Google age ID proposal may not suit Australia's under-16 social media ban, expert says
But while the proposed system will likely offer benefits for adults who have access to identification, it will probably be less useful for identifying teenagers without ID documents, raising questions about how helpful the technology would be for the ban.
It is seven months until the social media ban for children under 16 is due to come into effect, but how it will work is still being determined.
A trial of the technology that could be used for checking user ages on social media apps will be completed in June. The communications minister is also expected to decide which social media platforms it will apply to in the near future.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
Age Check Certification Scheme (ACCS), which is running the trial, did not publicise the progress of the trial during the course of the federal election campaign. However, this week the company released the minutes of a meeting held with stakeholders in March.
In the meeting, the Age Verification Providers Association executive director, Iain Corby, told the meeting that Google was 'considering' submitting a proposal to 'allow users to store an age credential in their Google Wallet and share it with apps and websites when needed'.
Separately, Google announced at the end of April that it would implement ID passes in Google Wallet in the UK – after already making it available in the US.
Under this system, users can take an issued ID such as a passport or licence, hold the information in the wallet, and share their date of birth with a website or app without sharing any other personal information.
In a website or app, it would offer a prompt similar to existing payment verification methods to allow users to share this information, and would use the existing authentication methods like passcode, fingerprint or facial recognition associated with phone-based payments.
Google also announced in February it was testing a 'machine learning-based age estimation model' to determine whether a user is under or over 18.
Google was approached for comment.
Apple announced similar technology in February, but the committee noted in its attempts to ask Apple about the technology, that the tech giant 'has been unresponsive, despite multiple outreach attempts'.
Dr Alexia Maddox, director of digital education at La Trobe University, said Google's proposal could be a 'fundamental misunderstanding' of the social media ban legislation. skip past newsletter promotion
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks Privacy Notice: Newsletters may contain info about charities, online ads, and content funded by outside parties. For more information see our Privacy Policy. We use Google reCaptcha to protect our website and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
after newsletter promotion
'The bill aims to protect children under 16, but Google Wallet is primarily an adult-oriented service that most children don't have access to,' she said. 'This creates a paradoxical situation where the very users the legislation aims to identify and protect – children – would be unlikely to have the verification tool being proposed.'
Maddox warned against 'retrofitting an existing commercial product rather than developing a purpose-built solution for child protection'.
'For age verification to be effective and compliant with the bill's privacy protections, we need approaches that work for all age groups, preserve privacy, destroy data after verification, and don't further concentrate data in the hands of major tech platforms.'
Before the social media ban legislation passed in December, Meta and TikTok pushed the government to make Apple and Google, as the device makers, bear responsibility for age assurance, but the federal government decided the onus should rest on the app makers.
As part of the trial, more than 1,000 students across five states will participate in testing of at least 25 different age verification or assurance methods, with priority placed on facial age estimation technology.
The trial will test some ways children may try to get around the verification, the meeting heard.
Following the re-election of the Albanese government, consultation will also continue on which platforms the ban should apply to. Guardian Australia revealed last month the chief executive of YouTube personally lobbied the communications minister, Michelle Rowland, less than 48 hours before she announced YouTube would be exempt from the ban.
The news sparked fury from YouTube's rivals, Meta and TikTok, over what was deemed to be a 'sweetheart' deal for the platform.
During the election campaign, the federal infrastructure department, which is overseeing the consultation, wrote to Meta stating 'while the former minister for communications proposed to exclude YouTube, no legislative rules have been made giving effect to this'.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
43 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
I run a supermarket and I've had to take drastic action because Aussies don't want to work and just want to sit on Centrelink
The head of a major supermarket chain said he has been forced to 'import' foreign workers to staff his stores because Aussies on Centrelink 'don't want to work'. The outspoken director of the family-run supermarket chain Drakes Supermarkets, John-Paul 'JP' Drake, opened up about the challenges plaguing the retail sector during a sweeping appearance on the 2 Worlds Collide podcast on Thursday. His father, Roger Drake, founded the independent supermarket chain in 1974, which has since grown to more than 60 stores across South Australia and Queensland. Mr Drake said the chain, which employs more than 6,000 people, has been forced to import workers from overseas despite efforts to attract local employees. He gave the example of Drake's distribution centre in Edinburgh North, Adelaide, where he claimed the unemployment rate was as high as 23 per cent. 'At my distribution centre... I've got a gym there, they get a full canteen with a free lunch, all this stuff and it's not enough to attract the locals to get a job, to work, to make a difference in the community,' he told podcast host Sam Bamford. 'You know why?' he said, adding: 'We pay enough out on Centrelink and benefits for the people that maybe don't deserve it and that is the problem.' Mr Drake said the issue, which affects the retail sector as a whole, had encouraged him to 'import' foreign workers who are more willing to work. 'I'm importing people from Vanuatu because I can't get workers to work at my site,' he said. 'They're unbelievable, their work ethic is amazing... Every single one of them, they act as a family, as a tribe together and they work as a team. 'English is not the best but, mate, they are smiling, they're happy.' While it is a commonly held belief that generous welfare entitlements disincentivise people from finding work, establishing a clear link has proven challenging for researchers. Research by non-partisan think tank e61 Institute, however, found that the $550-a-fortnight JobSeeker Coronavirus Supplement reduced job hunting by about 19 per cent. A 10 per cent increase in unemployment benefits would lead to a 2.1 per cent decline in job-finding rates, the research published earlier this year suggested. Mr Drake laid particular blame at the feet of the National Disability Insurance Scheme, which he said allowed people to 'make up anything to get anything'. 'I got in so much trouble when I mentioned this because there are people that need benefits, need handouts, I totally understand that,' he said. 'But when anyone can get $550 a fortnight... and you have a house load of people and you combine your money together... you don't need to f***ing work. 'And sell a few drugs and happy days.' Treasury forecasts spending on the NDIS, with annual costs projected to surpass $64billion in five years, will overtake spending on the aged pension within a decade. While not all agreed with Mr Drake's criticisms - including a prominent NDIS Facebook community which called for a boycott of his stores following the interview - concerns over the NDIS' growth are widespread. The scheme's ballooning price tag is expected to take centre stage at the federal government's economic roundtable's budget sustainability and tax reform session on Thursday. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese on Monday raised concerns with its growth, claiming its pool of recipients had outstretched its initial design. 'We need to make sure the system's sustainable,' he told Sky News. 'The NDIS was never envisaged that 40 per cent of the population would be on it. It's about giving people support who need it.'
Daily Mail
43 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Why 'perfect bag' with a genius hidden feature is selling out fast across Australia: 'It's the best thing I've ever purchased'
Daily Mail journalists select and curate the products that feature on our site. If you make a purchase via links on this page we will earn commission - learn more An Australian label that has experienced phenomenal growth for filling a gap in the market for affordable yet chic genuine leather accessories has seen its sales double overnight after updating its most popular bag. Vestirsi has brought back its sell-out Bella bag, elevating the design to a convertible 3-in-1 backpack, shoulder tote and crossbody bag. The Melbourne brand's cult bag has been a consistent bestseller since its launch, blending function and fashion. Handmade in Italy from high-quality pebbled leather, the style now comes in four colours and three sizes. Shoppers are 'obsessed' with the updated design of what was already hailed as the 'perfect bag'. 'Fits my laptop, Kindle, water bottle, daily touch-ups and AirPod max. The seamless and stylish transition from tote to backpack is like nothing I have ever seen,' a reviewer wrote of the design, which has attracted hundreds of five-star reviews. A mother-of-two said her Bella bag is a must-have for carrying everything her family needs: 'This is quite possibly the best thing I've bought in a while,' she wrote. 'The quality of the leather is really nice and I love that it has minimal branding. The size and functionality are perfect.' Bella Tan 3-in-1 Convertible Bag Handcrafted in Italy from supple pebbled leather, now with adjustable buckles for the perfect fit. Wear it as a tote, backpack, or crossbody. Available in Mini, Classic, and XL. One Bella for every woman, every moment. Shop Bella Black 3-in-1 Convertible Bag Introducing the Bella 3-in-1 Convertible Backpack Tote and Crossbody bag the next generation of our beloved bestseller, now thoughtfully redesigned for even greater versatility and ease. Shop Bella Milk Chocolate 3-in-1 Convertible Bag Timeless, practical and endlessly wearable, Bella 3-in-1 is a true everyday icon - now better than ever. Shop 'I'm a mom [sic] of two kiddos and while I don't need a diaper bag I'm still toting around wipes, snacks, and random small toys in my purse. I struggled with always having to switch bags and now I don't have to! 'I love carrying it as a tote when I'm out and about and switching effortlessly to a backpack when I need to. It looks clean and classic and suits my minimalist style perfectly, though it would go with anything. Vestirsi has a new loyal customer! 'I've truly not found a line of bags so perfect in style, quality and functionality before. I highly recommend.' Previously a 2-in-1 design, the Bella has been reimagined with discreetly adjustable straps to suit wearers of all heights, and increase its wearability as either a shoulder or crossbody tote, as well as a backpack. The mini is perfect for throwing in the essentials for a day out, while the classic and XL sizes make an ideal work or nappy bag. The mini can fit an 11 inch iPad, the classic size fits a 13 inch laptop and the XL a 16 inch. Each size comes in black, dark chocolate, milk chocolate and tan leather. A zip-top closure ensures valuables are secure, while a large zipped pocket plus two open pockets keeps everything organised. The timeless design features subtle gold hardware but is otherwise minimalist, fitting seamlessly into every wardrobe, for any occasion. Vestirsi was founded in 2019 by Monica Upton, who noticed a lack of stylish and quality handbags within her budget while working in luxury PR in Melbourne. Woven Bella Dark Chocolate 2-in-1 Convertible Backpack Tote Crafted from the finest Italian-washed leather, Bella boasts a sophisticated, intricate weave that exudes timeless style. Comfortable straps allow for effortless carrying, whether you prefer to drape it over your arm or wear it as a backpack for hands-free convenience. Shop Eden Brown Suede Shoulder Bag Your new go-to everyday shoulder bag. Crafted from Italian Suede, the Eden exudes a relaxed sophistication that elevates your everyday style. Its unstructured silhouette drapes effortlessly, creating a sense of casual luxury that's perfect for the modern woman on the go. Shop Scarlett 2.0 Milk Chocolate Leather Hobo Voted by VOGUE Australia as one of their favourite work bags, the Scarlett Leather Hobo Bag is a relaxed shoulder bag handmade from luxe pebbled leather, perfect to accompany you daily, whether that's to the office or for weekend wear. Shop Sloane Large Black Leather Top Handle Crossbody Handcrafted in Italy from supple pebbled leather, Sloane's clean lines and structured silhouette are complemented by our signature gold VESTIRSI turnlock and a removable crossbody strap. Whether worn as a shoulder bag, carried by the top handle, or styled as a clutch, Sloane transitions seamlessly from day to night. 'I needed to look the part, but I didn't want (nor could I afford) to spend $3000 to do it,' Upton says. With an Italian heritage, Upton knew high-quality leather didn't have to cost thousands, and so the idea for Vestirsi ('dressed up' in Italian) was born. 'I set off to my grandparents' hometown to find the best leather suppliers and the most skilled leather artisans, in the hope I could create this missing 'middle ground' handbag range myself.' ' Bella was one of the first bags I ever launched, and I poured so much thought into getting it just right,' Upton says. 'I wanted something that was elegant, functional, and affordable - a piece that didn't compromise. I had no idea it would take off the way it did.' The design has been a firm favourite for fashion editors and customers within the Vestirsi range - selling out repeatedly - and Upton says the latest design updates have made it more beloved than ever. ' Updating Bella to ensure it was adjustable and suitable for women of all heights, launching it in multiple sizes and transforming it to be a true 3-in-1 was all about listening to our community and giving them even more versatility - and the response has absolutely blown us away.' The Vestirsi handbag collection includes leather crossbody bags, clutches, totes, structured work bags, phone holders, and suede designs. The brand donates $1 from every sale to one of three Australian charity partners supporting women's mental health programs and initiatives. Customers can choose where the donation from their purchase is directed at checkout, selecting between Beyond Blue, Women's Community Shelters, or the Australian Childhood Foundation.
Daily Mail
43 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
One of Australia's oldest bowls club teeters on the brink of collapse after 122 years: 'Things are looking dire'
One of Australia's oldest bowls clubs has been placed into administration after 122 years, with locals fearing it could make way for housing. Olvera Advisers' Michael James Billingsley and Anthony Phillip Wright were appointed administrators of Warringah Bowling Club in Mosman, on Sydney 's lower north shore, on August 8. The move comes just months after venue manager Liarne Peek warned the historic club was on the brink of collapse. 'Warringah Bowls Club is hanging on by its fingernails,' she told Mosman Collective in April, urging the community to support the struggling institution. 'If the community could help us by coming in and buying a drink, it would help.' At the time, it was revealed the club had sold just 450 beers and 16 coffees over an entire week. 'Things are looking dire for the club - there is no other way to put it. We need a lifeline, and we need it now,' Ms Peek said. The club's books underline the extent of the crisis, with financial records showing an operating loss of $165,715 in 2023 and a further $45,677 deficit in 2024. Figures for 2025 have not yet been released. By comparison, neighbouring Neutral Bay Bowls Club reported a healthy $272,982 surplus in 2024, following a $443,010 profit the year before. In an attempt to turn things around, members voted in April to convert one of the club's bowling greens into six pickleball courts under a 12-year licensing deal with Mosman Pickleball. It was estimated the deal would bring in around $200,000 a year, assuming the pickleball players became club members and purchased food and drinks from the venue. The plan for a full overhaul, which would've included a resurfacing of the turf, appears to have been abandoned in the wake of the administration. A pickleball court has been erected on the site. Mosman Collective has urged residents to attend the venue in an effort to save it from going under. 'Warringah Bowling Club is more than a sporting club,' they said. 'It's one of the last remaining communal venues in Mosman - publicly accessible, family (and dog) friendly, heritage-rich and deeply embedded in our local fabric.' Focus is now shifting to the club's valuable landholding. The site covers more than 5,300sq metres, fuelling speculation that developers may swoop in if the property is put on the market. A rezoning and State Significant Development declaration could fast-track a residential project, transforming the site entirely. But rezoning remains a flashpoint on Sydney's lower north shore, with Mosman Council backing 89-year-old Judith Pearson in her legal fight against the NSW Government's housing reforms.
