Trial continued for last of Goshen School Board candidates involved in mailer scheme

Yahoo

02-05-2025

GOSHEN — One candidate accused of fraudulent filing in the 2022 Goshen Community Schools election race may yet be going to trial for the charges.
Andrea M. Johnson's jury trial scheduled for May 12, was continued in Elkhart County Superior Court 3 on Wednesday. Of the five individuals charged in the election fraud scandal, Johnson is the only one to not plead guilty. Johnson is also the only one who has not previously held public office.
Sitting Goshen School Board members, at the time, Roger Nafziger, Jose Elizalde, Allan Kauffman and Mario Garber, along with candidate Johnson first faced election fraud charges from the Elkhart County Election Board due to improperly tracking funds after a mailer was released from their election campaigns back in October 2022.
During an Elkhart County Election Board hearing April 27, 2023, Kauffman, who also happened to be Elizalde's campaign chairman, said he was approached by retired school teacher Sue Neeb because of concerns she had about 2022 Primary Election school board candidates Rob Roeder, Ryan Glick and Linda Hartman. At the time, Kauffman would not offer the name of the former educator for the same reasons the educator wished to remain anonymous.
The teacher told Kauffman she was concerned about the future of local education should Purple for Parents-endorsed candidates Roeder, Glick, and Hartman gain elected office. At the time, Kauffman said the teacher wished to remain anonymous to prevent backlash to her husband's business. The teacher helped gather funds summing up to $11,770, which Kauffman distributed them between the four election candidates, whose campaign finance committees paid Maple Leaf Printing for the cost of the mailer.
The campaigns listed Kauffman as the donor on campaign finance forms, which the election board later discovered was technically untrue as they were gathered by Neeb. Per election law, any person who donates more than $100 toward a campaign should be listed on finance forms.
The Elkhart County Election Board found that Neeb had collected funds from a total of 32 individuals and, while she did keep some records, election law dictates that donors offer name, address, occupation, date, and dollar amount for all donations — and Neeb did not collect all of the necessary information.
Back in December 2022, during election board proceedings, Johnson said she was concerned from the beginning that she'd made a mistake in her first-ever campaign and went to the clerk on several occasions with questions.
'I actually filed my very first report late because I was in my car going over things and didn't realize it had to be in 'by noon,' so it was in at like 12:30 or something like that,' she said. 'I went back in and checked again and then I was told that there were no other forms until the end of the year when everything would be closed out. It's my fault that I did not look. I just had no idea that there was an amount that I would have to file before the end of the year and so I apologize.'
She added that when she learned about the CFA-11 form, she emailed it late at night before the election along with a letter explaining, in hopes that she wouldn't be in violation.
She also told the board that she didn't know the funds weren't Kauffman's. As a newbie to campaigning, she said she was just happy to be included but made it clear to the group that she didn't have the money to help fund the mailer with the others, and was told that Kauffman would cover it and she believed the funds came directly from him.
Election board members ultimately issued penalties to nearly 40 people involved in the election campaign finance fraud in April 2023, ranging from $150 to $250, following months of proceedings. Neeb was fined $2,000, while the candidates were referred to the prosecutor's office for formal proceedings.
Each of the accused faced a charge of filing a fraudulent report, a Level 6 felony, and accepting a contribution made in another's name, a Class B misdemeanor. Kauffman had the same charges but had five counts of the Class B misdemeanor instead of the one.
Nafziger, Elizalde and Garber, remain sitting school board members although all were sentenced within the last year, having pleaded guilty to Count 1 — filing a fraudulent report, a Level 6 felony. Their second counts of accepting a contribution made in another's name, a Class B misdemeanor were dismissed, and their felony charges were treated as misdemeanors per the plea agreements. The same plea deal was offered to all but Kauffman; The deal offered to the other members of the election fraud scandal was to plead guilty to the felony and be sentenced to 365 days at the Elkhart County Jail, suspended on reporting probation, with probation to be terminated after one weekend of a community-oriented work program.
Former Goshen mayor Allan Kauffman resigned from the school board in February 2024, citing health concerns. The health concerns were also a contributing factor to his sentence. Despite being categorized by the state as the ringleader of the controversy, Kauffman pleaded guilty in open court on Friday and was sentenced on all counts without a plea deal. He was sentenced on Count 1, filing a fraudulent report, a Level 6 felony, to one year at the Elkhart County Correctional Facility suspended on reporting probation; Counts 2 through 6, all reckless contribution to a campaign, a Class B misdemeanor, to 180 days at the Elkhart County Jail suspended on one year of reporting probation, all to be served concurrently.
On Wednesday, Johnson's attorney told the court that they're still in discovery, with new and additional information received, they're not yet ready to go to trial over the matter. Her attorney, Phillip Miller said the defense team is also considering taking deposition from Kauffman, but could not do so until his case was resolved. Last Friday, he was sentenced. The state said they are also still in the discovery process.
Elkhart County Circuit Court Judge Teresa Cataldo agreed to continue the jury trial. A status conference is scheduled for Aug. 13.
DANIEL STARCHER
A man accused of stealing a car out of Michigan pleaded guilty to a lesser charge in Elkhart Circuit Court on Wednesday.
Police attempted to perform a traffic stop at C.R. 17 and Beck Drive on the stolen blue Ford F-150 at 2:03 p.m. Feb. 26 that fled the scene.
While fleeing, the truck was struck after disregarding a lighted red signal at the intersection of C.R. 17 and Beck Drive.
The vehicle was determined to be stolen out of Three Rivers, Michigan, after the owner left the truck running at a gas station. Police claimed Daniel Starcher, who was also involved in the crash, had stolen it and brought it home to pick up his dog before the crash.
Starcher admitted to stealing the truck.
Starcher pleaded guilty on Wednesday to Count 2, resisting law enforcement, a Level 6 felony. For his plea, Count 1, auto theft, a Level 6 felony, will be dismissed.
Sentencing is scheduled for May 28.
CRISTIAN A. ANDRADE-PALACIOS
A man pleaded guilty to a drunk driving crash that resulted in multiple injuries during Wednesday's court proceedings in Elkhart County Circuit Court.
Elkhart County deputies responded to the call for a crash at 4:14 p.m. June 17, 2023, where a 2014 Mercedes Benz driven by Cristian A. Andrade-Palacios had struck a 2020 Jeep Wrangler.
Police say Lillian Coffman had been driving southeast on Ind. 119 east of C.R. 9 in the Jeep when Andrade-Palacios in the Mercedes entered oncoming traffic to pass a vehicle in front of him heading north and caused a head-on collision with Coffman's vehicle.
Witnesses said traffic was slowed due to a tractor on the road.
Coffman suffered several fractures to her hand and remained without proper use of her hand into at least January 2024, was unable to write or type properly, and that gripping the steering wheel was also difficult.
In addition, an infant in Andrade-Palacios' vehicle suffered a broken leg that required surgery.
After the crash, police conducted field sobriety tests on him and Andrade-Palacios' consented to a blood test showing a 0.214 blood alcohol content. Andrade-Palacios' said he'd had three or four beers prior to the drive that lead up to the crash.
Andrade-Palacios pleaded guilty to both counts of causing serious bodily injury while operating a vehicle while intoxicated, both Level 5 felonies. Sentence is scheduled for May 28.