Driver admits stealing BMW in care home crash that killed two women
Two elderly residents at Highcliffe Care Home, Witherwack, Sunderland, died following the crash last month.
Sam Asgari-Tabar, of no fixed address, appeared before Newcastle Crown Court where he admitted robbery, relating to stealing a BMW 3-series, and causing serious injury by dangerous driving to a resident who suffered spinal fractures.
He denied a charge of kidnapping a woman who was in the BMW, which he was test driving.
The Crown Prosecution Service asked the court for more time to consider whether those pleas were acceptable.
Co-accused Ryan Parish, 21, of Sunderland, did not enter pleas to charges of robbery and kidnap, also relating to the BMW and the test drive.
Northumbria Police were alerted to reports of a stolen car in Fenham, Newcastle, on the evening of July 10 and a suspect vehicle was spotted in the Sunderland area 15 minutes later.
A pursuit then followed which ended with the BMW crashing into the care home, causing extensive structural damage to the building.
Initially, Northumbria Police said eight residents required hospital treatment.
Two days later, the force said a woman in her 90s and a woman in her 80s, neither of whom were in the eight taken to hospital, had died and police inquiries were ongoing.
The pair will appear again before Newcastle Crown Court on Aug 19 and Judge Carolyn Scott told Parish he must enter pleas on that occasion.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
8 hours ago
- ITV News
Jersey officials seize nearly £800,000 from major British drug smuggler
Officials in Jersey have seized nearly £800,000 of criminal proceeds from a major drug smuggler. Eitan Benzur, a British citizen, worked with others to supply 8.5 tonnes of cannabis from 2010 to 2014, with a combined street value of more than £9 million. He concealed the significant amounts of cash in safety deposit boxes and by transferring money abroad. After fleeing to Israel, he was eventually extradited to the UK in 2020 and was sentenced at Bristol Crown Court to nine years in prison. His assets were confiscated in Jersey following a request from the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) and the island's Attorney General. £397,000 has been transferred to the UK Home Office, while the remaining £397,000 will be kept in a Jersey confiscation fund, which the Treasury Minister can ask to use for crime prevention measures. Jersey's Attorney General, Mark Temple KC, says: "This case yet again demonstrates Jersey's ongoing commitment to assisting its overseas partners to ensure that criminals are denied the benefit of their criminal conduct." Chief Crown Prosecutor for the CPS Proceeds of Crime Division, Adrian Foster, adds: "Thanks to our joint contribution, Eitan Benzur has been stripped of his ill-gotten gains, which have been shared between our jurisdictions to prevent future economic crime."
Daily Mail
13 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Rise in sex offenders using 'sleepwalker defence' to deflect rape charges, CPS prosecutor warns
There has been a rise in rapists claiming they suffer with sexsomnia to evade conviction, a top Crown Prosecution Service lawyer has told a Daily Mail podcast. Speaking to The Trial, Charlotte Coulton-Smith said the CPS is making sexsomnia a 'key part of training' so case workers can better identify offenders who fraudulently claim to have the condition. The concern comes as courts have increasingly encountered the sleep disorder defence. Sexsomnia is a rare condition that causes people to engage in sexual activity while completely asleep, with sufferers having no memory of their actions. Those with the genuine condition can engage in a range of unconscious sexual behaviours including touching others, masturbation and full intercourse. In the last decade, several high-profile cases across Europe have seen men acquitted of rape after successfully proving to courts they suffer from the condition. But not all attempts succeed. Dean Final, 32, who was jailed for 11 years for rape in August, recently tried and failed to use a sexsomnia defence. 'It's certainly on the increase', Coulton-Smith told Trial host Caroline Cheetham. 'We're seeing more cases where defendants will claim to be suffering from sexsomnia. 'We are going to make sure that we are robustly challenging and dealing with these cases within the CPS. 'I don't expect to see it going away anytime soon. Women and girls need to be aware of it.' Sexsomnia cases present a complex challenge for courts, as there is no standard diagnostic method to verify the condition. Courts are more likely to accept it as a legitimate defence when defendants have a documented history of sleepwalking or display telltale signs during the alleged incident - such as keeping their eyes open throughout the sexual activity. Other key indicators that help distinguish genuine sexsomnia from fabricated claims include complete memory loss of the events and an absence of complex, coordinated movements during the activity. However, there is still debate within the medical community whether the condition actually exists. Coulton-Smith, who helped prosecute Final, described how the CPS worked to easily disprove his sexsomnia claim. 'Final served a claim that he was suffering from sexsomnia. We really wanted to make sure that never got in front of a jury. 'It was clear that there was no proper, expert foundation to say he was suffering with sexsomnia. 'He had no history of sleepwalking. In fact, we asked for a statement from the prison to say, has he been sleepwalking – they told us no. 'We asked his ex-partner: has he ever sleepwalked before? She told he hasn't. 'Effectively, this behaviour started and stopped just for this event. It's a clear demonstration of why we need to tackle this issue head on. 'If it's not properly challenged, this could be a road map for abusers to carry on their abusing. 'We will be looking with laser detail whenever this type of defence is raised.' To listen to full interview about the Dean Final case and the 'sexsomnia' defence, subscribe to The Crime Desk now.
Metro
13 hours ago
- Metro
US hitwoman who dressed in niqab for botched assassination guilty of murder plot
An American woman who wore a niqab disguise and tried to shoot a stranger dead in the street only for the gun to jam is facing a life sentence. Aimee Betro, 45, was flown to the UK from Wisconsin by Mohammed Aslam, 59, and Mohammed Nabil Nazir, 31, who orchestrated the murder plot to settle a 'vendetta' with a rival family in Birmingham in September 2019. The city's crown court heard the father and son wanted 'revenge' against Aslat Mahumad after they were beaten up at his clothing boutique a year earlier. Betro donned the disguise and lay in wait outside Mr Mahumad's home on September 7 before approaching his son Sikander Ali, with CCTV showing her raising her arm and pulling the trigger at point-blank range. Fortunately, Mr Ali managed to flee when the gun jammed and jurors heard Betro returned hours later and fired three shots into the family home, which was empty at the time. It took jurors 21 hours to convict Betro of conspiracy to murder, possessing a self-loading pistol with intent to cause fear of violence, and a charge of illegally importing ammunition. Betro, who work a purple T-shirt and with her hair in space buns, stared towards the jury bench as the verdicts were returned. She was found guilty by majority 11-1 verdicts on the conspiracy to murder and firearm charges, and by a unanimous verdict on the ammunition charge. Nazir and Aslam were jailed at the same court in November last year for their part in the plot, with the younger man given 32 years and his dad 10. Betro flew back to the US days after the bungled assassination attempt and was later extradited to the UK. She was found guilty of conspiracy to murder, possessing a self-loading pistol and a charge of fraudulently evading the prohibition on importing ammunition today. The court was told she was involved in another of Nazir's plots when she sent three parcels of gun parts and ammunition to the UK a month later. They were addressed to a man named Faris Quayum, who Nazir was hoping to frame by tipping police off to the delivery. Prosecutor Tom Walkling KC told jurors: 'The prosecution say that the evidence in this case is compelling and strong. 'Aimee Betro was the would-be assassin on September7, 2019. 'She was the shooter on Measham Grove in the early hours of the next day, and she was the person who furthered another of Nazir's vendettas when she sent ammunition to the UK in October 2019.' Betro denied any involvement in the failed hit, telling the court she flew to the UK to celebrate her birthday and go to a boat party. She also maintained that a woman described as having an American accent and being small and fat, who bought a BMW linked to the plot, was not her. Betro suggested it must have been 'another American woman' who sounded like her, used her phone and had almost identical trainers on. More Trending The fact she happened to be around the corner from the shooting minutes later was 'all just a terrible coincidence', she added. Cross-examining Betro, Mr Walkling said: 'So there must be, on your case, another American woman in Birmingham at the same time as you, who knew Mr Nazir, who sounded similar to you, who used the cheap phone that you bought, who called (a taxi firm) on your own telephone, and who wore at the very least the same sort of Converse trainers you had.' Betro answered: 'Yes.' She will be sentenced later. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: Man and woman arrested after one-year-old girl dies after suffering 'serious injuries' MORE: British granddad who 'tried to drown daughter-in-law in pool' pleads to be freed MORE: Three people killed after man 'in an Hawaiian shirt' opens fire outside Target store in Austin, Texas
