logo
Indigenous leaders celebrate as court rejects appeal in landmark Yunupingu compensation case

Indigenous leaders celebrate as court rejects appeal in landmark Yunupingu compensation case

The Guardian12-03-2025

Traditional owners say justice has been served for their people as the high court dismissed a commonwealth appeal in a landmark compensation case.
The commonwealth lost the high court battle over whether it may be liable for up to $700m in compensation for bauxite mining at Gove in north-east Arnhem Land.
Gumatj leaders Djawa Yunupingu and Balupalu Yunupingu celebrated outside the high court on Wednesday after hearing the judgment against the commonwealth.
'Justice has been served for my people and the people of north-east Arnhem Land,' Djawa Yunupingu said.
Renowned land rights activist the late Gumatj leader Dr Yunupingu originally brought the case in 2019, alongside an application for native title on behalf of his clan.
Djawa Yunupingu emotionally acknowledged his late brother as the 'mastermind' behind the effort.
'He was the one who had the vision,' he said.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
Gumatj lawyer Sean Bowden told reporters the decision was a 'victory for decency, common sense and the rule of law'.
'Today's decision validates the strength of belief in Aboriginal people, generally, not just in themselves but in their place in Australia,' he said.
In May 2023, the federal court found native title rights and interests are property, and the extinguishment is an acquisition, and therefore be made under 'just terms'.
It found the Gumatj clan's land was not acquired 'on just terms' before being leased to the Swiss-Australian mining consortium Nabalco in 1968.
In its decision on Wednesday, the high court upheld this decision.
'Native title recognises that, according to their laws and customs, Indigenous Australians have a connection with country,' the judgment read.
'It is a connection which existed and persisted before and beyond settlement, before and beyond the assertion of sovereignty and before and beyond Federation.
'It is older and deeper than the constitution.'
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
The federal government had argued if its appeal failed it would be liable to pay native title holders compensation 'to an indeterminate number of grants of interests' in the Northern Territory land and that would have 'enormous financial ramifications'.
After the high court judgment, the attorney general, Mark Dreyfus, said the government recognised the 'significant contribution' the late Dr Yunupingu made in initiating the case.
'The commonwealth appealed to the high court to settle critical constitutional issues in this case,' he said.
'This decision clarifies the constitution's application to those issues for parties to this and future matters.'
Greens Senator Dorinda Cox said the government must now 'step up' and ensure the Gumatj people receive the compensation they are owed.
'For too long, First Nations people have borne the cost of mining and resource extraction on our lands without proper respect and shared benefit,' she said.
'This ruling sends a clear message and precedent: the commonwealth cannot ignore its obligations when it comes to First Nations land rights.'
A native title application, which Dr Yunupingu filed at the same time as the compensation case, will continue to be heard in the federal court.
Help for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people is available on 13YARN on 13 92 76

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Major retailer with 106 branches to shut store in days as up to 40% closing down sale launched
Major retailer with 106 branches to shut store in days as up to 40% closing down sale launched

Scottish Sun

time3 hours ago

  • Scottish Sun

Major retailer with 106 branches to shut store in days as up to 40% closing down sale launched

Has a retailer near you closed down? We'd love to hear from you please email: money@ BYE BYE Major retailer with 106 branches to shut store in days as up to 40% closing down sale launched Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A MAJOR retailer with 106 store branches will shut a store in days. Smiggle will close its branch in Coney Street in York come June 15. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 1 The stationary store is preparing to close a branch in York Credit: Getty The brightly coloured stationary store first opened in the city centre nine years ago. It was reported in YorkshireLive that the decision to close the children's store came after the landlord decided not to renew the lease. A 50% discount sale has been launched to help shift stock before the store closes for good. The branch will close this Sunday, June 15 giving customers just a few days to say their goodbyes. However it is not all bad news as a new Smiggle branch is set to open in York Designer Outlet this July. The Sun has contacted Smiggle for comment. It comes as the Australian-born business has announced plans to close a number of other stores across the UK. A Cwmbran Shopping Centre will pull down its shutters for the final time in August. Meanwhile two other branches closed in back in May. A store in the Eastgate Shopping Centre, Inverness, shut its doors on May 21. Popular retailer to RETURN 13 years after collapsing into administration and shutting 236 stores While a store in the Darwin Centre, Shrewsbury, closed on May 25. In January 2024, the brand also closed a site in Dundee, Scotland. And Smiggle is not the only brand closing stores across the UK. STORE CLOSURES THIS JUNE River Island will shutter a branch in Banbury on June 28, giving customers just a few days to say their goodbyes. The fashion brand, which has been sported by Paris Fury and Cat Deeley, has quietly closed a number of stores in the past few months. A branch in Willows Place, Corby closed in April and a separate site in Vicar Lane Shopping Centre in Chesterfield closed in the same month. The Sun has contacted River Island for a comment. News of the closure comes days after it was revealed that up to 230 of the retailer's stores are at risk. Hobbycraft also has plans to close up to nine stores by June 21.

Bangkok's 7 best smash burgers
Bangkok's 7 best smash burgers

Time Out

time4 hours ago

  • Time Out

Bangkok's 7 best smash burgers

A fast-food-style setup that takes sourcing seriously, Prime Burger is where you go when you want speed without sacrificing meat quality. They grind Australian beef fresh daily, smash it on the grill to lock in the juice, and build a menu that lets guests 'travel' by name – Stockholm (B262), New York (B262), Tokyo (B262), etc. The real appeal, though, is that everything here holds up under scrutiny, from the even crust on the patty to the soft, not-too-sweet bun. Even vegetarians, pescatarians and beef lovers get a decent pick – rare in a burger joint trying to cover this much ground.

Tottenham set deadline to appoint Thomas Frank as £10m talks progress rapidly
Tottenham set deadline to appoint Thomas Frank as £10m talks progress rapidly

Daily Mirror

time15 hours ago

  • Daily Mirror

Tottenham set deadline to appoint Thomas Frank as £10m talks progress rapidly

Tottenham Hotspur sacked Ange Postecoglou after his second season in charge of the club and are pushing to appoint Brentford boss Thomas Frank as the new coach in the coming days Tottenham are nearing an agreement with Brentford over Thomas Frank and could appoint the Bees boss as their new head coach in time for the weekend. Spurs quickly turned to Frank as their preferred candidate after sacking Ange Postecoglou last week. The north Londoners parted ways with the Australian coach despite winning the Europa League after a sub-par 17th place finish in the Premier League. And Daniel Levy looks to have taken a change in tact by looking to appoint Frank, who is deemed as a more pragmatic option. ‌ The move is set to cost Tottenham £10million but Frank could be confirmed as the club's new boss within the next 48 hours such is the positive feelings around negotiations, according to the BBC. There is will from both parties to get a deal finalised quickly. ‌ It is said new Spurs chief Vinai Venkatesham, previously of Arsenal, has been a key figure in the process alongside Levy. Venkatesham only started work at the club just over a week ago. And the positive talks are set to be tied up soon. Having said that, the £10m compensation cost could rise depending on how many members of backroom staff Frank looks to bring with him to north London. One such figure Spurs already said to be in talks over is assistant Justin Cochrane. Discussions are underway over Frank's backroom team with Cochrane's arrival particularly apt after he started his coaching career with the Europa League winners. Cochrane was previously touted as being in contention to succeed Frank at Brentford. Frank himself moved up from an assistant role under Dean Smith to take the job. The 51-year-old Dane is already thinking about the new squad that awaits him and set out a task for his future employers. Frank would like to see Brentford star Bryan Mbeumo join him across London. ‌ The Cameroon international, who scored 20 goals in 2024/25, is a target for Manchester United. The 25-year-old has already indicated his willingness to make the move to Old Trafford with a significant pay increase. Brentford want to bring in £60m for the signature of their star, who has also drawn interest from Newcastle United. And perhaps Frank's exit could provide a complicating factor. Ex-Manchester United goalkeeper Ben Foster reckons the forward will be better served following his coach across London. ‌ "I would say that if you want to be part of something that's going to make you a better footballer and work hard and be part of a team, then go to Spurs with Thomas Frank," the ex- Wrexham shot-stopper said on his Fozcast podcast. "If you are happy picking up your wages knowing that there's going to be an awful lot more pressure, a lot more eyes on you, a lot more judgement and failure is just part of what they do, then you'd go to Manchester United." Join our new WhatsApp community and receive your daily dose of Mirror Football content. We also treat our commgunity members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store