New evidence suggests Russian forces caused Azerbaijan Airlines crash
Azerbaijani news outlet Minval claims it received an 'anonymous letter ... containing testimonies, audio clips, and technical details' pointing to 'technical deficiencies in the communications equipment used at the time.
Minval claims the letter includes a written statement 'allegedly signed by Captain Dmitry Sergeyevich Paladichuk, a Russian air defence officer (who) was acting under direct orders from Russia's Ministry of Defence when he authorised the missile strike.'
Euronews cannot independently verify the authenticity of the claims in the Azerbaijani news outlet's report.
Minval's news report on Tuesday quoted the letter claiming that 'Captain Paladichuk was stationed near Grozny on duty from 24 to 25 December. At 05:40 on the day of the incident, his unit was ordered to enter full combat readiness."
"Due to poor mobile reception and a lack of functional wired communication, coordination relied heavily on unstable mobile connections," the letter added.
"A potential target was detected at 08:11 and tracked using radar. Two missiles were reportedly fired at the object after Paladichuk was instructed via phone to destroy it — despite heavy fog obscuring optical confirmation.'
According to the letter, 'the coordinates, speeds, and directions of the target at the time of both missile launches were provided in detail in the written explanation. The first missile is said to have missed, while the second one allegedly detonated close enough for shrapnel to strike the aircraft.'
Minval also claimed that it reviewed "three voice messages" believed to support the claims made in the letter. The voices reportedly confirm that operational orders were given, two missiles were fired, and shrapnel from the explosion struck the aircraft, according to the outlet.
The outlet has released one audio recording purporting to depict the sequence in which a voice in Russian gives military directions, orders a missile to be fired, followed by the sound of what appears to be a firing sequence, the same voice saying 'target missed', and allegedly ordering another missile to be fired.
On the day of the tragedy, Azerbaijani government sources told Euronews that a Russian surface-to-air missile was fired at Flight 8432 during drone air activity above Grozny, the flight's destination. The same sources said that the shrapnel hit the passengers and cabin crew as the missile exploded next to the aircraft mid-flight, disabling it.
The damaged aircraft was not allowed to land at any Russian airports despite the pilots' requests for an emergency landing, the same sources said, and it was ordered to fly across the Caspian Sea towards Aktau in Kazakhstan, where it crashed while attempting an emergency landing, killing 38 and injuring 29.
Subsequent reports after the tragedy claimed that Flight 8243 was downed by a missile from a Russian Pantsir-S1 system.
Putin calls crash 'tragic incident', stops short of apology
Three days after the crash, in an address to the nation, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev said, "we can say with complete clarity that the plane was shot down by Russia (...) We are not saying that it was done intentionally, but it was done.'
At that time, on 29 December, Aliyev stated that Baku had made three demands to Russia in connection with the crash.
'First, the Russian side must apologise to Azerbaijan. Second, it must admit its guilt. Third, punish the guilty, bring them to criminal responsibility and pay compensation to the Azerbaijani state, the injured passengers and crew members,' Aliyev outlined.
Aliyev noted that the first demand was 'already fulfilled' when Russian President Vladimir Putin apologised to him on 28 December. Putin called the crash a 'tragic incident," though he stopped short of acknowledging Moscow's responsibility.
The Kremlin said at the time that air defence systems were firing near Grozny, where the plane attempted to land, to deflect Ukrainian drone strikes.
In the days following the tragedy, Russian military bloggers claimed that the said explosion happened over the Naursky District of Chechnya, where several Russian military units were posted at the time, including those with air defence systems, basing their conclusions on open-source data.
The new claims linking the Russian military to the Azerbaijan Airlines Flight 8432 tragedy appear at a time of a fast-moving escalation of judicial measures between Russia and Azerbaijan, as relations between the two countries reach a new low.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euronews
an hour ago
- Euronews
Moldova pushes to join the EU with or without Ukraine
As Moldova prepares to host a pivotal bilateral summit with the European Union this Friday in Chișinău, President Maia Sandu and her pro-European government are making a concerted push to accelerate the country's accession to the EU - potentially outpacing neighbouring Ukraine. Despite repeated hybrid attacks from Russia and economic headwinds, Moldova is eager to present its recent progress in aligning with EU standards as grounds for decoupling its enlargement track from Ukraine's. But Brussels remains cautious. A source within the Danish EU rotating presidency told Euronews that 'the decoupling of the enlargement process between Moldova and Ukraine is not for now.' EU leaders are wary that allowing Moldova to pull ahead might send the wrong signal - suggesting strategic acquiescence to Russia's destabilising goals in the region. From the EU's perspective, enlargement is not just a bureaucratic process; it's a geopolitical message. Maintaining a unified approach to Moldova and Ukraine is seen as a way to underscore solidarity and resist external manipulation. Romanian MEP Siegfried Mureșan, head of the EU–Moldova Parliamentary Association Committee, is one of Moldova's most vocal advocates in Brussels. He argues that the small nation is not only progressing quickly but would also require a lighter lift from EU institutions compared to Ukraine. 'Integrating the Republic of Moldova into the EU will be a smaller effort,' Mureșan told Euronews. 'The integration of small countries is easier than the integration of bigger countries. Moldova is a small country, and with our support, it can achieve a lot with sums that are not significant for the EU—but are transformative for Moldova.' Growth plan and economic resilience The EU is expected to unveil a three-year, €1.9 billion growth plan for Moldova - partly funded through loans and grants with the backing of the European Investment Bank. The investment aims to boost Moldova's economy and reduce its vulnerability to external pressures, particularly from Russia. 'We know Russia blackmailed it with high energy prices,' said Mureșan. 'The country suffered under high inflation; we need to strengthen its economy.' Moldova's energy infrastructure has undergone a significant transformation since 2022. It is now connected to the European electricity grid, and the EU has financed major upgrades to its domestic distribution systems. Chişinău has also committed to generating 27% of its energy from renewable sources by 2030. Despite setbacks - including a slowdown attributed to the energy shock from the war in Ukraine - the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) considers Moldova's economy resilient. In a landmark shift, over 50% of Moldovan exports went to the EU in 2024 - the highest in the country's history. Hybrid threats and strategic pressure from Russia Brussels remains acutely aware of the internal and external pressures facing Moldova. While public opinion is split between pro-Western and pro-Russian sentiment, the breakaway Transnistrian region - still under de facto Russian control - remains a source of instability. 'The Russian-speaking minority and companies in the so-called Transnistrian region benefit from European integration. More than 70% of their exports go to the European market. So I think Russia will continue to try to destabilise it,' said Mureșan, emphasising the paradox of Russian influence in the region. Security cooperation is already deepening. Under the EU–Moldova Security and Defence Partnership, the EU has allocated €197 million through the European Peace Facility (2021–2025) to modernise Moldova's armed forces. Moldova and Ukraine both applied for EU membership in March 2022 and were granted candidate status in June that year. Formal accession talks began in June 2024 - but how, and when, each country progresses remains politically sensitive. For now, Brussels appears unwilling to split the tracks. But if Moldova can continue demonstrating tangible reform, economic resilience, and geopolitical reliability, the case for accelerated accession may prove harder to ignore.
LeMonde
7 hours ago
- LeMonde
'Europeans are more wary than ever of a hastily negotiated deal between Washington and Tehran'
The silence between the French president and his Russian counterpart, who has been accused of war crimes, lasted a little less than three years. But the stakes over Iran's nuclear program were so high that Emmanuel Macron decided to reestablish contact on Tuesday, July 1, with Vladimir Putin, despite the ongoing war in Ukraine. While he still speaks with Donald Trump, the Russian president remains a pariah in Europe, as he refuses any prospect of a ceasefire at a time when his army is making gains on Ukrainian territory. Before agreeing to end "his" war, he once again demanded during his conversation with Emmanuel Macron that the "root causes" of the conflict be addressed – essentially, the alleged expansion of NATO – for which he places blame on "the West." Nevertheless, the French president intends to mobilize the members of the United Nations Security Council, including Russia and China, to step up efforts for negotiations over the Iranian nuclear program. After Vladimir Putin, who assured him that he was not encouraging his Iranian ally to acquire the bomb, the current resident of the Elysée plans to speak 'soon' with his Chinese counterpart, Xi Jinping. For Macron, the time has come to return to diplomacy following Israeli and American strikes, as the ceasefire between Iran and Israel, announced on June 24, ended what President Trump had dubbed the "Twelve-Day War." The French president is not alone in wanting a negotiated solution to quickly follow the American and Israeli military operations. His German counterpart, Friedrich Merz, and British counterpart, Keir Starmer – whose countries signed the Vienna Agreement on July 14, 2015, along with the United States, the European Union, Iran, France, China, and Russia – are essentially on the same page. However, they refuse to speak with the Russian president, whose word they deem "unreliable." In fact, the return of diplomacy is only just beginning to take shape, under the watchful eye of the unpredictable Donald Trump, a Nobel Prize candidate eager to be at the forefront seven years after tearing up the Vienna Agreement, which had been signed by Barack Obama to strictly oversee Iran's nuclear program. After the strikes, the diplomatic outlook remains extremely unclear. The American president has been stalling for time, saying he had "nothing to offer" Iran. Tehran, for its part, has refused to negotiate with Israel's main ally, whose military intervention has shaken the regime.
LeMonde
9 hours ago
- LeMonde
Russia becomes first country to officially recognize Taliban government in Afghanistan
Afghanistan's government said on Thursday, July 3 that Russia had become the first country to officially recognize its rule, calling it a "brave decision". The Taliban swept back to power in 2021 after ousting the foreign-backed government and have imposed an austere version of Islamic law. The announcement was made after Afghanistan's Foreign Minister Amir Khan Muttaqi met with Russia's ambassador to Afghanistan, Dmitry Zhirnov, in Kabul. "This brave decision will be an example for others... Now that the process of recognition has started, Russia was ahead of everyone," Muttaqi said in a video of the meeting posted on X. "Russia is the first country which has officially recognized the Islamic Emirate," Taliban foreign ministry spokesman Zia Ahmad Takal told AFP, using the government's name for their administration. Moscow's special representative for Afghanistan, Zamir Kabulov, told Russia's state news agency Ria Novosti that the government had "recognized" the Taliban government. Russia's foreign affairs ministry also confirmed the news to the TASS news agency. The move comes shortly after Taliban diplomat, Gul Hassan, assumed the role of Kabul's ambassador to Moscow. Moscow has taken steps to normalize relations with the Taliban authorities, removing their designation as a "terrorist organization" in April and inviting them to official events. Russia was the first country to open a business representative office in Kabul after the Taliban takeover, and has announced plans to use Afghanistan as a transit hub for gas heading to Southeast Asia. In July 2024, Russian President Vladimir Putin called the Taliban "allies in the fight against terrorism". Only Saudi Arabia, Pakistan and the United Arab Emirates recognised the Taliban during their first stint in power from 1996 to 2001. This time, multiple other states, including China and Pakistan, have accepted Taliban ambassadors in their capitals, but have not officially recognieed the Islamic Emirate. There has been limited but growing engagement with the Taliban authorities, particularly from its regional neighbors, but also major global players China and Russia. However, its restrictions on women and girls, barring them from education and squeezing them from public life, have been key sticking points for Western nations. The Taliban authorities have keenly sought international recognition and investment, as the country recovers from four decades of war, including the Soviet invasion from 1979 to 1989.
