Man convicted after burning Koran in public
Hamit Coskun shouted 'f--- Islam' and 'Islam is religion of terrorism' while holding the religious text above his head during a protest on Feb 13.
The 50-year-old, who was violently attacked by a passerby during the demonstration in London, went on trial last week, accused of an offence under the Public Order Act.
At Westminster magistrates' court on Monday, he was found guilty of a religiously aggravated public order offence of using disorderly conduct, which was motivated 'in part by hostility towards members of a religious group, namely followers of Islam'.
Robert Jenrick, shadow justice secretary, said: 'This decision is wrong. It revives a blasphemy law that parliament repealed.
'Free speech is under threat. I have no confidence in Two-Tier Keir to defend the rights of the public to criticise all religions.'
Blasphemy laws were abolished in the UK 17 years ago.
The CPS said that Coskun was not being prosecuted for burning the book.
They argued it was the combination of his derogatory remarks about Islam and the fact that it was done in public that made it an offence.
The CPS originally charged Coskun, who is an atheist, with harassing the 'religious institution of Islam'.
However, the charge was later amended after free speech campaigners took up his cause and argued he was essentially being accused of blasphemy.
District Judge John McGarva said, 'there was a real problem with the original charge, which referred to Islam as if it was a person, when it is not'.
He said, however, that the current prosecution was not 'an attempt to bring back and expand blasphemy law.'
He said: 'A decision needs to be made as to whether your conduct was simply you exercising your right to protest and freedom of speech or whether your behaviour crossed a line into criminal conduct.'
Katy Thorne KC, Coskun's barrister, had argued that even the amended charges against him effectively criminalised any public burning of a religious book and were tantamount to blasphemy laws.
'It is effectively chilling the right of citizens to criticise religion,' she said.
She said Coskun's actions were not motivated by hostility towards the followers of Islam but to the religion itself.
Judge McGarva, however, said he did not accept that argument.
Addressing Coskun, he said: 'You believe Islam is an ideology which encourages its followers to violent paedophilia and a disregard for the rights of non-believers.
'You don't distinguish between the two. I find you have a deep-seated hatred of Islam and its followers. That is based on your experiences in Turkey and the experiences of your family.'
Giving his verdict, Judge McGarva said: 'Your actions in burning the Koran where you did were highly provocative, and your actions were accompanied by bad language in some cases directed toward the religion and were motivated at least in part by hatred of followers of the religion.'
The judge ordered Coskun, who is currently claiming asylum, to pay a fine of £240.
The court heard Coskun, who is now in hiding, had to flee his home country of Turkey two and a half years ago to escape persecution.
He argued he was protesting against the 'Islamist government' of Turkish president Recep Tayyip Erdogan.
Giving evidence, Coskun made a number of comments about Islam, including claiming the majority of paedophiles are Muslim.
Lawyers for the CPS insisted that Coskun was not being prosecuted for setting fire to the Koran.
Philip McGhee, for the CPS, said: 'He is being prosecuted for his disorderly behaviour in public.'
He added: 'Nothing about the prosecution of this defendant for his words and actions has any impact on the ability of anyone to make any trenchant criticism of a religion.
On Feb 13, Coskun, who is of Armenian-Kurdish descent, travelled from his home in the Midlands to the Turkish consulate in Knightsbridge.
He then set fire to the holy book and held it above his head, shouting, 'Islam is religion of terrorism'and 'f--- Islam'.
As he did so, a passerby attacked him and appeared to slash at Coskun with a blade and then began kicking him when he fell to the ground.
Although the man has admitted assaulting Coskun, he has denied using a knife in the attack.
The man, whose identity is subject to reporting restrictions, will go on trial in 2027.
The National Secular Society (NSS), which, alongside the Free Speech Union, paid for Coskun's legal fees, said the verdict 'jeopardises' free expression.
A spokesperson for the FSU said: 'This is deeply disappointing. Everyone should be able to exercise their rights to protest peacefully and to freedom of expression, regardless of how offensive or upsetting it may be to some people.
'The Free Speech Union and the National Secular Society intend to appeal this verdict and keep on appealing it until it's overturned. If that means taking it all the way to the European Court of Human Rights, we will do so.'
'Religious tolerance is an important British value, but it doesn't require non-believers to respect the blasphemy codes of believers. On the contrary, it requires people of faith to tolerate those who criticise and protest against their religion, just as their values and beliefs are tolerated.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
30 minutes ago
- Chicago Tribune
Paul Wargaski: My son still doesn't have a way to get to school in Chicago
It's that time of year, when parents are buying backpacks, teachers are decorating classrooms and kids are heading back to school. But in Chicago, another tradition has become just as predictable: Chicago Public Schools can't get all of our kids to class. I received a message earlier this summer from our principal at one of the oldest dual language schools in the country that the CPS Hub Stop program will not be available when the school year starts in mid-August. The Hub Stop program is supposed to provide centralized pickup and drop-off locations for eligible general education students; however, it won't be available until December, when the school year is half over. This feels like a shrug from a system that's been shrugging for years. Let that sink in! This has been going on for several years, and CPS has not come up with sustainable options. Every year, families like mine are expected to scramble — taking off work, coordinating carpools and burning through gas, time and patience — to patch together a system that CPS should have had in place months ago. Last year, 20% of students with disabilities requiring transportation were not routed by the first day of school. This is not a small inconvenience. For some students, especially those who have disabilities or housing instability or those furthest from opportunity, this is a crisis. Even interim CPS CEO Macquline King has described the situation as a 'transportation crisis.' These are the same students CPS should be prioritizing. When push comes to shove, those priorities evaporate. The current transportation model is broken, and until we embrace alternative options to supplement traditional school bus routes, thousands of local kids will continue to be at a disadvantage. That's why legislation such as HB 989 matters. In short, the proposal increases the pool of safe, qualified drivers and routes. It also gives parents and caregivers the options to track rides in real time. The bill would allow participating school districts to contract with vetted, third-party transportation providers — giving them flexibility to serve high-need students who too often fall through the cracks. The program would focus specifically on students experiencing homelessness, students with disabilities, foster youths who face frequent placement changes and students who live outside traditional bus routes. In other words, it's a smart, measured step that gives school leaders one more tool to meet the urgent needs of their most vulnerable students. Illinois families are already stretched. Our schools are navigating staffing shortages, budget constraints and post-pandemic challenges. Adding unreliable transportation to that list only deepens inequities — and for many students, makes school access nearly impossible. We know many families where the lack of transportation has been a significant factor in moves out of the district and the state. Adopting HB 989 helps families stay in their schools and in Illinois. Let's think outside the bus to engage families and get kids to school. Illinois ranks among the top states for transportation-related chronic absenteeism, and it's low-income, Black, Latino, disabled and homeless students who are hit the hardest. We need a solution that would help turn that around — not by overhauling the system but by offering a safety valve when the traditional system falls short. The data from other parts of the country is clear. In Riverside County, California, home to nearly 2.5 million residents, the use of flexible transportation options helped boost attendance for foster youth from just 29% to nearly 80%. Nationwide, chronic absenteeism surged during the pandemic, rising from 17% in 2018-19 to 31% in 2021-22 — leaving nearly 15 million students chronically absent. This isn't about privatizing school transportation or replacing buses. This is about acknowledging that the world has changed. The rigid systems designed decades ago can't keep up with today's challenges. Driver shortages are a national issue. Routing delays and late starts have become normalized. Meanwhile, students are missing instructional time, special needs services and federally guaranteed accommodations. The question shouldn't be: Can we afford to provide options? It should be: Can we afford not to? Because here's what I know: When my son misses school, he falls behind. When parents miss work to get them there, families fall behind. When leaders fail to act — even when solutions are on the table — we all fall behind. As a parent, I can handle a lot — homework battles, early mornings, challenges that arise during the school day. What my fellow parents shouldn't have to handle is a system that tells their children that 'you're on your own.' We need to stop treating school transportation like an afterthought and start treating it like the educational lifeline that it is. No matter the school, no matter how caring the teachers are and no matter how dedicated a student may be, none of it matters if the kids can't get through the door. Let's fix this. Let's give our schools the tools they need. Let's give families the peace of mind they deserve. And most of all, let's give our kids a fighting chance to show up. Because showing up should be the minimum we guarantee.
UPI
9 hours ago
- UPI
Wife of slain NYPD officer Didarul Islam gives birth to son
Mourners attend the funeral services for NYPD officer Didarul Islam at Parkchester Jame Masjid on July 31, in New York City, after Islam and three other people were shot and killed at the 345 Park Avenue office building in Midtown Manhattan. On Monday, the NYPD announced Islam's wife had given birth to the couple's third son. Photo by Derek French/UPI | License Photo Aug. 18 (UPI) -- The wife of slain NYPD officer Didarul Islam, who was among four people killed in a mass shooting last month, has given birth to the couple's third son. New York Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch announced baby Arham's arrival Monday. Tisch said New York City Mayor Eric Adams joined Islam's widow, Jamila Akhter, at Mount Sinai Hospital on Sunday night after she went into labor. "Out of tragedy, a new life has entered this world," Tisch said. "Arham joins his two big brothers, Ahyan and Azhaan. "Together, they will carry forward their father's legacy of service and courage -- a legacy the NYPD will guard and uphold with the same devotion Didar gave to this city. Jamila, Ahyan, Azhaan, and now, Arham will forever be part of the NYPD family." Out of tragedy, a new life has entered this world. Last night, Jamila Islam, the wife of Detective First Grade Didarul Islam, gave birth to their beautiful son, Arham. Arham joins his two big brothers, Ahyan and Azhaan. Together, they will carry forward their father's legacy of... Jessica S. Tisch (@NYPDPC) August 18, 2025 NYPD officer Didarul Islam was killed July 28, while working security inside the New York City skyscraper, which houses the corporate offices of the National Football League and Blackstone. Islam was the first to be struck inside the lobby, where the suspect shot several other people before heading to the elevator. On the 33rd floor, the suspect shot another person and then himself. Islam, 36, was a three-and-a-half-year veteran of the department and an immigrant from Bangladesh. During his funeral at a Bronx mosque three days later, New York's police commissioner promoted Islam to detective, as thousands of officers and mourners lined the streets. Since the deadly shooting, two online fundraisers on behalf of Islam's family have raised nearly $500,000 to help care for Islam's wife and three sons. A GoFundMe has raised nearly $80,000, while another fundraiser by several law enforcement and NYPD organizations has received more than $416,000. "I know how special Arham's birth is for this family that is still dealing with heartbreak after losing their hero," Adams said in a post on X. "Rest in peace, Det. Islam. Your legacy lives on in your beautiful family."
NBC News
11 hours ago
- NBC News
Wife of slain NYPD Officer Didarul Islam gives birth to their third son
The wife of slain New York Police Officer Didarul Islam, one of five people fatally shot at a midtown Manhattan high-rise last month, has given birth to a son, police announced Monday. Arham became the third child of Didarul and Jamila Islam, and they're all boys, New York Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch said in a statement Monday afternoon. "Out of tragedy, a new life has entered this world," she said. "Arham joins his two big brothers, Ahyan and Azhaan. Together, they will carry forward their father's legacy of service and courage." Mayor Eric Adams said he was with members of Islam's family at the hospital when Jamila was in labor Sunday. "I know how special Arham's birth is for this family that is still dealing with heartbreak after losing their hero," he said on X."Our entire city stands with them and is here to support them." Islam, 36, was working in the lobby of the 44-story building on Park Avenue in New York City on July 28 when, police say, 27-year-old Shane Tamura of Las Vegas walked in and immediately opened fire using a semiautomatic rifle. Tisch said afterward that Islam was working in the lobby of the building with the department's permission under a program that allows officers to provide security off-duty but in uniform. On Monday she noted his formal title: Detective First Grade Didarul Islam. Adams said on MSNBC last month that Islam was the first Bangladesh-born NYPD officer to be killed in the line of duty. After the attack Adams said that those who knew the officer said he 'believed in living out the life of a godly person.' Tamura also shot a security guard and two civilians in the building before fatally shooting himself, authorities said. Adams said Tamura, who completed a cross-country drive just prior to the attack, was trying to target the headquarters of the NFL, which has offices in the Park Avenue building, but entered the wrong set of elevator banks and never made it to the league's offices. Two officials familiar with the matter told NBC News that the shooter, who played football in high school in Southern California, left a note at the scene that said he wanted his brain studied for chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or CTE. The neurodegenerative disorder associated with head injuries can cause changes in behavior and cognition and has been diagnosed in hundreds of NFL players after their deaths. Tamura, who never made it to the NFL, had a "documented mental health history," Las Vegas police said. Muhammad Mainul Islam, who identified himself as Didarul Islam's cousin, told NBC New York the officer was dedicated to providing for his family and raising his children. 'When he had time, and especially his off days, he went to the mosque with his two kids,' he said. Islam was assigned to the 47th Precinct in the Bronx. Patrick Hendry, president of the Police Benevolent Association, said after the attack: 'He went out every single day to provide for his family, whether it was overtime or whatever he had to do." Tisch said in her statement Monday that the newborn, his mother and his brothers are part of the NYPD fabric.
