Delete caste column from appraisal forms: T.N. Police Commission
The performance appraisal or Annual Confidential Report (ACR) is a crucial document that decides the professional growth of police personnel and officers in the force with regard to increments, promotions, medals, empanelment, deputation etc.,
In the Tamil Nadu Police, the ACR forms meant for Head Constables and Special Sub-Inspectors, who form a sizeable chunk of the 1.25 lakh force, have a reference to their caste/community.
There is also a column that seeks to know their contribution in lawfully assisting the oppressed classes during their period of appraisal, the sources said.
The Tamil Nadu Fifth Police Commission, headed by former Judge of the Madras High Court Justice C.T. Selvam and other senior serving and former bureaucrats, has recommended that the reference to caste/community in the appraisal forms be deleted.
'There is no need for the superior officer appraising the professional work to know the caste of the police personnel. Such references may lead to bias in awarding marks that are crucial for professional growth. The system had been in place for years with nobody objecting to the unwanted practice,' a senior IPS officer said.
'Absent in the ACR forms for other ranks'
Caste references were not there in the ACR assessment of other ranks, including IPS officers. 'The practice of asking the caste of complainants and accused persons at the police station level should also be dispensed with as there is no provision to do so under law,' the officer who preferred anonymity said.
While the State government is silent on implementing the report of the Commission, which submitted its final report to Chief Minister M.K. Stalin recently, the Home Department has called for several reports from the police headquarters on several issues highlighted for reforms by the panel, police sources said.
'Evolve political consensus'
One of the recommendations of the Commission to curb caste problems in the State was asking the government to hold all-party meetings to evolve the political consensus to remove caste names from streets and caste markers/identifiers on village boundaries to minimise the gravity of discrimination arising out of a false sense of caste pride.
Formation of Special Intelligence Cells (SIC) in all caste-sensitive districts to gather intelligence on caste-related developments that have a bearing on Law and Order was also recommended.
Amid allegations of police officials from a particular community being posted in caste and communally sensitive southern districts, the Commission asked Commissioners/Superintendents of Police of all cities/districts to ensure that too many police personnel from dominant communities were not assigned to these areas 'to avoid biased reporting on events and developments.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Withdraw free symbols, bring back ballot system: BRS urges EC
Hyderabad: BRS working president KT Rama Rao has asked Election Commission (EC) for the immediate withdrawal of eight free symbols and permanent safeguards to protect the visual identity of state-recognised parties, particularly in states where they are dominant players. The party said there was persistent misuse of free symbols that closely resemble its reserved election symbol, the car. In particular, the party flagged eight free symbols — camera, chapati roller, dolli, road roller, soap dish, television, sewing machine, and ship — which, when displayed in small sizes on EVMs and ballot papers, are indistinguishable from the car symbol, especially for illiterate and elderly voters. The BRS delegation, led by KTR, met the ECI officials in Delhi on Tuesday upon the Commission's invitation for an interaction. Rajya Sabha MPs KR Suresh Reddy, Vaddiraju Ravichandra, former MP B Vinod Kumar, and Balka Suman and RS Praveen Kumar were part of the delegation. You Can Also Check: Hyderabad AQI | Weather in Hyderabad | Bank Holidays in Hyderabad | Public Holidays in Hyderabad BRS said that in several past elections, including the 2019 Bhongir Lok Sabha (LS) election, the confusion caused by these symbols led to an abnormal diversion of votes meant for the pink party, helping rival or independent candidates. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Find out: this is how you clean your yoga mat! Kingdom Of Men Undo The party also expressed disappointment over the lack of timely action on its earlier representations during the 2023 assembly and 2024 LS elections. These included abusive and derogatory statements by leaders of rival parties, disparities in the Commission's response to complaints filed by BRS versus those filed against it, and inaction on the model code of conduct violations, including misuse of social media, hate speech, and politicisation of govt events. KTR also submitted a detailed representation to EC urging the constitutional body to address critical concerns affecting electoral integrity and a level-playing field. He highlighted four major issues: the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls underway in Bihar, the party's call for a return to paper ballots, the repeated misuse of identical free symbols that dilute the party's identity, and non-action on past representations regarding violations of the model code of conduct (MCC). BRS has called for a withdrawal of the current SIR in Bihar and also expressed its concerns over the continued use of electronic voting machines (EVMs), citing growing public distrust and international precedents. "BRS would like to voice its serious concern about suspicions over the usage of electronic voting machines. Several media reports to this effect have surfaced over the last few years. Many political parties, activists, and voters have also expressed their concerns about the usage of EVMs," BRS mentioned in its letter. It urged EC to consider reinstating paper ballots, starting with the upcoming Bihar assembly elections in Nov 2025, to restore public confidence in the democratic process.
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
Prince Harry says ‘damage done' after Sentebale probe clears him of wrongdoing: ‘The kids will pay the price'
Prince Harry has responded to the criticism after the UK's Charity Commission wrapped its investigation into Sentebale, the African charity he co-founded nearly two decades ago with Prince Seeiso of Lesotho. While the Commission found no evidence of bullying, misogyny, or racism within the organisation, clearing Harry of the accusations brought forward by current chair Dr. Sophie Chandauka, the damage, the Duke says, is already done. On August 5, the investigating commission said it found 'no overreach' by either Harry or Chandauka. The controversy began earlier this year with a major fallout inside the charity's board. Things got out of hand by March 2025, and the Duke, along with the entire board resigned. In a joint statement, they called the working relationship with Chandauka 'beyond repair' and said they could no longer serve under those conditions. They also claimed she was asked to step down but refused, and instead sued others to hold her position. Also read: 'Nothing against Meghan Markle': Prince Harry hits back at claims of physical fight with Prince Andrew that left him with a bloody nose Amid the public fallout, the Charity Commission launched a formal probe, which ended with a clear verdict: no wrongdoing by Harry or Chandauka. But while both walked away clean, the Commission slammed the charity's leadership for its failure to handle disputes internally and for letting the mess spill out in full view, damaging not just Sentebale, but trust in charities overall. In response to the report, a spokesperson for Harry welcomed the Commission's findings but made it clear, the Duke isn't satisfied. The spokesperson said that although the report found no fault with Harry, the consequences of the drama wouldn't be borne by either Chandauka or the board, but by the children the charity was created to help. Earlier, in a statement responding to the finding, a spokesperson of Harry told PEOPLE, 'Unsurprisingly, the Commission makes no findings of wrongdoing in relation to Sentebale's Co-Founder and former Patron, Prince Harry, Duke of Sussex.' They added, 'Despite all that, their report falls troublingly short in many regards, primarily the fact that the consequences of the current Chair's actions will not be borne by her — but by the children who rely on Sentebale's support.' Also read: Prince Harry and Meghan Markle to handle Netflix crisis Obama-style as bankruptcy rumours grow; new projects in pipeline A source close to Harry and Seeiso said they believe there's no way back to running the charity like before while Chandauka remains chair. They see the entire situation as a kind of hostile takeover. 'This was Prince Seeiso and Prince Harry's life work. They established it 19 years ago and in that time put in blood, sweat and tears and their own money into building this charity up to what it was: a multi-million pound charity that delivered nothing but good for the beneficiary community that is supported in Lesotho and Botswana,' the source told PEOPLE. Dr. Sophie Chandauka, meanwhile, issued her own statement. She said the report backed the governance concerns she had flagged earlier in 2025. Reflecting on what she called a pressure test for the organisation's resilience, she claimed Sentebale had kept serving tens of thousands of young people in Lesotho and Botswana. 'The unexpected adverse media campaign that was launched by those who resigned on 24 March 2025 has caused incalculable damage and offers a glimpse of the unacceptable behaviours displayed in private. We are emerging not just grateful to have survived, but stronger: more focused, better governed, boldly ambitious and with our dignity intact.' In a Financial Times interview from March, Chandauka claimed her working relationship with Harry broke after she refused to help him defend Meghan Markle.
The Hindu
6 hours ago
- The Hindu
Third phase of ‘Maaperum Tamil Kanavu' from August 6: Stalin
The third phase of the 'Maaperum Tamil Kanavu' initiative will commence on August 6 to benefit over two lakh students and 200 colleges, Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M.K. Stalin said on Tuesday. In a social media post, Mr. Stalin said that it was the primary duty of the DMK government to pass on the ideals of social equality, Tamil tradition, its antiquity, its rich culture, among others to the young generation. The 'Maaperum Thamizh Kanavu' event aims make the younger generation aware of ancient Tamils, their culture and literature, need for egalitarian society and the employment opportunities available for them, among others.
