Happy Face Season 1 Review – An ineffective blend of true crime and crime drama
Season 1
Episode Guide
Episode 1 -| Review Score – 3/5
Episode 2 -| Review Score – 3/5
Episode 3 -| Review Score – 3/5
Episode 4 -| Review Score – 3/5
Episode 5 -| Review Score – 2.5/5
Episode 6 -| Review Score – 2.5/5
Episode 7 -| Review Score – 2.5/5
Episode 8 -| Review Score – 2.5/5
It's hard to know what to feel while watching Happy Face. Do you enjoy the creepy thrills of a convicted serial killer of eight women sending his granddaughter drawings of herself and other women? Or do you feel the guilt and unease the killer's daughter experiences as the identity of her father chips away at her life?
This dissonance comes about from the fact that Happy Face Season 1 is loosely based on a true story. It is adapted from a podcast and autobiography by Melissa Moore, daughter of Keith Hunter Jesperson who is also known as the Happy Face Killer. The series turns Moore into Melissa Reed but keeps other broad details about Keith and her life pretty much the same.
The story kicks off when Keith, who has been arrested for eight murders, calls the TV show where Melissa works as a makeup artist and confesses to one more. But he will only give the details to Melissa. What follows is an investigation into this additional murder led by Melissa and Ivy, a producer for the show.
At the same time, as news about Melissa's connection to the serial killer leaks, it begins to affect her family. Her husband Ben and her kids, 15-year-old Hazel and 9-year-old Max, start feeling the ramifications as friends and coworkers find out the family's link to Jesperson. Hazel sees the difference in how students treat her at school, while Ben faces issues at work. Things get more tense because Melissa, who is focusing on the investigation, is forced to be away from her family at critical times.
As a whole, the Happy Face Season 1 follows a two-pronged approach to this story. On the one hand, it has all the markers of a crime thriller. Melissa and Ivy's investigation into the new murder offers a solid mystery to hang on to. We see them look for clues, collect evidence and speak to witnesses like in any other crime drama. The series pulls the puzzle together, piece by piece and with a few twists in between. At the same time, there is a sense that Keith is hiding something or planning something much bigger.
This side of the series leans into the drama. Tensions are high and the story is meant to offer a riveting and twisted mystery, though it does not always succeed. It also emphasises the unique thrill of a serial killer story — Dennis Quaid's performance as Jesperson is designed to give you the creeps and pique curiosity about what goes on inside the head of a man who killed eight women.
On the other hand, the show explores how Melissa's ordinary white picket fence life gets disturbed when people find out she's related to a killer. Friends change their behaviour, little Max loses a playmate, and prejudice raises its ugly head. Melissa and Ben face issues in their relationship.
Through clips from the past and events of the present, the series also looks at how many people suffered at the hands of Keith — Melissa, her brother Shane, their mother June, and even relatives of Keith's victims. This is meant to be a more grounded version of storytelling, a realistic portrayal of life as a killer's relative.
The two sides of the show simply don't work together. You can't easily pair high thrills, mystery and suspense with an unvarnished, grave depiction of reality. But the show forces them together and even flits between the two sides of the story in each episode. It leads to a tonally jarring experience where the mood shifts with every scene, which is just not a fun watch.
The inconsistency and clashing of moods get worse in the second half when the story tries to up the ante on both ends. While the murder mystery reaches a natural high point, the family's side of the tale enters dramatic territory. This is largely due to the storyline around Melissa's daughter, Hazel, who happens to get in touch with her grandfather and build a connection.
This plotline is ominous and leads to some chilling moments between them, trying to straddle the line between a depiction of the real world and a melodramatic crime thriller. Additionally, Ben decides to take certain steps that feel like a huge jump for his personality and are definitely not characteristic of a regular dad.
This is a weak attempt at giving otherwise flat characters some semblance of nuance and deeper characterisation. But instead of doing that, it just feels like watching them jump from one genre to another as they engage in increasingly absurd behaviour.
It doesn't help that the pacing is off and certain episodes feel stretched out, with even the murder mystery losing its momentum. Annaleigh Ashford's portrayal of Melissa begins to get monotonous and some of Quaid's dialogues feel laughable instead of creepy. Despite all the time the story spends on talking about guilt and duty and justice, it doesn't actually address these themes in a meaningful way.
Ultimately, Happy Face tries to be two kinds of stories in one and, as a result, fails. What's left is an uneven and easily forgettable mess. And that's just on its merits as a TV show. We've not even begun to dissect the real question — what it really means to take a story about real violence and real victims and turn it into entertainment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
6 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Adidas launch divisive Mary Jane version of its iconic Sambas
2025 has been the rise of the 'ugly' shoe trends, and Adidas' latest launch that combines the classic Mary Jane with its bestselling Samba has fans divided It feels like 2025 has been the year of the divisive shoe. We has UGG's platform Mary Jane Boots, the UGG AMBUSH sheepskin ballet flat and of course, the rise of the 'Sneakerina', loved by Bella Hadid and Dua Lipa. And Adidas' latest release has sparked some debate among fashion fans. The release in question is the adidas Originals Samba Mary Jane. Yep, you heard that right. A combination of one of Adidas' most iconic and trending styles, the Samba, mixed with popular 2025 shoe trend, the Mary Jane. The result? A sporty hybrid shoe that's not quite a trainer and not quite a Mary Jane. Priced at £80, this new shoe style is available to shop in classic white with black stripes, on-trend red, and black with white stripes. Fashion lovers and Samba fans on social media have been quick to leave their opinions on these conterversial shoes, with some calling it that they'll be the 'shoe of the summer ' and others comparing them to children's school shoes. I'm an Adidas samba wearer and lover myself, so I'm actually a fan of this pair myself. I love that feel silghtly girlier and feminine than sambas, but definitely look comfier than a traditional pair of Mary Janes thanks to the gum sole. If this style is up your street, you'll be pleased to know that tonnes of other brands have similar styles that toe the line between sporty and girly, and we've rounded up a few of our favourites. Charles & Keith Available for £75 here Not only are the sneakerinas a huge trend, but so are metallic shoes, so these silver satin sneakers from Charles & Keith combine both trends in one. If the silver isn't really your style, they are also available in a classic black colourway. Puma Dua Lipa posted an Instagram carousel sporting the Puma Speedcat Ballet Shoes, showing that she's given this controversial trend her seal of approval. Dua's exact metallic silver ones are currently out of stock, but we've found some suede pink ones from Puma that still perfectly fit into the trend. Vivaia Cristina Satin Sneakerinas Bella Hadid was spotted wearing this reasonably affordable £119 pair from Vivaia. And not only is Bella a huge fan of Vivaia's pair, but so is Charli XCX, who was seen sporting two different pairs in the Coachella desert. The Vivaia shoes have been crafted a smooth satin fabric like classic ballet shoes, but sit upon on a rubber sole like a trainer. The result? A sporty-looking ballet flat that perfectly combines feminine and athletic fashion.
Daily Mail
21 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Heartbroken girlfriend reveals genius way she dumped her cheating ex after finding out he'd been texting another woman
A broken-hearted student dumped her 'cheating' ex - by printing out 'sexts' he sent to another woman and hand-delivering them to him at work in a sympathy card. Melissa Viegas broke up with her partner after discovering he had sent explicit messages to another woman. The 23-year-old, who first met her former boyfriend via Instagram, said she was 'suspicious' of him talking to other women but didn't want to confront him until she had evidence. The masters student was lying next to her now-ex in bed when she received a message request from a stranger saying she had exchanged flirty messages with her boyfriend. Horrified, Melissa read through the texts exchanged between the pair, some of which contained references to explicit sexual fantasies. Armed with the evidence, Melissa, from the UK, began concocting a plan of how she could expose him. The bartender printed out multiple screenshots of the 'sexts' and stuck them inside a sympathy card that read 'remembering your loved one'. A devastated Melissa then delivered the card in person to him while he was working behind a bar, storming out before she could see his reaction. Melissa was lying in bed with her now-ex when she received a message from a woman who claims she and the man had been exchanging racy texts When contacted for comment, her ex admitted to 'engaging in some inappropriate messages that crossed a line' and said he would learn from it. After the man's apparent infidelity came to light, Melissa received more tip offs from women who say he had slid into their direct messages while they were still together. 'I had a lot of suspicions but I didn't have any hard proof that he was cheating,' Melissa said. 'Because there were so many suspicions, I was already thinking about leaving. I knew I deserved better. 'I was in bed lying next to him when I saw I had a new message request from a girl who he'd been messaging.' Apparently, the man told the woman he was messaging that he didn't have social media but she was sceptical. She did some investigating online when she came across his Instagram profile, saw posts with Melissa and 'felt terrible'. 'He tries to plan to see her multiple times. He was really full-on sexting. It really scarred me. It was horrible, especially seeing him call her the pet names he calls me,' Melissa said. 'So when that girl sent me all those receipts I knew I had all I needed and I wasn't going to put myself through anything like this again.' A week later, Melissa devised a plan to confront her partner about the messages alongside print-outs of the exchange. 'It really was hard not saying anything but I didn't see him a huge amount that week anyway because of his new job,' she recalled. 'My initial idea was just to print off the screenshots and give them to him at work. I ended up cutting them out and putting them in a 'sorry for your loss' card. 'I showed up to his work and gave him the card. He opened it, stared at it for a while and he was clearly embarrassed. He was offended I had done it at his work. 'My friend grabbed my hand and said 'Let's just go'.' After sharing her story on TikTok, Melissa's video racked up more than a million views. 'I just thought 'I'm going to make a video' because he was so shameless,' Melissa said. 'He knew I was suspicious and asking questions and he made me feel guilty about bringing up him cheating. I thought he needed to learn some shame. 'I had never realised how strong girl power could be. The only hate comments were from men. It's made me hold my friends even tighter now.' Since the clip went viral, Melissa was contacted by two other women claiming to have been messaging her ex without knowing he had a girlfriend. One of the women said she had a date lined up with him but in light of the new information will now 'stand him up'. Melissa also reported her former flame had messaged one of her friends saying 'I was going to break up with her anyway'. 'We literally booked a holiday two weeks ago for end of August so theres no way he was planning for that,' Melissa said. In response to the viral video, Melissa's ex said he 'deeply regrets any hurt caused' and wishes Melissa 'nothing but the best'. 'The claims in Melissa's viral TikTok don't reflect who I am,' the ex said. 'I deeply regret any hurt she felt during our relationship and breakup, and I take responsibility for engaging in some inappropriate messages that crossed a line. 'That was a mistake, not a reflection of my character, and I'm committed to learning from it. Break-ups are tough and I understand emotions can run high online. 'I'm not here to add to the noise or point fingers - I'm focused on moving forward with integrity and privately. 'I wish Melissa nothing but the best.'
The Review Geek
29-05-2025
- The Review Geek
Happy Face Season 1 Review – An ineffective blend of true crime and crime drama
Season 1 Episode Guide Episode 1 -| Review Score – 3/5 Episode 2 -| Review Score – 3/5 Episode 3 -| Review Score – 3/5 Episode 4 -| Review Score – 3/5 Episode 5 -| Review Score – 2.5/5 Episode 6 -| Review Score – 2.5/5 Episode 7 -| Review Score – 2.5/5 Episode 8 -| Review Score – 2.5/5 It's hard to know what to feel while watching Happy Face. Do you enjoy the creepy thrills of a convicted serial killer of eight women sending his granddaughter drawings of herself and other women? Or do you feel the guilt and unease the killer's daughter experiences as the identity of her father chips away at her life? This dissonance comes about from the fact that Happy Face Season 1 is loosely based on a true story. It is adapted from a podcast and autobiography by Melissa Moore, daughter of Keith Hunter Jesperson who is also known as the Happy Face Killer. The series turns Moore into Melissa Reed but keeps other broad details about Keith and her life pretty much the same. The story kicks off when Keith, who has been arrested for eight murders, calls the TV show where Melissa works as a makeup artist and confesses to one more. But he will only give the details to Melissa. What follows is an investigation into this additional murder led by Melissa and Ivy, a producer for the show. At the same time, as news about Melissa's connection to the serial killer leaks, it begins to affect her family. Her husband Ben and her kids, 15-year-old Hazel and 9-year-old Max, start feeling the ramifications as friends and coworkers find out the family's link to Jesperson. Hazel sees the difference in how students treat her at school, while Ben faces issues at work. Things get more tense because Melissa, who is focusing on the investigation, is forced to be away from her family at critical times. As a whole, the Happy Face Season 1 follows a two-pronged approach to this story. On the one hand, it has all the markers of a crime thriller. Melissa and Ivy's investigation into the new murder offers a solid mystery to hang on to. We see them look for clues, collect evidence and speak to witnesses like in any other crime drama. The series pulls the puzzle together, piece by piece and with a few twists in between. At the same time, there is a sense that Keith is hiding something or planning something much bigger. This side of the series leans into the drama. Tensions are high and the story is meant to offer a riveting and twisted mystery, though it does not always succeed. It also emphasises the unique thrill of a serial killer story — Dennis Quaid's performance as Jesperson is designed to give you the creeps and pique curiosity about what goes on inside the head of a man who killed eight women. On the other hand, the show explores how Melissa's ordinary white picket fence life gets disturbed when people find out she's related to a killer. Friends change their behaviour, little Max loses a playmate, and prejudice raises its ugly head. Melissa and Ben face issues in their relationship. Through clips from the past and events of the present, the series also looks at how many people suffered at the hands of Keith — Melissa, her brother Shane, their mother June, and even relatives of Keith's victims. This is meant to be a more grounded version of storytelling, a realistic portrayal of life as a killer's relative. The two sides of the show simply don't work together. You can't easily pair high thrills, mystery and suspense with an unvarnished, grave depiction of reality. But the show forces them together and even flits between the two sides of the story in each episode. It leads to a tonally jarring experience where the mood shifts with every scene, which is just not a fun watch. The inconsistency and clashing of moods get worse in the second half when the story tries to up the ante on both ends. While the murder mystery reaches a natural high point, the family's side of the tale enters dramatic territory. This is largely due to the storyline around Melissa's daughter, Hazel, who happens to get in touch with her grandfather and build a connection. This plotline is ominous and leads to some chilling moments between them, trying to straddle the line between a depiction of the real world and a melodramatic crime thriller. Additionally, Ben decides to take certain steps that feel like a huge jump for his personality and are definitely not characteristic of a regular dad. This is a weak attempt at giving otherwise flat characters some semblance of nuance and deeper characterisation. But instead of doing that, it just feels like watching them jump from one genre to another as they engage in increasingly absurd behaviour. It doesn't help that the pacing is off and certain episodes feel stretched out, with even the murder mystery losing its momentum. Annaleigh Ashford's portrayal of Melissa begins to get monotonous and some of Quaid's dialogues feel laughable instead of creepy. Despite all the time the story spends on talking about guilt and duty and justice, it doesn't actually address these themes in a meaningful way. Ultimately, Happy Face tries to be two kinds of stories in one and, as a result, fails. What's left is an uneven and easily forgettable mess. And that's just on its merits as a TV show. We've not even begun to dissect the real question — what it really means to take a story about real violence and real victims and turn it into entertainment.
