Soccer-Brazilian derby heartbreak leaves Botafogo's Club World Cup dream in tatters
Soccer Football - FIFA Club World Cup - Round of 16 - Palmeiras v Botafogo - Lincoln Financial Field, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, U.S. - June 28, 2025 Botafogo's Vitinho in action with Palmeiras' Estevao REUTERS/Susana Vera
PHILADELPHIA (Reuters) -Botafogo's Club World Cup run unravelled in the cruellest way as fierce domestic rivals Palmeiras ended their campaign with a 1-0 extra-time victory on Saturday that ended the momentum building around the famous Rio de Janeiro club.
Days after stunning European champions Paris St Germain, Botafogo's defensive shell cracked at precisely the wrong moment, leaving a team who had thrived as underdogs to taste bitter elimination at the hands of all-too-familiar foes.
A tense, compelling clash wrote another chapter in a captivating and intense rivalry that has gripped the South American nation in recent years.
Palmeiras overturned a three-goal deficit to beat Botafogo 4-3 in 2023 on the way to winning the title, and the Rio side responded by beating the Sao Paulo club twice en route to their Copa Libertadores and Brazilian league double the following year.
In Philadelphia on Saturday, Palmeiras fought back to end a five-match losing streak against their rivals and halted their remarkable journey through the tournament's Group of Death, in which Atletico Madrid were knocked out.
While Palmeiras surged forward with intent throughout, Botafogo's conservative approach backfired spectacularly. The team who had fearlessly taken down Champions League winners PSG suddenly looked bereft of ideas against opponents who know their every weakness.
"The idea was to play in a certain way at the beginning and then change to try to surprise Palmeiras," Botafogo coach Renato Paiva said, his voice heavy with disappointment. "The match ended up being decided by an individual play."
Paiva rued the chances they missed after Palmeiras, down to 10 men, sat back late in extra time, leaving their tournament journey to end in a whimper of domestic defeat.
For the thousands of Botafogo supporters who had dared to dream of further glory, the elimination came with a painful sting – not falling to European royalty but to neighbours from just down the Brazilian football block.
The bitter irony of conquering PSG only to stumble against Palmeiras will leave questions lingering over what might have been had Botafogo approached their countrymen with the same fearless spirit that toppled the European champions.
"The work Botafogo did in the U.S. should make anyone who is truly a Botafogo fan proud," Paiva said. "In the dressing room, the players were silent and downcast, unable to accept the result.
"I will forbid them from looking at the ground. They have to lift their heads and look up. The world now knows Botafogo better, and that is largely due to the work they have done in this tournament."
(Reporting by Fernando Kallas, editing by Ed Osmond)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
4 hours ago
- New Straits Times
South American clubs still lack killer instinct, say FIFA experts
MIAMI: The gulf between South American and European teams may not be as wide as expected at the Club World Cup, but a clear gap still exists in their efficiency in front of goal, according to FIFA technical experts. Arsene Wenger, FIFA's Chief of Global Football Development, and Juergen Klinsmann, former Germany and U.S. national team coach, were speaking at a round table on Saturday as the tournament enters its knockout phase. "At the start of the competition, many opponents seemed to fear playing against the European teams," Wenger said. "But as things progressed - especially the Brazilians - they began to realise it might not be so different after all." Flamengo and Botafogo beat European teams during the group phase of the 32-team competition, with the latter's 1-0 victory over European champions Paris St Germain standing out. Wenger said growing belief, especially among Brazilian sides, has shifted the dynamic heading into the last 16. "Maybe it's also because they've gained the confidence to do it. That shift in mindset could mean we'll see a different Brazil in the knockout stage than we saw in the group phase," he added. The Frenchman highlighted the influence of Filipe Luis, whose Flamengo side showed what Wenger called the most European tactical profile among South American sides at the tournament. "Filipe has ... played in Europe, and you can see that in the way his team approaches the game," Wenger said. GAP CLOSING Wenger and Klinsmann said South American clubs were quickly closing the gap in infrastructure and preparation. "When we visited the teams, we saw delegations of up to 100 people - support staff, analysts, advisors," Wenger said. "With squads of 23 to 35 players, these clubs are now fully professional in every department. That level of preparation allows teams to learn quickly." The key difference, however, remains in execution. "In the final third, European clubs are simply more clinical," Wenger said. Klinsmann agreed, saying the real divide lies in mentality. "Experience is also a big part of quality," he said. "When is a club like Pachuca or Monterrey (of Mexico) playing in a tournament like this?" Drawing on his time as U.S. national coach, Klinsmann stressed the importance of testing players outside their comfort zones. "That's why I always said, 'Get us into Copa America. Get us into Europe'. That's the kind of competition that develops a winning mentality," he said. "If this tournament were held again next year, Pachuca would be a different team - more confident, more refined. "But they have to be more clinical. When you're in the box, it's your head that makes the decision, not just your feet. And that's the difference." With the round of 16 underway on Saturday, analysts said the knockout stages would offer a clearer picture of how much ground South American teams have made up, tactically and psychologically. "We might see very different attitudes now," Wenger said.
Malay Mail
5 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Klopp: Club World Cup is ‘worst idea ever implemented in football'
LONDON, June 29 — Former Liverpool boss Jürgen Klopp has expressed concern about the Club World Cup, suggesting it is the 'worst idea ever implemented in football'. The new-look 32-team tournament started earlier this month, with the final taking place at the MetLife Stadium in New York on July 13, reported PA Media/dpa news. The Premier League resumes a month later, with Liverpool kicking off their title defence in the opening game of the season against Bournemouth on August 15. Klopp has previously spoken about issues such as fixture congestion and in an interview with German newspaper Welt am Sonntag, he suggested the Club World Cup will not provide any 'real recovery' for those players involved. 'It's all about the game and not the surrounding events – and that's why the Club World Cup is the worst idea ever implemented in football in this regard,' Klopp said. 'People who have never had or do not have anything to do with day-to-day business any more are coming up with something. 'There is insane money for participating, but it's also not for every club. 'Last year it was the Copa (America) and the European Championship, this year it's the Club World Cup, and next year the World Cup. That means no real recovery for the players involved, neither physically nor mentally.' After leaving his role as Reds boss last summer, Klopp became Red Bull's head of global soccer at the start of 2025. He added: 'I have serious fears that players will suffer injuries they've never had before next season. If not next season, then it will happen at the World Cup or afterwards. 'We constantly expect the players to go into every game as if it were their last. We tell them that 70 or 75 times a year. But it can't go on like this. 'We have to make sure they have breaks, because if they don't get them, they won't be able to deliver top performances — and if they can't achieve that anymore, the entire product loses value.' — Bernama-PA Media/dpa
Malay Mail
5 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Bayern vs Flamengo: Club World Cup tie has Champions League vibes, says Kompany
MIAMI GARDENS, June 29 — Bayern Munich coach Vincent Kompany says that for all the fascination and romance of playing against Flamengo in today's Club World Cup round-of-16 match, he expects the game to be similar to a Champions League contest. Six-times European champions Bayern take on three-times Copa Libertadores winners Flamengo at Hard Rock Stadium with a place in the quarter-finals up for grabs. It is the kind of fixture that Fifa surely had in mind when they came up with the idea for the tournament but for the Bayern boss, the task at hand is a familiar one. 'Flamengo is a top team with a good mixture of tactical discipline, aggressiveness, and a very real dose of Brazilian creativity and flair,' said the former Manchester City defender in his first season in charge of the Bundesliga giants. 'Most top-level Champions League teams defend as a unit, and Flamengo has that discipline. That's why I see this game as similar to a top-level game in Europe,' he said. 'Flamengo has a clear structure and discipline, which is essential for any top-level team. They defend well as a unit and have the ability to create dangerous situations on the ball,' he added. Bayern go into the game after losing their final group stage game against Benfica 1-0 having fielded a weakened team. But victories against Auckland City and Boca Juniors had already assured the German side of a place in the knockout stage. While Brazilian teams have shown during this tournament that they can compete with European clubs, Kompany still sees some elements of the country's traditional flair amid the tactical discipline. 'The way we associate Brazilian football is with creativity — things that people do on the pitch that we sometimes can't even think about,' he said. Like Kompany, Flamengo's coach Filipe Luis is only 39 and the former Atletico Madrid and Chelsea defender has clearly studied his opponent closely. 'I never played with him, I don't know him personally, but I know his career and the great character he has. Tactically, I studied his team a lot — even Burnley last year had interesting ideas,' said Luis. 'This year, especially early on at Bayern, I watched a lot of their games. He has some very interesting concepts. As I've said before, I try to copy and learn from the best. Bayern was a reference for many of us this year. So I had the chance to watch many of his games early in the season. 'It's a team that's really absorbed his model well, and without a doubt, one of the toughest opponents we could face. These are the kinds of matches every coach and player wants to be part of. So it's a big privilege,' he said. Kompany might be able to call again on German international Jamal Musiala, who having ended the season with injury missed the Benfica game after picking up a knock against Boca. 'He's back in training. For us it's preferable to not having him at all, for example. But as for his role — we'll have to wait and decide tomorrow,' said the coach. 'He's here, so he'll be in the squad tomorrow. But what happens then — we'll see.' — AFP
