Michael Boudin, ‘an appellate judge's judge,' who wrote key DOMA ruling, dies at 85
Yet he and the other two judges did just that when they ruled that the law's denial of federal benefits to legally married same-sex couples was unconstitutional. Many legal observers — from conservatives and liberals to activists who supported or opposed LGBTQ rights — saw that DOMA ruling as a significant signpost along the road toward the
Get Starting Point
A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday.
Enter Email
Sign Up
Advertisement
'He was extraordinarily brilliant and history will count him as one of the most significant judges of his era,' said
Respected in the federal judiciary and beyond, Mr. Boudin 'was an appellate judge's judge,' said
Mr. Boudin 'was a sound, intelligent, and thoughtful judge,' said
They had been friends since college, when Mr. Boudin was president of the Harvard Law Review and Breyer served under him as articles editor. Even in that realm, Mr. Boudin's intellect and expansive reading habits were notable, Breyer recalled.
Advertisement
'I tend to think he read every great book written in English,' Breyer said.
Before becoming a federal judge, Mr. Boudin served in the Reagan administration as a deputy assistant US attorney general in the Justice Department's antitrust division.
President George H.W. Bush nominated him in 1990 to serve as a US District Court judge in the District of Columbia. Mr. Boudin was never entirely comfortable in that job, and
Mr. Boudin announced plans to leave that judicial appointment and move to Cambridge, and then
Though he returned to Boston after serving in one Republican president's administration and being nominated by another to two judgeships, Mr. Boudin's family background was distant from GOP politics.
'He was for me a perfect parent — wise and devoted and considerate and charming — and I told him so,' Mr. Boudin said at a memorial service after Leonard died in 1989.
Mr. Boudin's only sibling, his younger sister, Kathy Boudin, was part of the militant Weather Underground. She served 22 years in prison for her role as an unarmed decoy in the 1981 robbery of a Brink's armored truck, during which other robbers shot and killed two police officers and a security guard.
Advertisement
The narrative of a conservative attorney-turned-judge from a liberal family proved irresistible to many reporters who wrote about Mr. Boudin over the years. But his friends said he was careful to rarely grant interviews and to never let his own political beliefs become part of the public conversation.
'This was a judge's judge, a really powerful mind, always looking for the right answer,' said
'You wouldn't be able to characterize him as conservative or liberal,' Levi said. 'He didn't fit into any of these labels because he such a seeker of the truth.'
Mr. Boudin's 'decisions were always guided by the law and constitutional requirements, and not at all by political points of view,' Lynch said.
Born in Manhattan, N.Y., on Nov. 29, 1939, Michael Boudin was the only son of Leonard Boudin and
Mr. Boudin received a bachelor's degree from Harvard College in 1961 and graduated from Harvard Law School in 1964.
He clerked for
Friendly was an especially important mentor, whose lessons Mr. Boudin revisited in 'Judge Henry Friendly and the Craft of Judging,' a 2010 University of Pennsylvania Law Review essay.
Advertisement
For example, Mr. Boudin wrote, Friendly knew 'that an appeal might well have a life after the judgment was handed down.'
Many judges assign clerks to write early drafts of decisions, or parts of them. Like Friendly, Mr. Boudin was known for writing his own first drafts and opinions.
He wrote in the essay that in complex cases, 'the choices spread out like a maze of tracks in a great railroad terminal. As the forks appear, the seasoned judge who is close to the case is more likely than the clerk to understand the realistic options and select the best route to an outcome.'
'There were times you almost felt superfluous because he was so good,' said David Friedman, who clerked for Mr. Boudin and is now
'In terms of the law,' Friedman said, 'it felt like he already knew all there was to know.'
Away from the bench, Mr. Boudin was known for his competitive approach to even a casual game of tennis and for his love of his cats. The last three were Julia, Chloe, and Nougat.
Over the years, he would bring his cats into his judge's chambers. Once during a meal with colleagues, the swirl of topics turned to the projected end of the universe, when all life would vanish.
'The problem,' Mr. Boudin deadpanned with sincerity, 'is that then there would be no cats.'
A memorial gathering will be planned for Mr. Boudin. In addition to his wife, and her three daughters from before they married, he leaves a nephew,
Advertisement
'What a profoundly impactful and brilliant and respected jurist he was,' Chesa said.
To his friends among other jurists, Mr. Boudin's devotion to the law seemed matched by his unending desire to keep learning by reading book after book.
'One passion was as an appellate judge, but the other was trying to understand this complex world in which we find ourselves, the human condition, how we make sense of it all,' Marshall said. 'He had a broad inquiring mind. That, to me, was Michael.'
Bryan Marquard can be reached at
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
14 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Republicans, some Democrats and even ex-Gov. Rod Blagojevich weigh in on ex-Speaker Michael Madigan's sentence
In what's become somewhat customary once an Illinois political titan falls, leaders throughout the state responded with condemnation and called for reforms upon hearing Friday that ex-Speaker Michael Madigan was sentenced to seven and a half years in federal prison and fined $2.5 million on federal corruption charges. House Republican leader Tony McCombie of Savanna and Senate Republican leader John Curran of Downers Grove called for bipartisan ethics reforms in the wake of the sentencing, with Curran specifically requesting committee hearings and votes on potential changes — something that didn't happen this session. Madigan's sentencing was 'a stark and shameful reminder of the corruption that has plagued Illinois government for far too long,' McCombie said in a statement. 'Justice was served — but the damage to public trust runs deep.' But Illinois' last prominent statewide politician who went to federal prison, former Democratic Gov. Rod Blagojevich, held back on the chance to take a swipe at a bitter nemesis when Madigan was sentenced. Though the two were Democrats, they feuded for nearly all six years Blagojevich was in office between 2003 and 2009. 'When that guy, Madigan, was on the top of the mountain, they were all kissing his ass,' Blagojevich said. 'Now they're going to be stomping all over his grave. And it's really, it's really sort of an unappealing side of human nature.' Blagojevich said Madigan's conviction underscores the systemic problems in politics and government in the state Capitol. 'Is the system in Springfield corrupt, in many ways, absolutely,' Blagojevich said in an interview with the Tribune while insisting he didn't break the law. 'It's a system, I've been saying this from the beginning, it all too often works for itself on the backs of the people.' Blagojevich — whose 14-year federal prison sentence for corruption was commuted by President Donald Trump, who ultimately also pardoned Blagojevich — didn't want to celebrate Madigan's prison sentence despite the two's often-tense relationship. 'I just don't think it's right for me to kick a man when he's down,' Blagojevich said. 'What's happening now to him, I know what it's like. And it's really easy for these politicians to get on their high horses and start kicking someone, stomping on someone.' Senate President Don Harmon, a Democrat from Oak Park who is facing a potential fine of nearly $10 million from the Illinois State Board of Elections for improper political fundraising, said Friday's sentence represented 'a solemn reminder' that the duty of public office holders is to serve 'and that there is accountability for those who do not.'
Yahoo
20 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Two immigrants came here legally. They were detained anyway, sparking Spokane's mass ICE protest
Jun. 13—It took almost no time for two immigrants to become part of Shelly O'Quinn's family. She was on the cusp of becoming one of their "sponsors" to guide them in the United States as part of the U.S.' asylum program. By all accounts, everything was going right. The two would spend their days working at the Airway Heights Walmart, check in with immigration and make it to every court hearing. It all changed on Wednesday when they received a notice to check in with immigration. But instead of a check-in, the two were picked up by federal authorities. "They are such good young men," O'Quinn said. "They did all of it legally. And they have such a heartbreaking story." O'Quinn, a former Republican Spokane County commissioner, met 21-year-old Cesar Alexander Alvarez Perez and 28-year-old Joswar Slater Rodriguez Torres last year at a church event after they escaped persecution in Venezuela. The two refugees met in Colombia and began the trek to Mexico, but their journey was largely traumatic, O'Quinn said — they were sleeping on roads, were robbed at gunpoint and threatened with machetes. "They got jobs in Mexico. They went to the border every day and applied to get into the U.S.," O'Quinn said. "They finally were accepted and came here legally, in the humanitarian parole program." They both qualified for asylum and were following the legal court process, O'Quinn said. Alvarez Perez qualified for the juvenile asylum process because he came to the U.S. younger than 21. They even had a court hearing scheduled for October, and it left O'Quinn optimistic about where things were headed. In Minneapolis on a work trip, she was stunned when she got the call that chaos had broke out on the streets of Spokane because the men were detained by ICE. Alvarez Perez's sponsor, former city council president Ben Stuckart, had taken the two to their check-in when authorities detained them instead. Stuckart posted a call to action on Facebook, which led residents to swarm the ICE office off West Cataldo Avenue in North Spokane. The protest erupted throughout the evening, with a group of people attempting to stop unmarked law enforcement vehicles from leaving. Federal agents pushed back, sending some protesters' belongings falling to the ground. Others crowded a bus to prevent it from leaving and were ultimately arrested for obstruction and failure to disperse, one of them being Stuckart. While more faced off with police and deputies, law enforcement began throwing canisters of smoke and pepper balls to disperse the crowd. Spokane Mayor Lisa Brown then issued a 9:30 p.m. curfew, calling the decision "the best path forward" for everyone to stay safe. Stuckart eventually posted bail, but he has yet to hear from Alvarez Perez and Rodriguez Torres, he said. O'Quinn, fearing the worst, flew to Seattle on Thursday and plans to attempt a visit with the two transported to Tacoma's immigration detention center. "If I can't see them, the next step is figuring out how I can ... Imagine if your kids were in a detention center with no contacts. It's a scary place," O'Quinn said. "I just imagine the fear they are feeling, and I want them to know someone cares for them." The legal way, no longer Alvarez Perez and Rodriguez Torres came to the United States through a legal program known as the Venezuelan Humanitarian Parole Program, or the "CHNV" program for Cubans, Haitians, Nicaraguans and Venezuelans. It allows for immigrants facing persecution to legally live and work in the U.S. "under parole." President Donald Trump attempted to terminate the program earlier this year, but a Massachusetts judge issued an injunction to pause the action. On May 30, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned the injunction, giving Trump free reign to end the parole program and continue mass immigrant deportations, something he has vowed to do since the start of his presidency. The crackdown on immigration has led ICE to detain people all across the country. On Thursday, the Department of Homeland Security issued a notice to the thousands of immigrants taking part in the program that their legal status has since been terminated, according to reporting from CNN. "This notice informs you that your parole is now terminated. If you do not leave, you may be subject to enforcement actions, including but not limited to detention and removal, without an opportunity to make personal arrangements and return to your country in an orderly manner," the notice says. It's unclear whether Alvarez Perez and Rodriguez Torres received a parole termination notice, O'Quinn said. Either way, she expected it wouldn't affect them because they had another pathway into the U.S. by asylum — but now, even their asylum status is murky. Alvarez-Perez also celebrated his birthday just this week, consequently aging him out of the juvenile asylum program he was part of. "We are a county that allows for due process. I believe they should have the right to due process. They did what they were supposed to do," O'Quinn said. "We are not a country that should be picking up people are who legally here without due process. It's a violation of our rights in the United States." The Supreme Court decision allowing for deportation of those on humanitarian parole is "brutal on its face," according to Spokane civil rights attorney Jeffry Finer. Normally, an injunction would give time for litigation while also preventing undue harm where there is no reasonable remedy, he said, like tearing down a historical building. "There's no way to bring back the building. You can't fix it or reverse it," Finer said. "So if it's going to have irreparable damages, an injunction is the way to litigate the merit and keep the status quo so nobody is harmed if the lawsuit is successful." The dissenting Supreme Court opinion states the court botched the way it protects people during ongoing litigation. Finer said his interpretation of it shows "the risk to the government is small" but "the risk to immigrants is huge" — because once they're deported, there likely won't be a push to bring them back. And there's no telling if the two will be deported, because the jail is "a black hole" of information, Stuckart said. Alvarez Perez and Rodriguez Torres were so desperate to flee, they walked for weeks to find freedom from persecution and remained here with no criminal record, Stuckart added, which tells him no one is exempt from deportations. Immigrants with minor or no criminal records are still being detained across the U.S. despite Trump saying he wants to crack down on immigrants with violent backgrounds. "They don't have years to wait. Once they did get here, these two gentlemen got legal work permits and were working full time and contributing to society with taxes," he said. "I don't know what the difference is between someone who comes in at one point or another point. Take politics out of it. This goes beyond a political lens." Past the politics O'Quinn's family refers to Rodriguez Torres as "Randy," a name he picked himself, because people had trouble pronouncing his name. It's hard for her to look at news reports and court records identifying him as "Joswar," she said. A picture of the two taken at the Barton English School, both smiling ear to ear, is "the smiles they always have on their face," O'Quinn wrote in a text. "I want him to come home," she said Thursday. "Both of them." While Stuckart is a Democrat and O'Quinn was a Republican commissioner, the urge to bring back the men spans the political divide. Stuckart has made contact with Sen. Maria Cantwell's office, and O'Quinn said she reached out to Rep. Michael Baumgartner for help, and he responded promptly by having his staff track information for her on how she could find where the men were taken. "He's actually been very supportive," she said, "And I appreciate that." Baumgartner released a statement Thursday about the protests applauding law enforcement's response and encouraging people to work with federal officials to enforce immigration laws. "We need both secure borders and immigration reform," the statement reads. "Peaceful protest is guaranteed under the Constitution, but there is no excuse for violence or impeding law enforcement officials." His office has not responded for further comment. The stories of Alvarez Perez and Rodriguez Torres deserve to be told, because "they have demonstrated their American values of hard work and integrity," O'Quinn said — they shouldn't become political pawns in a battle with red or blue. Both Republicans and Democrats have vouched for the men, Stuckart said later, calling them "the people you want in our country." Both agree the men did everything they're told to do as immigrants: apply to come into the country legally, get a job and pay taxes. It's the reason O'Quinn believes their detainment doesn't reflect the values of Spokane. "I am grateful for the people who stood up for their rights yesterday," she said. "It tells them that it wasn't Spokane that kicked them out." Editor's note — this story was corrected to reflect the men were not refugees under the U.S. Government but were rather seeking asylum.
Yahoo
20 minutes ago
- Yahoo
CRC Synod begins with 34 fewer churches after LGBTQ decision
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. (WOOD) — As the Christian Reformed Church of North America convenes for its annual assembly, it's doing so with about 34 fewer members in its midst. Delegates and church leaders on Friday began the denomination's annual Synod, meeting at Redeemer University in Ancaster, Ontario in Canada. Through June 19, almost 200 delegates will be working through a packed agenda. 'It's exciting to get together — people from all different backgrounds and walks of life — to talk about the business of the church and make big decisions,' CRCNA General Secretary Zachary King told News 8. 'Even though there can be some tense and difficult moments, it's just really wonderful and cool to see people work together to walk on path together. ….There's a lot of energy and hope in doing this work, even though it can be really difficult sometimes.' Churches prepare to leave CRC following LGBTQ+ decision This year's Synod follows a contentious meeting in 2024, when the denomination determined LGBTQ-affirming churches must repent — or leave. Around 34 churches have since disaffiliated, King said, adding that that number is expected to grow. That includes a number of churches in Grand Rapids. 'We're sad and we're disappointed of course that a significant number of churches … have disaffiliated with our denomination,' he said. 'We pray that somehow in the future, and even in the present, that we might have a good connection. … We hope that they flourish in their communities. … That's heavy, but we feel like it's a necessary moment and we want to navigate it with as much grace and kindness as we can.' After a few years of dialogue around the church's belief that LGBTQ+ relationships are sinful, King said this year, the conversation has 'a different tenor.' 'Obviously we've had a big discussion about human sexuality,' he said. 'I think we completed that discussion. Now we're trying to understand how we can work … better together.' CRC doubles down on forbidding deacon in same-sex marriage at GR church There's now more inner unity, he said, and the direction the denomination is going is more clear. Some items on this year's agenda will work through the impact of last year's decision. A report from CRC-affiliated Calvin University Board of Trustees clarifies how it will approach faculty members who disagree with the denomination's belief on LGBTQ+ relationships and other core beliefs (called confessional issues) of the denomination. Another item will determine the future of its relationship with the Reformed Church of America based on that denomination's stance on LGBTQ relationships, which is to 'live together in the midst of disagreement,' the RCA General Secretary Rev. Eddy Aleman wrote in a letter to the CRC Synod. Also on the agenda is a report from a task force that examined how the church should approach assisted suicide while showing love and support for families and individuals. In its report, the task force affirmed 'that life is precious, so we should not act to end life.' If you or someone you know need help, call the National Suicide Line at 988. Delegates will also discuss questions of funding, church planting and the role of virtual ministry, King said. Many young churches are leaning into using technology like Zoom for worship services, and the CRC is exploring how to leverage that for ministry and connection. 'We also realize that the in-person connection is important too,' King said. 'There's some tension there and we're trying to sort out you know how can we leverage the best of technology while avoiding some of the pitfalls.' Under God, Divisible: Political conflict deepens rift among Christians Overall, the denomination has several churches that are flourishing and growing, King said. 'We have a number of churches that may feel that they're plateaued in terms of their numbers, but they're really impacting their community in a positive way and seeing just a lot of fruit to their ministry,' King said. 'We do have churches that are struggling — as many denominations — but … God is really working through their community connections and some of them are just doing amazing things that only small churches could do.' The CRCNA is streaming Synod proceedings . Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
