'Ripped Band-Aid off': Legend backs Cherry-Evans call
Queensland has "ripped the Band-Aid off" by axing Daly Cherry-Evans and replacing him with Tom Dearden at No.7 and Maroons legend Chris Close insists it was the right call.
Cherry-Evans was sacked as captain and halfback for game two of the State of Origin series in Perth after a 26-game career including the last 19 as skipper.
His last two games for Manly, losses to Newcastle and Gold Coast, have been underwhelming and vindicated Slater's decision in some respects.
"On this game alone and his performance tonight, it shows that Billy Slater's call with Tommy Dearden was the right one," former Maroons half Cooper Cronk said on Fox League after the Sea Eagles' 28-8 loss to the Titans.
The 18-6 series-opening loss in Brisbane disappointed Close, man of the match in the first two Origins in 1980 and 1981, told AAP the performance of Cherry-Evans and Dearden, who came off the bench, was in stark contrast.
"You have to look at the impact both players had in game one," Close said.
"Daly Cherry-Evans turned 36 before the match as the oldest to ever play Origin. He goes into the game and carries it (with conviction) once.
"If you look at (NSW halves in game one) Cleary and Moses and look at Dearden and the amount of times they carry the ball, it is vastly different.
"You can't go into an Origin game and be inert. Just passing the ball and putting a few kicks in, more is required at Origin level. You have got to be the leader in your position. When Tom Dearden came on things did start to happen. We didn't look dangerous at any stage until he took the field.
"You've got to rip the Band-Aid off and get on with it. Sad as it is for Daly Cherry-Evans who has been an iconic performer for Queensland, Billy Slater has identified that his time is up and we need to go in a different direction if we want to look after our future and maintain our levels of performance, not only in this game coming up but in games beyond that."
Close said Dearden's Origin debut in the 2022 decider, won by the Maroons, spoke volumes.
"If you go back to the first game that Tom Dearden played in Origin, think about a pass he threw to Valentine Holmes that led to a try," he said.
"That was an Origin pass and what Origin players need to do. They need to be able to do that at the time when it is needed the most.
"I am not critical of Daly Cherry-Evans. How could anyone be critical of his Origin career? It was remarkable. Many, many times he led the way. But he has got to the stage where he wasn't allowed to get into that (opening) game. We have got to change that."
Close said those critical of the axing of Cherry to realise that "the world doesn't stop" when good players are forced to retire.
"Did the world stop when Wally Lewis couldn't play any more Origins? No it didn't," he said.
"Let's find another mindset where we find a player who will take over and give us what we need - a performance at a level that is way above what they give on a week-in and week-out basis.
"Every one of those New South Welshman that played in game one played above their club standard to a level that is called State of Origin. Apart from Tommy Dearden, I didn't recognise anyone in that Queensland side that went above that level."
Queensland has "ripped the Band-Aid off" by axing Daly Cherry-Evans and replacing him with Tom Dearden at No.7 and Maroons legend Chris Close insists it was the right call.
Cherry-Evans was sacked as captain and halfback for game two of the State of Origin series in Perth after a 26-game career including the last 19 as skipper.
His last two games for Manly, losses to Newcastle and Gold Coast, have been underwhelming and vindicated Slater's decision in some respects.
"On this game alone and his performance tonight, it shows that Billy Slater's call with Tommy Dearden was the right one," former Maroons half Cooper Cronk said on Fox League after the Sea Eagles' 28-8 loss to the Titans.
The 18-6 series-opening loss in Brisbane disappointed Close, man of the match in the first two Origins in 1980 and 1981, told AAP the performance of Cherry-Evans and Dearden, who came off the bench, was in stark contrast.
"You have to look at the impact both players had in game one," Close said.
"Daly Cherry-Evans turned 36 before the match as the oldest to ever play Origin. He goes into the game and carries it (with conviction) once.
"If you look at (NSW halves in game one) Cleary and Moses and look at Dearden and the amount of times they carry the ball, it is vastly different.
"You can't go into an Origin game and be inert. Just passing the ball and putting a few kicks in, more is required at Origin level. You have got to be the leader in your position. When Tom Dearden came on things did start to happen. We didn't look dangerous at any stage until he took the field.
"You've got to rip the Band-Aid off and get on with it. Sad as it is for Daly Cherry-Evans who has been an iconic performer for Queensland, Billy Slater has identified that his time is up and we need to go in a different direction if we want to look after our future and maintain our levels of performance, not only in this game coming up but in games beyond that."
Close said Dearden's Origin debut in the 2022 decider, won by the Maroons, spoke volumes.
"If you go back to the first game that Tom Dearden played in Origin, think about a pass he threw to Valentine Holmes that led to a try," he said.
"That was an Origin pass and what Origin players need to do. They need to be able to do that at the time when it is needed the most.
"I am not critical of Daly Cherry-Evans. How could anyone be critical of his Origin career? It was remarkable. Many, many times he led the way. But he has got to the stage where he wasn't allowed to get into that (opening) game. We have got to change that."
Close said those critical of the axing of Cherry to realise that "the world doesn't stop" when good players are forced to retire.
"Did the world stop when Wally Lewis couldn't play any more Origins? No it didn't," he said.
"Let's find another mindset where we find a player who will take over and give us what we need - a performance at a level that is way above what they give on a week-in and week-out basis.
"Every one of those New South Welshman that played in game one played above their club standard to a level that is called State of Origin. Apart from Tommy Dearden, I didn't recognise anyone in that Queensland side that went above that level."
Queensland has "ripped the Band-Aid off" by axing Daly Cherry-Evans and replacing him with Tom Dearden at No.7 and Maroons legend Chris Close insists it was the right call.
Cherry-Evans was sacked as captain and halfback for game two of the State of Origin series in Perth after a 26-game career including the last 19 as skipper.
His last two games for Manly, losses to Newcastle and Gold Coast, have been underwhelming and vindicated Slater's decision in some respects.
"On this game alone and his performance tonight, it shows that Billy Slater's call with Tommy Dearden was the right one," former Maroons half Cooper Cronk said on Fox League after the Sea Eagles' 28-8 loss to the Titans.
The 18-6 series-opening loss in Brisbane disappointed Close, man of the match in the first two Origins in 1980 and 1981, told AAP the performance of Cherry-Evans and Dearden, who came off the bench, was in stark contrast.
"You have to look at the impact both players had in game one," Close said.
"Daly Cherry-Evans turned 36 before the match as the oldest to ever play Origin. He goes into the game and carries it (with conviction) once.
"If you look at (NSW halves in game one) Cleary and Moses and look at Dearden and the amount of times they carry the ball, it is vastly different.
"You can't go into an Origin game and be inert. Just passing the ball and putting a few kicks in, more is required at Origin level. You have got to be the leader in your position. When Tom Dearden came on things did start to happen. We didn't look dangerous at any stage until he took the field.
"You've got to rip the Band-Aid off and get on with it. Sad as it is for Daly Cherry-Evans who has been an iconic performer for Queensland, Billy Slater has identified that his time is up and we need to go in a different direction if we want to look after our future and maintain our levels of performance, not only in this game coming up but in games beyond that."
Close said Dearden's Origin debut in the 2022 decider, won by the Maroons, spoke volumes.
"If you go back to the first game that Tom Dearden played in Origin, think about a pass he threw to Valentine Holmes that led to a try," he said.
"That was an Origin pass and what Origin players need to do. They need to be able to do that at the time when it is needed the most.
"I am not critical of Daly Cherry-Evans. How could anyone be critical of his Origin career? It was remarkable. Many, many times he led the way. But he has got to the stage where he wasn't allowed to get into that (opening) game. We have got to change that."
Close said those critical of the axing of Cherry to realise that "the world doesn't stop" when good players are forced to retire.
"Did the world stop when Wally Lewis couldn't play any more Origins? No it didn't," he said.
"Let's find another mindset where we find a player who will take over and give us what we need - a performance at a level that is way above what they give on a week-in and week-out basis.
"Every one of those New South Welshman that played in game one played above their club standard to a level that is called State of Origin. Apart from Tommy Dearden, I didn't recognise anyone in that Queensland side that went above that level."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
3 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
How Payne Haas helped end Laurie Daley's first spell in charge of NSW
'I wrote back, 'Be careful of what?' He then showed me a photo of the Queensland whiteboard, which simply said, 'Andrew Fifita'. 'I remember showing 'Loz' [Daley] and laughing and saying, 'That's when you know you've made it in Origin'. 'Then I heard they brought in Payne. He was only a schoolboy at the time, but he was big and versatile, we played kind of the same, and he was meant to mimic me. 'I think Cronulla played the Broncos last year and I wanted to know what had happened. He told me he was young, he helped Queensland out, but there's no way he'd do it now. 'That series ended up being the last one for Loz. It definitely cost me my chance to win an Origin series. 'Payne's not on the big money for nothing. He's so versatile, and knows what to do. He offloads, he attacks out wide – he does things front-rowers shouldn't do.' Haas, who was named man of the match following the 18-6 win over Queensland in game one last month, said he was never entirely sure what he was getting himself into when the young Broncos were called in to run an opposed session with the Maroons, a side which featured the likes of Billy Slater – now the Maroons' coach – Cameron Smith, and front-rowers Josh McGuire, Wallace and Josh Papali'i. Now 24, Haas also revealed how supercoach Wayne Bennett asked him to pledge his allegiance to the Maroons while still only a teenager in the Broncos system. Haas moved from Newcastle to the Gold Coast when he was 13, and he spent a short time in the Maroons pathways, only for Haas to come to his senses. The only thing that would have made the images of a beardless Haas training with the Maroons would have been him wearing the Queensland training gear, which, thankfully, he was not. 'I didn't know what I was getting into that day, they asked us Broncos boys to come in for an opposed session, and they wanted me to be a Fifita clone,' Haas said. 'It was weird because I was from NSW. Now, when I think back on it, if they asked me to do the same, I'd be like, 'f--- that'. 'I knew a few of the Queensland boys, including Josh McGuire, so it wasn't too bad. It was a cool experience at the time. I was given a taste of Origin, and got to find out how the players prepare. You also find out how much the Queenslanders hate us. Living in Queensland, I already knew that. 'I wanted to go hard against them and see how I went. It was good practice for me and I enjoyed it. 'We were at Sanctuary Cove. I was a baby then. I watched that first Origin game and Fifita killed it. 'I remember the Maroons wanting me to play for them. I remember Wayne Bennett wanting me to play for Queensland, and how he was off me when I told him I wanted to play for NSW. I knew I was always a Blue.' When you point out his Fifita impersonation helped Queensland put an end to Fifita's dominance on that series, and essentially left Daley without a job, Haas shakes his head and says: 'Loz had a great career in Origin. He's back here now. I'm indebted to him.' Haas was a standout when playing for NSW in the under-16s and under-18s. Mark O'Meley, a NSW hardman in his own right, coached Haas, and recalled how the Broncos front-rower, along with his Blues teammate Spencer Leniu, were the only pair to ever run over the top of him while holding tackling pads. One of the teams Haas loved watching growing up in the early 2000s was O'Meley's Bulldogs, which also featured Sonny Bill Williams, Willie Mason and Roy Asotasi. Loading O'Meley said of Haas: 'He's hands down the best prop in the comp. Someone said the other day he hasn't proven himself in Origin, or won a grand final, but he's won [five] Paul Morgan Medals with Brisbane, and a few Dally M props of the year. To me, when you watch him, he's the benchmark.' The frightening thing about Haas is he went into game one on limited preparation because of a quad injury – and now runs on to Optus Stadium injury-free and with a full week's worth of training. He is one of the rare big men with enough leg speed to get wide and run at the halves, just as he did with Daly Cherry-Evans and Cam Munster nearly three weeks ago. As for being the best prop in the game – potentially ever – Haas said: 'I've never looked at it like that. That chat is for other people. I don't play for the accolades, I play to win premierships, to win games, to have fun with my teammates, enjoy being in the present, and be where my feet are. I'm loving my time in Brisbane, and I'm loving my time in Origin camp. ''Madge' [Broncos coach Michael Maguire] has got me believing in myself and my leadership qualities. He's pushed me to be a leader, and I'm trying to be that leader around the boys at my club. 'He didn't want me to hurt myself before game one. I wanted to play, I expressed that to Madge, and he said, 'If you want to play, go and play'. He had a lot of faith in me.'
The Age
3 hours ago
- The Age
How Payne Haas helped end Laurie Daley's first spell in charge of NSW
'I wrote back, 'Be careful of what?' He then showed me a photo of the Queensland whiteboard, which simply said, 'Andrew Fifita'. 'I remember showing 'Loz' [Daley] and laughing and saying, 'That's when you know you've made it in Origin'. 'Then I heard they brought in Payne. He was only a schoolboy at the time, but he was big and versatile, we played kind of the same, and he was meant to mimic me. 'I think Cronulla played the Broncos last year and I wanted to know what had happened. He told me he was young, he helped Queensland out, but there's no way he'd do it now. 'That series ended up being the last one for Loz. It definitely cost me my chance to win an Origin series. 'Payne's not on the big money for nothing. He's so versatile, and knows what to do. He offloads, he attacks out wide – he does things front-rowers shouldn't do.' Haas, who was named man of the match following the 18-6 win over Queensland in game one last month, said he was never entirely sure what he was getting himself into when the young Broncos were called in to run an opposed session with the Maroons, a side which featured the likes of Billy Slater – now the Maroons' coach – Cameron Smith, and front-rowers Josh McGuire, Wallace and Josh Papali'i. Now 24, Haas also revealed how supercoach Wayne Bennett asked him to pledge his allegiance to the Maroons while still only a teenager in the Broncos system. Haas moved from Newcastle to the Gold Coast when he was 13, and he spent a short time in the Maroons pathways, only for Haas to come to his senses. The only thing that would have made the images of a beardless Haas training with the Maroons would have been him wearing the Queensland training gear, which, thankfully, he was not. 'I didn't know what I was getting into that day, they asked us Broncos boys to come in for an opposed session, and they wanted me to be a Fifita clone,' Haas said. 'It was weird because I was from NSW. Now, when I think back on it, if they asked me to do the same, I'd be like, 'f--- that'. 'I knew a few of the Queensland boys, including Josh McGuire, so it wasn't too bad. It was a cool experience at the time. I was given a taste of Origin, and got to find out how the players prepare. You also find out how much the Queenslanders hate us. Living in Queensland, I already knew that. 'I wanted to go hard against them and see how I went. It was good practice for me and I enjoyed it. 'We were at Sanctuary Cove. I was a baby then. I watched that first Origin game and Fifita killed it. 'I remember the Maroons wanting me to play for them. I remember Wayne Bennett wanting me to play for Queensland, and how he was off me when I told him I wanted to play for NSW. I knew I was always a Blue.' When you point out his Fifita impersonation helped Queensland put an end to Fifita's dominance on that series, and essentially left Daley without a job, Haas shakes his head and says: 'Loz had a great career in Origin. He's back here now. I'm indebted to him.' Haas was a standout when playing for NSW in the under-16s and under-18s. Mark O'Meley, a NSW hardman in his own right, coached Haas, and recalled how the Broncos front-rower, along with his Blues teammate Spencer Leniu, were the only pair to ever run over the top of him while holding tackling pads. One of the teams Haas loved watching growing up in the early 2000s was O'Meley's Bulldogs, which also featured Sonny Bill Williams, Willie Mason and Roy Asotasi. Loading O'Meley said of Haas: 'He's hands down the best prop in the comp. Someone said the other day he hasn't proven himself in Origin, or won a grand final, but he's won [five] Paul Morgan Medals with Brisbane, and a few Dally M props of the year. To me, when you watch him, he's the benchmark.' The frightening thing about Haas is he went into game one on limited preparation because of a quad injury – and now runs on to Optus Stadium injury-free and with a full week's worth of training. He is one of the rare big men with enough leg speed to get wide and run at the halves, just as he did with Daly Cherry-Evans and Cam Munster nearly three weeks ago. As for being the best prop in the game – potentially ever – Haas said: 'I've never looked at it like that. That chat is for other people. I don't play for the accolades, I play to win premierships, to win games, to have fun with my teammates, enjoy being in the present, and be where my feet are. I'm loving my time in Brisbane, and I'm loving my time in Origin camp. ''Madge' [Broncos coach Michael Maguire] has got me believing in myself and my leadership qualities. He's pushed me to be a leader, and I'm trying to be that leader around the boys at my club. 'He didn't want me to hurt myself before game one. I wanted to play, I expressed that to Madge, and he said, 'If you want to play, go and play'. He had a lot of faith in me.'
The Australian
8 hours ago
- The Australian
Yellow Brick goes agonisingly close to fairytale upset in Stradbroke Handicap
Queensland hero Yellow Brick almost pulled one of the great fairytale upsets in recent Stradbroke Handicap history but the $41 roughie was narrowly outgunned by favourite War Machine in the $3m race at Eagle Farm on Saturday. It was a bittersweet moment for father-and-daughter trainers Tony and Maddy Sears, who were proud of Yellow Brick's incredible effort but the moment was tinged with some sadness given they came so close to jagging the $1.8m winner's cheque. But they will settle for $540,000 in prizemoney as the runner-up in Queensland's premier race run on a good track on a sunny day in Brisbane. • PUNT LIKE A PRO: Become a Racenet iQ member and get expert tips – with fully transparent return on investment statistics – from Racenet's team of professional punters at our Pro Tips section. SUBSCRIBE NOW! The Straddie is 1400m but if it was run over 1500m on Saturday, the Sears would be popping the champagne corks because Yellow Brick, with Andrew Mallyon on board, was starting to wear down War Machine ($2.65) approaching the winning post. Tony Sears said he was incredibly proud of Maddy, who had been training Yellow Brick at the pair's Gold Coast stables before he joined his daughter on the Glitter Strip just two weeks ago. • 'The boys have done it': Hayes proud of sons' landmark Stradbroke success 'I'm more proud of Maddysen than the horse,' he said. 'She's done a great job getting him ready. 'I've only been down the Gold Coast for two weeks. She's defied all the odds. People think he wasn't going very well but we knew he was going well. 'I backed him. We honestly thought he could win. He's just got to be ridden quiet like that. 'It was unbelievable, she's done a great job with him.' Maddy Sears said after the race she was 'speechless'. 'He was tremendous,' she said about Yellow Brick, who last won in a $160,000 Listed race over 1400m at Eagle Farm in October. 'That was the favourite (War Machine) in the race and he gave him a fair headstart at the top of the straight. 'He was the widest runner and he had to do things the hard way but I couldn't be any prouder.' This week Maddy Sears compared five-year-old gelding Yellow Brick to a Labrador Retriever because he 'loves to be the centre of attention'. And although the spoils of victory went to War Machine and Lindsay Park, Yellow Brick sure grabbed his share of attention. • What the jockeys said: 2025 Stradbroke Handicap Meanwhile, champion jockey Craig Williams said another Queensland hero, old warrior Rothfire, was 'gallant' in finishing seventh for trainer Rob Heathcote, who would have preferred a softer track. The seven-year-old Rothfire had battled a hoof injury for the past 10 days after suffering an untimely stone bruise and was lucky to even make the prestigious race. 'From the outside barrier draw he gave me a beautiful ride from there,' Williams said about the 2020 JJ Atkins champion. 'I got on the back of the eventual winner. He travelled so well but the winner was too good for us late. 'He just got a bit tired today and as Rob Heathcote said, he didn't have the ideal preparation.'
