Israel and the Palestinians: The Road to 7 October, review: this series shows that peace is possible, but too few people want it
As Donald Trump reimagines Ukraine and carves up Gaza (or is it the other way round?), Israel and the Palestinians: The Road to 7th October (BBC Two) is an almost surreal watch. Here, across three dense episodes, we are presented with the nitty-gritty of Middle East/US relations over the course of two decades, while in today's White House the President takes a jackhammer to the very idea of international diplomacy. Watch all three episodes, however, and you might decide that a jackhammer is exactly what is needed.
The series will no doubt be a Rorschach test for those with already entrenched opinions on the subject, but it gives both sides a fair crack of the whip. Beginning in 2003 with Ariel Sharon's decision to 'withdraw from Gaza and throw the keys over the fence' and ending with the barbarous events of October 7 2023, it gives us a nerdy, diplomat's eye view of the many failed peace talks. Among the talking heads are Hillary Clinton, Tony Blair and John Kerry, but the greater insights come from the legion of security advisers and diplomats. The series is also remarkable for featuring interviews with Hamas leaders Khaled Mashal and Ismail Haniyeh (the latter of whom was assassinated a month later).
Produced by Norma Percy, this is fibrous stuff. No The Rest is History edutainment here, it's All Bran all the way. Aside from the odd amusing detail – an Israeli diplomat who desperately used a thesaurus to find the exact word for 'suspension'; Joe Biden trialling fist bumps as a diplomatic weapon – there is no sugar to be sprinkled on your cereal here. As an insight into the machinations going on behind the crisis, however, it's magnificent.
Some anecdotes come like a splash of cold water to the face (among them Mashal's smirking insistence that October 7 was righteous), but none more so than the moment that Benjamin Netanyahu told Kerry 'everyone in this region lies and you Americans don't take that into account'. It was clear that Netanyahu included himself in that statement.
As such, former Israel PM Ehud Olmert emerges as something of a tragic hero, having desperately tried to get the Palestinian Authority to sign off on a deal which would see Israel leaving 95 per cent of the West Bank. It was rejected, and would likely have been shot down by the Israeli cabinet, but Olmert's desperation was tangible. Time and time again the series shows that peace is possible, but too few people want it.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
37 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Albo, tell Donald Trump to 'bugger off': Brutal advice for PM as he drops clue about when he will meet US President
Karl Stefanovic has told Anthony Albanese he should tell Donald Trump to 'bugger off' as he faces mounting pressure to lock in a meeting with the US President. The Prime Minister is the only leader from the Quadrilateral Security Dialogue - made up of Australia, the US, India and Japan - who is yet to meet Trump in person since his re-election. Albanese appeared on various breakfast television programs on Tuesday morning to endorse a string of changes that came into force on July 1, but was instead grilled on when a meeting with Trump would be set up. 'Look, every Quad leader has met him. It's all got a little bit embarrassing hasn't it? Pretty simple question. When are you going to meet the Donald?' Stefanovic said. The PM said they would meet in the 'coming months' but refused to lock in a date. 'I can't comprehend how the President, given how close allies we have been with the US for so long, couldn't give a rat's about meeting with you,' Stefanovic continued. 'I think it's so disrespectful. And why don't you just tell him to bugger off?' Mr Albanese said he was having audio issues and missed the question which was repeated by co-host Sarah Abo. 'He (Trump) seems to be snubbing you,' she said. The PM rejected the assumption and said he and Trump had had 'really constructive discussions'. It comes amid speculation Albanese will finally meet Trump at a Quad meeting in India later this year. 'I'd be prepared, of course, to meet with President Trump when a suitable time can be organised,' the PM told the ABC on Monday. 'We also have the Quad meeting coming up that we are finalising as well. 'So these things are being organised, and I look forward to having a meeting and continuing the constructive dialogue that I've had with President Trump up to now.' The September meeting now offers the best chance for their long overdue meeting. That month, Albanese will also travel to New York for the UN leader's week, and may also be able to meet Trump there, or make a trip to Washington. Sticking points in the US-Australia relationship which are crying out to be addressed include the AUKUS nuclear submarine deal, which is currently under review by the Trump administration, and punishing tariffs imposed by the US on Aussie imports, including a 50 per cent levy on steel and aluminium. The prime minister has been accused of dragging his feet in meeting with the leader of Australia's most important security ally. Since Trump was inaugurated in January, the pair have spoken on the phone three times. He missed an opportunity to meet the US president at the G7 Summit in Canada earlier this month when Trump left the Summit early to deal with the Israel-Iran conflict. He also did not attend last week's NATO Summit, where political observers had hoped he would have a second chance to meet with Trump. Even US lawmakers are now urging Albanese to come to the White House and develop a personal rapport with Trump in order to save the wavering AUKUS pact. The meeting, when it does happen, will not necessarily be an amicable one. Trump is expected to leverage tariffs and his commitment to AUKUS in order to pressure Albanese to increase defence spending, which at 2.2 per cent of GDP is well short of the 3 per cent that the US has previously demanded of Australia. There is added pressure on Australia to boost defence, now that NATO members have agreed to lift their defence spending to 5 per cent of GDP over 10 years - with the White House later indicating it expects its allies in the Asia-Pacific to follow suit. Trump also reportedly does not like Australia's ambassador to the US, Kevin Rudd, and may view Rudd's ongoing tenure as a barrier to improved relations. Rudd enjoys cross-party support in Australia, but his position has been under threat since past comments he made about Trump came to light. In November, shortly after Trump's election win, Daily Mail Australia revealed how Rudd never envisioned his comeback, calling his first term a period of 'episodic craziness'.
Leader Live
38 minutes ago
- Leader Live
Protesters target Wimbledon over Barclays sponsorship links to arms firms
Around two dozen demonstrators from the Palestine Solidarity Campaign (PSC) gathered outside the main gates of the All England Club on Monday morning, just yards away from Centre Court. They chanted: 'Barclays bank, you can't hide, we charge you with genocide,' and held banners criticising the bank's alleged investments in defence companies linked to the Israeli military. Damian McCarthy, 53, a lawyer and organiser with the PSC, told the PA news agency: 'I'm a local resident – and a lot of people in Wimbledon think the genocide in Gaza is appalling. 'We want to raise awareness. Barclays' investment in genocide is wrong. 'It's not about Wimbledon, it's not about tennis, it's about the investment in genocide, and we've got to stop it.' An artist taking part in the protest unveiled an installation in memory of Hind Rajab, a five-year-old girl killed in Gaza in January 2024 after her family's car was hit by an Israeli tank shell. Barclays has been contacted for comment.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Trump news at a glance: Republicans scramble to pass ‘one big, beautiful bill' as deadline looms
Senate Republicans are racing to meet Donald Trump's self-imposed 4 July deadline to pass the president's massive tax-and-spending 'one big, beautiful bill'. In a marathon session, senators convened at the Capitol to propose amendments to the legislation over many hours. Democrats, who universally oppose the bill, are expected to use the process to force their opponents into politically tricky votes that they will seek to wield against them in elections to come. Even if it passes the Senate, the bill will still need to go back through the House, which is being called back to session for votes as soon as Wednesday. Here's the latest: As the marathon session kicked off on Monday morning, Senate majority leader John Thune sounded optimistic that the measure would soon clear his chamber. 'Let's vote. This is good for America, this is good for the American people, it is good for working families,' he said. Chuck Schumer the Senate minority leader said the bill 'steals people's healthcare, jacks up their electricity bill, take away their jobs – all to pay for tax breaks for billionaires'. He said Democrats would offer amendments to 'see once and for all if Republicans really meant all those nice things they've been saying about 'strengthening Medicaid' and 'protecting middle-class families', or if they were just lying'. Republican Senator Thom Tillis said 'this bill will betray the promise Donald Trump made,' a few hours after announcing he would not seek re-election in politically competitive North Carolina. Read the full story The Trump administration has codified its efforts to strip some Americans of their US citizenship in a recently published justice department memo that directs attorneys to prioritize denaturalization for naturalized citizens who commit certain crimes. The memo, published on 11 June, calls on attorneys in the department to institute civil proceedings to revoke a person's United States citizenship if an individual either 'illegally procured' naturalization or procured naturalization by 'concealment of a material fact or by willful misrepresentation'. Read the full story The United States has said that Canada's prime minister Mark Carney 'caved' to demands from the White House after his government abruptly scrapped their digital services tax on US technology companies, which was set to go into effect on Monday. 'It's very simple. Prime minister Carney and Canada caved to president [Donald] Trump and the United States of America,' press secretary Karoline Leavitt said in a daily briefing. Read the full story The Trump administration has concluded that Harvard University violated federal civil rights law in its handling of Jewish and Israeli students, and it threatened the school with a potential 'loss of all federal financial resources' as a result, according to the Wall Street Journal. In a Monday letter addressed to the Harvard president, Alan Garber, administration attorneys stated that the university was aware Jewish and Israeli students felt unsafe on campus but failed to take meaningful action. The letter, obtained by the Journal, accused Harvard of 'deliberate indifference' toward those concerns. Read the full story Donald Trump has signed an executive order to lift some financial sanctions on Syria in a move that the White House says will help stabilise the country after the ousting of Bashar al-Assad. Read the full story The US dollar has had its worst first half-year in more than 50 years, as the financial markets over the last six months were dominated by geopolitical crises and Donald Trump's trade war. The dollar has fallen by 10.8% against a basket of currencies since the start of 2025. That is its worst performance over the first six months of any year since 1973, and the worst half-year since the second half of 1991. Read the full story The US Department of Homeland Security has for the first time built a national citizenship database that combines information from immigration agencies and the social security administration. The Trump administration is on track to oversee one of the deadliest years for immigrants in detention after the recent deaths of two men – one from Cuba and another from Canada – while in federal custody. The US supreme court agreed on Monday to hear a case that could further erode restrictions on money in politics, in a challenge that comes in part from vice-president JD Vance. Catching up? Here's what happened 29 June.
