Indonesia's budget battles sink its aircraft-carrier dreams
For a nation of more than 17,000 islands at the southern edge of one of the world's most contested waterways, the idea of an aircraft carrier might seem like a bold, even necessary, step.
Advertisement
But
Indonesia 's dream of owning such a symbol of naval might is colliding with a harsh reality: the lack of money and, perhaps, need.
'It seems that we need an aircraft carrier for non-war military operations,' Admiral Muhammad Ali said at a press conference on February 6, citing humanitarian assistance, disaster relief and maritime security among the potential uses for such an oceangoing platform.
Indonesia's Chief of Naval Staff Admiral Muhammad Ali is seen at an air force base in Jakarta in 2023. Photo: AFP
The naval chief's remarks, reported by national news agency Antara, underline Indonesia's desire to modernise its navy, which has recently acquired two Italian frigates and has plans for more upgrades.
Yet observers remain unconvinced that an aircraft carrier, often seen as the crown jewel of naval power, is the right choice for Jakarta.
A pricey symbol
The idea of acquiring an aircraft carrier specifically for non-combat operations 'does not make strategic and operational sense', according to Abdul Rahman Yaacob, a research fellow at the Lowy Institute's Southeast Asia programme who specialises in defence and security.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
HKFP
an hour ago
- HKFP
US, China agree on trade ‘framework' after high-level talks in London
Top officials from the United States and China said Tuesday that they had agreed on a 'framework' to move forward on trade, following two days of high-level talks in London to resolve tensions. US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick expressed optimism after a full day of negotiations that concerns surrounding rare earth minerals and magnets 'will be resolved' eventually, as the deal is implemented. But this framework will first need to be approved by leaders in Washington and Beijing, officials said, at the end of meetings at the British capital's historic Lancaster House. All eyes were on the outcomes of negotiations as both sides tried to overcome an impasse over export restrictions. US officials earlier accused Beijing of slow-walking approvals for shipments of rare earths. The world's two biggest economies were also seeking a longer-lasting truce in their escalating tariffs war, with levies currently only temporarily on hold. 'We're moving as quickly as we can,' US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer told reporters. 'We would very much like to find an agreement that makes sense for both countries,' he added, noting that the relationship was complex. 'We feel positive about engaging with the Chinese,' he maintained. Speaking separately to reporters, China International Trade Representative Li Chenggang said: 'Our communication has been very professional, rational, in-depth and candid.' Li expressed hope that progress made in London would help to boost trust on both sides. Productive talks US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent earlier described the closely watched trade talks as productive, although scheduling conflicts prompted his departure from London with negotiations still ongoing. Bessent, who led the US delegation with Lutnick and Greer, left early to return to Washington for testimony before Congress, a US official told AFP. Chinese Vice Premier He Lifeng headed his country's team in London, which included Li and Commerce Minister Wang Wentao. Both sides do not yet have another gathering scheduled. But Lutnick said Tuesday that US measures imposed when rare earths 'were not coming' would likely be relaxed once Beijing moved forward with more license approvals. Global stock markets were on edge, but Wall Street's major indexes climbed on hopes for progress earlier Tuesday. The London negotiations follow talks in Geneva last month, which saw a temporary agreement to lower tariffs. This time, China's exports of rare earth minerals — used in a range of things including smartphones, electric vehicle batteries and green technology — were a key issue on the agenda. 'In Geneva, we had agreed to lower tariffs on them, and they had agreed to release the magnets and rare earths that we need throughout the economy,' US President Donald Trump's top economic adviser, Kevin Hassett, told CNBC on Monday. Even though Beijing was releasing some supplies, 'it was going a lot slower than some companies believed was optimal', he added. 'Mirror arsenal' Both countries 'have developed almost a mirror arsenal of trade and investment weapons that they can aim at each other,' said Emily Benson, head of strategy at Minerva Technology Futures. As they tap economic tools to try and shift global power structures, she told AFP, it may not be reasonable to expect a typical trade and investment deal. But both sides could find ways to level off a downward spiral. A dialing-down of temperatures could involve Chinese efforts to shore up the process for granting export control licenses, Benson said. She noted Beijing appeared understaffed given the volume of requests. On the US side, this could look like a relaxation of certain export curbs in the high-tech domain, she added. But observers remained cautious, with Thomas Mathews of Capital Economics warning that Washington was unlikely to 'back off completely.' This could weigh on markets. Since returning to office, Trump has slapped a 10 percent levy on friend and foe, threatening steeper rates on dozens of economies. His tariffs have dented trade, with Beijing data showing Chinese exports to the United States plunged in May. The World Bank on Tuesday joined other international organizations to slash its 2025 global growth forecast amid trade uncertainty. China is also in talks with partners including Japan and South Korea to try to build a united front countering Trump's tariffs.
RTHK
7 hours ago
- RTHK
China, US agree on trade framework after talks
China, US agree on trade framework after talks Vice Premier He Lifeng and US Secretary of Treasury Scott Bessent pose for photos on Monday during trade discussions in London. Photo: AFP Top officials from China and the United States said on Tuesday that they had agreed on a framework to move forward on trade, following two days of high-level talks in London. Speaking to reporters, China's international trade representative and vice minister of commerce, Li Chenggang said: "Our communication has been very professional, rational, in-depth and candid." "The two sides have, in principle, reached a framework for implementing the consensus reached by the two heads of state during the phone call on June 5th and the consensus reached at the Geneva meeting," Li told reporters. Li expressed hope that progress made in London would help boost trust on both sides. He was speaking following the first meeting of the China-US economic and trade consultation mechanism held in London. Vice Premier He Lifeng headed his country's team in London, which included Li and Commerce Minister Wang Wentao. Both sides do not yet have another gathering scheduled. In a separate briefing, US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick told reporters that the framework puts "meat on the bones" of a deal reached last month in Geneva. "We have reached a framework to implement the Geneva consensus and the call between the two presidents," Lutnick said. "The idea is we're going to go back and speak to President Trump and make sure he approves it. They're going to go back and speak to President Xi and make sure he approves it, and if that is approved, we will then implement the framework." US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent, who led the US delegation with Lutnick and US Trade Representative Jamieson Greer, left early to return to Washington for testimony before Congress. China is also in talks with partners including Japan and South Korea to try to build a united front countering US President Donald Trump's tariffs. (Agencies)
RTHK
12 hours ago
- RTHK
Lebanon says two dead in Israel strike
Lebanon says two dead in Israel strike The Lebanese village of Shebaa lies close to the border with Israel. File photo: AFP An Israeli strike killed a Lebanese father and son on Tuesday in a southern village, the Lebanese health ministry and state media said, the latest deaths despite a November ceasefire. A second son was also wounded in the strike in Shebaa, the state-run National News Agency reported. "An Israeli enemy drone carried out a strike in the village of Shebaa, killing two people and wounding one," a health ministry statement said. The Israeli army said in a statement that it had killed a Hezbollah member and a man who operated in the "Lebanese Resistance Brigades," which it says are directed by Hezbollah. The military alleged that the two men were "handling weapons used by Hezbollah for terrorist purposes and for observation of (Israeli) soldiers in the area." Israel had warned on Friday that it would keep up its strikes on Hezbollah targets across Lebanon despite the condemnation expressed by the Lebanese government after a massive strike on south Beirut the previous night, on the eve of the Eid al-Adha holiday. Hezbollah, which is backed by Iran, said the strikes levelled nine residential blocks. The Israeli military said the strikes targeted underground drone factories. Lebanese President Joseph Aoun condemned the attack as "a flagrant violation" of the November 27 ceasefire agreement, which was supposed to end more than a year of hostilities between Israel and Hezbollah that culminated in two months of full-blown war. (AFP)
