Proposal to suspend work of Vancouver's integrity commissioner quietly fizzles out
A year-long controversy at Vancouver City Hall has ended not with a bang, but with a procedural ruling on a point of order.
"This motion would be frivolous, and is out of order," read Mayor Ken Sim at council on Tuesday morning, dismissing an amendment to Vancouver's code of conduct that would have temporarily suspended Integrity Commissioner Lisa Southern's ability to investigate complaints against the mayor and council.
"Basically, we can just carry on."
The motion was brought forward last July by ABC Vancouver councillors, who argued an external review and temporary suspension of investigations would allow for more clarity around the Office of the Integrity Commissioner.
But the debate became paralyzed and acrimonious due to code-of-conduct investigations prompted by accusations from various members of council and park board against each other, and allegations that councillors were trying to silence the body in charge of investigating them.
WATCH | Debate over integrity commissioner ends:
Vancouver council ends debate over integrity commissioner
10 hours ago
Duration 3:01
The debate over Vancouver city hall's independent watchdog has ended, at least for now. Last summer, council proposed suspending the work of its integrity commissioner. But while the matter was finally put to rest, the issue is likely to be brought back up by the province soon. CBC's Justin McElroy reports.
Over the last 11 months, the vote for a suspension of investigations was delayed four times. During that time an external investigation into the office — which recommended more independence from council — was launched and concluded.
"It has been a lot of wasted resources and time to get to this point," said Coun. Pete Fry.
Vancouver's Mayor Office said they considered the matter closed.
In a statement, Southern said she looked forward to continuing her work, while noting she has endorsed the city hiring her replacement before her term ends in December.
"Throughout the past three and a half years, I have remained committed to carrying out my responsibilities impartially and diligently, and I am proud of the work my office has done in service of council and the public," she wrote.
"I look forward to supporting a smooth and professional transition over the coming months."
'It's somewhat toothless'
While Vancouver's debate over how to resolve code-of-conduct disputes has subsided, the province is deciding how future investigations into local politicians should be conducted amid frustrations over a number of feuding city councils across the province.
Fry said he supported Vancouver continuing to have its own integrity commissioner, but said the province could create mechanisms to protect the office and allow for binding punishments, neither of which exist at the moment.
"We need a little bit more enforcement with some of these rulings when it comes to breaches of our oath of office, or code of conduct," he said.
"The integrity commissioner doesn't have the ability under the Vancouver Charter to impose any sanctions. So in many respects, it's somewhat toothless."
It was a point underlined by Reece Harding, Surrey's first ethics commissioner, who has been hired for code-of-conduct investigations in multiple municipalities.
"[In B.C.], there's nothing really that dictates how decision-makers are put in place, clarity around process, clarity around sanctions and remedies," Harding said.
"And so it's a bit of a free-for-all out there."
What model to take?
Each province that has tackled the issue has come up with slightly different solutions.
Ontario recently passed legislation that standardizes municipal codes of conduct across the province, and allows for mayors and councillors in serious violation of the code to be removed from office, but only if the province's own integrity commissioner agrees and it gets a unanimous vote from council.
Last year, New Brunswick created the Local Governance Commission, which can take complaints if people are not satisfied with internal investigations. It has the power to suspend local politicians or appoint supervisors, which it did two months ago in Strait Shores.
Alberta has gone in the opposite direction, eliminating municipal codes of conduct while suggesting a separate ethics commissioner could be appointed.
"There will be circumstances where it seems reasonable to me that the province needs to have a bigger stick," Harding said.
He added that whatever system is enacted should stop situations where municipalities spend months or years investigating themselves with no resolution.
"Clear process, clear remedies and a role for the provincial government where the local jurisdiction has become frozen and can't get themselves out of that frozen ice mask," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Globe and Mail
10 minutes ago
- Globe and Mail
China imposes 75.8% duty on Canadian canola, prompting industry calls for federal support
Canada's canola industry is facing steep losses and urging Ottawa to compensate farmers after Beijing announced a 75.8-per-cent preliminary duty on Canadian canola seed. The Tuesday morning announcement comes toward the end of a one-year anti-dumping probe launched by China in September. Canada's agricultural sector has benefited from extensive government subsidies and preferential policies that distort markets, said an announcement from China's Ministry of Commerce on Tuesday. But Beijing's actions are not about dumping and effectively cut off Canada's most lucrative crop from one of its most important markets weeks before harvest, say many in the sector. Canadian canola is exported in accordance with rules based trade and fair market access, said Chris Davidson, President of Canola Council of Canada. Beijing's tariffs are instead a 'political issue that needs a political resolution,' he said. The anti-dumping investigation came after Ottawa imposed 100-per-cent tariffs on Chinese-made electric vehicles and 25-per-cent tariffs on Chinese steel and aluminum. Beijing imposed 100-per-cent tariffs on meal and oil in March as retaliation for Ottawa's tariffs. Now all three canola products - meal, seed and oil - are facing Chinese tariffs. 'There are geopolitical forces and we seem to be getting side-swiped,' said Dale Leftwich, Policy Manager at SaskOilseeds, adding that farmers feel like 'collateral damage.' Canola farmers feel their livelihoods are being sacrificed to save the auto industry 'This is fairly devastating right now,' said Alberta farmer Roger Chevraux. His crop is around three weeks away from harvest and it lost $90,000 in value after markets reacted and the price per bushel dropped by $1. Mr. Chevraux will try to hold onto the crop until prices improve. But storage space is limited and September is an expensive time of year. Costs like fuel from running harvest machinery and the bill for fertilizer might force a number of farmers to take a low price. The price could also fall lower. 'We need a return to rules based trade all the way around the world ... We need normal trade we can rely on.' In the meantime, Mr. Chevraux would like to see Ottawa offer compensation. 'They're willing to support other industries in Canada. I sure hope they don't forget about us.' Valued at $4-billion in annual exports, China is the largest market for Canadian canola seed. It is also the largest vegetable oil consumer in the world, with an annual consumption of 38.3 mmt. The product set for China cannot be easily move elsewhere. There have been some promising developments in Ottawa's relationship with China, said Mr. Davidson. In early June, Canada and China trade ministers committed to convening the Joint Economic and Trade Commission. 'We will be looking for the government to double down on those efforts moving forward.'
CTV News
10 minutes ago
- CTV News
Bick's pickles disappear from some Canadian shelves amid tariff dispute
Some Canadian shoppers have noticed something missing from their local grocery store shelves - and experts say it's a case study on how tariffs can reduce choices and raise prices. Bick's pickles, the iconic brand founded in Canada in 1951, is now owned by U.S.-based TreeHouse Foods. While the cucumbers and jar lids are sourced in Canada, the pickles are processed in the U.S. before being shipped back north. Under current trade rules, that makes them subject to counter-tariffs Ottawa imposed in response to U.S. duties on Canadian goods. 'It's a bit weird because the Bick's product is actually more Canadian than some properly labelled Canadian pickles,' Sylvian Charlebois, professor of food distribution and policy at Dalhousie University, told CTV's Your Morning Tuesday. Charlebois says the policy, aimed at pressuring Washington, ends up hurting domestic competition. 'We're tariffing products that are actually grown in Canada. If you reduce supply, prices tend to go up.' Some Canadian retailers will still carry Bick's, he noted, but availability will be reduced. Alternatives like Mrs. White's pickles, made in Canada, are still on store shelves. Ian Lee, a business analyst at Carleton University, calls the situation a 'lose-lose proposition' that punishes Canadian farmers, manufacturers and consumers. 'The jar gets hit by Canadian tariffs,' Lee told CTV News Channel in an interview Monday. 'The profit margins in grocery retailing are already razor-thin, so some stories just take them off the shelf.' According to CTV News Winnipeg, a Sobeys in the city let customers know that tariffs will impact what they can stock on their shelves. In July, a sign placed in the Winnipeg store on a shelf that normally holds Bick's Pickles read, 'Bick's Pickles are currently unavailable as an unfortunate impact of tariffs. We are pleased to offer a selection of alternatives for your shopping convenience.' The tariffs were introduced as retaliation to U.S. duties introduced by U.S. President Donald Trump. But Lee says mimicking the U.S. approach does more harm than good. 'We're poking Donald Trump in the eye but we're hurting Canadians in the process,' Lee said. has reached out to TreeHouse Foods, Sobeys and Loblaw for comment.
40 minutes ago
Country singer Dallas Smith winks at Trump's annexation threats with 51-date tour
Country singer Dallas Smith isn't looking to stir the political pot, but he admits it's no coincidence that his upcoming Canadian concert tour is booked for 51 dates. In a wink to U.S. President Donald Trump's threats of making Canada the 51st state, the British Columbia-born country singer and frontman of rock band Default says he's investing in his homeland with an acoustic tour that rolls through 51 communities starting this fall. We were close to that number and then we said let's just make that happen, he said with a laugh in a recent interview. It was important for me to come, especially at this time, [with] a lot of Canadian pride. I want to get out there, really go hard, and visit all these places that I haven't been and see the country. The Dallas Smith & His Band (Unplugged) tour will focus on places he's never toured before and is mostly booked in small theatre venues of several hundred to a thousand seats. Enlarge image (new window) Dallas Smith poses on the red carpet at the Canadian Country Music Awards in Calgary, Alta., Sunday, Sept. 11, 2022. Photo: The Canadian Press / Jeff McIntosh He starts in Fort St. John, B.C., on Oct. 3 and continues to less-travelled communities such as Kitimat, B.C., Enoch, M.B. and Wingham, Ont. By the time it's over, Smith will have wound through nine of the 10 provinces — skipping Newfoundland and Labrador and the territories — reaching his final stop in Belleville, Ont., on Dec. 14. Sporting a red-brimmed maple leaf baseball cap emblazoned with Canada, Smith explained the reasons behind making Canada his main focus for the rest of the year. There is a lot going on in the U.S. that goes against my upbringing and what I think is right, he said in a video chat from Nashville, where he was meeting with his management. So why not double down and spend the time in a place that I really want to enjoy and be around my people? 'Nooks and crannies' of Canada Few Canadian musicians take on the challenge of playing so many small markets. Life on the road can be mighty expensive once accounting for all the people required to carry a tour. With his band Default, Smith is more familiar with big venues, music festivals and major events, such as the Calgary Stampede, where he's roared through hits like Wasting My Time and Deny . LISTEN | Smith talks about switching to country (new window) He intends to revisit some of those older songs on this tour with stripped-back versions, while sharing stories of his upbringing, music career and newer solo tracks, including How Do You Miss Me and Drop . The concept is inspired by the MTV Unplugged sessions of the 1990s made famous by Nirvana and Alice In Chains. Smith said he's been throwing around the idea of exploring the nooks and crannies of Canada since before the COVID-19 pandemic, but the plan never took shape. More recently, alongside his management team, he mapped out a budget to make it happen, shedding the lavish perks and complex lighting rigs for something more modest — a single bus, trailer, full band and most of his regular crew. Together they'll work on a tight schedule that, at times, sees them booked for six consecutive nights in six different cities before they have a break. To make it happen, their stage setup will be minimal. We're gonna dial back and allow the beauty of these venues to kind of lead the way and be the backdrop, he added. Smith's approach might seem counter to the music industry trend of making shows bigger and more social media friendly — think towering digital screens and gimmicky celebrity appearances. But he said he's often rejected those pressures, and with this tour, he focused on making tickets affordable, within the $60 to $100 range, without impacting the live performance. I did not want to sacrifice how these songs would be played, Smith said. I love the guys in my band; they're like brothers to me. Playing these songs together, and paying them a full wage where they feel valued ... and balancing that with ticket price, it's a little tricky, but we landed in a good spot where everybody feels really happy.
