logo
A messy masterpiece at the 'G, ending with Mannagh from heaven

A messy masterpiece at the 'G, ending with Mannagh from heaven

The Age21-04-2025
Conversely, Geelong's super veteran Patrick Dangerfield grabbed those crucial opportunities – seizing them forcefully – and booted three goals in his new role as de facto key forward, including Geelong's first of the final quarter.
Jack Gunston, a near contemporary of the 35-year-old number 35, had an outstanding game as a marking forward, and would have been the most influential afield had he nailed a couple of additional shots. The ageless performances of players well into their 30s has been notable in 2025.
This game, if not quite at the standard of the best Cats and Hawks classics, was eventful and contained multiple twists, momentum shifts and was on the line, the margin the barest, until under three minutes remained.
It had villains, too.
For the gold and browns in the record 88,746 crowd, the man in the metaphoric black hat wore a white headband and long locks.
Bailey Smith, the game's most visible brand on social media, pushed the footy in the face of Jarman Impey in the second quarter and was subsequently booed, pantomime-style, for the duration and often (he had plenty of possessions and was among his team's best).
Conor Nash was the bad guy for the Geelong folk at the MCG after he clobbered and knocked out Gryan Miers with a crude round arm, a strike that, while not intentional – the ball was thereabouts – was simply unacceptable and should earn him weeks from the match review officer.
But the match was far more than a compilation of incidents.
Just when the Hawks appeared to be sinking, as Geelong's lead stretched to 23 points in the second quarter, they surged and took over in the midfield.
Clearances can be overrated as a measure of what matters, but Hawthorn's 11-consecutive clearances were a genuine barometer of the shift in the match. They owned territory in the dozen minutes before half-time and really should have been level, rather than 11 points behind.
Lloyd Meek was important in the surge, as were James Worpel and Jai Newcombe. Later, in the second half, Amon's ball use and run were important in levelling up the scores.
Max Holmes, who covers more territory than the ABC's Back Roads program (421 metres to half-time) produced a play early in the third quarter that was near the standard of Harley Reid's 2024 goal of the year – three bounces, running around hapless Hawks – except that Holmes merely kicked it to Jeremy Cameron, who converted from the goal square, rather than booting it, himself.
As the match unfolded, it asked multiple questions.
One was whether Hawthorn could convert their opportunities, if they had the nerves to finish the job and to turn their territorial advantage into victory.
The other was whether the Cats could stem those stoppage defeats, and either rebound or gain enough midfield impetus to let their efficiency deliver the win. In the second half, the Cats duly did overcome that stoppage problem, helped by the forever-unsung Tom Atkins.
Hawthorn played with marginally more verve, speed and enterprise. Geelong, as the more-seasoned unit, played with the greater composure.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell admits West Coast Eagle Harley Reid could blow Hawks' budget
Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell admits West Coast Eagle Harley Reid could blow Hawks' budget

West Australian

time21 hours ago

  • West Australian

Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell admits West Coast Eagle Harley Reid could blow Hawks' budget

Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell admits the club may not be able to afford to poach in-demand star Harley Reid amid reports he could fetch up to $2 million per season at West Coast. Mitchell revealed he posed the question to his list management team, asking if they were indeed 'obsessed' with the 20-year-old. Reports published this week suggest Hawthorn are desperate to add the former No.1 draft pick to their young midfield group, but with record-breaking deals being discussed, Mitchell said it could be beyond the brown and gold's pockets. 'If I'm really honest, I actually don't know (if we could afford him),' he told SEN on Friday. 'I don't have anything to do with the financial stuff. It doesn't seem right for us. At some point, that's going to happen, isn't it? Whether it's in this CBA or the next one, the money in the game continues to go up. 'The average salary continues to be higher and higher and higher and as they should be. Everyone wants to play the game, and the spectacle of what we're putting on at the moment is pretty good. I think the players deserve what they're getting, it's just how you attribute that. 'With our midfield as an example, being pretty workmanlike and making sure that we're consistent across the board. If you're putting $2 million into one player, that makes it a little bit more difficult, of course.' Mitchell has shown few reservations about going after West Coast players so far in 2025, having jetted into Perth for a secret meeting with Eagles co-captain Oscar Allan that was later exposed and saw the forward apologise. The Hawthorn coach was also photographed laughing and joking with Reid at former Eagle Tom Barrass' wedding, adding fuel to the fire. But Mitchell said after he heard the word 'obsessed' linking Reid and Hawthorn, he felt the need to chat to his list management team. 'I saw the word obsessed and I went in the next day and I said to a couple of list guys, 'are we obsessed with Harley Reid'? Then I saw some of the numbers that were getting thrown up, and I said, 'what is happening here'? And they're like 'just don't even read the papers',' Mitchell said. 'He's obviously a good player, but he's contracted to West Coast and he's having a pretty good year.' Reid is contracted on his draft deal until the end of 2026, meaning any new contracts wouldn't kick in until the 2027 campaign.

Hawks respond to Harley Reid rumour as fresh details emerge
Hawks respond to Harley Reid rumour as fresh details emerge

Daily Telegraph

time21 hours ago

  • Daily Telegraph

Hawks respond to Harley Reid rumour as fresh details emerge

Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News. Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell has provided some insight on whether the Hawks really are 'obsessed' with Harley Reid. Reports earlier this week stated the Hawks were 'obsessed' with Reid and now the Hawks coach has had his say. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer. 'I saw the word obsessed and I went in the next day and I said to a couple of list guys, 'Are we obsessed with Harley Reid?' and then I saw some of the numbers that were getting thrown up and I said 'What is happening here?' And they're like 'just don't even read the papers',' Mitchell said on SEN's Fireball this morning. 'He's obviously a good player but he's contracted to West Coast and he's having a pretty good year. A bit like 'Daysy' getting sat on in his first game back, it's a bit like, 'oh', I mean this 20-year-old is getting sat on most weeks now. He's a good player.' Harley Reid's future remains up in the air. (Photo by) Earlier this week, AFL Media's Cal Twomey reported that the Eagles have put what would be 'the biggest deal in AFL history' to the star youngster, keeping him at West Coast through to the end of 2037 with its value totalling over $20 million. Channel 7's Ryan Daniels said the deal was far more eye-watering with Reid potentially set to pocket $2.2m per season for 11 years. 'The proposed deal would be for two years initially, with an option for Harley to extend that to 11 years, until the end of 2037, and be worth around $2.2 million per season. The total number would likely be north of $24 million,' Daniels said. Reid's manager, Nick Gieschen, has recently arrived in WA and attempted to downplay the reported offer. 'I don't think anyone is ready to be the highest-paid player in the comp,' Gieschen said. 'But nah, we're working through it. Nothing's finalised. We're in negotiations but we'll take every day as it comes. 'Harley is enjoying his time here and like I said before, we're talking about what the future looks like. We're having discussions with West Coast and we'll go from there. 'Nothing in concrete, we're just talking at the moment and we'll see where we get to.' With easily the biggest deal ever seen in AFL history reportedly on the table, it's tough bidding for any Victorian clubs to swoop in and lure him away. 'If I'm really honest I actually don't know. I don't have anything to do with the financial stuff. It doesn't seem right for us. At some point that's going to happen isn't it? Whether it's in this CBA or the next one, but the money in the game continues to go up,' Mitchell said. Harley Reid could be set to sign the biggest contract in AFL history. (Photo by) 'The average salary continues to be higher and higher and higher and as they should be. Everyone wants to play the game and the spectacle of what we're putting on at the moment is pretty good. I think the players deserve what they're getting, it's just how you attribute that. 'With our midfield as an example, being pretty workman-like and making sure that we're consistent across the board. If you're putting $2 million into one player, that makes it a little bit more difficult of course.' As rumours surrounding Reid's future continue to swirl, Eagles skipper Liam Duggan believes the young star will stick with the club. 'I'm really eager for Harley to sign. I mean, he's going to be paid very well regardless of where it is, and he's going to get a long-term deal regardless of where it is,' he said on Triple M. 'But all I can speak of at the moment is that his investment in what we're going after at the moment is second to none. 'He has been so dialled into what we're going after as a footy club at the moment, he's been very vocal in that amongst the group, the way he's playing, you can see that in the way that he's playing, and I think our supporters would be able to see that in the way that he's going about his footy right now.' Originally published as Hawks respond to Harley Reid rumour as fresh details emerge

Hawks respond to Harley Reid rumour as fresh details emerge
Hawks respond to Harley Reid rumour as fresh details emerge

Courier-Mail

timea day ago

  • Courier-Mail

Hawks respond to Harley Reid rumour as fresh details emerge

Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News. Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell has provided some insight on whether the Hawks really are 'obsessed' with Harley Reid. Reports earlier this week stated the Hawks were 'obsessed' with Reid and now the Hawks coach has had his say. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer. 'I saw the word obsessed and I went in the next day and I said to a couple of list guys, 'Are we obsessed with Harley Reid?' and then I saw some of the numbers that were getting thrown up and I said 'What is happening here?' And they're like 'just don't even read the papers',' Mitchell said on SEN's Fireball this morning. 'He's obviously a good player but he's contracted to West Coast and he's having a pretty good year. A bit like 'Daysy' getting sat on in his first game back, it's a bit like, 'oh', I mean this 20-year-old is getting sat on most weeks now. He's a good player.' Harley Reid's future remains up in the air. (Photo by) Earlier this week, AFL Media's Cal Twomey reported that the Eagles have put what would be 'the biggest deal in AFL history' to the star youngster, keeping him at West Coast through to the end of 2037 with its value totalling over $20 million. Channel 7's Ryan Daniels said the deal was far more eye-watering with Reid potentially set to pocket $2.2m per season for 11 years. 'The proposed deal would be for two years initially, with an option for Harley to extend that to 11 years, until the end of 2037, and be worth around $2.2 million per season. The total number would likely be north of $24 million,' Daniels said. Reid's manager, Nick Gieschen, has recently arrived in WA and attempted to downplay the reported offer. X Learn More SUBSCRIBER ONLY 'I don't think anyone is ready to be the highest-paid player in the comp,' Gieschen said. 'But nah, we're working through it. Nothing's finalised. We're in negotiations but we'll take every day as it comes. 'Harley is enjoying his time here and like I said before, we're talking about what the future looks like. We're having discussions with West Coast and we'll go from there. 'Nothing in concrete, we're just talking at the moment and we'll see where we get to.' With easily the biggest deal ever seen in AFL history reportedly on the table, it's tough bidding for any Victorian clubs to swoop in and lure him away. 'If I'm really honest I actually don't know. I don't have anything to do with the financial stuff. It doesn't seem right for us. At some point that's going to happen isn't it? Whether it's in this CBA or the next one, but the money in the game continues to go up,' Mitchell said. Harley Reid could be set to sign the biggest contract in AFL history. (Photo by) 'The average salary continues to be higher and higher and higher and as they should be. Everyone wants to play the game and the spectacle of what we're putting on at the moment is pretty good. I think the players deserve what they're getting, it's just how you attribute that. 'With our midfield as an example, being pretty workman-like and making sure that we're consistent across the board. If you're putting $2 million into one player, that makes it a little bit more difficult of course.' As rumours surrounding Reid's future continue to swirl, Eagles skipper Liam Duggan believes the young star will stick with the club. 'I'm really eager for Harley to sign. I mean, he's going to be paid very well regardless of where it is, and he's going to get a long-term deal regardless of where it is,' he said on Triple M. 'But all I can speak of at the moment is that his investment in what we're going after at the moment is second to none. 'He has been so dialled into what we're going after as a footy club at the moment, he's been very vocal in that amongst the group, the way he's playing, you can see that in the way that he's playing, and I think our supporters would be able to see that in the way that he's going about his footy right now.' Originally published as Hawks respond to Harley Reid rumour as fresh details emerge

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store