Judge hands Trump administration partial win in ‘Alligator Alcatraz' fight
U.S. District Judge Rodolfo Ruiz agreed the administration's new designation of a Miami-based immigration court to handle the detainees' cases makes their Fifth Amendment claims against the federal government moot.
'This is a classic case of mootness,' wrote Ruiz, who was appointed to the bench by President Trump.
As for the detainees' separate First Amendment claims, which allege they aren't able to communicate confidentially with counsel, Ruiz said those remain a live controversy that can proceed.
Still, the judge agreed with the administration that those issues should go before the federal judicial district in Florida that covers the 'Alligator Alcatraz' site, rather than Ruiz's courtroom in Miami.
'The job of the District Court is not to rule first and ask questions later,' Ruiz wrote.
'Instead, it must ensure that it is imbued with the ability to decide such a case in the first instance, pursuant to the limits on judicial power imposed by Article III and Congress's statutory limitations on venue,' he continued.
Ruiz was assigned the case filed by a group of migrants detained at 'Alligator Alcatraz' and several immigration legal services organizations. They are represented by Americans for Immigrant Justice and the American Civil Liberties Union.
They sued soon after officials opened 'Alligator Alcatraz' in early July to house thousands of migrants in the facility surrounded by the Florida Everglades. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem has cast it as a model for state-run immigrant detention facilities elsewhere in the country.
The plaintiffs urged Ruiz to issue an injunction guaranteeing that migrants can promptly communicate with their attorney confidentially as the litigation proceeds. Monday's ruling landed just hours after the judge convened a multi-hour hearing in the case.
At the hearing, lawyers for both the Trump administration and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis's (R) administration contended that the detainees for weeks have been able to receive a meeting and there are now no complaints.
'Plaintiffs would have your honor go to 'Alligator Alcatraz' and become the warden,' Nick Meros, an attorney representing Florida, told the judge.
Some of detainees had also claimed their Fifth Amendment protections were violated because the administration had failed to identify an immigration court with jurisdiction over their cases.
The Justice Department over the weekend, however, designated Krome Detention Center in Miami to handle the migrants' cases. The detainees still raised alarm that the administration could change course again, but the judge declined to intervene by finding the matter moot.
The lawsuit is one of two major legal challenges to 'Alligator Alcatraz.' Environmental groups convinced another judge to temporarily block new construction at the site over accusations it violates federal law, but that case hasn't impacted officials' ability to detain individuals.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
7 minutes ago
- New York Post
California park ranger fired after helping hang transgender pride flag on popular Yosemite monolith
A non-binary park ranger was fired by Yosemite National Park after they were caught hanging a transgender pride flag from the park's famous El Capitan rock formation in May. Shannon 'SJ' Joslin, 35, was first hired as a ranger and wildlife biologist at the park in 2021 — their dream job that they said was stripped away in a violation of their First Amendment right. 5 Shannon 'SJ' Joslin was fired from the Yosemite National Park after they helped hang a transgender pride flag on El Capitan rock. Miya Tsudome Advertisement Joslin claimed that a temporary deputy superintendent fired them on Aug. 12 for 'failing to demonstrate acceptable conduct' within their capacity as a wildlife biologist for the park. 'I want my rights and I want my career back,' Joslin wrote on Instagram. Joslin noted that they hung the flag in their 'free time, off-duty, as a private citizen.' Advertisement 5 Joslin was with the park for four and a half years. Instagram / shannonekj 'NOTHING about it had anything to do with my work,' they fumed. Joslin highlighted all that they've done for the National Parks Service over the years, including willingly stacking overtime hours and accepting a lower-paying job when they could easily be 'making a lot more money in Silicon Valley' with their bioinformatics PHD. 'I'm devastated. We don't take our positions in the park service to make money or to have any kind of huge career gains. We take it because we love the places that we work,' Joslin told NBC News. Advertisement 5 Joslin said that they hung the flag in opposition to the Trump administration's policies. Instagram / shannonekj The axed ranger said that the inspiration for their stunt came in the spring after President Trump issued an executive order barring transgender women from competing in women's sports. 'I was really hurting because there were a lot of policies coming from the current administration that target trans people, and I'm nonbinary,' Joslin told The Associated Press. The flag only flew for two hours before park officials ordered climbers to remove it, never once mentioning any overt violations that it posed, Joslin told NBC News. Advertisement The day after their stunt, the NPS issued a new rule banning the hanging of large flags in wilderness areas. 5 Joslin plans on fighting the park's decision. Instagram / shannonekj Then, a week later, Joslin said a criminal investigation into the flag's display was launched. Their firing came at the end of the three-month investigation. Joslin asserted that they — and two other NPS employees under investigation for helping hang the flag — are the only people to ever be punished for draping a flag on El Capitan. The NPS, however, is apparently working on 'pursuing administrative action against multiple National Park Service employees for failing to follow National Park Service regulations,' a spokesperson for Yosemite National Park told the outlet. 5 Two other National Park Service employees are also being investigated for hanging the flag. Instagram / shannonekj The spokesperson did not elaborate on what regulations the employees allegedly violated. A spokesperson for the NPS added that it is currently taking administrative actions against several employees and even 'possible criminal charges against several park visitors who are alleged to have violated federal laws and regulations related to demonstrations' in tandem with the Justice Department. Advertisement The Post reached out to the NPS for comment. Joslin plans on fighting the park's decision through the use of an executive order penned on Trump's inauguration seeking to restore the First Amendment and 'end federal censorship.' The NPS is a government bureau within the US Department of the Interior overseen by former North Dakota Gov. Doug Burgum. 'Preservation has been my life's work—of Yosemite, the wildlife, the land, recreation, of peoples rights and safety, of community and acceptance, and now the Constitutional First Amendment,' Joslin wrote.
The Hill
7 minutes ago
- The Hill
Trump called Orban to win his support for Ukraine joining EU: Report
President Trump called Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban on Monday to win his support for Ukraine to join the European Union (EU), a conversation that came after discussions with European leaders who were at the White House, Bloomberg News reported on Tuesday, citing people familiar with the matter. The talk with Orban, one of the staunchest Trump allies in Europe, resulted from the president's Monday deliberations with European leaders who were in Washington, along with Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky. The top European officials asked if the president could utilize his sway over the Hungarian prime minister to force the nationalist leader to do away with his opposition to Ukraine's joining the EU, a goal Kyiv has long sought, the outlet reported. Hungary expressed willingness to host the next summit, featuring both Zelensky and Russian President Vladimir Putin. Trump has backed the idea of a Putin-Zelensky summit, after which a trilateral meeting would take place between the two leaders and the U.S. president. The location and timing for the meeting are unclear. The White House is eyeing a trilateral meeting between Trump, Putin and Zelensky in Budapest, Politico reported on Tuesday, citing a White House official and another person close to the administration. Orban, who has a warm relationship with Putin, has tried to block or delay the EU's attempts to send weapons to Ukraine in the past, along with, at times, objecting to sanctions against the Kremlin. Neither the White House nor Orban's office has commented on the call. Orban said on Tuesday on Facebook that Ukraine's membership in the EU 'does not provide any security guarantees,' therefore, 'linking membership with security guarantees is unnecessary and dangerous.' Trump's call with Orban came the same day as the president's discussion with Putin, which lasted about 40 minutes and took place without European leaders or Zelensky being in the room with the commander-in-chief. The gathering of European officials and Zelensky in Washington on Monday came just days after Trump, along with Secretary of State Marco Rubio and special envoy Steve Witkoff, met with Putin, alongside two other Russian officials, on Friday in Alaska. Rubio now leads the recently formed joint commission that will work on drafting a security guarantees proposal for Ukraine. The commission is made up of U.S., European, Ukrainian and NATO officials. Trump, who has pushed to end the Russia-Ukraine war, the conflict that has raged for about three-and-a-half years, signaled openness to providing air support for Ukraine as part of security guarantees. 'We're willing to help them with things, especially, probably, if you talk about by air because nobody has stuff we have,' the president said Tuesday.
Wall Street Journal
8 minutes ago
- Wall Street Journal
Trump Backs Giant Arizona Copper Project After Court Setback
President Trump signaled support for a giant copper mine in Arizona following a meeting with the heads of two of the world's biggest mining companies, a day after the project was delayed by a court injunction. The project, called Resolution Copper, has been under development by mining giants Rio Tinto and BHP Group BHP -0.55%decrease; red down pointing triangle for roughly two decades, but it has faced legal challenges from Native American people, religious groups and others who say the planned mine will turn a sacred area into a crater.
