
Unethical or inevitable? Artists question where to draw the line on AI-generated art
Lauren Thomander recently began selling a series of prints on her Etsy page inspired by the illustrated covers of The New Yorker magazine.
But when they were reposted on Halifax Noise, a popular Instagram feed with more than 80,000 followers, the response was mixed.
Some praised the work and eagerly followed the link to her shop to purchase a print, but others, including many illustrators themselves, were quick to criticize the idea.
"People are kind of saying that AI trains itself with other people's work, and that it's not my work anymore," she said. "I don't see it that way because it is my picture that you can see there."
In Thomander's view, using ChatGPT to make an illustration is no different than using software to edit photos.
"Whether you're maybe changing the background of a photo, removing somebody that's in the way of your subject, or even putting a filter over it, I feel like that's all kind of in the same boat as AI," she said.
'The process is totally unethical' says illustrator
Illustrator and printmaker Alex MacAskill strongly disagrees. The print may have originated from Thomander's picture, but she's a photographer and not an illustrator, he says.
"I think if you flip the situation on the other end and take illustrations you want to convert into photography, I can't help but feel that the person on the other end of the equation would feel similar to how illustrators feel in this particular situation," said MacAskill, who owns and operates Midnight Oil Print and Design House in Halifax.
He said Thomander could have realized her idea instead through collaborating with another artist.
"To replace that with AI … and to remove that person from the process is totally unethical," he said
Large-language models, like those used to build ChatGPT or Google's Gemini or Anthropic's Claude, are trained by mining large data sets that include the creative output of many thousands of artists and writers, often without their consent.
When you ask ChatGPT a question, for instance, it's using that data to answer the query, which is why it's able so quickly to translate Thomander's work into an illustration that wouldn't look out of place on the cover of The New Yorker.
Photography was once seen as threat
It's no secret that many previous innovations in the world of technology have been received skeptically in the art world.
It wasn't that long ago that photography was viewed as an existential threat to painting, says Ray Cronin, the curator for the Beaverbrook Gallery in Fredericton.
"When photography was introduced in the 19th century, people were convinced it was going to kill painting," Cronin said.
Even more recently, when Mary Pratt, a renowned Canadian artist who was known for making lifelike paintings of everyday objects, began painting from photographs in the late 1960s, there were some people who thought she wasn't playing by the rules
"Her parents thought she was cheating because she wasn't inventing the images herself," said Cronin, who wrote a book about Pratt's life and work.
Pratt would select an image from her collection of photos, maybe one she took herself. From there, she would project the image onto a blank canvas and trace the outline before starting to paint by hand.
It was all part of what Cronin says was her desire to "make the human eye look at the world the way the camera looks at the world."
"The skill to do that is immense," he said " It's not something that could just be fed into some kind of algorithm."
When Pratt died in 2018, this was unquestionably true. The matter has become more complicated in the age of readily available generative AI.
A simple prompt on ChatGPT asking to "create a painting with apples in the style of Mary Pratt" will churn out an image that might, to a less discerning viewer, look just like the real thing.
But this ignores a key quality of Pratt's work, Cronin said. Although photography played a role in the work, Pratt's paintings are special because they were made by a real person using real materials.
"Everybody knows the experience of seeing something, whether it's a photograph or a painting or a sculpture, that you can't just walk by. You have to actually look at it. And the longer you look at it, the more you see," he said.
Even still, Cronin is not ready to write off AI altogether.
"I think AI is a tool and tools are only as good as the people who use them. And they're only as interesting as what's made with them."
However, he hasn't found much art made with AI particularly interesting.
"I'd rather see somebody with their mistakes and failures and experiments … than the kind of perfection AI always seems to create," he said.
Imperfection makes art interesting, says Cronin
Art, in his view, isn't perfection. It's the absence of it. In Pratt's 1994 painting Glassy Apples, that much is clear.
The painting, based on a photograph she'd taken of a crystal bowl filled with apples that had been a wedding present, was made as her marriage to painter Christopher Pratt was falling apart.
"The thing she always pointed out about that work that was most important to her is that there's a chip in the rim of the crystal bowl," said Cronin.
When she took the photo in advance of the painting, she turned the bowl so that a chip was visible.
"She's showing that there's a crack in everything. It's breaking," he said. "That's not something you'd get from asking AI to make a bowl of apples in Mary Pratt's style."
Future unknown
For both MacAskill and Thomander, how AI will affect art in the future is an open question.
Beyond the ethical implications of using AI, MacAskill worries about what may happen if we lose sight of why art is valuable in the first place.
"I think to value the convenience of creating something over the humanity behind it is really just doing a disservice to all of us," he said.
But Thomander believes that as AI continues to develop as a technology, it will be prudent to get acquainted with how it works.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CBC
9 minutes ago
- CBC
Lithium-ion battery fires jump 162% in Toronto over 2 years, city says
The number of fires sparked by lithium-ion batteries in Toronto has more than doubled in the span of two years, the city says. Between 2022 and 2024 the number of fires jumped 162 per cent, from 29 to 76, according to a city news release Monday. So far this year, Toronto Fire has responded to 43 fires, the city says. "We're seeing a concerning rise in fires caused by lithium-ion batteries, many of which are preventable," said Fire Chief Jim Jessop in the release. The batteries are commonly found in e-bikes, smartphones, laptops and many other electronic devices. When used correctly, lithium-ion batteries are generally safe, the city release says. But the city is reminding people that modifying or tampering with these batteries can be dangerous, saying it's a common cause of many recent fires. The reminder comes as Toronto Fire kick-starts its second annual campaign aimed at educating people on the fire risks associated with lithium-ion batteries. There are a few things users can do to reduce the risk of a fire, the city says, aside from not tinkering with the batteries. People should only use certified, manufacturer-approved batteries and chargers and keep them in sight while they charge, the city says. Should users notice anything out of the ordinary with a battery — strange odours, discolouration, excessive heat, change in shape, leaking or odd noises — the city says they should stop using it and contact the manufacturer.


Cision Canada
18 minutes ago
- Cision Canada
viaim Offers Prime Day Deals on AI-Powered Recording Tools for Global, Privacy-First Workflows
NEW YORK, July 7, 2025 /CNW/ -- AI workplace technology brand viaim has announced a global Prime Day promotion, offering at least 20 percent off across its entire product lineup from July 7 through July 19. The promotion features its flagship recording earbuds RecDot, the comfort-focused OpenNote, and the desktop companion NoteKit. Together, these tools form a seamless AI-powered productivity hardware suite built for multilingual, mobile, and high-compliance professional environments. More than just earbuds, these tools mark a step toward bringing AI into the everyday routines of global professionals. viaim hardware is engineered for real-time efficiency. Using FlashRecord, users can start recording immediately with a long press, without having to download any app or configure Bluetooth pairing, with all products supporting real-time transcription and translation in multiple languages. For time-strapped users, viaim's proprietary AI system automatically generates structured summaries and to-do lists based on meeting audio. This allows professionals to turn two hours of content into one minute of actionable output. By embedding intelligence directly into devices people already wear and trust, viaim is making AI practical, wearable, and truly personal. During Prime Day, customers can experience viaim's most advanced features through its three-device ecosystem. RecDot is a wireless AI recording earbud designed for professionals who need reliable, on-the-go capture of conversations and meetings. It delivers call and meeting recording with 48 decibels of hybrid noise cancellation and ergonomic controls. OpenNote is a long-wear headset built for all-day comfort and seamless transcription during travel or work. It lasts up to 53 hours and features AI-assisted meeting summaries and text clean-up, and a silicone loop design suitable for long-term wearers including glasses users. NoteKit is a lightweight USB audio recorder tailored for desktop setups and hybrid meetings that complements the suite by capturing high-fidelity audio in any computer-based setting and bridging gaps that traditional microphones often miss. viaim's vertical approach to product design is what sets it apart. Rather than offering generic features, viaim optimizes for professional needs such as cross-border meetings, multilingual project reviews, and sensitive industry use cases such as legal and healthcare. The entire ecosystem is built with privacy at its core. Recordings are encrypted and stored locally, with no cloud dependency. All devices meet HIPAA and GDPR data compliance standards, directly addressing concerns from 38.6 percent of users who worry about recording privacy, as shown in recent user surveys. Alex Taylor, a cross-border M&A consultant and part-time outdoor content creator, uses RecDot and NoteKit to manage over ten international meetings a week. He records compliant audit calls on the go, captures bilingual Zoom negotiations, and uses OpenNote to draft content while cycling coastal highways. In his words, the viaim setup gives him the freedom to work and create anywhere, without compromise. Ahead of Prime Day, Dr. Song Wang, Chief Technology Officer of viaim, emphasized the growing market demand: "Our research shows that North American users have increased their recording time by 120 percent year-over-year, yet over half of meeting value is still lost in disorganized notes. With viaim, clients in finance are closing compliance reporting 40 percent faster, and tech teams are making decisions 2.1 times more efficiently." viaim is an AI-driven technology company focused on intelligent workplace hardware for global professionals. With users in over 180 countries, viaim combines precision acoustics, real-time translation, and local-first data security to create tools that work across languages, industries, and time zones.


CBC
24 minutes ago
- CBC
'Sometimes it doesn't work out': Calgary tech community reacts to ATTAbotics insolvency
Social Sharing Long considered a highlight of Calgary's tech scene, local robotics company ATTAbotics is now restructuring as it deals with insolvency. That restructuring includes terminating 192 of its 203 employees, keeping only 11 as it navigates the road ahead, according to documents published by insolvency trustee firm Richter Inc. Founded in 2016 by Scott Gravelle, ATTAbotics had carved a name out for itself not only in Calgary but internationally, working with the likes of Microsoft, Accenture and the United States Department of Defense. Neither Gravelle nor ATTAbotics responded to requests for comment ahead of publication. Several terminated employees declined interview requests. The company's financial troubles came as "sad news" to Terry Rock, president and CEO of tech hub Platform Calgary. "It's always surprising when a company that has something so cool doesn't make it for whatever reason," he told CBC News. ATTAbotics designed a robotics supply chain management system in which robots store and grab warehoused goods, with the goal being to boost shipping efficiency and streamline warehouse operations. The concept was a hit with funders: by the end of 2022, ATTAbotics had received over $200 million, including over $97 million in funding led by Export Development Canada along with the Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan Board in 2022, $34 million through the federal government's Strategic Innovation Fund in 2020, and $4.5 million from the Opportunity Calgary Investment Fund in 2018. Documents published by Richter say that ATTAbotics, "as an early-stage technology company, has never achieved profitable operations," with annual losses of $49.5 million in 2024 and $43 million the year prior. As of March 31 this year, the assets of ATTAbotics are valued at $31.6 million, while its total liabilities are approximately $73.8 million, according to the documents. On July 2, ATTAbotics filed a notice of intention to make a proposal under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, which gives the organization time to figure out its restructuring plan and come up with a proposal for creditors. The company's 11 remaining employees are considered essential to the company's restructuring, according to the Richter documents. A longtime promoter of Calgary's innovation scene, Rock said the city's tech sector growth comes with both wins and losses. "In the world of technology innovation, these people are taking big risks," he said. "They're trying to change the world with what they're doing, really exciting ideas and technologies, and sometimes it doesn't work out." According to its website, ATTAbotics at one time had over 300 employees. Former employee discusses 'challenges' at company Former ATTAbotics project manager Andrew Rockwell, who left in 2024 after nearly six years, told CBC News that there had been "internal struggles" at the company. "There were ongoing challenges at the company in kind of getting out of that startup status and commercializing the product that ATTAbotics was making," he said. "I kind of felt that the momentum forward was slowing. We were having a hard time getting off the ground." He said he was "really proud" of his work at ATTAbotics, adding that he made sure to keep in touch with former colleagues. "Seeing how things played out, I guess I'm glad I left when I did," he said. "But it still is a sad thing for me, even as an outsider now, to be seeing what's happened to the company." Rockwell hopes the employees that were let go are able to continue contributing to the city's tech scene. "I would love to see all of those excellent people land other great jobs here in Calgary … working happily here in the city, supporting a tech industry in the city," he said. He also hopes that the ATTAbotics technology "can rise from these ashes," especially to continue supporting customers that utilized it. ATTAbotics has about 150 granted and pending patent applications worldwide.