Indigenous leaders celebrate as court rejects appeal in landmark Yunupingu compensation case
The commonwealth lost the high court battle over whether it may be liable for up to $700m in compensation for bauxite mining at Gove in north-east Arnhem Land.
Gumatj leaders Djawa Yunupingu and Balupalu Yunupingu celebrated outside the high court on Wednesday after hearing the judgment against the commonwealth.
'Justice has been served for my people and the people of north-east Arnhem Land,' Djawa Yunupingu said.
Renowned land rights activist the late Gumatj leader Dr Yunupingu originally brought the case in 2019, alongside an application for native title on behalf of his clan.
Djawa Yunupingu emotionally acknowledged his late brother as the 'mastermind' behind the effort.
'He was the one who had the vision,' he said.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
Gumatj lawyer Sean Bowden told reporters the decision was a 'victory for decency, common sense and the rule of law'.
'Today's decision validates the strength of belief in Aboriginal people, generally, not just in themselves but in their place in Australia,' he said.
In May 2023, the federal court found native title rights and interests are property, and the extinguishment is an acquisition, and therefore be made under 'just terms'.
It found the Gumatj clan's land was not acquired 'on just terms' before being leased to the Swiss-Australian mining consortium Nabalco in 1968.
In its decision on Wednesday, the high court upheld this decision.
'Native title recognises that, according to their laws and customs, Indigenous Australians have a connection with country,' the judgment read.
'It is a connection which existed and persisted before and beyond settlement, before and beyond the assertion of sovereignty and before and beyond Federation.
'It is older and deeper than the constitution.'
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
The federal government had argued if its appeal failed it would be liable to pay native title holders compensation 'to an indeterminate number of grants of interests' in the Northern Territory land and that would have 'enormous financial ramifications'.
After the high court judgment, the attorney general, Mark Dreyfus, said the government recognised the 'significant contribution' the late Dr Yunupingu made in initiating the case.
'The commonwealth appealed to the high court to settle critical constitutional issues in this case,' he said.
'This decision clarifies the constitution's application to those issues for parties to this and future matters.'
Greens Senator Dorinda Cox said the government must now 'step up' and ensure the Gumatj people receive the compensation they are owed.
'For too long, First Nations people have borne the cost of mining and resource extraction on our lands without proper respect and shared benefit,' she said.
'This ruling sends a clear message and precedent: the commonwealth cannot ignore its obligations when it comes to First Nations land rights.'
A native title application, which Dr Yunupingu filed at the same time as the compensation case, will continue to be heard in the federal court.
Help for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people is available on 13YARN on 13 92 76
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
2 hours ago
- Reuters
Dollar higher as U.S. producer prices surge in July
NEW YORK, Aug 14 (Reuters) - The U.S. dollar snapped a two-day losing streak on Thursday as data showed U.S. producer prices increased more than expected in July amid a surge in the costs of services and goods, suggesting a broader pickup in inflation in the months ahead. The hot measure of inflation at the wholesale level follows the release on Tuesday of a better than feared rise in consumer prices in July, which emboldened traders to boost bets on interest rate cuts from the Federal Reserve in coming months. While Thursday's data did not upset the case for a September rate cut it did raise worries that tariffs could still stir up inflation in coming months and change the course of interest rate cuts for the rest of the year. It also hurt the case for the Fed to resume cutting rates with a 50 basis point cut in September, something Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent suggested in an interview on Wednesday. "I think that was never particularly likely, but presumably this PPI report quashes that," Matt Weller, global head of market research at StoneX. More importantly the inflation data raises questions about whether the Fed can deliver an aggressive pace of cuts for the rest of the year, he said. "Some people were saying that we could see three consecutive 25 basis point rate cuts ... but if anything approaching this level of inflation is in place it seems like we might be looking at more of a max of two interest rate cuts and even that might be questionable," Weller said. While financial markets have priced in an interest rate cut from the Federal Reserve next month, rising services inflation and the expectation tariffs could still significantly boost goods prices left some economists doubtful of an aggressive resumption in policy easing in the absence of further labor market deterioration. Traders still see a Fed rate cut on September 17 as a near certainty, according to LSEG data. The dollar index , measuring the currency against a basket of peers, was 0.5% higher at 98.17. The euro was 0.5% weaker at $1.16485 while the British pound eased 0.3% to $1.3538. Still, analysts warned against expecting a sustained rebound in the buck. "The market is very much likely to remain 'all in' on the idea of a September cut, at least until we hear from Powell at Jackson Hole next week," Michael Brown, market analyst at online broker Pepperstone in London, said, referring to the Fed's Jackson Hole Economic Symposium later this month. The yen rose against the dollar earlier in the session after Bessent suggested the Bank of Japan needs to raise rates again soon, before ceding ground to trade about flat on the day at 147.385 yen to a dollar. The stronger greenback weighed on the Australian dollar even as upbeat jobs data calmed concerns about a downturn in the labour market and lessened the need for another rate cut in the very near term. The Aussie was last down 0.8% to $0.6493. . Meanwhile, bitcoin earlier hit its first record peak since July 14, pushing as high as $124,480.82 before trimming gains and was last down nearly 4% at around $118,536. Bitcoin was already underpinned by increased institutional money flows this year in the wake of a spate of regulatory changes spearheaded by Trump, who has billed himself the "cryptocurrency president." In the latest move, an executive order last week paved the way to allow crypto assets in 401(k) retirement accounts. "Corporate treasuries like MicroStrategy and Block Inc. continue to buy bitcoin," said IG analyst Tony Sycamore.
Reuters
5 hours ago
- Reuters
Sterling ticks higher against dollar as economy slows less than expected
LONDON, Aug 14 (Reuters) - The pound rose to a fresh three-week high against the dollar on Thursday even as the greenback advanced against other major currencies, after UK GDP figures for July showed the economy slowing less than expected in the second quarter. At 0937 GMT, the pound was 0.1% higher at $1.135875, sitting at a three-week high against the dollar . Meanwhile, the dollar rose against the euro and Swiss franc. Against the euro, sterling rose 0.22% to 86.01 pence . Official figures published on Thursday showed Britain's economy slowed less than expected between April and June after a strong start to the year, despite the shock of U.S. import tariffs and a weaker jobs market, offering help to finance minister Rachel Reeves in meeting her budget goals. Francesco Pesole, FX strategist at ING, said while the numbers were generally positive they matter more for gilts and for the government heading into the autumn budget. "The BoE hasn't really looked at GDP numbers closely because they're volatile and backward-looking, and they're really looking much more closely at inflation and jobs." UK labour data on Tuesday showed weakness in hiring but persistent wage growth, a headache for the Bank of England, which is faced with the tricky task of balancing a slowing economy and stubborn inflation. The next batch of inflation figures is due on August 20 after last month's CPI figures for June showing UK inflation rising to 3.6% - its highest since January 2024. "The fact that policymakers are pondering how to respond to the challenging combination of a rather weak real economy and persistent inflation has bolstered the pound," wrote Commerzbank analysts in a note. "...these doubts reinforce the view that the BoE is not leaning towards a dovish stance." Money markets expect the BoE to hold rates steady at 4.25% at its next meeting on September 18 .
Reuters
6 hours ago
- Reuters
Swiss gold industry warns against Swatch boss's US gold tax proposal
ZURICH, Aug 14 (Reuters) - Switzerland's gold industry on Thursday voiced scepticism about a proposal by the boss of watchmaker Swatch (UHR.S), opens new tab to introduce a levy on gold exports to the United States in retaliation for U.S. tariffs on Switzerland. U.S. President Donald Trump last week imposed tariffs of 39% on imported Swiss goods, causing shock and dismay in the Alpine republic, a major refining and transit hub for gold. The U.S. Customs and Border Protection afterwards said Washington might put tariffs on the most widely-traded gold bullion bars in the United States. However, Trump said on Monday that gold would not face tariffs. Swatch CEO Nick Hayek told Swiss newspaper Blick that Trump's announcement indicated that tariffs on gold would be painful for the U.S. president. "Now is the time to go on the offensive. Switzerland should order a 39% export tax on gold bars for the United States," Hayek told the paper. "That's where we have to get at him. That's his Achilles' heel." The Swiss Association of Manufacturers and Traders in Precious Metals (ASFCMP) said that while ideas to better balance bilateral trade were welcome, careful consideration needed to be given to Switzerland's longer-term interests. "An export tax on Swiss gold destined for the USA would not only harm Switzerland economically, but also damage the reputation of a country that has consistently promoted and defended free trade," ASFCMP President Christoph Wild said. The Swiss Economy Ministry declined to comment on the proposal, but said the support of business representatives was in general welcome and helped underscore the close economic ties between the U.S. and Switzerland. Trump justified his 39% tariff by pointing to Switzerland's sizeable trade surplus with the United States. Part of that is due to gold exports. Hayek said that even if a gold levy failed to move Trump, it would cut the U.S. trade deficit with Switzerland. "If Trump doesn't give in to our pressure, we'll at least improve the trade balance with the U.S. if the Americans no longer import gold bars via Switzerland," he told Blick. Switzerland is continuing to hold talks with U.S. officials aimed at lowering the U.S. tariffs.
