Post Office Inquiry: Horizon scandal drove 13 people to suicide, report finds
A damning report into the Post Office Horizon IT scandal has concluded that at least 13 people may have taken their own lives after being accused of wrongdoing.
The report, issued as part of the long-running inquiry into the faulty Horizon IT system used in Post Office branches, described the impact on subpostmasters as 'disastrous' and said it heard evidence from 59 others who had also contemplated suicide as a result of the pressures from the scandal.
Approximately 1,000 subpostmasters were wrongfully prosecuted by the Post Office between 1999 and 2015 after the faulty Legacy Horizon software made it look as though money was missing from their accounts.
Tuesday's 162-page report, written by inquiry chair Sir Wyn Williams, also concluded Post Office bosses knew the Horizon IT system had widespread faults, but had 'maintained the fiction' it was accurate for years.
Sir Wyn said: 'Although many of the individuals who gave evidence before me were very reluctant to accept it I am satisfied from the evidence that I have heard that a number of senior, or not so senior employees, of the Post Office knew or at the very least should have known that Legacy Horizon was capable of error.
'Yet, for all practical purposes, throughout the lifetime of Legacy Horizon, the Post Office maintained the fiction that its data was always accurate.'
The report also found the Legacy Horizon system's 2010 replacement – known as Horizon Online – was also 'afflicted by bugs' and that employees of Fujitsu and the Post Office 'knew that this was so'.
It emphasised the human cost of the scandal and criticised the failure to provide adequate redress, following years of ambiguous and inconsistent financial compensation offers from the Post Office.
The inquiry estimates that as many as 10,000 people may have been affected by the Horizon scandal, including both convicted subpostmasters and those who experienced financial or reputational damage as a result of the system's failures.
Sir Wyn described the attitude of the Post Office and its advisors in making compensation offers to victims as 'unnecessarily adversarial' and added this has had 'the effect of depressing the level of which settlements have been achieved'.
What does the report recommend?
Sir Wyn set out 19 recommendations, including: Delays and lack of legal support: The report found serious failings in the four compensation schemes – the Horizon Shortfall Scheme (HSS), the (GLO) Scheme, the Overturned Convictions (OC) Scheme, and the Horizon Convictions Redress Scheme (HCRS) – highlighting that 'the Post Office, the Department and Ministers simply failed to grasp' how hard timely redress would be. It criticised the refusal to fund legal advice under the HSS, saying the department 'continues to resist this as if its life depended on it.'
The report found serious failings in the four compensation schemes – the Horizon Shortfall Scheme (HSS), the (GLO) Scheme, the Overturned Convictions (OC) Scheme, and the Horizon Convictions Redress Scheme (HCRS) – highlighting that 'the Post Office, the Department and Ministers simply failed to grasp' how hard timely redress would be. It criticised the refusal to fund legal advice under the HSS, saying the department 'continues to resist this as if its life depended on it.' Slow progress in GLO scheme: The GLO scheme, meant to compensate Alan Bates and other subpostmasters involved in litigation, was singled out as being 'very slow'. Sir Wyn warned that compensation may not be settled by the end of 2026.
The GLO scheme, meant to compensate Alan Bates and other subpostmasters involved in litigation, was singled out as being 'very slow'. Sir Wyn warned that compensation may not be settled by the end of 2026. Call for clarity and fairness: The report urged the government to define what it means by 'full and fair financial' redress and stated that compensation should reflect 'the top end of the appropriate range of damages' a court might award.
The report urged the government to define what it means by 'full and fair financial' redress and stated that compensation should reflect 'the top end of the appropriate range of damages' a court might award. Financial support for family : It called for a formal process to compensate close family members of those harmed by the Horizon scandal.
: It called for a formal process to compensate close family members of those harmed by the Horizon scandal. Broader redress system proposed: It recommended creating a permanent public body to oversee future financial redress for victims of state wrongdoing.
The report states that the government, Post Office and Fujitsu must provide a written response to the recommendations by October 10, 2025.
A Post Office spokesperson said: 'The Inquiry has brought to life the devastating stories of those impacted by the Horizon Scandal. Their experiences represent a shameful period in our history.
'Today, we apologise unreservedly for the suffering which Post Office caused to postmasters and their loved ones. We will carefully consider the report and its recommendations.'
The government is expected to give is a statement in the House of Commons later on Tuesday.
Post Office Minister, Gareth Thomas, said: 'I welcome the Inquiry's publication today and pay tribute to Sir Wyn and his team for their comprehensive and penetrating work.
'We must never lose sight of the Horizon Scandal's human impact on postmasters and their families, which the Inquiry has highlighted so well.
'Sir Wyn's report highlights a series of failings by the Post Office and various governments. His recommendations are immensely helpful as a guide for what is needed to finish the job, and we will respond in full to Parliament after carefully considering them.'
Get all the latest news from around the country Follow STV News
Scan the QR code on your mobile device for all the latest news from around the country
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
2 days ago
- The Sun
I get paid £24 per HOUR to do a job no one wants – all I do is stand in line
A MAN has revealed he makes a £24 an hour, just for standing in a line. The man quit his 9-5 to do the unusual job full time, and can be paid up to £100 for one job. 1 Everyone hates standing in queues, whether it's for restaurants, concerts or theme park rides. And now, those who can afford it, are paying others to do it for them. Using TaskRabbit, a website that offers odd job services, people are now making a full-time wage for standing in line for other people. 'I do this all week now", one man told The i Paper. "I get asked to wait in line at restaurants, or for concert tickets or the Post Office; anything, really. "I do various errands and make a decent living out of it." The man revealed that the longest he has waited in a queue for someone is three hours, and added that his pay varies depending on where he needs to be and how long he needs to wait. And although you may think that no one would pay for this kind of service, the man revealed that there are plenty of people who have the disposable income to pay for it. Many restaurant chains such as Dishoom and Padella have chosen not to offer reservations, meaning that customers often have to queue for a long time before getting seated. So it makes sense that the rich would rather sit back and relax whilst someone does the queueing for them. I earn cash by selling 'actual rubbish' on eBay - I flogged a freebie I found on the floor by a bin for £10, it's crazy To hire someone to queue for you, all you need to do is head to TaskRabbit, put in the details of where you want the queuer to go, what you want them to order, and your card details. You will then be shown available queuers in your area, who can complete the task for you. And if you want to become a queuer yourself, all you need to do is sign up via the TaskRabbit website. Grave cleaner And standing in queues isn't the only unusual job you can do to make cash. Do I need to pay tax on my side hustle income? MANY people feeling strapped for cash are boosting their bank balance with a side hustle. The good news is, there are plenty of simple ways to earn some additional income - but you need to know the rules. When you're employed the company you work for takes the tax from your earnings and pays HMRC so you don't have to. But anyone earning extra cash, for example from selling things online or dog walking, may have to do it themselves. Stephen Moor, head of employment at law firm Ashfords, said: "Caution should be taken if you're earning an additional income, as this is likely to be taxable. "The side hustle could be treated as taxable trading income, which can include providing services or selling products." You can make a gross income of up to £1,000 a year tax-free via the trading allowance, but over this and you'll usually need to pay tax. Stephen added: "You need to register for a self-assessment at HMRC to ensure you are paying the correct amount of tax. "The applicable tax bands and the amount of tax you need to pay will depend on your income." If you fail to file a tax return you could end up with a surprise bill from HMRC later on asking you to pay the tax you owe - plus extra fees on top. A side hustle whiz has revealed how he makes an extra £4,000 a month, from a job nobody wants to do. Known only as @thegravecleaner online, the money-making pro cleans people's headstones for cash, alongside his regular job. The cleaning pro charges £135 for a basic clean, and up to £452, for a full restoration. TikToker @themoneyshark, who used the grave cleaner as an example of a great way to make extra cash, said: "You're probably thinking to yourself, no one's gonna pay for that. People don't even visit graves anymore. "Well, you're wrong, because he stays booked up." The Money Shark explained that one of the best things about this side hustle is that there isn't much competition, because "let's be real, not many people wanna offer this service". He added that it also doesn't cost much to get started, as you just need around £150 to purchase all of the supplies you need.
BBC News
4 days ago
- BBC News
Wrongly accused Birmingham postmaster returns for her dad
A woman returning to her family Post Office business after being wrongly accused of theft in the Horizon scandal says she is doing it for her Gill ran the Wattville Road Post Office in Handsworth, Birmingham, which was started by her father. But that ended when, due to a faulty Post Office computer system - and like hundreds of other postmasters and mistresses - she was falsely said to have stolen money. Now, more than a decade on from an ordeal that left her feeling suicidal, she is about to work there said her dad had been "devastated" by the accusation, "so for him I want to stand back there and say 'I didn't do it'." Her alleged wrongdoing - for which she was later fully exonerated - meant the Post Office dismissed her from the branch, which was based within a shop also run by the banished from the branch, taken over by a third party, she was able to continue working at the shop, which meant she still saw her old customers. Her dad - whom she said was among the first British Asian postmasters outside of London - died before her exoneration and the scale of the scandal was laid bare, although he had supported her through the Gill is due to get back the keys to the branch next week. She said she had been determined to take the helm once more. "I think it's going to be amazing," she said. "It's going to be emotional, but it's going to be exciting."But it comes after she lost her home, her car, and her reputation in the wake of the try to balance the books and stay out of jail, she said she ended up missing card and mortgage payments. The first report from the official inquiry into the scandal said last month the events had had a "disastrous" impact on those accused. Ms Gill first became aware of problems at her Post Office when accounts were falling short and she could not understand why."One day it would be one amount and the next day it would be a different amount. Figures were duplicating," she said."I just couldn't understand what the problem was or why."At the time, she had no idea that hundreds of other postmasters were in the same position as morning, her world came crashing down around her."The auditors came and did a stock balance and realised how much was short and I was asked to leave - hand back the keys, there and then, and they brought in interims to run the Post Office the next day," she said."It was horrible. Absolutely horrible." 'I lost everything' In the aftermath of her dismissal, Ms Gill and her husband's marriage suffered, with both knowing they had not taken any money and wondering where it had gone"I couldn't face anybody for a long time. I was depressed," she said."I lost my house, I lost my car, I lost everything."Things just got on top of me at one stage and I didn't want to be here, I tried to take my life. "Luckily now I'm here, but things could have been a lot different."The Post Office Horizon scandal broke into the public attention many years later, heightened by the ITV drama series Mr Bates vs The Post Gill said she felt angry over her experience, adding: "It was just anger not understanding why we didn't know other people had the same problem or why the Post Office hadn't done anything about it to rectify it and why it took a programme or a podcast for people to realise what was going on." While Ms Gill has been exonerated, an "amazing" point in her life, several of her loved ones are not here to see it."I lost my husband, my mom also passed away after I'd been convicted," she her father supported her after she was dismissed, selling a property to fund the missing money, he died before his daughter was cleared, and before news of the scandal became public."I just wish he'd been here to actually see or hear something, just a clip - maybe there's a chance," she said."But no. But I know he's watching, I know he knows." Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
Daily Mirror
4 days ago
- Daily Mirror
HMRC using AI to snoop on people's social media accounts
HMRC is using AI to scan for signs of a lifestyle that could indicate tax fraud Tax inspectors are using artificial intelligence to snoop on Brits' Facebook, Instagram and other social media posts in the hunt for evidence of tax fraud, it has emerged. The technology, capable of scanning for signs of lavish lifestyles such as luxury holidays or expensive purchases, is already being used in criminal investigations. Officials insist it is used only in serious cases and with 'robust safeguards'. But campaigners and MPs have warned it risks becoming a mass-surveillance tool that could wrongly accuse innocent taxpayers. The admission comes amid growing concern over the creeping use of AI in government decision-making – and fresh memories of the Post Office Horizon scandal, where blind faith in computer systems wrecked lives. Bob Blackman MP branded the tactic 'draconian', warning: 'If they start taking legal action against individuals based on that, you can see there's going to be a problem.' Sir John Hayes, former security minister and chair of the Tory Common Sense Group, said: 'The idea that a machine must always be right is what led to the Post Office scandal. I am a huge AI sceptic.' The AI tools work alongside HMRC's powerful 'Connect' system – a data-crunching network that has for years scanned billions of records from banks, property deeds and other databases to spot potential cheats. Chancellor Rachel Reeves has ordered officials to claw back £7billion of the UK's £47billion 'tax gap', and HMRC is trialling AI-powered assistants to flag suspicious returns – even issuing warnings that could later be used in court. Critics warn the technology is edging towards making automated decisions, despite HMRC's insistence that 'a human is always in the loop' and has the final say. The fears intensified after a tribunal ordered HMRC to reveal whether AI was already being used to assess claims for research and development tax credits – a move prompted by a Freedom of Information request from tax expert Tom Elsbury. The Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) is also trialling AI, with 20,000 staff using it to draft documents and summarise meetings. HMRC has approached around a dozen tech firms about using AI to help recover billions in unpaid tax – much of it linked to offshore accounts. An HMRC spokesman said: 'Use of AI for social media monitoring is restricted to criminal investigations and subject to legal oversight. It supports our processes but does not replace human decision-making.'
