Loans issued by Irish Nationwide in face of financial crash 'hard to justify'
Failed lender Irish Nationwide Building Society was operating akin to a merchant bank when taking "very strong lending positions on speculative proposals", a state-appointed director has told the High Court case against former bank chief Michael Fingleton Sr.
State appointed chartered accountant Rory O'Ferrall on Tuesday told the High Court that a series of multi-million euro loans were "very unusual" in the face of an economic crash and were "hard to justify" given Mr Fingleton pledged in 2007 to the society's board that the lender should be "risk averse" in the face of the financial climate.
Advertisement
The civil case against the former INBS chief executive and managing director alleges that he negligently mismanaged the building society and engaged in property "gambles" with high-net-worth individuals in an informal and speculative manner in the mid-2000s, leading to fatal losses.
Mr Fingleton (87), who cannot give evidence due to ill-health, joined the building lender in 1971 and retired in 2009 - he held the roles of both managing director and chief executive in that time. At its height in 2007, INBS had reported assets of €16 billion but was a high-profile casualty of the financial crisis of 2008.
Liquidators for Irish Banking Resolution Corporation (IBRC) have taken the case against Mr Fingleton, who denies the allegation of negligent mismanagement.
The total losses at INBS had been estimated to be €6 billion. However, only €290 million in damages is being pursued by IBRC, relating to five specific loans, allegedly approved by Mr Fingleton.
Advertisement
The court has been told that Mr Fingleton was allegedly 'nodding through' top-ups and extensions to certain clients without the knowledge of the society's board.
Today at the High Court, Mr O'Ferrall likened the lending of the society to that of a "merchant" bank which, he said, takes higher risks in lending but takes a share of the proposed profit from loans made on projects.
He said this criteria of operating requires a different set of skills and expertise in specific industries and areas of the globe in fields such as shipping, railways, property and development.
Mr O'Ferrall said Irish Nationwide under Mr Fingleton had taken up "very strong lending positions" in property development on speculative proposals in the UK and France.
Advertisement
Mr O'Ferrall said that at around the time of loans issued between 2006 and 2009, there was a "generally held view by investors and banking" by 2007 that there was going to be a property market downturn and that by 2008, "all banks" were experiencing the predicted difficulties.
Mr O'Ferrall told Lyndon MacCann SC, for IBRC's liquidators, that INBS no longer held a banking licence, was therefore not trading anymore and that its only activity was in resolving various claims, including some from abroad.
Gerry McGinn, a former chief executive who arrived after the departure of Mr Fingleton, referenced a loan for a luxury hotel project in a skiing area in the south of France, referred to as 'Ice Mountain', which the borrower had valued at €32.85M with planning permission.
However, the project had no planning permission and was then hit with a bill of €565K by French tax authorities. INBS paid the borrower, Cyril Dennis', tax bill when requested to "stay in the game" regarding the asset which was never developed.
Advertisement
When Nama bought the loan for Ice Mountain in 2010, it stood at around €31 million. Nama paid just under €11 million for the loan, resulting in a loss of €20 million for the tax-payer.
Mr McGinn said that when INBS received a valuation "about a hotel in a foreign country, and just getting a number on a page... it is pretty meaningless".
Mr McGinn said the interest of the society seemed to have been "secondary" to some of the relationships between Mr Fingleton and the borrower.
Mr McGinn said there were a number of different risks in lending into a foreign jurisdiction. He said that the society may have felt that it was a "gun to your head situation" in paying the French tax bill upon Mr Dennis' request in order to avoid being "badly exposed".
Advertisement
It may, he said, have been a question of the society being stuck "between the devil and the deep blue sea".
The case continues at the High Court.
In opening the case earlier this month, Mr MacCann said Mr Fingelton "gambled" with the society's money when he allegedly approved "speculative, risky" commercial loans, which sometimes had already been greenlit by him before they were taken before the board of directors or the credit committee.
The five loans allegedly approved by Mr Fingleton relate to property land development projects between 2006 and 2009 in the UK and France, despite them having no zoning or planning permission, counsel said.
It is further alleged that there were no securities in place on the loans and no personal guarantee sought for or provided by the borrowers.
Mr Fingleton was a prominent presence in Irish business during the Celtic Tiger and was reported to have been worth around €75 million in 2006. However, his son has told the courts that his father is reduced to €25,000 in two personal bank accounts and has outstanding judgment debts of more than €10.7 million.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
27 minutes ago
- The Independent
Zia Yusuf's return to Reform UK ‘great news', says deputy leader
Reform UK deputy leader Richard Tice has said it is 'great news' that Zia Yusuf is returning to the party just 48 hours after quitting as its chairman, adding he has 'done a brilliant job in growing the party'. Mr Yusuf said his decision to stand down had been the result of 'exhaustion' and working for 11 months 'without a day off'. Party leader Nigel Farage, speaking to the Sunday Times newspaper alongside Mr Yusuf, said the former chairman will now effectively be doing 'four jobs', though his title has not yet been decided. He will lead Reform's plans to cut public spending – the so-called 'UK Doge', based on the US Department of Government Efficiency which was led by tech billionaire Elon Musk. The ex-chairman will also take part in policymaking, fundraising and media appearances. Mr Yusuf said he was quitting Reform following the latest in a series of internal rows, in which he described a question to the Prime Minister concerning a ban on burkas from his party's newest MP as 'dumb'. On Sunday, it was put to Mr Tice that it does not look very professional for Reform's chairman to be in, out, then back in again. He told the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg programme: 'Zia Yusuf has done a brilliant job in growing the party, creating huge infrastructure, over 400 branches, but it's a massive job and as we were growing incredibly fast, essentially that job was too much for one person, so we're reorganising, and I'm delighted that Zia is staying with the party, and he's going to be focusing on our Doge unit. 'There is so much waste you've been talking about, how does the Government find more money? 'Well, the best thing is to stop wasting money. I'm afraid, what we're discovering as we look under the bonnet of the 10 councils that we are now in control of, is there's waste everywhere, and it's got to stop. 'That's what Zia is going to focus on, as well as fundraising. So it's great news he's with us.' Meanwhile, shadow home secretary Chris Philp called Reform UK a 'protest party' and said it is offering 'populist policies that are essentially Liz Truss on steroids'. Asked if it is time for the Conservatives to think about a more constructive approach to Reform, he told Sunday Morning With Trevor Phillips on Sky News: 'Nigel Farage is saying he wants to destroy the Conservative Party, which makes it quite difficult to work together. 'I mean, they're all essentially a protest party. 'You just asked about Liz Truss… they're offering populist policies that are essentially Liz Truss on steroids.' Announcing his resignation on Thursday afternoon, Mr Yusuf said: 'I no longer believe working to get a Reform government elected is a good use of my time, and hereby resign the office.' Mr Yusuf said he had been left feeling undervalued by some in the party and drained after being subjected to relentless racist abuse on X, and that he made the comments in 'error'. He added: 'I spoke to Nigel and said I don't mind saying I made an error. It was a function of exhaustion.' Asked about the row over talk of banning the burka, Mr Yusuf said he 'certainly did not resign because I have any strong views about the burka itself' but felt blindsided by Sarah Pochin's question to Sir Keir Starmer. He said: 'If there were a vote and I was in Parliament, I would probably vote to ban it actually,' but that 'philosophically I am always a bit uneasy about banning things which, for example, would be unconstitutional in the United States, which such a ban no doubt would be'.
Sky News
28 minutes ago
- Sky News
Buyout firms circle corporate intelligence firm G3
A corporate intelligence firm which employs Sir John Sawers, the former head of MI6, is closing in on a deal to sell a big stake to a buyout firm. Sky News has learnt that G3, which was founded in 2004 and advises clients on a range of risks affecting their businesses, has been in detailed talks in recent weeks with private equity suitors including Oakley Capital and KKR. Precise details of a transaction were unclear on Sunday, although one source suggested that a deal was likely in the coming days, and could value the business at between £200m and £250m. They said that Oakley Capital - founded by the entrepreneur Peter Dubens - had emerged as the most likely investor, although a deal had yet to be agreed. Bridgepoint, another London-based private equity firm, had also expressed an interest in G3, the source added. G3 already has some external investment, having struck a deal with All Seas Capital in 2022, according to the latter's website. The firm - which files accounts under the name G3 Good Governance Group - advises companies, private equity firms, sovereign wealth funds and pension funds on areas of commercial risk such as cybersecurity, reported a 27% rise in revenue in 2023. During that year, the latest for which accounts are available, it recorded earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation of nearly £9m. Sir John, who stepped down as the head of MI6 in 2014, was named chairman of G3's advisory board last year.
The Guardian
32 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Trump tariffs could ‘wipe out' European steel sector, senior industry figure says
Europe's steel industry faces being 'wiped out' in the face of Donald Trump's prohibitive 50% tariffs, high energy costs and a mountain of cheaper Chinese steel, one of Germany's biggest industrial groups has warned. Ilse Henne, a board member at the steel, engineering and chemicals group ThyssenKrupp, said the industry faced an existential crisis after the US president's decision last week to double tariffs on steel and aluminium imports from 25% to 50%. Asked at the European Policy Centre conference on security in Brussels if she 'feared a wipeout', she replied: 'Of course.' Henne, who is chief executive of ThyssenKrupp Materials Services, told the Guardian: 'Steel is at the beginning of the value chain, so you create a lot of instability for all these supply chains that get disrupted that now all of a sudden have to deal with much more expensive steel.' Steel and aluminium are foundational industries, central to everything from submarines, aircraft and cars to everyday products such as stainless steel cutlery, food mixers and joists in housing. 'If the European steel industry disappears, we will have a lot of collateral damage,' said Henne. 'A weak European steel industry is not only a weak European steel industry. It also puts all the other steps in the industry and the value chain in danger.' She said Europe must step in to save the sector because it was fundamental for military security and was a large employer, and if it failed, the continent would be left reliant on the US and China for a key manufacturing material. There is also the growing problem of cheap Chinese steel imports, something the European Commission has in its sights in current talks with Beijing over its dumping of goods in the EU, which are also covering the oversupply of cars and fast fashion. Chinese steel imports soared by 36% in the first quarter of 2025, according to Eurostat. According to Henne, Russian steel is still appearing on the market, at a level of 3m-4m tonnes a year, just short of the 3.8m tonnes the EU as a whole exports to the US. The US doubling of the tariff on steel and aluminum imports does not apply to the UK, which will continue to pay 25% until 9 July and is racing to implement the terms of a bilateral deal struck last month that would take the rate down to zero. Ministers are working to ensure the UK's biggest player in the sector, Tata Steel, is not excluded from the deal because it has begun importing semi-finished products from India and Europe since closing its blast furnace in south Wales last year. This could breach US rules that require all steel to be 'melted and poured' in the country from which it is imported. US representatives also have concerns that British Steel, which is owned by China's Jingye group, could be used as a 'back door' to bring in Chinese products. The UK government used emergency legislation to take control of the company's plant in Scunthorpe, and according to the Sunday Times, ministers now face a standoff with Jingye over a £1bn-plus compensation claim to get it to relinquish its interest. Sign up to Business Today Get set for the working day – we'll point you to all the business news and analysis you need every morning after newsletter promotion Henne said Trump's tariffs strategy could backfire and kill US heavy industries rather than deliver the revival he has promised. 'Following the 50% tariff increase, all US steel producers have immediately bumped up their prices. So the cost of manufacturing has gone up,' she said. The impact 'is a lesson that the US has to learn, unfortunately, I believe, the hard way,' she said. 'What they are doing is actually limiting their own growth potential.' In its second quarter outlook report issued last Thursday, Eurofer, the EU steel trade association, said the US tariffs had dealt 'a severe blow' to recovery expectations. It has called on the EU to bring in 'emergency' measures to help save the industry. 'There is a lot that we can do to save the steel industry,' said Henne, calling on the European Commission to do more to ensure hydrogen came on stream at a competitive price to reduce the reliance on oil- and gas-fuelled furnaces. 'Reducing the tariffs would be a good thing, but equally important for us is competitive energy pricing,' she said.
