Canada's voting system is constitutional, Ontario Court of Appeal rules
A panel of three Ontario Court of Appeal judges unanimously affirmed the constitutionality of Canada's first-past-the-post electoral system in a ruling released on Monday.
The system, laid out in the Canada Elections Act, sees the candidate who receives the most votes in a given riding or electoral district become the member of Parliament.
Fair Voting BC and the Springtide Collective for Democratic Society argued in court that the system violates the Charter of Rights and Freedoms' guarantee of effective representation.
The groups also said the system leads to the underrepresentation of women and other groups in Parliament, breaching the Charter's equality rights provision.
In a proportional representation system, the number of representatives a party elects reflects the percentage of the total vote the party receives.
In November 2023, the Ontario Superior Court dismissed the challenge from Fair Voting BC and Springtide. It said that while a proportional representation system would be a fair alternative to the current system, it's not required by the Constitution.
In its decision, the province's Court of Appeal also rejected the groups' key arguments.
"The electoral system is not in conflict with either the right to vote or the right to equality. It does not violate the Charter," Justice Grant Huscroft said in written reasons delivered on behalf of another judge on the panel.
"The appellants' arguments that the electoral system violates the Charter are, in essence, a repackaging of failed political arguments as constitutional rights violations."
Limitations of litigating policy disputes
The expert evidence "put forward in support" of those arguments, Huscroft wrote, is "replete with highly contestable policy arguments about which reasonable disagreement abounds, not only in the academic community but amongst the public at large…
"This evidence demonstrates the shortcomings of constitutional litigation in addressing public policy disagreements."
The short answer to the argument that the electoral system violates the Charter is that Canadian citizens are free to vote for anyone they choose, and for any reason they choose, Huscroft added.
"There is no constitutional requirement that their individual choices aggregate in a way that achieves some ideal of representational diversity," he wrote. "Neither the political party affiliation nor the personal characteristics of the candidates who win election are relevant to the constitutionality of the electoral system."
During the 2015 election campaign, then Liberal leader Justin Trudeau promised it would be the last federal election held under the first-past-the-post system.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
42 minutes ago
- CBC
Alleged illegal jet ski crossing into U.S. exposes 'holes' in border security: CBSA's union
While the search for a man who allegedly crossed the border illegally on a rented jet ski continues, some officials say the incident is exposing holes in Canada's border security. Sarnia police and its American counterparts are investigating after a Sea-Doo was recovered on the Michigan shore, after being rented by a Toronto man from a southwestern Ontario border city business. When the jet ski was not returned, a search was mounted and the jet ski found a few hours later. The man has still not been found. In a statement, Sarnia police said he remains outstanding in both Canada and the U.S. but " work is underway to apprehend him," and that the investigation is ongoing. Sarnia—Lambton— Bkejwanong MP Marilyn Gladu says more needs to be done to combat "porosity," at the border — noting that Sarnia does not have an RCMP office. "Really it's not ... patrolled formally," Gladu said. "You have the Coast Guard available if there's a concern expressed, but otherwise … we have to call London or Windsor to get any support from the RCMP. "We've had this concern for a while and both myself and [Sarnia mayor] Mayor Bradley have been calling on the government to address the porosity of the border here." In a Windsor stop on Tuesday, Ontario Premier Doug Ford said the border is short "thousands" of patrol officers and placed the blame on the previous federal government. In January, Ford's government launched Operation Deterrence, which saw hundreds of officers assigned to the borders. The province has also committed to buying the Windsor Police Service, among others, a helicopter for further surveillance. However, the premier added border patrol shouldn't be the responsibility of municipal or provincial police. Instead, he said it should rest with the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA). "We cannot have Windsor Police Service patrolling our borders, they have enough issues to take care of on the land," said Ford. Windsor harbourmaster says money, action needed to combat illegal border crossings 2 days ago While Gladu said she agrees with Ford, she also maintained any and all resources are needed. "All help that we can get is appreciated and more needs to be done." Border security has become a top issue since the re-election of U.S. President Donald Trump, who has made repeated comments about Canada's borders letting drugs and crime into his country — while also indicating a desire to annex Canada. In a bid to stave off tariffs in February, then-Prime Minister Justin Trudeau committed to moving forward with a previously approved $1.3 billion border plan on border security and appointing Kevin Brosseau as the country's new fentanyl czar. The current federal government has also introduced the Strong Borders Act, which expands the powers of intelligence and security agencies. "This is essential to maintaining the safety and security of our country … it is also a priority that we share with our neighbours," said Minister of Public Safety Gary Anandasangaree when the bill was unveiled. But the president of the union representing CBSA workers says while they've been promised resources, they haven't seen much yet. Mark Weber of the Customs and Immigration Union says he wasn't surprised to hear about the Sarnia jet ski incident. "It is very commonly known," he said. "I think the issue of who takes care of things between ports of entry is a kind of a big blind spot right now that's completely left to the RCMP." Weber says if CBSA agents witness someone crossing the border illegally, they have to call the RCMP, despite having the same legal authority. "It makes no sense at all that we're not part of doing that work," Weber said. "We're not saying, we want to replace the RCMP or do all of that work. "It's a big border. It takes a lot of people and a lot of manpower to get that work done, but we want to be part of that solution." Staffing is a major concern, he said, with ports of crossings racking up virtually "unlimited" amounts of overtime. Weber says CBSA officers should be encouraged to tackle the issue of illegal crossings. Ride along with the RCMP to see how they're patrolling the Canada-U.S. border in new ways 5 months ago RCMP officers in the Windsor, Ont. detachment are patrolling the Canada-U.S. border in ways they've never done before ever since Donald Trump pushed for an increase in security between the neighbouring countries. In a statement, the RCMP said patrolling the Detroit and St. Clair Rivers is a joint effort between their officers and "federal, provincial and municipal" law enforcement partners. In Windsor, the RCMP maintains a Shiprider unit that does cross-border law enforcement alongside the U.S. coast Guard, OPP, Windsor police and Walpole Island First Nations police. That unit, a spokesperson said, works on activities including the illegal drug trade, migrant smuggling, firearms trafficking and terrorism — while also relying on its American partners for enforcement on the water.
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Advocates calling on City of Regina to adopt encampment strategy
Advocates calling on City of Regina to adopt encampment strategy WATCH: A group of advocates are calling on the City of Regina to adopt an encampment strategy ahead of council at the end of the month.
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Confederation Centre campaign featuring John A. Macdonald's face drawing criticism
Social Sharing Some business owners in downtown Charlottetown are refusing to use promotional material featuring John A. Macdonald that's aimed at helping the Confederation Centre of the Arts raise money for renovations. Laura Noel owns The 5th Wave Espresso & Tea Bar, just blocks away from the cultural centre. At first she was happy to agree to help raise money for the centre, but when she opened a package of promotional coffee sleeves, she quickly had concerns. "The sleeve is pure orange with a white wording and there are two faces on the sleeve. One is John A. Macdonald," Noel said. Macdonald was Canada's first prime minister, who is credited with being one of the main Fathers of Confederation for his persuasive skills at the Charlottetown Conference in September 1864. He went on to play a key role in the implementation of the residential schools in the 19th century. More than 150,000 First Nations, Métis and Inuit children across the country were forced to attend church-run, government-funded residential schools between the 1870s and 1997. In the last few years, there have been many movements across the country to have Canadians acknowledge the harm that effort did to Indigenous communities and families. One is the Every Child Matters campaign, which is associated with the colour orange. "I just know orange and him do not go together," Noel said. "The colour orange is not problematic. John A. Macdonald's history to me is a history; you can call it problematic if you like. However, when you put the two together is when it becomes an issue. "Separately, this is all things we can have a discussion about, but together it's going to trigger people. It's going backwards in what we're trying to do in reconciliation." Noel has Indigenous family members and wouldn't want to put a sleeve featuring Macdonald's face on their coffee cups, she said. "It could definitely trigger someone who has had negative experiences with the residential schools, with politics, with the history of Canada." Noel notes that the City of Charlottetown removed the Macdonald statue that sat on Queen Street for years after it was vandalized multiple times. The P.E.I. Brewing Company also stopped using Macdonald branding on its honey wheat ale. Inviting others to have their say: CEO Responding to the concerns on Wednesday, Confederation Centre of the Arts CEO Steve Bellamy pointed out that the centre is Canada's national monument to the founding fathers of the country — and any such list has to include Macdonald. "Of course, we've been focused on the challenges in that in the last couple of decades, working on truth and reconciliation and acknowledging that while Canada is a wonderful country, it was not founded in the best way," he said. The goal of the campaign was meant to be part of truth and reconciliation efforts, by acknowledging that people such as Macdonald had already had their say about how the country should be organized, Bellamy said. "Now it's everyone else's turn. So we're trying to acknowledge the past and invite everyone to take part in building the country that we should be." We need to acknowledge the past... It's the truth part of truth and reconciliation. History can repeat itself if we don't acknowledge the past, Bellamy said, adding that some Indigenous leaders with whom he has spoken suggest that erasing history or taking down statues might not be the best way to move forward. "We need to acknowledge the past. We need to recognize who these significant important figures were in the past so we can move forward. It's the truth part of truth and reconciliation." Bellamy also pointed out that the colour orange has been used for promotional material for the cultural centre since it was opened in 1964. Despite that, he said he does understand why some Islanders could be concerned about this campaign, which he said would be short-lived. "If this was an oversight, we definitely apologize for this, and didn't intend to imply any connection whatsoever to the very important Orange Shirt Day — which we participate in — and the campaign around Every Child Matters," he said. "I can understand that people are seeing those two things paired together and making that connection… I do feel badly that people made that connection between the two. It was definitely not, of course, intended." As for Noel, she said she doesn't want to "cancel" the centre: "I think it was just a fumble that maybe got out of hand. Too many eyes have passed for it to not have been brought up."
