Surgeon loses £14m snowmobile crash claim because of ‘s--- happens' text
Andrew Cannestra, 54, a neurosurgeon, suffered a brain haemorrhage and injured his leg when he crashed into a tree during a £23,000 holiday in Lapland with Pure McLaren Arctic Experience.
Mr Cannestra's snowmobile went off track after negotiating a forest turn, and he was knocked out for 30 minutes following the impact in February 2020.
He claimed his injuries left him unable to work to the same capacity. He launched a legal case against McLaren Automotive Events for the loss of his future earnings, which he claimed exceeded £14m.
Lawyers for McLaren Automotive denied blame, and insisted that on-the-spot guides did their utmost to ensure a safe trip, carefully briefing Mr Cannestra and Kaitlin Mealor, his then-partner.
Judge Andrew Ritchie dismissed the claim at London's High Court as he said that Mr Cannestra, an American from Florida, who was dubbed an 'adrenaline junkie' by Ms Mealor, had 'wanted more speed' and had caused the crash himself when he 'accidentally hit the gas instead of the brakes'.
The judge also pointed out that the surgeon had sent a post-accident text to McLaren staff, saying: 'No worries … s--- happens … I asked... if I owe you guys a snowmobile, or any other costs. Please let me know. It was my error and my responsibility.'
In another, he wrote: 'Thank you both so much for your help yesterday and thru my little self-destructive snowmobile behaviour. Please let me know anything I am responsible for.... transport.... a snowmobile..... etc. we had a great time and all is good!'
Mr Cannestra insisted his post-accident messages did not amount to an admission of fault.
Neil Block KC, for Mr Cannestra, had told London's High Court that both riders were 'absolute novices' and argued their guides should have done more to explain the detailed layout of their route through the forest.
The surgeon crashed after a pause in the journey during which his guide had changed the drive mode so that the doctor's snowmobile could hit higher speeds.
Lasting problems
The impact resulted in a brain haemorrhage and severe leg injuries, causing lasting problems with 'word-finding, comprehension, memory and fatigue' and worsening his previous hand tremor.
Mr Cannestra, who was earning around £1.8m per year, has had to give up brain surgery, although his lawyers say he 'continues to work to a limited extent.'
Dismissing his claim, the judge said: 'He was following a guide round a snowy track through trees, but he lost control, drove off the track and hit a tree. He was injured. At first, he thought it was all his own fault, apologised and offered to pay for the smashed-up snow mobile.
'At the ambulance in the car park, he told [the guide] that he accidentally pressed the throttle in the middle of turn two and blamed his glove.
'At hospital, he told a medic he accidentally hit the gas instead of the brakes. He considered that he himself was the cause of the accident. He did not blame [the guide] for rushing him or disappearing.
He said the guide was not dealing with a '17-year-old new car driver ' who had just passed their driving test, adding: 'He was guiding a mature, supercar and jet-ski aficionado, who had ridden confidently and wanted more speed.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.
Solve the daily Crossword
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Fox News
24 minutes ago
- Fox News
Attorney breaks down potential for Bryan Kohberger appeal
'America's Newsroom' panelists Mark Eiglarsh and Nicole Parker discuss the legal case against Bryan Kohberger, who has pleaded guilty to murdering four Idaho college students, and whether he could appeal his conviction.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Scottish airport fined £144,000 for failures that led to death of employee
The company that runs Glasgow Prestwick Airport has been fined more than £144,000 for failures that led to a member of airport staff falling to his death when a guardrail gave way. Joseph Dempsey, an experienced member of the airport's ground handling team, died in the incident on January 11 2023. The 59-year-old had been preparing to unload cargo from an aircraft using a pallet loader. He had positioned the loader alongside the aircraft and was repositioning a guardrail when it suddenly gave way and he fell to the tarmac some 10 feet (three metres) below. Mr Dempsey's colleagues immediately went to his assistance and paramedics attempted CPR and advanced life support. However, these efforts proved unsuccessful and Mr Dempsey was pronounced dead at the scene. An investigation by the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) found that one of the guardrail posts had completely fractured, and that there were visible signs of significant corrosion, discolouration and flaking white paint around the area. At Ayr Sheriff Court on June 25, Glasgow Prestwick Airport Ltd pled guilty to a breach of health and safety legislation, having failed to ensure the pallet loader was maintained and in good repair. At the same court on Thursday, the company was fined £144,050, including a victim surcharge of £10,050. Debbie Carroll leads on health and safety investigations for the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS). Speaking after the sentencing, she said: 'Joseph Dempsey lost his life in circumstances which could have been avoided if Prestwick Airport had in place a suitable and adequate maintenance and inspection programme to ensure the equipment he was using was in a good state of repair. 'This prosecution should remind duty holders that a failure to fulfil their obligations can have fatal consequences and they will be held accountable for this failure.' Metallurgical examination of the guardrail posts carried out during the investigation found differences in chemical composition, manufacturing, and wall thickness which indicated the posts were manufactured from two different tubing sections. The HSE found these welded sections were not a feature of the manufacture's original design, and appeared to have been modified while the loader was under the ownership of Prestwick Airport. The investigation also found the welds on both the guardrail posts contained defects which would allow moisture in, creating a corrosive environment and speeding up deterioration. It was also found that the maintenance programme in place at the time did not cover the parts of the guardrail where failure or deterioration could lead to health and safety risks. Graeme McMinn, HM principal inspector of health and safety, said: 'Employers have an absolute legal duty to ensure that equipment they use at work is maintained in an efficient state and in good repair and full working order. 'This incident is a tragic reminder of what can result when that does not happen.' Since the incident, Prestwick Airport has undertaken a review of all work at height, and checks of the guardrails on the platform loaders have been made part of the regular service and inspection schedule.
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Dad guilty of murdering premature baby in hospital
Warning: This article contains details that some may find distressing, including details of severe injuries. A father has been found guilty of murdering his two-week old baby on a neonatal ward. Brendon Staddon, who was born prematurely at 33 weeks, suffered multiple injuries including a fractured skull, a broken neck, a broken jaw and broken legs in Yeovil District Hospital's special care baby unit on 5 March 2024. His father Daniel Gunter, 27, of no fixed address, denied harming him, but was convicted of murder at Bristol Crown Court earlier. He will be sentenced on 3 October. Brendon's mother, Sophie Staddon, was acquitted of a lesser charge of causing or allowing the death of a child and was told by the judge she "was free to go". A female juror was visibly upset as the foreman returned the verdicts and as she wiped tears away, she was comforted by two fellow jury members. The defendants showed no emotion as the verdicts were returned. Following the verdict, Brendon's grandfather Simon Gunter said his grandson - who the court was told weighed "less than a couple of bags of sugar" - had been "so tiny, but so beautiful". "As a family, we were so happy and excited," he said, explaining that the family had bought toys and clothes in their excitement for his arrival. "But, we have been robbed of a life of memories of Brendon," he added. "We won't get to see his first steps, hear his first words, take him on his first holiday and see him grow into a young boy then a man. We will never have those memories. They have been taken from us and he will never be replaced. "I hope Daniel gets what he deserves for what he did to Brendon but, whatever the outcome, it will never bring him back." 'Evil' During his short life, nursing staff at the Somerset hospital said they had many concerns about Brendon's parents' behaviour, particularly Gunter's repeated rough handling of him, Bristol Crown Court was told. The jury was told that while in hospital, Gunter repeatedly ignored the advice of nurses, taking Brendon out of the incubator without asking, overstimulating the child to the point of causing him distress, and removing his nasal gastric tube. A medical expert told the trial that Brendon's injuries were consistent with his head being swung against a hard surface "more than once" while he was held by his ankles. Ch Insp Nadine Partridge, of the major crime investigations team at Avon and Somerset Police, said the case was one of the most challenging of her 22-year career as a detective and described Gunter's actions as "evil". She said having to view the post-mortem injuries had been very distressing for investigators. "The extent of the injuries are nothing I've ever seen before. Brendon's little tiny precious body at just two weeks old, there wasn't any part of him that wasn't harmed," she said. The jury heard Gunter was seen getting angry with Brendon while changing his nappy and threatened to make formal complaints about nursing staff when they tried to intervene. Nurses also feared Ms Staddon was being controlled by Gunter because he would speak for her and order her meals, jurors were told. Brendon was born on 20 February, but the couple left the hospital on 29 February and did not return until the afternoon of 4 March. At about 04:00 GMT the following morning, Ms Staddon told nurses she had awoken to find Brendon "cold". Doctors think he would have been dead for at least 30 minutes before the alarm was raised. While doctors tried to resuscitate him, Gunter said he and Ms Staddon were going outside "for air" and they both went to smoke, the court heard. 'No remorse' Neither Gunter or Ms Staddon gave evidence during the trial. Ch Insp Partridge said Gunter had been more concerned about his phone and vape being taken when he was arrested, and had never asked after Brendon. "Daniel's not shown any remorse whatsoever on his arrest or during his police interviews," she said. Following the verdict she added: "Brendon was failed in life. In death, justice is the only protection we can still offer him. "Cases where both the victim and the defendant are related in some way are among the most challenging for us as police. "I would like to firstly give my condolences to Brendon's grandparents and their wider family, who we have supported through specialist family liaison officers." Following the verdict a spokesperson for Somerset NHS Foundation Trust said it has been an "incredibly distressing" case in which its colleagues gave evidence about their interactions with Gunter and Ms Staddon. "We are part of the Child Safeguarding Practice Review, along with other agencies, that will thoroughly examine the circumstances around baby Brendon's death," they added. "It is well underway and will be published in the autumn." Follow BBC Somerset on Facebook and X. Send your story ideas to us on email or via WhatsApp on 0800 313 4630. Related internet links HM Courts & Tribunals Service