logo
Vision Capital Corporation Comments on Speculated Amendments to Ireland's Housing Regulation

Vision Capital Corporation Comments on Speculated Amendments to Ireland's Housing Regulation

National Post2 days ago

Article content
A two-tier system would be folly, and would exacerbate Ireland's housing crisis, not solve it
Article content
TORONTO — We are very concerned about the prospect that recent press reports regarding amendments to rental housing regulations in Ireland would, if implemented, further exacerbate the nation's current policy-induced housing crisis.
Article content
Article content
Rent control regulations on housing have been a dismal failure for decades globally, and can be observed more recently in Ireland, primarily as they significantly harm those that they are intended and purported to help.
Article content
If affordable housing is a social and strategic goal for a community and society, then policies that effectively achieve this aim should be promoted, not politically popular yet severely detrimental rent control regulations. To this point, policy should target broader social and economic and considerations: for example, if a society determines it is an appropriate social goal to support lower-income individuals and families with housing subsidies, policies that fund these subsidies would achieve a vastly superior outcome compared to governments interfering in the housing market that, without restrictive rent controls can and will respond to supply and demand forces to increase housing supply.
Article content
Programs that have successfully increased affordable housing globally include affordable housing development programs, market incentives, integral affordable housing components in new developments, and a variety of innovative and low-cost financing options.
Article content
In contrast, restrictive rent controls regulations stifle new supply. One cannot solve a demand problem by restricting supply. Doing so does not solve the problem – it exacerbates it.
Article content
Moreover, rent control regulations create a disincentive to invest capital in maintaining the physical property, resulting in deteriorating housing stock and poor living conditions for residents. To alleviate this significant problem, any new regulations should also include provisions that allow landlords who make bona fide capital improvements to properties, in addition to regular operating maintenance expenses, to apply for what is known in other rent-regulated markets as 'above-guideline increases' or 'AGIs'. AGIs recognize that to facilitate these investments, landlords need to receive a return on their capital invested, in addition to the allowed annual rent increases. Such policies have worked effectively to slow the deterioration of the housing stock. These regulations need to provide more flexibility than the Substantial Change Exemption provision in existing regulations, which generally restrict funding qualification to only the most transformative property changes.
Article content
The recent report that the government is considering a two-tier system, which differentiates the existing housing stock by maintaining a 2% rent increase cap on existing apartments, while allowing a 4% cap on new developments, is not sustainable and would be folly for at least four reasons:
Article content
The 2% rent cap is an uneconomic proposition for apartment owners and results in the previously noted underfunding of capital expenditures and a deteriorating quality of housing stock and living conditions.
It is essential to appreciate that the vast majority of the affordable rental apartments in Ireland are owned by individual landlords and small businesses. With annual inflationary pressures on their costs and operating expenses, as well as regular capital expenditures increasingly straining their budgets, these owners have been increasingly selling their flats. This market reality further reduces the supply of affordable rental units, and a failure to address these trends will further exacerbate the current housing crisis.
As a two-tier system is unsustainable, stakeholders will not trust the stability of the regulatory framework, which, in turn, will create market uncertainty. Market uncertainty impinges on and restricts investment decisions.
Therefore, these policies and the accompanying market uncertainty will not effectively increase the urgently needed new supply, once again, highlighting the stark contrast to the stated major policy objective.
Article content
Politicians and all stakeholders should be confident, if not inspired, that alleviating restrictive and punitive rent regulations can, and does, work. Dallas/Fort Worth, Texas, in the United States and Calgary, Alberta, in Canada, are two of the highest population growth regions in North America. Neither of these markets has rent controls. Not only have there been record amounts of new apartments constructed in these cities, but the average monthly rents in these markets are among some of the most affordable relative to other urban centres in the United States and Canada, respectively.
Article content
We urge all major political parties in Ireland to align together in a non-partisan effort to acknowledge that the facts starkly contrast with the politics and take action to do what is right to enable affordable housing solutions. There is too much at stake at this critical juncture to pretend otherwise. At a minimum, any new regulations must not create a 'two-tier' difference between the existing stock and new developments and should allow for above guideline increases where landlords make bona fide capital improvements.
Article content
Vision Capital Corporation ('Vision') is the manager of the Vision Opportunity Funds, investment funds that invest exclusively in publicly traded real estate securities. Vision's senior portfolio management team brings over 100 years of collective experience in all facets of property markets and have researched and served as advisors and industry experts on policy considerations impacting the industry for over 40 years.
Article content
Article content
Article content
Article content
Article content
Article content

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

3 Warning Signs That It's Time to Sell Cardano
3 Warning Signs That It's Time to Sell Cardano

Globe and Mail

timean hour ago

  • Globe and Mail

3 Warning Signs That It's Time to Sell Cardano

Few investments age gracefully when the world around them speeds up. The same pressure applies in crypto. Builders, investors, and users do not wait politely for laggards to catch up; they migrate to speed, liquidity, and, most of all, excitement. That reality now confronts Cardano (CRYPTO: ADA), which was once celebrated for its emphasis on peer-reviewed research to advance its underlying technology, as well as for its deliberate pace of technical progress. Three red flags, in particular, suggest that the project risks permanent middle-of-the-pack status unless something changes quickly. Let's check out each of these warning signs in detail. 1. Rivals are racing ahead in every dimension In the crypto world, developers are the lifeblood of a blockchain. They build decentralized apps (dApps), protocols, and tools that generate utility, liquidity, and real-world adoption. A thriving developer ecosystem attracts users, capital, and other partners, creating a virtuous cycle that drives a chain's value and growth. Without them, even the most technically sound chain can remain a ghost town. In terms of developer activity in Cardano's ecosystem, it doesn't hold up very well against its chief competitors, Ethereum and Solana. Per Cryptometheus, a cryptocurrency data provider, Solana had 499 active developers, and Cardano had just 175 developers pushing updates for the week, down 33% from three months ago. Furthermore, developers flow toward concentrations of capital, and that capital is pooling elsewhere. Fidelity, a major asset manager, filed in March to list a Solana exchange-traded fund (ETF). Bloomberg now pegs the approval odds of that ETF at 90% for 2025, which would be an institutional seal of approval that no Cardano product enjoys. Meanwhile, Solana's total value locked (TVL) on its chain was nearly $12 billion in January and currently rests at around $8.6 billion. Cardano's TVL is just $331.6 million, down from $680.8 million in early December 2024. That means there's less real money parked on its chain. And when builders, money, and regulators all prefer the other options, it's a big problem. 2. New upgrades aren't getting used Blockchains tend to have technical constraints. Sometimes, those constraints are troublesome enough for users that the main engineers of the chain create big new modules or other solutions in an attempt to prevent the flight of disaffected investors, users, or ecosystem developers. The success or failure of those solutions is, thus, often a major factor in determining whether to invest in the chain's native token. And in Cardano's case, the record with successfully developing workarounds to the chain's issues isn't great, at least not in recent times. Cardano's Layer-2 (L2) system, Hydra, dazzled testers with a 1 million transactions-per-second (TPS) demo last December, implicitly promising to solve the issue of lethargic transaction times during periods of peak load. L2s like Hydra are designed to handle transactions off the main blockchain, reducing congestion and perhaps also fees while maintaining security and interoperability. But they only matter if users adopt them and volume grows. Otherwise, they're tech demos, not adoption drivers. Five months after launch, no major exchange, payment processor, or other project has committed to using Hydra beyond a pilot. Another solution, called Midnight, is a side chain, which means it's a parallel network intended for specialized features such as privacy, among others. Side chains can extend a blockchain's functionality by providing specialized services that don't burden the main chain. Midnight aims to attract institutional users who want confidential holding of assets on the chain, but so far, no major financial players have signed on, and no real user base exists. These technical marvels might eventually matter. But until developers, institutions, or users adopt them, they remain tantalizing but empty promises. And that's a big warning sign that Cardano is failing to match its development of capabilities to the features that are actually in demand. 3. Cardano's mindshare is eroding, not expanding Crypto is a popularity contest masquerading as a set of technologies. On June 4, Cardano counted around 23,273 daily active addresses, whereas Solana cleared nearly 5 million in the same day. That gap widens whenever meme coin mania or non-fungible token (NFT) drops spark traffic spikes. Those are segments where Cardano barely registers, as its ecosystem is very sparse in both areas. Social chatter mirrors the numbers. Per data from Santiment, a crypto data aggregator, Cardano ranks far below Ethereum and Solana in terms of social media post volume, hinting that investor excitement has simply remained elsewhere. If users, developers, and institutions are not talking about Cardano now, why would they flock to it later? In other words, Cardano's investment thesis -- that academic rigor in the tech development process will eventually lead to late-bloomer dominance -- faces mounting counter-evidence. Unless Hydra suddenly wins real traffic or Midnight lands marquee clients, the token's upside may remain capped while the opportunity cost mounts. And there's just not much evidence to suggest that's happening, nor is there any reason to believe it will soon. Should you invest $1,000 in Cardano right now? Before you buy stock in Cardano, consider this: The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy now… and Cardano wasn't one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years. Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $669,517!* Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $868,615!* Now, it's worth noting Stock Advisor 's total average return is792% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to171%for the S&P 500. Don't miss out on the latest top 10 list, available when you join Stock Advisor. See the 10 stocks » *Stock Advisor returns as of June 2, 2025

Tenants rally to stop ‘profit-motivated' eviction of East Vancouver senior
Tenants rally to stop ‘profit-motivated' eviction of East Vancouver senior

CTV News

time2 hours ago

  • CTV News

Tenants rally to stop ‘profit-motivated' eviction of East Vancouver senior

Residents of an East Vancouver apartment building gathered with supporters on Wednesday outside the downtown office of their landlord in an effort to get him to drop the planned eviction of a long-term tenant. (CTV News) Residents of an East Vancouver apartment building gathered with supporters on Wednesday outside the downtown office of their landlord in an effort to get him to drop the planned eviction of a long-term tenant. Terry McIntosh has lived at 1177 E. 14th Ave. for 27 years. The building's owner Andrzej Kowalski recently issued a notice to end McIntosh's tenancy so that a live-in caretaker can move into his unit. The Vancouver Tenants Union sees the eviction attempt as 'profit-motivated,' noting in a statement Wednesday that the building contains only seven units, and that Kowalski attempted to evict all of the tenants and convert the property into condos in 2023. 'The tenants all sent a letter to the landlord about a month ago, demanding that Terry's eviction was dropped,' said Sydney Ball of the VTU. 'They all see this as profit-motivated, and every suite signed on.' Ball said the tenants had not received a response to their letter. Wednesday's gathering – organized by residents and the VTU – was an attempt to deliver the letter to Kowalski in person. In addition to maintaining that a caretaker is unnecessary for such a small building, the tenants argue that the landlord has an incentive to evict McIntosh in order to avoid having to compensate him under the city's tenant relocation and protection policy for redevelopment happening due to the Broadway Plan. 'Last year, when we were battling this landlord with the evictions for the whole building, he always maintained that it was going to be under redevelopment, eventually,' Ball said. 'If that's still his plan, then it seems like (it's) definitely profit-motivated to kick Terry out of his home of 27 years.' CTV News made multiple attempts to contact Kowalski on Wednesday, but has not received a response. This story will be updated if one is received. Ball said the VTU has seen a sharp uptick in evictions for landlord's use – such as a family member or caretaker moving in – since the province cracked down on renovictions. 'That's now the most common way to get people out of their homes to jack up the rent, and it definitely always targets long-term tenants, who are often seniors just like Terry,' Ball said. Speaking at Wednesday's event, McIntosh himself highlighted this connection, saying his situation is 'one of many.' 'There are a lot of other tenants that are also under pressure,' he said. The VTU has been calling for the provincial government to remove the motivation for landlords to evict long-term tenants by tying rent controls to the unit, rather than the tenant. Such a policy, sometimes referred to as 'vacancy control,' would limit the amount by which a landlord could raise the asking rent between tenancies. Currently, B.C. law prohibits landlords from raising rents more than once a year and limits the percentage by which they can be raised. The landlord organization Landlord BC has told CTV News in the past that it opposes all rent controls, describing them as a 'blunt and ineffective' tool that discourages building maintenance and ultimately drives up housing costs by suppressing the construction of new supply.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store