Shipwreck mystery solved after nearly 140 years
The mystery of a maritime disaster has been solved after experts found a vessel that sank almost 140 years ago.
Diver and explorer Dom Robinson identified the SS Nantes, off Plymouth, after examining the wreck site and finding crockery.
Dr Harry Bennett, an expert in maritime history, said the dive team had found "the underwater archaeological equivalent of a needle in a haystack".
Mr Robinson said solving the mystery ensured those who died were not forgotten.
In November 1888, the SS Nantes, which was operated by the Cunard Steamship Company, collided with a German sailing vessel, the Theodor Ruger, said Dr Bennett.
The crew spent "several hours" trying to save their ship, the honorary associate professor in history at the University of Plymouth said.
"They used mattresses to plug the gap which had opened up in the haul of the SS Nantes," he said.
"[The ship sank] with the loss of a substantial number of the crew. There were some 23-odd fatalities. There were three survivors."
Bodies from the wreckage washed ashore at Talland Bay and Looe, in Cornwall, and "locals were confronted by this picture of horror, pieces of ship together with bodies," he said.
Afterwards the "wreck was essentially lost, obviously you're dealing in a period with no satellite navigation," said Dr Bennett.
He added while the crew tried to save the ship it "drifted for several hours, before it finally made its way to the bottom, sadly, with many of its crewmen on board".
He said the wreck was lost until a local dive team identified it in 2024.
Mr Robinson, who has been diving for about 35 years, said he heard about the unidentified wreck from the UK Hydrographic Office.
He said the wreck "was clearly an early steamship when we got down there" but "at the end of my dive I found a broken piece of plate... I decided to bring it up to the surface [and] we found that had the Cunard Steamship crest on it".
"It was then bingo, we've found it," he said.
Dr Bennett said it was identified by the build and dimensions of the wreck, the technology on board, the cargo and "lastly and most telling, they find a plate on the back of which is stamped Cunard - this is a Cunard ship".
"[It was] very methodical, very, very dedicated detective work," he said.
More news stories for Devon
Listen to the latest news for Devon
Mr Robinson said: "This was an awful tragedy. One of the things I like to think is by solving mysteries and telling those stories I'm ensuring that those people aren't forgotten."
Since the initial find, Mr Robinson said he had dived the wreck again and found a second piece of Cunard crockery, providing "even more confirmation".
"There are very few mysteries left to explore in this world," he said.
"As a normal human being like me, going in exploring shipwrecks and identifying shipwrecks, that is just something different to my normal life, and it's a fantastic feeling."
Dr Bennett said "all the pieces fit and I think the local dive team are to be congratulated on a splendid piece of detective work which reveals this maritime disaster".
He said he had looked at the footage and methodology and had confirmed they were right "beyond any reasonable shadow of a doubt, this is the SS Nantes".
Follow BBC Devon on X, Facebook and Instagram. Send your story ideas to spotlight@bbc.co.uk. Follow BBC Cornwall on X, Facebook and Instagram
Wreck thought to be WW2 storm-hit vessel
Diver buys WW1 shipwreck for £300 on Facebook
University of Plymouth
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Works to replace unsafe 'high fire risk' cladding on Thamesmead blocks
A housing developer will replace the unsafe 'high fire risk' cladding of eight Thamesmead tower blocks but residents remain frustrated, feeling the job is only half-finished. Residents of Royal Artillery Quays (RAQ) have campaigned for over half a decade to make their home safe after several investigations identified building defects in the residential complex that posed a serious fire risk. As previously reported by the Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS), chartered engineering and advisory firm Urban Change gave all eight buildings a high fire risk rating in 2022 primarily due to the 'poor workmanship' it identified in the installation of the external wall insulation (EWI) system. Urban Change found that fire break fixings were missing, not regularly spaced and made of plastic and not steel, making them more susceptible to failure if exposed to fire. The investigation also discovered that the expanded polystyrene (EPS) render system in the EWI wasn't thick enough, with the report stating: 'This could lead to early exposure of the combustible insulation to fire.' Barratt Developments, the original developer of the eight block complex that was built in 2002, has announced that work to remediate the problems found within RAQ's external walls will begin this month, at no cost to leaseholders. These works are based on the recommendations of the Urban Change report and have recently been approved by the Building Safety Regulator (BSR). A Barratt spokesperson said: 'As the original developer for Royal Artillery Quays, we remain committed to remediating any fire safety issues identified in the original construction of the buildings, at no cost to leaseholders, in line with our obligations under the Developer Remediation Contract we signed in March 2023. 'Now that the external wall remediation designs have been approved by the Building Safety Regulator, we look forward to starting works in mid-late June.' The Local Democracy Reporting Service understands that the work will involve the removal and replacement of the EPS render system contained within RAQ's EWI that covers approximately 90 per cent of the overall development building façade, as well as any other items identified as requiring remediation. Although pleased that this work will begin soon, RAQ residents still fear the job is not done as no plan to remedy problems found in the complex's internal walls has been offered. RAQ's property manager Rendall & Rittner commissioned fire safety inspectors to conduct a fire stopping survey at three of the eight tower blocks in 2019. The purpose of the survey was to test whether the internal sections and rooms within the tower blocks had sufficient structural integrity to prevent fires spreading from one part of the building to another. In a report seen by the LDRS, the inspectors stated: 'Our survey establishes that the areas, as surveyed, currently do not meet the minimum statutory requirements, and without remedial attention it is conceivable that any fire incident could result in significant loss and possible prosecution of The Responsible Person(s) and their individual Duty Holders.' RAQ resident George Boyd said: 'Crucially, the internal remediation work has not yet been approved. "We are aware of the potential for extensive costs, as evidenced by the £432 million spent to rectify similar internal defects at Olympic Village. 'Disturbingly, fire safety reports for RAQ, including the Gresham IMS report, highlight the serious nature of these internal defects, even suggesting the possibility of prosecutions in the event of a fire.' Mr Boyd also fears that the external wall remediation work won't go far enough either, as Urban Change stated that only the first two storeys of aluminium corner panels on RAQ's fire escape staircases would need to be replaced, despite the insulation of these panels having a Euroclass rating of E, the second most combustible rating in the fire class system. Urban Change said: 'The other corner panels higher up the stair core are not being replaced as there are no ignition sources externally or internally.' Mr Boyd was critical of this, claiming that this decision will condemn RAQ residents to permanently higher insurance. He said: 'While the external wall remediation is approved, we are deeply concerned that combustible materials, now prohibited in new constructions, will remain within our fire escape stairwells. 'Insurers have indicated that this will lead to permanently high insurance premiums, likely further increasing our already substantial monthly service charges. Furthermore, real estate experts have advised that this partial remediation, sanctioned by the BSR, is likely to have a significant negative impact on the value of our properties. 'As a long-term resident nearing retirement, my flat represents my life investments, and this continued devaluation is a major worry.' Another RAQ resident Sue McDougall said the remediation work 'will not make me feel safe' due to the lack of internal work being carried out. She said: 'Am I and other residents celebrating? Unfortunately, the answer from many of us is not yet.' Steve Day, chair of the Royal Artillery Quays Residents association, has been campaigning to rectify the fire safety problems at RAQ for over five years. He has been critical of Greenwich Council for not backing residents' claims that Barratt breached building regulations during the development's construction over 20 years ago. He said: 'We welcome the work starting on the external wall remediation, but are concerned that the internal remediation hasn't yet been scoped and signed off. 'The undermining of all our evidence by the council of building safety breaches at the time of construction severely hampers our campaign to ensure our internal remediations are done to the standards that are required.' Mr Day referred to an email seen by the LDRS that was sent to him by Greenwich councillor Rachel Taggart-Ryan on April 22 which stated: 'There is no evidence to suggest that the works were in breach of the Building Regulations applicable at the time of construction.' In response to Barratt's announcement that the BSR had approved the EWI remediation work, a Greenwich Council spokesperson said: 'We believe strongly that everyone in Royal Greenwich should have a safe and secure home. 'Royal Artillery Quays is a private development, and its cladding is the developer's responsibility. "We will continue to engage with residents and stakeholders as appropriate to ensure necessary action is taken. 'While we remain neutral in terms of the building's original construction, we're pleased a scheme of work, proposed by the developer, has now been agreed by the Building Safety Regulator and we understand that works are due to begin by the end of June 2025 to bring all buildings to the BSR standards. 'There are no specific powers available to the council to speed up the developer's process. Our priority is ensuring a swift resolution, mediating where appropriate, to ensure the works agreed between the developer and BSR are completed.'
Fox News
2 hours ago
- Fox News
Etiquette expert criticized for claiming 'only way' to eat a banana is with knife and fork
An etiquette expert and the author of a new book about manners is causing plenty of online chatter about the proper way to eat a banana and other common handheld foods. William Hanson is the author of "Just Good Manners: A Quintessential Guide to Courtesy, Charm, Grace and Decorum," which was released on May 27. Hanson is an executive director of London's The English Manner, the "leading etiquette and protocol institute" in the United Kingdom, according to its website. He's also gained a large audience with his etiquette videos on social media, with over 6 million followers on Instagram and TikTok combined. In a recent video, Hanson talked about "the only way you should be eating a banana." "No, we don't pick it up and peel it like a primate," Hanson, who declined to be interviewed, said in the video. "Instead, we use a knife and fork. First, going from one end, cut it off, then cut off the other end, turning your knife on its side. Then score down the skin, peel back and eat like so." The video shows him eating a banana slice with a fork. It has prompted over 200,000 views and over 28,000 comments. "I'm not doing extra dishes for a banana, William," one person wrote. "That's enough now, William! Time out!" wrote another commenter. "Bruh, you offended the entire world's population," said another person. For more Lifestyle articles, visit He has similar videos about the proper way to eat grapes, rice and peas. But what's supposedly sophisticated in England may come across as peculiar in the United States. "There are definitely different customs in other countries, but most often you will not be served a whole banana with the peel in most formal settings," Diane Gottsman, founder and owner of the Protocol School of Texas in San Antonio, told Fox News Digital. Gottsman called Hanson "a wonderful personality." She said it's perfectly acceptable to eat a banana with your hands. "There is seldom a time when you will be served a whole banana at a formal function," she said. "The best thing to do is observe the host and follow the same technique."
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Terrifying moment blaze tears through Edinburgh banana flats as locals watch on
Edinburgh locals captured the terrifying moment a fire tore through the iconic banana flats on Friday night. Cables Wynd House saw a large fire break out around 10.50pm on June 6, with fire services battling the blaze for over eight hours. Video footage shared with Edinburgh Live shows flames pouring from the windows of a flat near the top floor. READ MORE: Excited Edinburgh couple take on new venture to transform community pub READ MORE: Edinburgh police cordon off city centre street in 'ongoing incident' Some residents filmed from the ground while others captured the chaos from inside Cables Wynd flats across a courtyard. Smoke can be seen billowing into the air from the scene. Police Scotland confirmed the flat was empty at the time and no one was hospitalised following the incident. All residents, bar two households, have been allowed to return to the building. A message on Cables Wynd House's Facebook called the fire "heartbreaking" and said residents are "waiting for answers" following the "scary experience". Locals and politicians took to social media offering words of support to those impacted by the blaze. Tracy Gilbert, MP for Edinburgh North and Leith, announced: "I can confirm that three people were treated at the scene last night for smoke inhalation but thankful did not require hospitalisation. Can I thank the Fire Services, Police Scotland and Edinburgh Council for the response last night. I'm so glad that everyone is safe." Chas Booth, a city councillor for Leith, said: "Very concerned to hear about this and my thoughts are with all those affected. I'm in touch with council officers about this and I understand staff are in the building this morning helping residents affected." A concerned local shared: "I wonder how it started and where. Very sad for the people affected. I've never heard this before in 50 years living in Leith." One resident of Cables Wynd House who captured the shocking footage told Edinburgh Live: "It was bad. I was a scared if someone was in the flat and I thought we were going to have to leave the building in case it started spreading more. "It was like something exploded. I feel bad for the people [who live there], they have lost all their stuff in the house fire." The message on the Cables Wynd House Facebook page read: "So tonight has been a really scary experience of a fire in the building, a fast evacuation and worries of lives of those anywhere near those flames. Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages. "This is a time for all of us to pull together & support each other. In kindness, respect & neighbourly solidarity. "We are waiting for answers but right now we're focusing on our neighbours who've all been through such a scary experience and those whose homes were damaged in the flats." A spokesperson from the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service said: "We were alerted to a fire at Cables Wynd House, known locally as the 'banana flats' at 10.49pm on June 6. "We dispatched nine appliances and departed just after 7.00am on June 7. There are no casualties that we were made aware of." A Police Scotland spokesperson said: "Around 11pm on Friday, 6 June 2025, police were advised by SFRS of a fire at a flat in Cables Wynd House, Edinburgh. "The flat was empty at the time. No one required to be taken to hospital. All residents, bar two households, have been allowed to return to the building. Enquiries into the cause of the fire, which at this time is not being treated as suspicious, are ongoing." Cables Wynd House was made famous by its appearance in the 1996 film Trainspotting. Built in the 1960s, it has since become an Edinburgh landmark. In 2017 it was given top listing by Historic Environment Scotland - the same level as Edinburgh Castle.
