Famed NYC restaurant grilled over $30 sandwich: ‘Really overrated'
They won't 'have what she's having.'
Venerated New York City institution Katz Delicatessen was spit-roasted online over its $30 sandwich, which viewers labeled 'diabolical' and a 'waste of money.'
Founded in 1888, Katz's is the oldest deli of its kind in NYC — and was made world-famous by the iconic orgasm scene in the 1989 film 'When Harry Met Sally.'
Advertisement
4 A server prepares a Reuben at Katz Deli.
@jujuonthemic/TikTok
The backlash came in response to an X post that began in praise of the Lower East Side pastrami purveyor.
'The sandwich, sold for $27 in New York, is famous for its generous amount of ingredients,' wrote businessman Tansu Yegen in the post.
Advertisement
An accompanying clip shows a worker preparing what looks like Katz' mondo reuben, which actually retails for $29.95 barring substitutions, and features several tiers of luscious corned beef (or pastrami) that's traditionally piled with sauerkraut, Swiss and Rueben dressing and bookended by two giant slices of rye.
Despite being one of the deli's most venerated noshes — outside their legendary pastrami (which costs $28.95) — many X users felt that the juice was not worth the financial squeeze.
'Such a waste of food and money,' decried one critic on X. 'How do you not get sick to your stomach halfway through. Average person can't finish that and shouldn't and for $27???'
4 Meg Ryan during the iconic Katz Deli scene from 'When Harry Met Sally.'
©Columbia Pictures/courtesy Everett Co / Everett Collection
Advertisement
'$27 is highway robbery. What generous amount…' said another.
'Half the ingredients, half the price, please. No one is eating a small animal and a bag of cheese between two pieces of bread lol,' scoffed a third.
4 Katz Deli's iconic pastrami sandwich.
@katzsdeli/Instagram
'Katz deli, really overrated & a total tourist trap,' said one critic. 'Go to a neighborhood bodega, a third of the price & twice the quality imo.'
Advertisement
'Crazy because a single patty cheeseburger at Five Guys is like $25,' said another, likely referring to the recent uproar over a bacon cheeseburger and fries that ran a customer $24.10 at the burger monger.
4 Katz Deli on 205 Houston Street (near Ludlow) on the Lower Eastside.
Angel Chevrestt
'All respect to Katz, but to pay $27 I'd need to be in a movie theater located at a baseball game being played in Las Vegas,' quipped one X wit.
'And Americans say British food is bad, that looks absolutely diabolical,' critiqued another.
However, some Katz stalwarts flocked to the restaurant's defense with one fan declaring, 'If any sandwich is worth $27, it might be that one.'
'Katz Deli … a must-visit in NYC and now one of the only Kosher places left there,' said another. 'Amazing food and a scruffy restaurant-perfect!!'
'Had it a week ago. Worth its weight in gold,' said another while lauding the meat, which is 'cured for weeks in a saltwater brine,' before getting boiled, steamed and painstakingly sliced by hand.
Advertisement
'The sandwiches are totally amazing and worth it,' defended one Katz die-hard. 'The meat is incredibly rich and it would be difficult to eat an entire sandwich. My wife and I really enjoyed the place!'
They added, 'As I said, the sandwiches are massive and next time I'm in NY I will go with their soup/sandwich combo.'
In December, Taste Atlas named Katz the most legendary restaurant in the Big Apple and the 8th most iconic eatery in the world.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
an hour ago
- Axios
Former Biden press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre leaves Democratic Party
Former White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre has become an independent after serving under two Democratic presidents, according to the publisher of a new book from Jean-Pierre out this fall. The big picture: Jean-Pierre, whose encounters with White House reporters grew tense last year amid questions concerning former President Biden 's age and health, will detail in her new book the weeks that led to his 2024 campaign departure, per a publisher's description. Driving the news: The book, "Independent: A Look Inside a Broken White House, Outside the Party Lines," pledges to take readers through the "betrayal by the Democratic Party" that prompted Biden's decision. In it, according to Legacy Lit — a Hachette Book Group imprint — Jean-Pierre will urge Americans to "embrace life as Independents" in an assessment of what she sees as a broken two-party system. "In a hard-hitting yet hopeful critique, Jean-Pierre defines what it means to be part of the growing percentage of our fractured electorate that is Independent," the announcement reads. Political independents make up a dominant voting bloc, with an average of 43% of U.S. adults identifying as independent in 2023, per Gallup data. What she's saying:"I think we need to stop thinking in boxes and think outside of our boxes and not be so partisan," Jean-Pierre said in a video shared to Instagram. "If you are willing to stand side by side with me, regardless of ... how you identify politically, and as long as you respect the community that I belong to and vulnerable communities that I respect, I will be there with you," she said. Catch up quick: Jean-Pierre became the first Black woman and openly LGBTQ+ person to become the White House press secretary after Jen Psaki left the post.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Topgolf CEO talks value as consumer spending tightens
Topgolf Callaway (MODG) is planning to split this year into two separate companies. This summer, as Americans tighten their spending, Topgolf will focus on value-conscious consumers with deals like half-price golf Monday through Thursday. Topgolf CEO Artie Starrs joins Catalysts to discuss what the company will look like after the Callaway split and how they plan to grow. To watch more expert insights and analysis on the latest market action, check out more Catalysts here. Topgolf looking to attract value conscious consumers this summer with deals, as Americans pull back on spending due to economic uncertainty. This comes as Topgolf Callaway Brands remains on track to separate into two separate companies this year. Joining us now, we got Artie Starrs, Topgolf CEO and my morning brief co-host Brad Smith. Artie, great to speak with you. Thanks for making the time. Want to get your take on the state of the consumer, of course, but first, walk us through what Topgolf's business is going to look like after this split. What are you anticipating? Well, first of all, Brad and Melissa, thank you so much for having me. Uh, after the split, we, we believe we're going to be an extremely strong company just like we were before. Both businesses were strong independent businesses before. We're excited about the, you know, the focus that each business will be able to have on, on the specific things that we do, in the case of golf equipment and apparel, uh, golf clubs and fantastic shirts and things. And in the case of Topgolf, the amazing experiences that we bring to life in our venues every day that our play makers bring to life. So we're, we're extremely enthusiastic about, uh, about the separation and, and look forward to updating your audience on it as the rest of the year evolves. Artie, within that, I wonder what the forecast for growth looks like from here. I've been to a Topgolf experience across six different states, multiple types of, you know, different premises that they're on, but, and, and never send a video to our team because obviously they will figure out a way to make sure that it lights up the screen. But, you know, at the end of the day, these are highly replicable experiences that you're able to bring forward. But is it at a premium right now, knowing the type of land that needs to be secured, knowing the type of resources, and the staffing as well right now? Yeah, so we continue to see, uh, significant opportunity for new venues. You, you mentioned very well, Brad, the, our, our venues are, are highly repeatable. So the, the types of sites that we look at and what we build, we're able to build the same foot on the same footprint and, and provide the same fantastic experience. I think in this environment, what, what we're actioning for the summer is bringing value to our players' lives. You know, we value is always important, but at this moment in time, we've launched Sunday Funday, which is for families, which meets families where they're at. We have Topgolf Nights or TG nights so that, that nightcap or after dinner on a Friday and Saturday night where groups can get together and have a fantastic time at Topgolf. And then, uh, next week we'll be launching an advertising campaign where Monday through Thursday, um, half off golf at Topgolf. I mean, what's better than that? So, uh, filling the venues up is our priority. So we see a lot of growth in that. The, the testing of these value initiatives have gone extremely well to driving traffic. So we're excited to meet players where they're at this summer. You know, that kind of gets into our, our next thought here, which is what you're seeing in the pulse of the consumer right now, those who kind of look at this as both an experience economy play, but also a food away from home, a, or even on the corporate side as well. I know you run events. So all those things kind of married together here, what are you seeing in that pulse of the many different types of consumers that Topgolf engages with? Well, players are looking for great value, and the, the question I posed to our team and our marketing agency a short while ago is like, why would you just eat? Why would you just do something when you could do it all at, at Topgolf? So we've, we view an experience at Topgolf is where you can have an active live entertainment experience where you're part of the action. We have unbelievable food and beverage. We hear it from time and time again from our players that they are pleasantly surprised at how great the food is. And what makes it all tick is our playmakers. We call our team members playmakers because they make play. And when you gobble that all together, uh, we're seeing our value scores improve. We win on fun and atmosphere and overall experience. And, you know, we're extremely optimistic that whether it's an experience economy or an out-of-home, uh, eating economy, we're there for it. Sign in to access your portfolio
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Franklin boys lacrosse shuts out Waltham to open MIAA Division 1 state tournament run
Frank Nazar And Alex Vlasic Earn Thrilling Gold Medal At World Championships The Chicago Blackhawks sent two Americans to the IIHF World Championships. Alex Vlasic, in the role of a defensive defenseman, and Frank Nazar, in the role of an offensive depth piece, played huge parts in helping the team get to the Gold Medal Game for the first time since 1934. 1:42 Now Playing Paused Ad Playing
