No new trials for Michigan school shooter's parents despite violation by prosecutors, judge rules
A judge on Wednesday denied requests for new trials by the parents of a Michigan school shooter, despite finding that prosecutors had committed a violation by failing to disclose agreements with two important witnesses.
Setting aside the involuntary manslaughter convictions of James and Jennifer Crumbley and starting over would be too severe, Oakland County Judge Cheryl Matthews said.
'The court would effectively be ignoring the impact of dozens of hours of testimony, postulating a basis for the jury verdict, dismissing a plethora of other evidence suggesting guilt, and impermissibly speculating about what 'might have happened,' ' Matthews said.
The Crumbleys are serving 10-year prison sentences. They didn't know their son had planned to commit a mass shooting at Oxford High School in 2021. But they were accused of failing to lock a gun at home and ignoring Ethan Crumbley 's mental health needs. Four students were killed.
The parents didn't take Ethan home on the day of the shooting when they were confronted with his macabre drawing of a gun, blood and dark messages.
School administrator Nick Ejak and counselor Shawn Hopkins testified about that meeting. But unknown to jurors and defense lawyers: The men earlier had given interviews to investigators with the promise that their words would not be used against them. They were never charged.
Lawyers for the Crumbleys argued that producing those agreements was a fundamental obligation of prosecutors. They said trial attorneys would have further tried to cast doubt on the credibility of Ejak and Hopkins during cross-examination.
'The lack of disclosure ... is in itself disturbing,' the judge acknowledged.
Prosecutor Karen McDonald's team had argued that the deals weren't immunity agreements and didn't need to be shared.
Jennifer Crumbley's appellate lawyer said the fight will continue in higher courts.
'So the prosecution intentionally cheated and violated the court rules, but they didn't cheat hard enough for the court to do anything about it," Michael Dezsi said.
Ethan Crumbley is serving a life prison sentence.
Crumbley, now 19, is serving a life prison sentence. His parents, James and Jennifer Crumbley, are each serving 10-year sentences for involuntary manslaughter. Prosecutors said they had ignored his mental health needs, bought him a gun as a gift and then failed to safely secure it.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
12 minutes ago
- The Independent
Washington erupts after agents handcuff Democratic Senator at DHS Secretary press conference
Washington erupted at the site of Sen. Alex Padilla of California being forcibly removed and pinned to the floor during a press conference with Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem. Almost immediately, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer denounced the apprehension of Padilla during a speech on the Senate floor. 'I just saw something that sickened my stomach, the manhandling of a United States Senator,' Schumer said. 'We need immediate answers to what the hell went on.' Padilla arrived at Noem's press conference to confront her about the Trump administration's 'increasingly extreme' actions on immigration. Los Angeles has seen unrest over the last week after Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) launched a series of raids on the nation's second-largest city, which has a large Latino and immigrant population. President Donald Trump sent in the National Guard despite the governor not giving permission to do so. Padilla's apprehension came as the House of Representatives was voting. Rep. Sylvia Garcia, a Democrat of Texas, could barely speak to The Independent because she was saddened by it. 'I've been saying this for months now, Donald Trump wants to be a dictator, and this is the latest escalation in what has been a very, very concerning series of events in recent weeks,' Rep. Yassamin Ansari of Arizona told The Independent. Almost immediately afterward, members of the House Democratic Caucus marched to Senate Majority Leader John Thune's office, where they passed by House Speaker Mike Johnson and heckled him as Johnson held a gaggle with reporters. Johnson, for his par,t assailed Democrats' behavior. 'The Democrat Party is on the wrong side,' Johnson told reporters. 'They're defending lawbreakers and now they're acting like lawbreakers themselves.' Afterward, as Johnson made his way to his office, Rep. Madeleine Dean, a Democrat from Pennsylvania, had a private exchange with the speaker, where Johnson supposedly told her that he is talking to Trump. 'I said, 'What's going on in LA? That's so incendiary,' she told reporters. 'What's the message that the president sent on day one when he pardoned everybody who attacked this Capitol and would have killed any one of us?' But as the White House prepared to host lawmakers for the annual congressional picnic — typically a setting for inter-branch comity — administration officials reacted to the images of Padilla being taken to his knees by federal agents with nothing short of glee. Communications Director Steven Cheung took to X to describe the California senator as 'a complete lunatic' who'd suffered a 'freak out.' One White House official slammed his behavior as 'attention-seeking' and 'embarrassing' while suggesting that Democrats who speak up in Padilla's defense will be showing themselves to be more concerned about their own privilege as elected officials than about the officers who are being harmed by violent rioters. Another said that the president had been delighted by the scene because it made Padilla look weak and emotional. White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt took to X to condemn the senator as well, writing that he'should be ashamed of his childish behavior' and accusing him of having 'crashed the middle of an official press conference being held by a cabinet secretary' and 'recklessly lunging' towards Noem while refusing to leave the room as directed by law enforcement officers. A person familiar with internal deliberations within the president's inner circle who asked not to be identified out of concern for retaliation said the administration sees no political downside to the images of law enforcement putting their hands on Democratic lawmakers because a significant portion of Trump's most fervent supporters have spent years calling for prominent members of that party to be arrested and prosecuted. Earlier this week, Trump suggested that his 'border czar,' Tom Homan, should arrest California Gov. Gavin Newsom. He has also called for Padilla's partner in the Senate, Adam Schiff, to be arrested for treason when Schiff served as a congressman. In the hours afterward, plenty of Democratic Senators, including Chris Murphy of Connecticut, Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts and Cory Booker of New Jersey, took to the Senate floor to defend their colleague. The incident with Padilla is just the latest flash point as the Trump administration continues to ramp up its efforts to conduct mass deportations of undocumented immigrants in the United States. It also coincides with his planned military parade.
Telegraph
34 minutes ago
- Telegraph
LA riots backed by pro-Hamas activists who called for city to burn
The violent protests engulfing Los Angeles are backed by pro-Hamas activists who called for the city to be 'burned', it can be revealed. Unity of Fields (UoF) celebrated attacks on police and encouraged an 'intifada' in response to the detention of illegal migrants. They shared details of upcoming protests with their members, encouraging them to take part in the 'uprising' and to spread the unrest across the US, The Telegraph can reveal. The group also celebrated a rioter who burned a self-driving Waymo car while wearing a Hamas armband and waving a Mexican flag. 'Wearing a Hamas armband and a PFLP (Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine) headband while burning a Waymo vehicle and waving a Mexican flag at the militant anti-ICE resistance is some real unity of the fields type s—,' the group wrote of the man. Protests against ICE raids targeting illegal migrants in California, some taking place at their workplaces, erupted in the state on Friday, with some turning violent. UoF organisers encouraged the followers to intervene to thwart ICE agents from arresting illegal migrants writing: 'Direct confrontation is the only way.' Formerly known as Palestine Action US, the group formed in 2023 shortly after the October 7 attacks. UoF, a phrase referring to a unified Palestinian armed resistance against Israel, announced it was transitioning into 'militant propaganda' against the United States a year later. 'We don't mean unity for unity's sake, but the protracted struggle it will take to reach a principled, higher unity against the forces of imperialism, Zionism, and fascism,' it wrote at the time. The group was subsequently banned from social media, including Meta, but remains on X. Marco Rubio, the secretary of state, last year implored the Department of Justice to open a domestic terror investigation into the 'anti-zionist' group over fears it could harm American citizens. Using Telegram, the encrypted messaging service, the group shared details of the LA riots to 10,000 supporters, who they have dubbed the 'Hamas Marxist army''. Apple subsequently banned the Telegram channel on all iPhones and other iOS devices in recent days. But their inflammatory language has continued online, where they referred to police officers as 'pigs' and urged them to be terrorised. 'Study the way that the broader community showed up to defend the UCLA encampment from zionist pigs and the LA pig department. This kind of community defence is embedded in the ground work that is happening in LA, learn from them,' a post read. The group wrote on X: 'You know what are good optics? Burning s--- down, pushing fascists off your block, and keeping your loved ones out of the state's dungeons. (Some might even call that winning)' In a statement to The Telegraph, UoF said its 'LA Intifada is one part of the international revolutionary sequence that was opened up by the Toufan Al-Aqsa,' a reference to the Hamas massacre of Israelis on October 7. The group went on to describe as 'legitimate' the killing of two innocent Israeli embassy workers in Washington DC last month. 'We view any acts of resistance against the violence of US-led imperialism as legitimate, from the George Floyd Rebellion to the LA Intifada to Elias Rodriguez's martyrdom operation.' Mr Rodriguez has been charged with federal and local murder offences in connection with the shooting of the Israeli embassy workers on May 27. The statement concluded: 'The duty of every revolutionary is to make the revolution. Long live the global intifada!' They concluded the statement with 'Up the Ra!' seemingly a reference to the IRA. As protests spread around the country, so too did the call for violence. The Solidarity Network, a group of 'anarchist organisers' in South Florida, shared a post on social media suggesting peaceful protests do not work. Writing that they were in 'solidarity with those fighting in LA', it said: 'Riots downtown are great, but what can you accomplish in small numbers, wearing a mask at night, with your phone at home?' They wrote: 'How's your cardio? Do your friends and you have a unique sign language? Have you ever crushed up car spark plugs? Do you know how to dampen and treat tear gas and pepper agents?' The group urged those interested to turn up to join protests 'in a mask', before adding it was 'not discouraging nor encouraging any specific illegal activity'. While the groups' funding remains unclear, one billionaire with links to Shanghai is accused of bankrolling some of the radical organisations involved in this week's peaceful protests. China-based Neville Roy Singham is expected to be called to testify in front of Congress about his funding of non-profits and Marxist groups. They include the Party for Liberation and Socialism, which is thought to have organised the peaceful demonstrations against ICE officials. There is no suggestion they were involved with any of the violence that engulfed LA. 'Paid insurrectionists behind violence' Donald Trump has claimed 'paid insurrectionists' were behind the violence in California. The US president said well-equipped 'agitators' had been paid to cause chaos in the country's second-biggest city, which has been the scene of disorder since Friday. 'These are paid insurrectionists. These are paid troublemakers. They're agitators. They're paid,' Mr Trump told reporters in the Oval Office on Tuesday. 'Do you think somebody walks up to a kerb and starts hammering pieces out, has all the equipment necessary and starts handing it out to people to use as a weapon? These are paid insurrectionists or agitators or troublemakers.' Using the term 'insurrectionists' opens the door to the president invoking the 1807 Insurrection Act, which would give deployed troops the power to arrest protesters. While the majority of protesters have been peaceful in Los Angeles, agitators have been turning up looking for trouble. Some have torched self-driving cars or thrown rocks, fireworks and Molotov cocktails at police. These groups, who are often dressed in head-to-toe black, their faces completely covered by masks, become more active after dark. Several journalists were shot by officers using non-lethal rounds as they covered the protests including a photographer employed by The Telegraph. Mr Trump deployed 2,000 members of the National Guard to the city, prompting a power struggle with Gavin Newsom, the California governor. A further 700 US marines have since arrived in the city. On Monday evening, police made over 100 arrests while two officers were injured. Ninety-six of the arrests were for failing to disperse in the downtown Los Angeles area.
Reuters
35 minutes ago
- Reuters
US court blocks CFPB move to scrap racial discrimination settlement
June 12 (Reuters) - A federal judge in Chicago on Thursday refused to allow the U.S. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau to vacate a racial discrimination settlement reached last year with a mortgage lender, finding there was no basis for granting an extraordinary request. The decision marked a setback after senior Trump administration officials claimed in March they were seeking redress for a company, Townstone Financial, that they said had been baselessly "persecuted" without evidence. Representatives for the agency and Townstone, which jointly filed the motion with the CFPB, did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The CFPB originally brought the case in 2020 during Donald Trump's first presidency, accusing Townstone of "redlining" by discouraging would-be Black home buyers from applying for mortgages through derogatory and disparaging comments in promotional materials. U.S. District Judge Franklin Valderrama cast doubt on CFPB claims that there had been no evidence underlying the CFPB's original case. Reversing a prior CFPB action in this way, he said, amounted to "an act of legal hara-kiri that would make a samurai blush." "At bottom, to grant the motion based on the arguments advanced by the parties would be to undermine the finality of judgments," Valderrama said. "That is a Pandora's box the court refuses to open."
