Minister regrets 'clumsy' reference to Nazi Germany
The attorney general has said he regrets "clumsy" remarks in which he compared calls for the UK to depart from international law and arguments made in 1930s Germany.
In a speech on Thursday, Lord Hermer criticised politicians who argue the UK should abandon "the constraints of international law in favour of raw power".
He said similar claims had been made by legal theorists in Germany in the years before the Nazis came to power.
Tory leader Kemi Badenoch accused him of "calling people who disagree with him Nazis," and urged the prime minister to sack him.
A spokesperson for Lord Hermer said he rejected "the characterisation of his speech by the Conservatives".
But they added the Labour peer "acknowledges though that his choice of words was clumsy and regrets having used this reference".
They added that the speech was aimed at "defending international law which underpins our security, protects against threats from aggressive states like Russia and helps tackle organised immigration crime".
In a speech at the Royal United Services Institute think tank, Lord Hermer said the Labour government wanted to combine a "pragmatic approach to the UK's national interests with a principled commitment to a rules-based international order".
He said the approach was "a rejection of the siren song that can sadly now be heard in the Palace of Westminster, and in some spectrums of the media, that Britain abandons the constraints of international law in favour of raw power".
Lord Hermer added: "This is not a new song.
"The claim that international law is fine as far as it goes, but can be put aside when conditions change, is a claim that was made in the early 1930s by 'realist' jurists in Germany, most notably Carl Schmitt, whose central thesis was in essence the claim that state power is all that counts, not law.
"Because of the experience of what followed in 1933, far-sighted individuals rebuilt and transformed the institutions of international law, as well as internal constitutional law."
Adolf Hitler became German chancellor in 1933.
Carl Schmitt, a German legal scholar, was a supporter of the Nazi Party who sought to justify Hitler's policies in his writings on legal and political theory.
The Conservatives and Reform UK have been critical of some elements of international law and the courts that enforce it.
For example, some politicians from these parties have called for the UK to withdraw from the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), an international treaty which sets out the rights and freedoms people are entitled to in signatory countries, including the UK.
Critics of the ECHR say it hampers the UK's ability to deal with migration issues, including deporting people who cross the English Channel on small boats.
Badenoch, who has previously suggested the UK would have to leave the ECHR if it stops the country from doing "what is right", said Lord Hermer had shown "appalling judgement" in his speech.
"Now he's calling people who disagree with him Nazis," she added.
"This isn't just embarrassing, it's dangerous. Hermer doesn't understand government.
"If Keir Starmer had any backbone, he'd sack him."
Reform UK's deputy leader Richard Tice said Lord Hermer should apologise.
"If anyone on the right of politics used his language, there would be outrage," Tice posted on social media.
"He has shown himself as unfit to be attorney general."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Polish presidential election too close to call, exit polls suggest
A second exit poll in Poland's presidential election has indicated that conservative historian Karol Nawrocki is ahead with 50.7% of the vote over Warsaw's liberal mayor, Rafal Trzaskowski with 49.3%. The second exit poll sensationally overturned the result of an exit poll published immediately after voting ended that put Trzaskowski ahead with a narrow lead of 50.3% to Nawrocki's 49.7%. The official result is due to be published on Monday morning, the head of the state electoral commission said. Trzaskowski had already claimed victory after the first exit poll indicated he was the winner. "We won," he said. "We won, although the phrase 'razor's edge' will forever enter the Polish language and politics," he added. His wife, Malgorzata, jokingly told the crowd, "I'm close to having a heart attack". Trzaskowski promised to reach out to voters who supported his opponent. I will be a president for all Polish women and men," he said. Nawrocki, meanwhile, told his supporters after the result of the first exit poll that it was too close to call. "Let's not lose hope for this night. We will win during the night, the difference is minimal. I believe that we will wake up tomorrow with President Karol Nawrocki," he said. Poland's president is a largely ceremonial role with limited influence on foreign policy and defence, but they can veto legislation and Donald Tusk's pro-EU coalition government lacks a big enough parliamentary majority to overturn it. The current conservative incumbent president, Andrzej Duda, has used his powers to prevent Prime Minister Tusk delivering key campaign promises including removing political influence from the judiciary and liberalising the country's strict abortion law. If Trzaskowski's victory is confirmed that obstacle would be removed and would allow Tusk to cement Poland's place in the European mainstream. However, Tusk also faces opposition from within his own coalition from the conservative Peoples' Party on issues including abortion and legalising civil partnerships. A victory for national conservative Karol Nawrocki, who is supported by opposition Law and Justice (PiS) party, would mean continued conflict between the government and president. It would also re-energise PiS, which lost power 18 months ago, giving the party the belief that it can go on to win parliamentary elections in 2027. Both candidates support continued assistance for neighbouring Ukraine, although Nawrocki has said he opposes its entry into Nato and the EU for now while Russia continues its war of aggression. Both men differ over their approach to the EU. Trzaskowski, a former Europe minister, supports Tusk's vision of a Poland at the heart of the European mainstream, influencing decisions through strong relations with Germany and France. A deputy leader of Tusk's Civic Platform, he has served as Warsaw mayor since 2018. He's the son of a famous Polish jazz pianist, speaks several languages and is viewed by some voters as a member of the country's liberal elite who is out of touch with ordinary Poles. According to the CBOS polling company, Trzaskowski's typical voter is aged 30-40 years old, is relatively well off with left-liberal views and is open to LGBTQ+ and migrants' rights. They tend to live in large cities and have positive views of the EU. Some voters said he tried to "artificially" present himself as a candidate who values patriotism. During the campaign, he has taken a much tougher line against illegal migration, something Tusk started to do before winning power in 2023 and he has volunteered to do basic military training. Nawrocki, 42, supports a strong sovereign Poland and does not want the country to cede any more powers to Brussels. He opposes the EU's climate and migration policies. He's a conservative Catholic that prioritises traditional family values. He was relatively unknown nationally before he was selected by opposition party PiS to be their "unofficial" candidate. A keen amateur boxer and footballer, he often posted images of himself working out, allowing PiS to present him as a strong candidate who would stand up for ordinary Poles and the country's national interests. A fan of President Donald Trump, he flew to Washington during the campaign for an extremely brief meeting to get a thumbs-up photo of himself with the American president in the Oval Office. During the campaign he was attacked by the government and media for being morally unfit to be the country's president, but the allegations did not diminish his support during the last week of campaigning. During a presidential debate, Nawrocki said that he, like most Poles, owned one apartment. That turned out to be a lie. Nawrocki was accused of taking advantage of a vulnerable senior citizen to acquire his council flat at a huge discount in exchange for promises of care that were unfulfilled. Following the scandal, Nawrocki said he would donate the flat to charity but always denied the accusation. Polish news website accused Nawrocki of helping to arrange sex workers for guests at the luxury Grand Hotel in the Baltic seaside resort of Sopot when he worked there as a security guard. The story was based on anonymous sources, but said the witnesses had sworn they would repeat the allegations under oath in court. Nawrocki called the story a pack of lies and said he would sue the website. His opponents portrayed him as a football hooligan who admired gangsters and neo-Nazi ultras. Nawrocki did not deny taking part in hooligan brawls as a younger man, calling them "noble fights". He has also said these allegations were an attempt to smear his reputation. Some Nawrocki voters told me they did not believe certain stories about him, saying they were inventions of the mainstream Trzaskowski-supporting media. Polish knife-edge presidential vote pits liberal mayor against conservative Warsaw's liberal mayor narrowly wins Polish presidential vote Polish voters set for tight presidential race after 10 years of Duda
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Reform UK to win majority of seats in Cumbria says poll
Reform UK could win a majority of seats in Cumbria at the next election according to the latest poll. The party, led by former UKIP leader, Nigel Farage, won 5 seats at last year's general election but picked up votes across the country in both rural seats and Labour's industrial heartlands. The latest poll would see the party win in Barrow, Carlisle, Penrith and the Solway and Workington and Whitehaven according to online analyst, Election Maps UK. Nowcast Update: Reform just shy of a Majority, Tories fall to 5th. RFM: 319 (+314), 29.6% - [7 Short] LAB: 134 (-277), 22.3% LDM: 80 (+8), 14.4% SNP: 44 (+35), 2.8% CON: 33 (-88), 17.9% PLC: 7 (+3), 1.1% GRN: 6 (+2), 9.3% Oth: 8 (+3), 2.7% — Election Maps UK (@ElectionMapsUK) May 25, 2025 In the 2024 general election, Reform beat the Tories into second place in Whitehaven and Workington whilst pushing them close in Penrith and the Solway and Carlisle. READ MORE: Warning issued after scam emails sent to musical organisations | News and Star Labour has had a difficult time in the polls since winning their historic election as they forced through some controversial legislation on cancelling winter fuel payments for pensioners and keeping the two-child benefit cap. According to Election Maps UK, the party would fall just short of a majority on 318 seats with Labour next on 134 seats.
Bloomberg
2 hours ago
- Bloomberg
China's Coal Industry Has a Big, Dirty Secret
Exactly a century ago, two German chemists patented a process to transform coal into liquid fuels. Following its discovery in 1925, the Fischer-Tropsch synthesis eventually became infamous: The Nazis used it to fuel their war machine, and apartheid South Africa turned to it to offset the impact of an oil embargo in the 1980s. Its last — and huge — user is China. Largely unnoticed, the size of this obscure corner of the Chinese coal industry has reached gargantuan proportions: It consumes about 380 million metric tons of coal as a feedstock for chemical and liquid fuel production, according to the International Energy Agency. To understand its size better, it helps to think about the segment as if it were a country. As such, it would rank as the world's third-largest consumer, only behind the rest of the Chinese coal sector and India, but ahead of the US, Japan and other top coal-consuming nations like Indonesia and Turkey. It's not a little dirty secret — it's a big one, with significant implications for global climate and energy policy. The longer China remains addicted to coal, the more difficult it will be to decrease carbon dioxide emissions. Despite its huge progress in green energy, from electric cars to solar panels, the Asian giant consumes more coal than every other country on the planet combined. Crucially, the Chinese coal-conversion industry is set to expand even further, potentially offsetting declines elsewhere in the country, including a reduction in coal demand to produce cement and steel. 'We expect a growth between 5% and 10% in the coming years,' Carlos Fernandez Alvarez, head of coal at the IEA, tells me. Unfortunately, the sector is a black hole, as China publishes scant statistical information about it. For decades, China has converted some of its coal into chemical products and liquid fuels in what scholars call the 'traditional' coal chemical industry. The starting point was almost always metallurgical coal, converted into coke, and further transformed into ammonia-based fertilizers and acetylene-based chemicals. Yet over the last two decades, China has built a second layer, typically referred to as the 'modern' coal chemical industry, based on new variations of the old Fischer-Tropsch process plus sophisticated new methods, including methanol synthesis to produce petrochemical goods, such as olefins, used in turn to make plastics. The modern part of that processing was largely experimental in the early 2000s. Commercial-scale projects mushroomed in the 2010s, and, after a brief hiatus, more have emerged in recent years, particularly in the Chinese heartland, where the bulk of the country's coal fields are located far from coastal cities. By now, its scale — which dwarfs all other countries' coal-to-chemicals production — and growth is surprising even veteran industry observers. Look at some modernized plants and coal is nowhere to be seen: It's mined underground almost directly beneath the chemical facilities, carried by conveyor into the furnaces where it's gasified and transformed. From there, it goes into your plastic water bottle or synthetic fabric clothes. 1
