‘Students shouldn't have to gamble future on outdated system' – Social Democrats TD on why CAO system needs a switch-up
UP TO 61,000 students will sit the Leaving Cert this year.
But before a paper has even been seen, there are concerns that the class of 2025 will be at a disadvantage when it comes to the CAO process.
Advertisement
2
61,000 students will sit the Leaving Cert this year
Credit: Getty Images - Getty
2
Ciara Kelly from Newstalk added her voice to the campaign
Credit: Bryan Meade - The Sunday Times
This is because around 15,000
She said that grade inflation has caused
Writing in the Irish Sun on Sunday today, Education Spokesperson for the Social Democrats, JEN CUMMINS TD, says a more general reform of the Leaving Cert is needed if we're to ensure equality of opportunity for all...
Advertisement
READ MORE IN OPINION
FROM the first day of first year, secondary
It's no wonder, then, that pupils and their
Numerous
Their concerns are justified, as the
Advertisement
Most read in The Irish Sun
This comes as a result of the rudderless Government
Successive
GRADE INFLATION CRISIS
In 2023, over 15 per cent of students received a H1 grade in at least one of their subjects - almost twice those who achieved that milestone in 2019.
In tandem, the average points awarded to students increased by almost 60 points over that same period, a monumental surge.
Advertisement
The
Gross artificial points inflation, a kneejerk reaction to life during lockdown, has led to points lotteries becoming the norm for high-demand courses like medicine, law and engineering - six years of building towards Leaving Cert excellence now often culminates in the equivalent of throwing your name into a hat.
SCHEMES IMPACTS DILUTED
As a result, students now feel they must achieve perfect scores just to compete for entrance to these lotteries, an unreasonable burden fraught with anxiety and pressure which detracts from a healthy education and general
Nobody needs reminding of how stressful the Leaving Cert experience was before its expectations were ramped up even higher - generations of past pupils who are still haunted by Leaving Cert nightmares can attest to as much.
Advertisement
Even more crucially, grade inflation has diluted the impact of the The Higher Education Access Route (HEAR) and Disability Access Route to Education (DARE) schemes, which were designed to level the playing field for students facing socioeconomic or
Applicants once supported by up to 40 point reductions as a result of the schemes are now being outpaced by peers aided by overall grade inflation, an indiscriminate boost which may kick the ladder away from those who should gain entry to their desired course via these pathways.
Both initiatives require urgent recalibration to restore their intended functions - we're already seeing applicants slip through cracks which were once covered by these schemes up until the last few years.
Students shouldn't have to gamble their future on inflated grades and limited places"
While these pitfalls must be addressed immediately, more general reform of the Leaving Cert is needed if we're to ensure equality of opportunity for all.
Advertisement
A broader model of assessment, more continuous evaluation, and a system that values learning over rote performance is long overdue.
The CAO itself also needs restructuring if it's to reflect the realities of modern student achievement and course demand.
The
The Minister for Education must ensure that runaway measures like grade inflation are not deployed as remedies to any future crises without maintaining a notion of how fairness can be maintained.
Advertisement
Students shouldn't have to gamble their future on inflated grades and limited places.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
6 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Pro garden designer reveals 69p hack that will kill green flies without using any nasty chemicals to harm your plants
IF your garden is looking a bit of a mess and you want to ensure it looks fresh, you've come to the right place. It turns out that there's a nightmare pest that may be living in your garden - and it could be the reason why your 2 You may spot aphids clustered on the stem of soft shoots – look under leaves in particular Credit: Getty 2 Pollyanna Wilkinson, right, shared how to banish the pest without harming your garden Credit: The Ins & Outs Podcast Aphids are extremely common and can impact plant growth. They have tiny soft pear-shaped bodies, and are usually green or black. You may spot them clustered on the stem of soft shoots – look under leaves in particular – or may find a sticky substance on your plants that gives away aphids have been there sucking at the sap. But while there's no need to be alarmed, it's best to identify the problem as soon as possible - and luckily, a gardening whizz has come to rescue with a wallet-friendly solution. read more on gardening Speaking on her podcast, Pollyanna Wilkison responded to a listener who had written into the show how to banish the The gardening designer said: ''We're getting a lot of questions about how to get rid of aphids and it's a tricky one. ''Because on the one side, I want to say to you aphids are actually amazing forage for loads of really important insects - ladybugs, hoverflies, parasitoid wasps all eat aphids. ''They will be eaten by these guys if you leave them alone.'' Most read in Fabulous However, if you're dealing with ''an absolute infestation'', there's something you can use - and it's already in your According to Pollyanna, green-fingered Brits can use washing-up liquid - which you can snap up for around 65p from your local supermarket. The £14.50 Wickes buy people are swearing by to get rid of weeds on their driveway for GOOD She explained in ''That's not going to hurt anything. ''Whatever they breathe through, it blocks it and then they die.'' Keep pests out all summer IF you want to ensure that your home is pest free this summer, here's what you need to know. Hornets and wasps - hate the smell of peppermint oil so spraying this liberally around your patio or balcony can help to keep them at bay. Moths - acidic household white vinegar is effective for deterring moths. Soak some kitchen roll in vinegar and leave it in your wardrobe as a deterrent. Flying ants - herbs and spices, such as cinnamon, mint, chilli pepper, black pepper, cayenne pepper, cloves, or garlic act as deterrents. Mosquitoes - plants, herbs and essential oil fragrances can help deter mozzies inside and out. Try eucalyptus, lavender and lemongrass. ''We're not here for the pesticides - the washing-up liquid will do it absolutely fine.'' The gardening whizz also recently shared 'Hate them. I effing hate hanging baskets. 'And the reason I hate them is much the same reason that I hate small pots.' She shared the first reason for this is that she doesn't think they are 'very attractive as a vessel.' Pollyanna explained on the 'And I don't like seeing plastic in the garden. 'And also the body of soil that a hanging basket holds - unless it's those amazing ones outside the Ritz, which are just the most extraordinary thing I've ever seen, but those are the sides of a beach ball - it's just, it's this tiny little dish of mud.'
Irish Independent
11 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Leaving Cert 2025: English Paper One – how would you get on?
From Margaret Atwood to the Booker Prize-winner and a short story about a reckless character, the paper was varied but much to be expected for students. In case you haven't had a bout of Leaving Cert nightmares recently, check out if you could answer the below questions that came up on today's paper. The paper is split into two sections, with reading comprehensions making up the first section and a personal essay in the second section. Section one Section one contained three texts based on the underdog effect, a speech by Margaret Atwood, and edited extracts from Samantha Harvey's novel, Orbital. Text 2 focused on a speech given last year by Margaret Atwood, author of The Handmaid's Tale. It focuses on Atwood's advice to the younger generation. A timely question given the recently released season finale of the series inspired by Atwood's novel. Do you think you could answer these three questions? Text 3 featured edited extracts from Harvey's novel, Orbital published in 2023. It tells the story of six astronauts in an H-shaped spacecraft rotating above the earth. Orbital is also current, with the novel taking home the Booker Prize in November 2024. Can you answer this question? Section two Section two features a choice of seven different composition assignments intended to reflect language study in the areas of information, argument, persuasion, narration and the aesthetic use of language. Questions varied from asking students to write a feature article, short story, discursive essay, speech and personal essay. Check out these three questions to see if you'd be up to the challenge.
Irish Examiner
13 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Could you pass English paper 1? First Leaving Cert exams of 2025 'very balanced'
Podcasting, underdogs, a 'love letter to Ireland', a rally cry to young people from the author of The Handmaid's Tale and an extract from the Booker Prize winner all featured on the higher level 2025 English paper 1. Overall, the first papers to open the 2025 Leaving Cert exams were 'very balanced' and themed around perspectives. Podcasting and poetry made appearances on the Junior Cycle papers, where a question on short stories may have caused some students to stumble. There were lots of opportunities for students when it came to the higher level English paper 1 Leaving Cert questions, according to Kate Barry. The English teacher with Loreto Secondary School, College Road in Fermoy and subject spokesperson for the Association of Secondary Teachers Ireland (ASTI) said she believed this year's papers were 'very fair on the whole.' 'I really liked the three texts they gave,' she added. This included an article by science writer David Robson, a speech made by Margaret Atwood, author of The Handmaid's Tale, and an extract from Samantha Harvey's 2024 novel Orbital which won last year's Booker Prize. In her speech, Margaret Atwood gives advice to young people, referring to herself, 'a wise old counsellor'. 'It's good to see someone of her calibre appearing,' Ms Barry said. "There was a good level of challenge in the Section A questions.' 'The three questions were very similar, they were very consistent, and nice and general. They asked students to write about elements of language that are elegant, thought-provoking, or inspiring. Sometimes those questions can be very 'tick the box', whereas I thought this was nice and broad, you can bring in a lot there. However, she was more critical of the paper's Question Bs, which carry 50 marks. In particular, a question that asked students to imagine they are a contributor to a podcast while reflecting on how their perspective on a significant issue changed. 'I don't see why that question needs to be for a podcast,' Ms Barry said. 'It's a lovely invitation to write, it's a very nice topic and encourages them to think and reflect, but I don't see why it needs to be for a podcast.' 'I think they are trying to be current, and they think 'well a lot of people listen to podcasts'.' The other two Question Bs were more creative, asking students to imagine they are either a sports captain or a hotel manager. 'Not everybody is up for that so it was good to have a question where they could write as themselves.' Meanwhile, the higher-level essay topics, which carry 100 marks, were 'really nice'. 'There were some really nice options there, I thought,' Ms Barry said. In particular, she liked the option that asked students to write a speech for or against the motion that: Truth has become a valueless currency in today's world. 'I really like the questions where students can take it personally, and can write about their own lives, but there was plenty of scope there if they do want to engage in current events.' Another of the questions she liked was the option to write a love letter to Ireland. 'Some of these essay questions can be a bit doom and gloom, but this question asked students to view contemporary Ireland from an optimistic lens. It gives them an opportunity to be positive, which actually can be a challenge.' The only essay question she has concerns about was one asking students to reflect on some of the factors that would influence their voting intentions in future elections. 'You'd really expect and hope that all the people correcting that would put their own views to the side. I don't think it would be a popular one anyway." Ordinary level English paper 1 The ordinary level English paper 1 had some 'accessible' texts that included extracts from the writing of Paul Howard and Rosaleen McDonagh as well a visual image question themed around 'Love in Many Guises' which included song lyrics from The Beatles, Ed Sheeran and Taylor Swift as well as Mark Twain and Lao Tzu among others. In particular, Ms Barry liked the essay question on this paper that asked students to reflect on the importance of people standing up for their views and beliefs. "Sometimes people have different reasons for taking ordinary level English,' she said. 'Sometimes they haven't been in Ireland very long and wouldn't have enough English to do the higher-level paper but they would be well able to come up with their own thoughts and opinions. "It's not aimed too young, it takes into account that they are emerging adults, grappling with adult themes too.' Junior Cycle Overall, the Junior Cycle papers were 'lovely and clear', Ms Barry said. Similarly, the idea of perspectives came up on the Junior Cycle exam. Podcasting made another appearance on the 2025 Junior Cycle exam, with a question based around 'The Black & Irish Podcast'. However, a question asking students to write about a short story they have covered may have caused some to stumble. 'That technically is on the course, it is a specification but that specification is huge,' Ms Barry explained. 'The amount of material they must cover on it, and that is the first year they have specifically been asked to cover a short story they have studied. It's very, very difficult to teach the whole specification,' she added. 'I would expect they would interpret short stories there liberally when they go to correct it. It's something they might not have done. They would have read them as part of the Junior Cycle, but they mightn't have been expecting them as an exam question.' 'It's come up in the past to write their own short story, rather than analyse one as a text. Some of our students here, they were able to take something they had read and answer that way but I do think out of all the questions, that was so new and that would have been the one that caused some to stumble.' 'That will all be reflected when they come to the marking scheme, I would reassure people about that.' The ordinary level Junior Cycle paper was very 'nice and straightforward', she added. 'I'm not sure about this way they have of testing vocabulary where they ask what this word means, and they mightn't know the word, they just get given a random five words, but overall, I did think it was very candidate friendly.' Read More Record number of students to sit State exams this year
