How Sean ‘Diddy' Combs got off on sex trafficking, racketeering charges after feds built ‘weak' case': experts
Federal prosecutors overplayed their hand in Sean 'Diddy' Combs' bombshell federal trial by building a case based 'more on sensationalism' with 'mobster-like charges' than a solid legal basis — ultimately leading to his stunning acquittal Wednesday on the most serious charges he faced, legal experts told The Post.
Jurors found Combs, 55, not guilty of sex trafficking and racketeering charges, while convicting him on lesser prostitution counts.
The outcome didn't surprise veteran defense attorney David S. Seltzer, managing partner at Seltzer Mayberg, LLC, who said the feds proved that Combs abused women and enjoyed voyeuristic sex, but failed to prove that the mogul's sins and kinks were part of a Mafia-like criminal enterprise.
Advertisement
3 Sean 'Diddy' Combs was acquitted on racketeering and sex trafficking charges Wednesday.
AP
'The government's case was weak from the start,' Seltzer, who wasn't involved in the case, told The Post.
'They tried to put a square peg in a round hole, using mobster-like charges, when all they had were glorified State Court charges.'
Advertisement
3 Prosecutors alleged Combs ran a criminal enterprise.
Getty Images for The Recording Academy
Prosecutors pursued a Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act — or RICO — case against the Bad Boy Records mogul, alleging he used his business empire to conceal sordid crimes, including forcing his girlfriends into degrading, drug-fueled sex romps he dubbed 'freak-offs.'
Defense attorney and former prosecutor Neama Rahmani agreed that the outcome hinged on how prosecutors could prove he ran a criminal enterprise.
'Like I've said all along, this case will come down to racketeering,' Rahmani predicted ahead of the verdict.
Advertisement
'If the government doesn't get a RICO conviction, this will be a huge loss and the most expensive prostitution trial in American history.'
During the sensational two-month trial, Combs' former girlfriends Cassie Ventura and a woman only identified as 'Jane' testified they were coerced into disturbing 'freak-offs' with escorts.
But Nicole Brenecki, a New York trial attorney, said the testimony indicated that Combs' ex-girlfriends appear to have 'willingly taken part in 'freak-offs.''
'Voluntary participation, no matter how controversial, doesn't equal organized crime,' Brenecki said.
Advertisement
The prosecution's case fell apart because it was 'built more on sensationalism than a solid legal basis,' Brenecki opined.
'RICO charges require proof of an ongoing criminal enterprise with coordinated activity by multiple actors, not just deviant parties and disgruntled ex-girlfriends,' she said.
'Add to that the lack of paper trails, cooperating witnesses inside the alleged 'enterprise,' or any clear hierarchy of criminal role, and you're left with smoke, but no fire — and a not guilty verdict follows.'
3 One expert said prosecutors proved Combs had sexual kinks, but not that he ran a Mafia-like organization.
David Schwartz, a New York City-based trial attorney and former prosecutor, agreed that the prostitution charges were the strongest.
'The case was overcharged and the jury got this one exactly right,' Schwartz said.
Combs' defense team, by contrast, 'owned' the bad facts in the case and it 'paid off' for the hip-hop mogul, said Anna Cominsky, a professor at New York Law School.
Advertisement
'This trial was a major gamble and Combs won that bet,' she said.
'Everything is stacked against the defendant going into a federal case, in particular one like this. His attorneys were smart and they owned the bad facts. They fought on the things that mattered and it paid off.'
The federal prosecution office that oversaw the Combs case released a statement Wednesday that 'sex crimes deeply scar victims' — without commenting directly on the verdict.
'Sex crimes deeply scar victims, and the disturbing reality is that sex crimes are all too present in many aspects of our society,' US Attorney for the Southern District of New York Jay Clayton and Special Agent in Charge of the New York Field Office of Homeland Security Investigations Ricky Patel wrote.
Advertisement
'Victims endure gut-wrenching physical and mental abuse, leading to lasting trauma,' the statement added. 'New Yorkers and all Americans want this scourge stopped and perpetrators brought to justice.'
The statement did not directly address the jury's decision to acquit Combs on more serious racketeering and sex trafficking charges and convict him only on lesser prostitution raps.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
22 minutes ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Photos of grief and tributes after deaths of Diogo Jota and his brother
The death of Portugal and Liverpool forward Diogo Jota, and his brother, prompted an outpouring of grief from fans, players and officials across both women's and men's soccer. Jota and his brother André Silva were killed in a car crash shortly after midnight in northwestern Spain when the Lamborghini they were traveling in veered off a road and burst into flames, according to Spanish police. This is a photo gallery curated by AP photo editors. ___
Associated Press
38 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Photos of grief and tributes after deaths of Diogo Jota and his brother
The death of Portugal and Liverpool forward Diogo Jota, and his brother, prompted an outpouring of grief from fans, players and officials across both women's and men's soccer. Jota and his brother André Silva were killed in a car crash shortly after midnight in northwestern Spain when the Lamborghini they were traveling in veered off a road and burst into flames, according to Spanish police. This is a photo gallery curated by AP photo editors. ___ AP sports:
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Violent gangs have ‘near-total control' of Haiti's capital, UN says
Haiti's criminal gangs have exerted 'near-total control' over the capital, as escalating violence pushes the Caribbean nation 'closer to the brink,' senior U.N. officials warned Wednesday. Gangs control an estimated 90% of Port-au-Prince, Ghada Fathy Waly, executive director of the U.N. Office on Drugs and Crime, told the U.N. Security Council. Waly noted that gangs are expanding into previously peaceful areas. Advertisement 'Southern Haiti, which until recently was insulated from the violence, has seen a sharp increase in gang-related incidents,' she said. 'And in the east, criminal groups are exploiting land routes, including key crossings like Belladere and Malpasse, where attacks against police and customs officials have been reported.' U.N. Assistant Secretary-General Miroslav Jenca informed the council that 'the ongoing gang encirclement of Port-au-Prince' and their strengthened foothold in the capital and beyond is 'pushing the situation closer to the brink.' 4 According to Ghada Fathy Waly, executive director of the U.N. Office on Drugs and Crime, gangs control an estimated 90% of Port-au-Prince, Haiti. AP 4 Armed members of the G9 and Family gang stand guard at their roadblock in the Delmas 6 neighborhood of Port-au-Prince, Haiti, in March 2024. AP Advertisement 4 Security guards stand watch as Haiti's Prime Minister Alix Didier Fils-Aime, center, talks with Mexico's Charge d'Affaires Jesus Cisneros in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, on June 26. AP 4 Protesters make their way to the Villa d'Accueil to demand increased security from the government, in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, on April 2, where over one million people have been displaced by gang-related violence in the country. AFP via Getty Images Every morning, the NY POSTcast offers a deep dive into the headlines with the Post's signature mix of politics, business, pop culture, true crime and everything in between. Subscribe here! 'Without increased action by the international community, the total collapse of state presence in the capital could become a very real scenario,' he warned. Advertisement Gangs have gained power since President Jovenel Moïse's assassination in July 2021, previously controlling 85% of the capital. Haiti has not had a president since the assassination. A new U.N. report covering last October through February highlights that gangs have exploited political turmoil and Haiti's disorganized security response, saying competing political ambitions and corruption allegations within transitional governing bodies have hindered action. 'While the expansion of territorial control brings gangs additional sources of revenue and bargaining power,' the U.N. experts said in the report, 'these attacks are also backed by individuals trying to destabilize the political transition for their own political goals.' Advertisement The U.S. State Department issued a travel advisory for Haiti in September 2024, warning Americans against visiting due to kidnapping, crime, civil unrest and limited healthcare. In May, the Trump administration designated two of Haiti's most powerful gang networks, Viv Ansanm and Gran Grif, as foreign terrorist organizations and specially designated global terrorists.
