Tyre Nichols murder trial is underway. What to know about the deadly traffic stop
Tyre Nichols murder trial is underway. What to know about the deadly traffic stop Three ex-Memphis police officers are facing state charges including second-degree murder and aggravated assault in the beating death of Tyre Nichols.
The state criminal trial of three former Memphis police officers charged in the beating death of Tyre Nichols after a traffic stop resumed for a fourth day of testimony.
Tadarrius Bean, Demetrius Haley and Justin Smith Jr. are facing charges that include second-degree murder, aggravated assault, aggravated kidnapping, official misconduct and official oppression. All three defendants pleaded not guilty to all charges. The trial started on April 28.
Two other officers took plea deals ahead of a federal trial last year and will not be tried as part of this state trial, though they could testify.
The out-of-town jury hearing the case is from Hamilton County, Tennessee, and is mostly white, made up of nine women and six men. The jury will be sequestered for the duration of the trial.
Here's a brief timeline of what happened leading up to the trial and what witnesses have said so far.
What happened to Tyre Nichols?
Nichols was pulled over in the evening hours of Jan. 7, 2023. Haley and another officer initially pulled him over and pulled him from his car.
A struggle ensued, with pepper spray being used and a Taser being fired at Nichols as he ran from officers. It is unclear if the Taser made contact with him.
Another set of officers eventually caught up to Nichols, who was running toward his mother's house. He was less than 100 yards away when he was tackled.
When more officers got to the scene, while officers held Nichols' arms and hit him with a barrage of kicks, punches, baton strikes and pepper spray.
The assault lasted minutes and was captured on body cameras and a SkyCop camera. When Nichols goes limp, he is handcuffed and leaned against an unmarked squad car. More than 20 minutes pass before he is put on a stretcher and taken to the hospital.
Nichols was in critical condition when he arrived at the hospital. He died three days later when he was taken off life support.
Defense starts presenting its case and raises questions about drugs, stolen credit cards
In opening statements, defense attorneys focused on Nichols resisting arrest, and the dangers of being a Memphis cop. Attorneys for each of the three former officers on trial ‒ Bean, Haley and Smith ‒ took a slightly different approach with the jury, but argued a similar theme: Nichols was dangerous to the officers.
They said drugs and stolen credit cards were found in Nichols' car and argued he could have had superhuman strength due to drug use. Investigators confirmed IDs, credit cards, psilocybin and multiple items that tested positive for cannabis were found in Nichols' vehicle.
The officers' lawyers also argued the traffic stop was warranted and Nichols resisted arrest and struggled against them.
'My son was beaten to a pulp' Emotional testimony as Tyre Nichols murder trial begins
Former officer who fired Taser says he heard Nichols grabbed gun
Former Memphis police officer Preston Hemphill, who was fired but not criminally charged after firing his Taser at at Nichols, said he saw Nichols switch lanes without a blinker and said he was fleeing from police. That, according to Hemphill, gave him reason to pull over the car.
During the stop, Hemphill said Nichols struggled with officers, and Haley pushed him into the car. At one point, Hemphill said he heard Emmitt Martin III, one of the officers who took a plea deal, yell, 'Let go my gun.'
'It increased the risk as high as it can go for me,' Hemphill said.
Hemphill said he tried to bear hug Nichols, but was unable to keep him restrained. He fired his Taser, but did not know that his weapon failed to connect with Nichols until after the incident.
Hemphill estimated he, Haley and Martin weighed about 750 pounds collectively. Defense attorney Martin Zummach asked Hemphill if he was exaggerating when he said Nichols pushed all three men off him. Hemphill said no, he was not exaggerating.
TBI investigator said drugs, stolen credit cards were found Nichols' car
Special Agent Charles 'Chuck' Baker, the lead investigator with the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation on Nichols' case, confirmed IDs and credit cards were found in Nichols' car.
Baker also said there were 1.77 grams of psilocybin and multiple items that tested positive for cannabis in Nichols' vehicle. A charred substance, he said, was 0.6 grams of cannabis.
Baker said TBI did not do independent toxicology testing, but did obtain copies of tests done by the hospital. Zummach pushed hard on Baker about whether TBI investigators were aware that the accused officers believed Nichols was high and when bloodwork was done on Nichols.
Baker said TBI also reviewed allegations that Nichols had an extremely high pain tolerance and a large amount of strength. Those allegations, Baker said, were not founded, based on the video and other evidence.
Michael Stengel, Haley's attorney, asked about the stolen cards found in Nichols' car. In total, Stengel showed five credit cards, debit cards, and IDs.
"Say everything in that car was stolen, it still has no bearing on me as to the seriousness of the crime I was asked to investigate," Baker later told Deputy District Attorney Paul Hagerman. Hagerman went on to point out that none of the officers on trial knew about the drugs or cards found in the car. He also asked if Baker has ever associated psilocybin use with superhuman strength.
Baker said he has never found someone on psilocybin to be super strong. Hagerman asked the same questions about marijuana use.
'No, they're very peaceful,' Baker said.
Medical examiner found Nichols' cause of death was homicide
Dr. Marco Ross, the chief medical examiner for the West Tennessee Regional Forensic Center, said Nichols had multiple injuries including abrasions and bruises across his body. Ross said some injuries were 'superficial,' but the investigation of Nichols' body revealed deeper traumas and damage.
Ross said there was hemorrhaging due to multiple areas of tearing within Nichols' brain. Ross said Nichols also had axonal injuries due to the trauma from impact. Axons are part of nerve cells, he explained, and connect with other nerves. They're important for sending electrical signals throughout the body, he said.
'Most commonly, I've usually seen these types of injuries in car accidents,' Ross said. "It's the power of the forces involved with the impact on the head.'
Ross said Nichols' cause of death was blunt force trauma to the head and the manner of death was homicide.
According to Ross, Nichols tested positive for alcohol, caffeine, nicotine, drugs administered by paramedics and hospital staff, and marijuana products. Nichols' alcohol level was .049 on the breathalyzer scale, according to Ross. He added that Nichols' marijuana levels were seen in standard, recreational use.
Former officer shared photo of Nichols 11 times after beating
After the beating, Haley took a photo of Nichols' body leaned up against the side of an unmarked police cruiser, according to Derek Miller, a cybercrimes forensics expert with the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation.
The photo, presented for the first time publicly, showed Nichols leaned against a car with his hands cuffed behind his back. His clothes were dirty, presumably from being thrown to the ground, and his mouth was covered in blood.
Miller said it is believed the photo was shared "up to 11 times." He added that the first person who received the photo had it sent to them "two or three minutes" after it was taken.
Officer who pepper sprayed Nichols admits to lying about beating
Former Memphis Police Department officer Desmond Mills Jr., one of the five officers charged in relation to Nichols' death, said he pepper-sprayed Nichols three times and sprayed multiple people, including himself and other officers.
Mills took a plea deal before the federal trial and could be sentenced to life in prison.
Mills said Nichols did not throw a punch or kick. He added the beating Nichols received should have been stopped by himself or others. After the beating, Mills said Martin asked him to turn off his body camera. Mills said he obliged and they talked about what prompted the officers to beat up Nichols.
Mills said he later lied on police paperwork to keep himself and his coworkers out of trouble. He said he didn't know a SkyCop camera at the scene recorded what happened. On the footage, Nichols can be heard screaming for his mother as officers held him on the ground, pepper sprayed him and asked for his hands.
"During any of those videos did you ever say stop?' Hagerman asked Mills.
'No,' Mills replied.
Tyre Nichols' mother shares emotional toll of losing her son
Nichols' mother, RowVaugh Wells spoke about the emotional toll of losing her son on the first day of the trial.
Wells is softspoken on most days, and her voice wavered as she recalled police arriving at her house the night Nichols was beaten.
Her voice, still quiet, grew firm when Headley asked about Nichols' appearance when Wells visited him in the hospital.
"My son was beaten to a pulp. His head was the size of a watermelon," she said. "He was bruised from head to toe."
Federal charges adjudicated, mixed verdicts
In 2023, federal prosecutors announced criminal indictments of five officers in the death, including Bean, Haley, Martin, Mills and Smith. That case went to trial in September 2024.
Martin and Mills entered into plea deals prior to trial and both testified in the federal case. Bean and Smith were found guilty of witness tampering but were acquitted of all other civil rights charges.
Haley was found guilty on all counts — using excessive force, being deliberately indifferent, witness tampering and conspiracy to witness tamper.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
18 minutes ago
- New York Post
Police still investigating death of Brett Gardner's 14-year-old son as potential homicide
Costa Rican authorities are still seeking answers in the tragic death of Miller Gardner. The 14-year-old son of ex-Yankees star Brett Gardner died at Arenas Del Mar Beachfront & Rainforest Resort on March 21, with investigators continuing to determine if the cause will be homicide. 'The purpose of the investigation is precisely to determine whether or not we are dealing with a possible homicide,' a spokeswoman for the Prosecutor's Office of Costa Rica told ESPN on Thursday. 'For this reason, it is not possible at this time to confirm or rule out that a crime has been committed.' 3 Miller Gardner, 14, was vacationing with his family in Costa Rica when he died from carbon monoxide poisoning. Gardner died of carbon monoxide inhalation according to a toxicology report in early April, which noted 'high levels' of the noxious gas in his hotel room, which was adjacent to a mechanical room. The resort denied the validity of a report by the Judicial Investigation Agency of Costa Rica that revealed high levels of carbon monoxide in the Gardner family's hotel room, saying that the high levels were confined to the machine room. Authorities are seemingly still in the first stage of their criminal procedure of collecting and analyzing evidence, with a potential second stage involving formal charges before a trial. Gardner was initially theorized to have died from asphyxiation in his sleep after choking on vomit after food poisoning, but was later revealed to have no windpipe blockage. 3 Miller Gardner (second from right) was the son of Yankee great Brett Gardner (right). The Gardner family has not commented on Miller's death since publishing an obituary for the teen on March 31. 'The void Miller's passing leaves in the hearts of his family, friends, teammates, teachers, coaches and others will be felt for years,' the family wrote. 'Miller's time here with [his friends and family] was brief, but his spirit will carry on forever through those who were impacted by the way he lived. Miller was so blessed with experiences and friendships in his 14 years, and would want other children to have the opportunity to create their own wonderful memories.' 3 Yankees' Brett Gardner during a 2021 game against the Blue Jays. for the NY POST Brett Gardner, 41, played the final of his 14 MLB seasons with the Yankees in 2021. He won the 2009 World Series with the team, collecting an All-Star appearance and a Gold Glove throughout his career, all spent in The Bronx.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Armed man who attacked officers outside police station jailed for life
A man armed with Molotov cocktails and a hatchet who attacked officers outside a South Wales police station has been jailed for life and ordered to serve a minimum of 22 years in prison. Alexander Dighton, 28, knocked one officer unconscious and stabbed another in the leg when he launched an attack on Talbot Green Police Station in Rhondda Cynon Taf on January 31. In a police interview after the attack, Dighton, of Pontyclun, said he did not consider the scope of damage, 'merely that blood had to be spilt'. He previously admitted 10 charges relating to the incident, including attempting to murder Detective Constable Jack Cotton and attempting to cause grievous bodily harm with intent to Sergeant Richard Coleman. Dighton also admitted assaulting Pc Joshua Emlyn and threatening Pc Stephanie Fleming with an adapted wooden pole. Judge Mark Lucraft KC sentenced Dighton, who had been referred to the anti-terrorism programme Prevent in January 2024, to life imprisonment and ordered him to serve a minimum of 22 years. The judge told the defendant, who represented himself in court, that the offences had 'a terrorist connection'. He said: 'It is clear that you continue to hold entrenched views. 'Other than the early guilty pleas, there is little else to be said to your credit.' The judge said the police officers that encountered Dighton were experienced. He added: 'Whilst they accept potential violence and difficult confrontations are part of the role of being a police officer, they were all deeply shocked by the nature and ferocity of your attack.' Prosecuting, Nicholas Hearn described how Dighton's sister had reported him to Prevent due to concerns he held 'racist and anti-Muslim views' and was likely to be involved with incel groups. The incel movement is made up of people who find themselves unsuccessful in relationships, often harbouring extreme and misogynistic views. On the night of the attack, Dighton arrived at the police station shortly before 7pm, where he lit a petrol bomb and threw it at a police van. When that failed to ignite, he attempted to start a fire by pouring lighter fluid over the van before smashing the windows of two vehicles using a pole. When confronted by officers, Dighton said 'I'm fed up, I'm done', before launching his attack. Attempts to restrain him using a Taser were unsuccessful because of the body armour he was wearing. He swung a pole at one officer, punched one in the head and stabbed another in the thigh, narrowly missing his femoral artery. Two of the three injured officers were taken to hospital for treatment. Speaking after the case, Frank Ferguson of the Crown Prosecution Service said Dighton wanted to attack the Government and the state. 'We were able to show that Dighton's attack was not only pre-meditated and meticulously planned, but that his motivations were connected to terrorism,' he said. 'While it is not a criminal offence to hold extreme or offensive views, it is one to carry out attempted murder and attack police officers because of them.' Chief Superintendent Stephen Jones, of South Wales Police, paid tribute to the 'bravery and professionalism' of the officers at the scene. 'Each officer is not just a public servant but also a husband, wife, or parent, and their families are undoubtedly deeply affected by incidents such as these that officers face daily,' he said. 'I want to also recognise the detectives' unwavering commitment throughout the investigation which is also commendable.'
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
Video of Antonio Brown's altercation resurfaces after attempted murder charge
Several videos from the night during which ex-NFL wide receiver Antonio Brown allegedly fired a gun in Miami following a boxing match and brawled with several individuals, leading to an arrest warrant being issued for attempted murder with a firearm, have started to circulate again on social media. Brown, 36, claimed at the time he had been jumped in an attempt to steal his jewelry following a Brand Risk boxing event hosted by streamer Adin Ross. Two videos posted in a compilation by NFL aggregator on X @NFL_DovKleiman showed the former Steelers star brawling with several individuals outside a building, with Brown falling to the ground during the ruckus. He kicked a man after rising from the ground before another man attempted to calm him down. 9 A shot of Brown during the wildness. MEGA 9 Antonio Brown appearing to run. MEGA Warning: Unsettling videos Brown ran behind several cars during the skirmish. A third video in the compilation displayed a large group of people standing around in the aftermath before several people attempted to run away after what appeared to be gunshots ringing out. 9 Brown brawling with several men. @NFL_DovKleiman/X The person filming the clip stated, 'Shots is crazy,' while another compilation of videos posted May 17 at 6:30 a.m. ET from X user @ONLYinDADE showcased a longer video of the reaction to the alleged gunshots in which the person behind the camera said: 'Shots were fired.' That video collection also featured a shirtless Brown being escorted by an officer with his hands behind his back — seemingly wearing handcuffs — toward a cop car. 9 An arrest warrant has been issued for Brown. MEGA A third clip from that video featured Ross talking to Brown after the incidents, with Brown stating 'nothing happened' when asked about what transpired and claimed that he 'blacked out.' Brown clarified on May 17 that he had not been arrested, and TMZ reported he was let free 20 minutes later. 9 Brown before kicking a man during the ruckus. @NFL_DovKleiman/X 'I was jumped by multiple individuals who tried to steal my jewelry and cause physical harm to me. Contrary to some video circulating, Police temporarily detained me until they received my side of the story and then released me,' Brown wrote on X. 'I WENT HOME THAT NIGHT AND WAS NOT ARRESTED. I will be talking to my legal council and attorneys on pressing charges on the individuals that jumped me. I will keep you all posted step-by-step on the process. Thank you for the support and love.' 9 Brown running during the incident. MEGA The City of Miami police department said in a May 17 release that it received a ShotSpotter Alert around 3 a.m. on May 17, but no arrests had been made, nor had anyone been injured. The arrest warrant states an off-duty officer told the police he heard gunshots and saw Brown in a melee with another man, according to The Washington Post. 9 The arrest warrant reportedly lists a $100,00 bond. MEGA Those in the parking lot informed police that Brown had fired the shots, but the warrant also notes that Brown did not have a weapon on him when officers searched him. The warrant states investigators discovered two spent shell casings plus an empty gun holster, per the report. Officers later received videos allegedly showing Brown taking a gun from a security officer and running toward the man he had hit, according to The Washington Post. Cell phone video 'captures' two gunshots as Brown moved toward the man, per the report. 9 Brown during his time with the Buccaneers in 2022. AP The man told police on May 21 that Brown 'began to run toward him with a firearm' and shot him twice, potentially hitting him in his neck area. Brown and the man — who said he's known the former NFLer since 2022 — reportedly fought for control of the gun before Brown exited, and the man went to Aventura Hospital. 9 Brown after the incidents in question. @ONLYinDADE/X The arrest warrant reportedly lists a $10,000 bond and for Brown to remain under house arrest pending a trial. Brown did not respond to The Post's attempt to reach him Thursday night via the email listed on his social media account. The mercurial receiver starred in the NFL from 2010-21, mostly playing for the Steelers before appearing in one game for the Patriots and finishing his career by playing two seasons for the Buccaneers. He has since become a controversial figure for his X posts.
