which is not at all what I would do. I would like her to want us to be happy, and to be amenable to moving to a smaller home or even an apartment. Can you help us? — Trapped Trapped: Even though the home was an investment for you, after 20 years, it makes sense that your mother has started to feel that it's home. Your lives are moving at different speeds, and you have different needs right now. It sounds like she's trying to come up with a compromise that keeps her from experiencing even more disruption. Because, it should be pointed out, when you move out, that's going to change a lot of things for her. Is there a way that her desire to stay in her home and your desire to move to the next stage in your relationship with your boyfriend aren't in opposition? For instance, can she buy you out of your half of the house, either in full or gradually over time? If you want to move in with your boyfriend, but most of your cash is tied up in the house, is renting together for a year a possibility? You write that you want her to be happy, part of that entails acknowledging that while she's not part of the decision-making process for you and your boyfriend, she has her own life, and home, and relationship with you. (Send questions to R. Eric Thomas at eric@ or P.O. Box 22474, Philadelphia, PA 19110. Follow him on Instagram and sign up for his weekly newsletter at 2025 Tribune Content Agency, LLC.
Washington Post
3 days ago
- Washington Post
Asking Eric: Stepson has plans for widowed stepparent's next chapter
Dear Eric: My husband passed away 12 days ago after an extended illness. I have two step-kids. Two days after my husband died, one of the kids started asking for some of my husband's belongings then unveiled his plan to 'help me build a house' on some vacant land I own to 'fulfill my husband's dream.' I was taken aback. I told him I was spent from taking care of my husband and am not making any decisions.
Chicago Tribune
4 days ago
- Chicago Tribune
Asking Eric: We are done playing host
Dear Eric: I've been married to a great guy for the better part of 30 years. We are empty nesters, and during Covid-19, I agreed to help my male cousin who became homeless. I knew my husband wasn't wild about the idea, but he didn't fuss about it, so we let him move in. Fast-forward five years: he's living with us. I figured I could use the money, so I made him pay rent. A few days ago, I got home before my husband and decided to wait for him to get home in bed undressed. That's something we do often. To my surprise, he was mad at me and accused me of sleeping with my cousin. I was so crushed. I couldn't believe it. I can't stop crying. I can't believe he thought so little of me. I feel like my relationship is shipwrecked. Of course, I asked my cousin to leave immediately but I can't bring myself to hold my husband close to me anymore. Why can't he understand why I'm so hurt? – Wrongly Accused Dear Accused: This idea, incorrect as it is, likely took root in your husband's mind long before the blowup. And since he didn't talk about it with you, it had plenty of time to fester and flourish until it was overwhelming. I can't say why he would believe this in the first place or why he wouldn't bring it up earlier in an attempt to clear the air. I'm sorry that you and your cousin had to suffer for it. What you and your husband need right now is a clear, calm conversation that can help to chip away at the story he's created in his mind and lead you both to the root of the issue. That's going to be very hard to do without a third party guiding you, listening to you and helping you listen to each other. That third party might be a therapist, a religious leader or a friend who is skilled at remaining neutral and asking questions. Lay out the basic truth: you're hurt, and he's upset and neither of you wants to feel this way. You may want to reinforce that you're not trying to set him up or convince him. You're trying to create a space that's safe enough for both of you to hear each other and move forward. Dear Eric: For more than 30 years my husband and I hosted extended family, friends and neighbors for multiple occasions every year, including Christmas Day with gifts, kid's birthdays, bridal and baby showers and our daughters' milestones. Also, every year we threw a big Fourth of July party and included our neighbors with swimming, barbecue and tickets to our town's fireworks event where I brought desserts and coffee, etc. These occasions were wonderful, and everyone always seemed to have a great time, however, planning, preparing and hosting all of these events with both of us working full time was extremely stressful and costly. After 30 years, we decided that we were done playing host, with the exception of our daughters' families. Now we hardly ever see these former guests and when we do the typical comment is 'Where have you been hiding?' or 'Is everything OK – we have not heard from you?' as if something is wrong with us. We are stymied as to how to respond in a manner that lets people know we have been fine but decided it was time for someone else to host the get-togethers. I would love your advice. – Hosting No More Dear Hosting: Agh, the curse of the good host. You're so diligent about throwing parties, that others around you come to expect it. And when you don't do it, no one else steps up because, well, they were having too much fun eating your food and celebrating your milestones. Social gatherings really thrive on good communication and clear direction. Think of how name tags can facilitate easy conversation at a mixer or clear signage can help everyone end up in the right place at the right time for a surprise party. When people ask where you've been, it'll be helpful for you to tell them you've retired from the party business and encourage them to invite you to their gatherings. 'We miss seeing you. Maybe you can host us sometime.' This might feel forward, but people often need a little push or a little permission. And this isn't you inviting yourselves over. The others can always say no. I would even go a step further and send out a little card – maybe at a holiday, maybe whenever it comes to mind. Think of it as a reverse invitation that says, 'We've stepped back from hosting, but we still want to see you. We invite you to invite us; we'll bring dessert.'
