Kilkenny Arts Festival review: Depth of writing is unmatched by the music in this Savita Halappanavar opera
St Canice's Cathedral, Kilkenny
★★☆☆☆
It's a neat and potent idea. Custom of the Coast, a new opera by composer Kamala Sankaram and librettist Paul Muldoon, focuses on two women who lived centuries apart: the Irish pirate Anne Bonny and the Indian dentist Savita Halappanavar.
Bonny's birthplace is believed to have been Cork, and her name appears prominently on the title page of the second edition of Captain Charles Johnson's A General History of the Pyrates.
That highly entertaining work, which was published in 1724 and has sometimes been attributed to Daniel Defoe, is also the source of many of today's misperceptions about pirates.
Halappanavar died after she was denied an abortion at University Hospital Galway in 2012, an avoidable tragedy that generated public outrage and helped sustain the campaigning which would ultimately lead to abortion being legalised in Ireland.
READ MORE
The two women, each of whom has an entry in the Dictionary of Irish Biography, are connected by the fact that Halappanavar died in 21st-century Ireland because she was carrying a child, yet nearly three centuries earlier Bonny was able to use pregnancy as a plea for mercy at a trial in Jamaica in 1720.
Custom of the Coast is described as 'An Operatic Conjuring in One Act'. It's cast for two singers, soprano Anchal Dhir (Halappanavar) and mezzo-soprano Michelle O'Rourke (Bonny), with accordion (Danny O'Mahony) and string quartet (players from Crash Ensemble), under the musical direction of cellist Kate Ellis.
The semi-staged presentation, directed and designed by Alan Gilsenan, with culturally apt costumes by Sinéad Lawlor, is the far side of minimal. Not least because for most of the 70-minute work the singers take it in turn to narrate their individual situations.
The stage of St Canice's Cathedral is dominated by a large, suspended disc, which is lit to evoke both sun and ovum, with Matt Burke's lighting design often casting multiple shadows into the depths of the chancel.
The singers have real presence and good voices and they are a pleasure to listen to. The characters' stories have a relevance beyond time and place.
So why does this come across as such a problematic work? Partly because everything is amplified, not for clarity, but in a way that substitutes a sense of aural closeness for the feeling of intimacy. And, more importantly, because so many of the words get lost in the melange.
From the words that can be heard, it's clear that Muldoon's writing has a depth and complexity that the music can't either match or support or provide an interesting background to. And the traditional music on accordion (which is the composer's instrument) is trotted out as a kind of pig-in-the-kitchen cliche.
On this hearing, I couldn't help feeling that the baggage of opera has burdened what might more successfully have been conceived as a standalone concert work.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
38 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Breaking Out: The remarkable life of gregarious and charismatic songwriter Fergus O'Farrell
The late songwriter Fergus O'Farrell wrote music of heartbreaking beauty and of breathtaking tempestuousness. So it is apt that his story should be brought wrenchingly to the screen by director Michael McCormack with the documentary Breaking Out (RTÉ One, Wednesday, 10.35pm). It is a feature-length sobathon filmed over 10 years and forged grippingly from the stuff of life itself: hope, struggle, death and the redemptive power of a great tune. But there is humour too – and a surreal cameo from movie star Jeremy Irons , a neighbour of O'Farrell's in west Cork who we see appearing to the singer in a dream, after he suffers an accident and wonders if he has the will to carry on. READ MORE O'Farrell passed away in 2016 during the shooting of the documentary, shortly after he had finished the album he had set out to make with his band Interference – and with the help of his friend Glen Hansard , of The Frames. Diagnosed in childhood with muscular dystrophy, the Schull, Co Cork, artist was forced to stop touring just as his career was taking off. 'An Irish Jeff Buckley' is how he was described by Steve Wall of The Stunning, a contemporary of O'Farrell's in late 1980s Dublin, when every new Irish band was heralded as potentially the next U2. [ North Circular review: 'You'd have robbed cars flying around ... It used to be chaos, but good fun' Opens in new window ] As a kid, O'Farrell was always less athletic than his siblings. When he was eight, the postman told his parents there was 'something wrong' with their son, and they took him to Cork city for tests. His mother recalls how the doctor ignored Fergus and told her that her son would be in a wheelchair by 12. 'And at 18 … he snapped his fingers.' But Fergus made it past 18 and, having moved to Dublin, found healing in music. Gregarious and charismatic, O'Farrell was a lodestar to other artists. He came from comparative wealth (he was educated by the Jesuits in elite Clongowes Wood College) and his father had been able to lease for him an old shoe factory in Dublin that served as both digs and rehearsal space. Actor Jeremy Irons was a neighbour of O'Farrell's in west Cork. Photograph: Joaquin Corchero/Europa Press via Getty Images 'There was a constant shuffle of sleeping bags,' recalls singer and actor Maria Doyle Kennedy . 'It seemed to be a home for the bewildered.' O'Farrell was an artist's artist – an inspiration to a young Glen Hansard and countless others. 'You could see this frail being – this huge ego of a soul trapped in a very limited physical body,' recalls Hansard, who describes O'Farrell's singing as the sound of 'pure freedom'. Hansard felt he owed a creative debt to O'Farrell, and he repaid it by having Interference's song Gold feature in the soundtrack to his movie Once. [ Lucy Letby: Who to Believe review - Baffling exploration of convicted neonatal nurse's case Opens in new window ] The track took on a life of its own – it was performed at the 2012 Tony Awards and, in one of Breaking Out's most moving sequences, we accompany O'Farrell to New York where, alongside Hansard, he plays it at the famed Radio City Music Hall. But it is O'Farrell's final years in Schull that yank at the heartstrings. McCormack doesn't soft soap the impact of O'Farrell's declining health, nor the pressure it places on both O'Farrell and his wife, Li. In the end, Breaking Out is really about their relationship as much as it is about Interference or their fans. 'She is my controlled nuclear explosion, she is my happiness,' says O'Farrell, recalling how they met when he was in hospital in Cyprus and she was the nurse assigned to care for him. It's one more emotionally devastating scene in a film packed with them. Breaking Out can be viewed on RTÉ One at 10.35pm.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Victim's family condemns ‘disgusting' Féile na Phobail tribute to Brendan ‘Bik' McFarlane
The family of a young woman murdered during the Troubles has called the tribute paid to her killer at Féile an Phobail as 'absolutely disgusting'. An image of Brendan 'Bik' McFarlane appeared on the screen during a show by Scottish band Shebeen at the closing night of Féile an Phobail in Belfast on Sunday night. Féile an Phobail , which bills itself as Ireland's biggest community arts festival, is partially funded by the Department of Foreign Affairs ' Reconciliation Fund, which gave €157,704 in 2022. Linda Boyle (17) was killed during a machine gun and bomb attack on the Bayardo Bar on the Shankill Road in August 1975 McFarlane, who died earlier this year, was convicted and sentenced for the Bayardo Bar massacre which occurred 50 years ago on August 13th, 1975. READ MORE Then aged 23, he and two others, Peter Christopher Skeet Hamilton (22) and Séamus Joseph Clarke (19) carried out a bomb and gun attack on the pub they suspected of being used by UVF members. A tribute to Brendan 'Bik' McFarlane on the screen at the Falls Park tonight as Shebeen sing Marcella, the song Bik wrote in memory of his friend and comrade Bobby Sands. — Féile an Phobail (@FeileBelfast) Two civilians were machine-gunned to death outside the pub while three more died in the subsequent explosion which injured dozens of people. Among those killed in the Bayardo Bar massacre was 17-year-old Linda Boyle. In a statement marking the 50th anniversary, Ms Boyle's family said what happened on Sunday night – which was shared on the Féile an Phobail social media channel – was a 'sick tribute'. They added: 'We can barely find the words to express how we feel about what happened. It's so depressing that these things happen, and it's not an isolated incident, almost weekly we see instances of glorification of terrorism and what's done about it? 'We rejoice in how Linda lived and the values she represented, and no one will ever take that away from us.' They stated that Linda was a 'stylish young woman who was caring and friendly and who had a real zest for life. 'She would now be of retirement age and would be at a point where she should be relaxing and exploring a further chapter of life, Linda's storybook was ended before she got beyond her first chapter.' The South East Fermanagh Foundation, which supports victims of the Troubles, said the events of Sunday night were part of a 'concerted campaign on the part of Irish republicans to infiltrate the genre of traditional Irish music, to integrate what was once fringe rebel music into the mainstream'. McFarlane was officer commanding in the H Blocks during the hunger strikes of 1981. According to David Beresford, the author of the 1987 book Ten Men Dead, McFarlane's crimes were such that it would have been a 'one-man public relations disaster' had he gone on hunger strike too. McFarlane escaped from the Maze Prison in September 1983. He was later charged in connection with the kidnapping of businessman Don Tidey , a case that went on for nearly a decade. Mr Tidey was kidnapped in November 1983. He was kept in a hideout in Derrada Wood outside Ballinamore in Co Leitrim until December 16th of that year when it was discovered by a search party involving gardaí and army personnel. Pte Patrick Kelly and recruit Garda Gary Sheehan were shot dead by the IRA gang when they came across the hideout 23 days after Tidey's abduction. The gang also shot and seriously wounded Det Sgt Donie Kelleher before fleeing. McFarlane was named by gardaí as a suspect in the aftermath of the events of Derrada Wood even before forensic evidence confirmed that his fingerprints were found in the hideout. A garda at the scene later identified McFarlane as one of the gunmen who shot directly at him during the escape. McFarlane allegedly confessed to the kidnapping and murders at Dundalk Garda station after being arrested in 1998. After a lengthy trial process, the confession was deemed as inadmissible and the case collapsed.
Irish Times
16 hours ago
- Irish Times
Kilkenny Arts Festival review: Sinews strain as daylight fades in uplifting Neon Dusk
Neon Dusk Castle Yard, Kilkenny – Kilkenny Arts Festival ★★★★☆ Many modern circus and acrobatic shows feature multiple performers for substantial audiences in large auditoria. This show, from Jonah McGreevy, co-creative director of Cork -based Loosysmokes, and Portuguese performers Daniel Seabra and Mafalda Gonçalves, is different on many fronts. A small, almost intimate audience is seated outdoors in Castle Yard, three or four rows on two sides of a low, basic platform, for a 50-minute show as day gives way to the beginning of darkness. There's a simplicity and low-tech feel to this and it's powered by solar energy, with a bank of PV panels adjacent. Thus the faint light from low heights throws striking and gentle shadows of the performers onto Castle Yard's beautiful backdrop of curved stone walls and circular windows. There is no equipment or aerial paraphernalia or bells and whistles, just three bodies in jeans and T-shirts, and, at the beginning, a rope for Seabra, which effectively sets a tone evoking control and captivity. There is throwing and catching and falling, holding each other up, building towers or mounds or angled shapes of bodies, using balance and trust as the glue. Their strength of arm and leg is phenomenal, with tremendous balance, throws-twirls-catches, then falling or flopping. READ MORE The intimacy of all this is the most striking aspect. Unlike many larger acrobatic shows where distant bodies can look like they're made of rubber and bouncy stuff, here we're seated a metre or so from the acrobat-dancers. We can see the effort and how hard this is on their faces. Sinews strain and limbs shake as a pose or movement becomes more difficult. We witness nods which indicate they're ready to hold or catch or be thrown. As a performer falls to the floor and lies there, we can see into their eyes. We see up close the work, skill, struggle. The audience is silent throughout, aside from the occasional gasp, as if holding collective breath. The programme refers to the show 'exploring the troubling times we're living through'. Much of the action and images created are indeed bleak and troubled, evoking pain or aggression, fleeing or chasing. The performers' expressions are solemn, sometimes ferocious. They fall to the floor, are dragged unmoving, dead. There is struggle and hardship and fear. The stage darkens and the music has an unrelenting beat, pulsating, rhythmical, foreboding, sometimes otherworldly. The effect is ominous and fearful. And yet the nature of what they are doing is at odds with this aesthetic. McGreevy, Seabra and Gonçalves exhibit tremendous co-operative balance as they build structures with piling bodies, or shapes through multiple physical balancing feats. They must each trust that the others will catch or hold when they leap, or lead them when blinded. This trust, and the strength from co-operation, working together, is redolent of more positive aspects of our world. In this way, the unsettling is also uplifting. Runs at Castle Yard, Kilkenny, from August 13th-17th
