Aaron Nola Injury, Jose Alvarado Suspension Test Phils Pitching Depth
Philadelphia Phillies' Aaron Nola plays during the second baseball game of a doubleheader Wednesday, ... More May 14, 2025, in Philadelphia. (AP Photo/Matt Slocum)
On the surface, things appear to be going swimmingly for the Philadelphia Phillies. After a weekend sweep of the Pittsburgh Pirates, they stand at 28-18, on the heels of the New York Mets in the NL East. A couple of recent events add unexpected stress to the club's pitching staff, however.
The starting rotation, the team's clear primary strength, will be hampered in the short term by the loss of Aaron Nola with a sprained right ankle. Perhaps even more importantly, their bullpen - clearly not an area of comparable depth - will be without their closer, Jose Alvarado for 80 games due to a suspension for use of external testosterone, a banned PED. Upon completion of his suspension, Alvarado will not be eligible for the 2025 playoffs, should the Phils qualify.
Let's deal with Alvarado first. He's saved their bacon early, as the newly acquired Jordan Romano got off to a dreadful start. While Romano has now gathered himself, at least temporarily, he is one of only three Philly relievers (along with Matt Strahm an Orion Kerkering) who can currently be trusted anywhere near the end of anything resembling a close game. Joe Ross isn't bad himself, but is more a middle/long guy/spot starter candidate, and I'm already being charitable including Kerkering, who has a big arm but struggles to pitch with a downhill plane.
As good as the Phils' rotation is, they simply must have more reliable arms in their pen, and find themselves in a bit of a bind regarding how to address this shortfall. Do they cycle through their existing group and some of their more experienced Triple-A guys to find a hot hand, or trade from their starting pitching surplus or the top of their stacked deck of prospects to land an impact reliever type like the Orioles' Felix Bautista via trade?
While they may eventually be forced to go the latter route, I wouldn't rush into it. Mick Abel looked great in his MLB debut on Sunday, perhaps raising his trade value to a level justifying a deal. With even better prospect Andrew Painter on the way, Abel could be the guy eventually moved. Honestly, that might be preferable to dealing one of their elite position player prospects, like SS/3B Aidan Miller, OF Justin Crawford or C Eduardo Tait. Perhaps moving down a tier to the likes of OF Gabriel Rincones might make a little more sense.
But back to Abel for a second. There's no way he's going anywhere at this very moment due to the loss of Nola. As bad as he's been this season, Nola has arguably been the majors' most consistent provider of innings bulk in recent memory. With his velocity down about one mph on all of his pitches this season, the club is hoping that a brief stint on the shelf will rejuvenate him and restore him to peak effectiveness.
I'm not necessarily buying that.
Nola supposedly first felt the pain in his ankle warming up for his next to last start against the Guardians. While that outing and the subsequent one versus the Cardinals were admittedly poor, he was no great shakes before then, either.
Looking at Nola's performance thus far in 2025 compared to 2024, there are stark areas of similarity and difference. His K rate has barely moved, ticking downward from 24.0% to 23.6%, both within the league average range. His BB rate has nudged upward from 6.1% to 7.3%, moving up into the league average range. Notable, but still not a huge deal.
It's on the contact management front where things have fallen apart. One of Nola's issues in 2024 was a tendency to yield line drives, and that has intensified a but in 2025. He's up from 21.7% to 22.3%, over a half standard deviation above league average. Line drive authority has become an issue as well this season, as his average liner exit speed is 94.7 mph, also well above league average. This has pushed his overall average exit speed allowed to 89.3 mph - only four 2024 NL ERA qualifiers fared worse. His Adjusted Contact Score was almost exactly league average at 98 in 2024; it sits at an abysmal 136 thus far in 2025.
When you break it down on a pitch-by-pitch basis it gets much more acute. Each season I issue pitch grades to the arsenals of every pitcher with 135 or more innings, based on bat-missing and contact management relative to the league. In 2024, Nola had a subpar changeup ("D+"), but three average or better pitches, including a pair of 'A' offerings in his four-seamer and knuckle-curve. (His sinker earned a 'B'.)
I don't worry about starting pitchers until their fastball(s) go south. Nola's four-seamer has utterly fallen apart this season. Last year, I didn't issue an 'F' grade to a single qualifying pitch - thus far in 2025, Nola's four-seamer would earn an 'F-', if that's even possible. A 209 Adjusted Contact Score and 4.5% pitch-specific whiff rate is no way to go through life. Even his signature knuckle-curve hasn't been very good - he gets an interim 'C' grade for it, again due to poor contact management (153 Adjusted Contact Score). His sinker again gets a 'B', eerily possessing the same 4.5% repeating-decimal whiff rate as the four-seamer.
One positive - Nola's changeup has improved and become a viable pitch this season, improving to a 'B' grade. Its whiff rate has exploded from 4.9% in 2024 to 18.0% this season. He has taken notice and begun to throw it more, with its usage rate increasing from 9.6% in 2024 to 14.8%. This increase has come at the expense of the knuckle-curve. If Nola sheds his skin and morphs into a different form, the changeup will be at the forefront of his efforts.
Is it possible that everything just clicks into place once Nola comes off of the injured list? I guess, but I wouldn't bank on it. Nola was already becoming more a quantity rather than a quality guy entering this season, and such a decline in fastball effectiveness can be a bit scary. Once Felix Hernandez lost his fastball, things got hairy in a hurry.
A reliable Nola could be the key to the remainder of the Phils' season. If they can count on him to take the ball and give them six competent innings every time out once he returns, they can better justify giving up a key piece or two to fill their bullpen needs. If they can't, then there's another hole in the dike that must be plugged. You don't appreciate 200-inning workhorses until they're gone.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
33 minutes ago
- CBS News
Buxton's 479-foot homer powers Twins to 6-2 win over Rangers
Court filings reveal reason for federal raid in Minneapolis, and more headlines Court filings reveal reason for federal raid in Minneapolis, and more headlines Court filings reveal reason for federal raid in Minneapolis, and more headlines Byron Buxton launched a 479-foot home run, the second-longest in the majors this season, to power the Minnesota Twins past the Texas Rangers 6-2 on Wednesday night. Buxton's three-run shot to center field off starter Jack Leiter (4-3) was the longest of his 144 career homers, and it gave Minnesota a 3-2 lead in the third inning. The only big league home run hit farther this year was a 484-foot drive by Angels star Mike Trout on April 19. Buxton finished with three hits and a stolen base. His titanic homer came moments after he made a highlight-reel catch that resulted in a standing ovation from Twins fans. With two runners aboard, Buxton sprinted to the gap in left-center and dove to rob Marcus Semien of a hit to end the top of the third. Willi Castro added a two-run triple in the fifth for Minnesota and scored on Carlos Correa's ground-rule double. Minnesota Twins starting pitcher David Festa (58) delivers a pitch against the Texas Rangers during the first inning of baseball game Wednesday, June 11, 2025, in Minneapolis. Matt Krohn / AP David Festa (1-1) allowed two runs and three hits in six innings, matching the longest start of his career. Leiter lasted just four innings and allowed four runs on five hits and four walks. Semien homered in the second for Texas, and Josh Smith had an RBI double in the third. While Buxton's homer was huge, his catch in the top of the third was also pivotal. Texas had runners on first and second, both of which might have scored on Semien's drive had Buxton not made the diving catch. A pair of Twins players extended their streaks at the plate. Ty France pushed his on-base streak to a career-high 22 games with a single in the fifth. Brooks Lee stretched his hitting streak to 11 games with a third-inning double. LHP Patrick Corbin (3-5, 3.52 ERA) starts the series finale for Texas, looking for his first win in nearly a month. Minnesota counters with RHP Bailey Ober (4-2, 3.78), who allowed five runs in a loss his last time out.
New York Times
37 minutes ago
- New York Times
Jackson Jobe's injury is another reminder of the perils MLB pitchers face
DETROIT — Every time another one of these pitchers comes along, the thought lingers in the back of everyone's mind. No one wants to say it. No one even wants to think about it. But it has become reality in this game. Pitchers who heave triple-digit fastballs and twirl nasty breaking pitches damage their arms. Advertisement With every young ace-in-the-making these days, we hold our breaths and try to ignore the elephant. The uncomfortable thought tiptoed into the room May 23 after a start in which Detroit Tigers rookie Jackson Jobe battled the Cleveland Guardians admirably but never looked quite comfortable himself. After that outing, Jobe made multiple vague references to not feeling good physically. 'Today was definitely not the best I've felt,' Jobe said. 'But not looking too much into it. Just kind of part of it.' Can't blame Jobe for acting like the rest of us. Maybe it's nothing, it was easy to think. This is the major leagues. Aches and pains are part of the job. The next time out? Jobe went 4 2/3 innings against the Giants. He gave up seven hits, walked three batters and surrendered three runs. His velocity was down all across the board. Postgame, there was no sight of the talented young pitcher the Tigers drafted third overall in 2021. Cue the real worries. The first medical review indicated a Grade 1 flexor strain. That meant the mildest form of the injury. This was still concerning for a young pitcher who has battled a back injury and a hamstring issue in his time in the minor leagues. But this was his first arm injury. In many ways, Jobe represented the type of pitcher teams hope can be immune — at least for six years of team control — from the effects of pitching in the modern game. He did not emerge as a full-fledged pitcher until late in his high school career. He hardly worked as a starter until his senior year of high school. Even the time missed with non-arm injuries in the minor leagues suggested Jobe had saved some of his bullets. It's rarely that simple. If there were a one-size-fits-all way to save arms, everyone would be doing it. Jobe went in for further medical evaluation. Those exams revealed damage to his ulnar collateral ligament. Now, he is headed for surgery. Speaking to reporters in Baltimore, Tigers general manager Jeff Greenberg said Dr. Keith Meister will perform the surgery. No date has been set for the procedure. Advertisement 'As is standard in our medical evaluation process, we sought additional evaluations,' Greenberg told reporters. 'Through that evaluation process a UCL injury was also discovered. From there, there were a series of conversations between Jackson, the doctors and our medical staff. Ultimately, surgery was determined as the path.' Until Meister opens up Jobe's elbow, they likely won't know the exact nature of the procedure. The internal brace has become a trendy innovation that can stem off full UCL reconstruction. The hope is the brace, even when combined with full UCL reconstructions, can quicken recovery time and make UCLs more durable in the future. But the amount of two-time Tommy John pitchers is also on the rise. So the fear of injury still dominates every conversation around starting pitching. It lingers when we discuss contracts extensions or big free-agent deals. It's there when you see a young hurler like Jobe or Paul Skenes. This spring, Hall of Fame manager Jim Leyland was talking about Skenes when the topic arose. 'I think at the end of the day, I don't know if there's ever a way you can prevent (injury),' he said. 'Some pitchers get hurt. That's just the way it is. It's been going on forever. I think you just accept the fact that it's possible to happen.' No one wants to whisper those words in the case of Tarik Skubal, who had Tommy John surgery in college and had a flexor tendon surgery in 2022. During that flexor tendon surgery, Skubal has said, Dr. Neal ElAttrache looked at his elbow and determined the UCL was in pristine condition. That was three years ago. Skubal has been durable ever since. But when you see him throwing 102.6 mph in the ninth inning … who's to say what that means? It's another thing everyone thinks but no one wants to utter aloud. The truth is, pitchers and UCL tears go hand in hand. Pending some sweeping rule change, that might not reverse anytime soon. This is no longer a trend. It is a fact. It happened to Skubal and Casey Mize, to Alex Faedo and Joey Wentz and Sawyer Gipson-Long, to pitchers young and old all across baseball. Advertisement Jobe now joins the club. Awful for him, even if it's halfway expected. 'Obviously it's never news you want to receive and it's obviously really disappointing for him,' Greenberg said. 'But he's in great hands. He's a determined individual. We've seen this before. We know what that process will look like, and very confident he's going to come back and be a really important contributor for this team for a long time.'
Associated Press
38 minutes ago
- Associated Press
Aaron Judge homers in third straight game, Clarke Schmidt dazzles as Yankees beat the Royals, 6-3
KANSAS CITY, Mo. (AP) — Aaron Judge homered for the third consecutive game, Clarke Schmidt allowed just two hits over six innings, and the New York Yankees cruised to a 6-3 victory over the Kansas City Royals on Wednesday night. Paul Goldschmidt added a pair of RBIs during a five-run second inning for New York, which improved to 5-0 against the Royals this season. The Yankees are are 12-3 against them since the start of last season, including their playoff series win. Salvador Perez hit a two-run homer during a three-run ninth for Kansas City. Schmidt (3-3) allowed one runner to reach second base, and that was courtesy of his own balk that advanced Maikel Garcia in the first inning. He also struck out seven to remain unbeaten in six regular-season appearances against the Royals. Devin Williams got the final two outs for his eighth save. Kris Bubic (5-4) looked like he might be in for a duel with Schmidt after a perfect first inning. But he proceeded to allow five runs on four hits and two walks during the second, and ultimately six hits and four walks in just 4 1/3 innings. Judge's homer off Steven Cruz came on the heels of a two-homer game Sunday against Boston and a 469-foot shot in the series opener against Kansas City on Tuesday night. The two-time MVP has eight RBIs over the three-game span. Until Perez's homer, the biggest highlight for the Royals came in the fifth inning, when the Yankees loaded the bases with one out. DJ LeMahieu hit a sharp grounder to third base, where Garcia fielded it while falling to his rump. He threw to second from his back side, and a relay by Jonathan India to first base resulted in an inning-ending double play. Key moment Jazz Chisholm, who later left the game with left groin tightness, drew a walk in the second inning after plate umpire Lance Barrett called what would have been the third strike a questionable ball. The Yankees capitalized on their fortunes, sending 10 batters to the plate in what became the decisive inning. Key stat The Royals (34-34) are 10-18 after going on a 16-2 run in April and May. Up next Yankees RHP Will Warren (4-3, 5.34) starts the series finale Thursday night. RHP Seth Lugo (3-5, 3.46) goes for Kansas City. ___ AP MLB:
